Shows
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep94: Lies, Truth, and The KeepersIn this episode of Foul Play, Shane and Gemma are joined by Mike, an expert in detecting deception through body language, as they dive deep into the perplexing case of Sister Cathy. The trio scrutinizes the most promising suspects and unpacks intriguing visuals from The Keepers, shedding new light on evidence that has long baffled investigators. Combining detailed analysis with engaging discussion, they explore the nuances of witness behavior and the subtle cues that may reveal the truth behind the murder. Tune in for an insightful and suspenseful investigation that challenges everything you thought you knew about this cold...2025-02-031h 16
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep93: Sister Cathy, Continuing the TimelineIn this episode of Foul Play, Shane and Gemma pick up where they left off, completing the intricate timeline of events surrounding the disappearance and murder of Sister Cathy Cesnik. They shed light on pivotal moments, uncover new connections, and discuss the lingering questions that continue to haunt this decades-old case. Listeners will also hear thoughtful responses to more submitted questions, as Shane and Gemma explore fresh perspectives and theories that deepen our understanding of the tragedy. Join them as they continue their pursuit of justice and uncover the stories that demand to be told.Support t...2024-12-071h 07
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep92: Sister Cathy, A Timeline of Events and Key InsightsIn this episode of Foul Play, Shane and Gemma discuss the significant developments and unanswered questions surrounding the disappearance and murder of Sister Cathy Cesnik. They outline a detailed timeline leading up to and following her disappearance, touching on key events and interactions with people close to her. The episode also delves into the potential involvement of certain individuals, the investigative efforts by the police and FBI, and the forensic analysis of evidence. They address numerous listener-submitted questions, providing comprehensive answers and exploring various theories around the case.Support this podcast at — https://redcircle.com/foul-play-crime-series/do...2024-11-241h 10
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep91: Sister Cathy, Slides of Hope: A Doctor's Quest for JusticeIn this episode, recorded as 2022 drew to a close, Shane and Gemma are joined in Maryland by Catherine Rentz, a seasoned journalist and producer from Maryland. Also present is, John Benam, the esteemed Director of Photography known for his work on "The Keepers."Catherine Rentz takes us deep into the heart of a story that unravels like a tapestry of mystery against the backdrop of 1970s Maryland. At the center of this narrative is a doctor whose meticulous preservation of evidence from sex crimes forms a crucial bridge to solving cold cases that seemed forever lost to...2024-02-121h 43
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep90: Sister Cathy, The Jesuit SeminarianIn this episode, Shane and Gemma dive into a new twist in the unsolved murder of Sister Cathy. They are joined by Ronnie Norpel, whose parents were friends with Gerry Koob, a Jesuit priest who was close to Sister Cathy and a person of interest in the case. Ronnie shares her shocking allegations against Koob, and reveals how he often brought Sister Cathy to her parents' house. What secrets did Koob and Sister Cathy share, and how are they connected to the dark web of corruption and cover-ups that surrounded her death?Here is the Baltimore Banner...2024-01-141h 05
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep88: Sister Cathy, Reflections on the Attorney General's Report on Clergy AbuseIn this thought-provoking episode of Foul Play, hosts Gemma and Shane delve into the profound implications of the Maryland Attorney General's recent report on clergy abuse. Joined by advocate and paralegal Mary Beth and survivor Kim, the episode offers an in-depth analysis of the report's findings and its impact on the ongoing struggle of survivors.Listeners will be drawn into a heart-rending discussion about how the report sheds light on the traumatic experiences of abuse survivors and the steps taken by the Archdiocese of Baltimore in response to these revelations. The conversation critically examines the Archdiocese's decision...2023-12-0658 min
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep87: Sister Cathy, Bankruptcy and Betrayal - How Bankruptcy Shields PredatorsWho Stands to Gain? The Complex Web of Archdiocesan Bankruptcies and Sister Cathy’s Unsolved Murder. After funneling an extensive amount of resources into fighting against survivors in Maryland to preserve the statute of limitations, the Archdiocese of Baltimore has now opened a new legal front—filing for Chapter 11 bankruptcy.Astoundingly, the archdiocese seems willing to spend millions more in legal and court fees to essentially carve out their own type of statute of limitations, a privilege that bankruptcy can afford them. This unsettling move is not unique to Baltimore; it's part of a wider pattern with 30 other arch...2023-10-201h 06
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep86: Sister Cathy, Uniting for Survivors - The Battle for TransparencyGemma and survivor Donna find themselves at the forefront of a critical moment in the fight against clergy abuse in the Archdiocese of Baltimore. This episode captures the essence of a pivotal press conference where SNAP (Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests), their attorneys, Gemma, and Donna unite to advocate for the full disclosure of a comprehensive report on child sexual abuse within the church.The episode delves into the context of this significant legal and moral battle. The Maryland Attorney General's 456-page report, the culmination of an extensive investigation, documents the abuse of over 600 victims at...2022-12-0248 min
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep85: Sister Cathy, Transparency and Accountability at the Archdiocese of BaltimoreThe Maryland Attorney General investigation into the sexual abuse of children by clergy in the Archdiocese of Baltimore (AOB) has concluded. The 456-page report details the sexual abuse of more than 600 victims at the hands of 158 Catholic Priests that were part of the AOB. Attorney General Brian Frosh has turned his report over to the courts and has asked the court to release it to the public saying his investigation uncovered many attempts of coverups of priests abusing children by those in the Archdiocese. While Shane travels to Baltimore to do some podcasting with Gemma, he stops at...2022-11-3026 min
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep84: Sister Cathy, The Truth in the Machine - Understanding PolygraphsShane and Gemma elcomes a distinguished guest, William Ortiz, a retired FBI Special Agent and Marine Corps veteran. With his extensive experience in law enforcement and as the founder of Ortsec, a polygraph service company, William brings invaluable insight into the world of polygraph examinations.In this episode, Shane and Gemma delve into the fascinating realm of lie detectors with William, exploring the intricacies of how these machines work and their role in both law enforcement and broader investigative contexts. The conversation begins with a historical overview of polygraph technology, tracing its evolution and the principles that govern...2022-10-2844 min
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep83: Sister Cathy, Teresa & Jean - the Courts, the Church and the Cops, Part 2Shane and Gemma sit down with Jean and Teresa from Netflix's The Keepers to discuss the courts, the church, and the cops. If you are curious what the status of the 4 year Maryland attorney general investigation into Clergy abuse is then you have come to the right place.Join Shane Waters and The Keepers' Gemma Hoskins in this series, along with many of the women and men featured in the the Netflix series. This is an ongoing series.Find us online.Support the show by joining our Black Label by becoming a Patron...2022-09-2645 min
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep82: Sister Cathy, Teresa & Jean - the Courts, the Church and the Cops, Part 1Shane and Gemma sit down with Jean and Teresa from Netflix's The Keepers to discuss the courts, the church, and the cops. If you are curious what the status of the 4 year Maryland attorney general investigation into Clergy abuse is then you have come to the right place.Jean and Teresa are inviting you to stand up for truth, and support them and all survivors of child sexual abuse, by using your voice, making noise, sending e-mails and sharing their conversation to demand accountability and serious change. You can find Jean's books here: https://jeanwehnercoach.com...2022-09-2353 min
Mind Over MurderBONUS: Gemma Hoskins of The Keepers: A Coverup for Murder in Baltimore? (Part 1)Gemma Hoskins of "The Keepers" joins Mind Over Murder co-hosts Bill Thomas and Kristin Dinner as they discuss whether the Catholic Church is responsible for a coverup for the murder of Joyce Malecki and Sister Cathy Cesnik in Baltimore. This is part 1 of a 2 part discussion"It's Foul Play" Podcast with Gemma Hoskins and Shane Waters:https://www.itsfoulplay.com/Goodreads on "Keeping On: How I Came to Know Why I Was Born" by Gemma Hoskinshttps://www.goodreads.com/book/show/54899962-keeping-on"The Keepers" Netflix Series Trailer:...2022-07-2847 min
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep81: Sister Cathy, Walking with AletheiaShane and Gemma are honored to host Jean Wehner, a key figure from the documentary "The Keepers," along with her brother. This episode offers a deep dive into Jean's newly published book, "Walking with Aletheia," a memoir that chronicles her journey of discovery, healing, and truth.Jean Wehner, whose story of resilience and courage captivated audiences in "The Keepers," shares the essence of her book, providing listeners with an intimate look at her experiences, struggles, and triumphs. "Walking with Aletheia" is more than a memoir; it's a testament to the power of speaking one's truth and the transformative...2022-06-2253 min
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep80: Sister Cathy, Safe in Socks - Teresa Lancaster's JourneyThe 80th episode of our series on Sister Cathy, features a profound discussion with Teresa Lancaster, a pivotal figure from the documentary series "The Keepers." Teresa courageously shares her harrowing experiences of abuse within the Catholic Church and her relentless pursuit of justice. In this episode, Teresa delves into her book "Safe N Socks," a poignant narrative that chronicles her personal story and sheds light on the systemic issue of abuse in the church. She speaks candidly about the challenges she faced in coming forward, the legal battles she navigated, and the healing process that followed. Her account...2022-03-1528 min
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep79: Sister Cathy, The Brother - Unveiling Hidden PathsShane and Gemma delve deeper into the intricate web surrounding the unsolved murder of Sister Cathy Cesnik. In this episode, they conduct an enlightening interview with “the brother,” a religious figure who shares his unique perspective on Sister Cathy's life and the events leading up to her tragic disappearance and death.The Brother offers a rare glimpse into his life as a religious brother and his interactions with Sister Cathy, reflecting on the path that led her from teaching in a religious setting to a public school. His narrative provides an intimate look at the religious community at the...2021-11-0337 min
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep78: Sister Cathy, Inside Richter's OfficeShane and Gemma discuss the courageous decision of Liz, a former medical assistant, to come forward with her experiences working for Dr. Christian Richter. Liz's account adds a chilling layer of detail to the tangled narrative surrounding the Sister Cathy Cesnik case and the alleged criminal activities linked to Richter and Joseph Maskell.Throughout the episode, Liz recounts her time in Dr. Richter's office, painting a disturbing picture of the doctor's conduct and the enigmatic circumstances she witnessed. She describes instances where young female patients, often accompanied by priests, were brought in for appointments after normal office hours...2021-06-0940 min
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep77: Sister Cathy, Echoes of Tragedy - The Pamela Conyers CaseShane and Gemma delve into a case that potentially intersects with the unsolved murder of Sister Cathy Cesnik and Joyce Malecki. They are joined by Ingrid, the niece of Pamela Conyers, who shares the haunting details of her aunt's tragic death and the ongoing quest for justice.Pamela Lynn Conyers, a student at Glen Burnie High School, disappeared after attending a homecoming bonfire and pep rally on October 16, 1970. Her last known location was the Harundale Mall in Glen Burnie, from where she vanished, leaving behind only her family's 1967 Dodge Monaco. Days later, her body was tragically discovered...2021-06-0231 min
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep76: Sister Cathy, Live Q&A - Unraveling the Mystery, Part 2In an interactive and dynamic episode, Shane and Gemma take their investigation into the public sphere with a live podcast session dedicated to answering listener questions. Episode 75 offers a unique opportunity for the audience to engage directly with the hosts, bringing their queries and theories to the forefront of the discussion.Throughout this live broadcast, Shane and Gemma address a spectrum of inquiries about Sister Cathy Cesnik's case, clarifying details, debunking misconceptions, and exploring new angles based on listener input. The session becomes a platform for collective investigation, where the hosts' expertise and the public's curiosity converge...2021-05-2640 min
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep75: Sister Cathy, Live Q&A - Unraveling the Mystery, Part 1In an interactive and dynamic episode, Shane and Gemma take their investigation into the public sphere with a live podcast session dedicated to answering listener questions. Episode 75 offers a unique opportunity for the audience to engage directly with the hosts, bringing their queries and theories to the forefront of the discussion.Throughout this live broadcast, Shane and Gemma address a spectrum of inquiries about Sister Cathy Cesnik's case, clarifying details, debunking misconceptions, and exploring new angles based on listener input. The session becomes a platform for collective investigation, where the hosts' expertise and the public's curiosity converge to...2021-05-1954 min
Profiling Evil Podcast with Mike KingThey Murdered My Teacher! In-depth Interview with Gemma Hoskins from the Netflix Docuseries The Keepers - Profiling Evil PodcastGet the inside scoop on the Netflix Documentary “The Keepers” and learn how Gemma Hoskins continues to search for answers in the murder of Sister Catherine CesnikBuy Gemma's Bookhttps://amzn.to/3yckUBdGemma Hoskinshttps://twitter.com/hoskins_gemmahttps://www.gemmahoskins.com/Start your own podcast with Buzzsprout: https://www.buzzsprout.com/?referrer_id=1171763=======================================Profiling Evil B.O.L.O. Newsletter:https://cutt.ly/bolonewslettersignup Order today!Deceived: An Investigative Memoi...2021-05-1257 min
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep74: Sister Cathy, Who was Sister Russell?Shane and Gemma Hoskins from the acclaimed Netflix series 'The Keepers' sit down with Beth, a former student and friend of Sister Russell Phillips. This episode offers a unique and personal insight into the life of Sister Russell, a significant figure intertwined with the tragic and unsolved murder of Sister Cathy Cesnik in 1969.Beth shares her close connection with Sister Russell, who was Sister Cathy's roommate and a key person in the unfolding events of the infamous case. She delves into her own background, recounting how her paths crossed with Sister Russell and the profound influence this...2021-05-1229 min
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep73: Sister Cathy, From Shadows to Light – Erin's JourneyShane and Gemma engage in a powerful and deeply personal conversation with Erin, a long-time friend of the podcast. Erin's story is a stark testament to the destructive consequences of trauma and addiction, yet it is also a beacon of hope for recovery and resilience.Erin bravely opens up about her experiences with familial abuse, drawing unsettling parallels to the scandals highlighted in 'The Keepers.' Her narrative unfolds a life marred by addiction, starting with alcohol and spiraling into a dangerous heroin habit. Erin recounts her harrowing journey through the criminal justice system, her battles with...2021-05-0545 min
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS6 Ep9: From the Archives - Redhead MurdersJoin Shane and Gemma as they discuss the final victim of the Redhead Murders, Summarize what we know so far, and end the series with a very promising update and lead! *** Listen to the Follow-up season to the Redhead Murders - The Throwaways! ***Support this podcast at — https://redcircle.com/foul-play-crime-series/donationsAdvertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brandsPrivacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy2021-05-0453 min
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS6 Ep8: From the Archives - Redhead MurdersShane discusses the very first victim thought to be linked to the Redhead Murders found in Wetzel County, West Virginia. Also in on the discussion is grassroots amateur investigator featured on Netflix’s Docu-Series The Keepers - Gemma Hoskins, along with Kayla Vandeventer who was a student in Teacher Alex’s high school sociology class featured previously in the series. Could a trucker navigate the winding road this Jane Doe was found off of? Could this victim be related although she was older than all the others? With numerous female victims, this series of murders remains an unsolved murder mystery....2021-05-0323 min
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS6 Ep6: From the Archives - Redhead MurdersShane travels again to Elizabethton, Tennessee, to join the high school sociology class at a press conference to tell the world about the Redhead Murders and the Bible Belt Strangler. With numerous female victims, this series of murders remains an unsolved murder mystery. Join host and investigative podcaster, Shane Waters, alongside Netflix Docu-Series The Keepers grassroots investigator Gemma Hoskins as they explore this forgotten serial killer case.Support this podcast at — https://redcircle.com/foul-play-crime-series/donationsAdvertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brandsPrivacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy2021-05-0136 min
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS6 Ep5: From the Archives - Redhead MurdersJoin Shane as he travels to Barbourville, Kentucky to trace the steps the Bible Belt Strangler made when he killed an innocent victim along 25E. With numerous female victims, this series of murders remains an unsolved murder mystery. Join host and investigative podcaster, Shane Waters, alongside Netflix The Keepers grassroots investigator Gemma Hoskins as they explore this forgotten serial killer case.Support this podcast at — https://redcircle.com/foul-play-crime-series/donationsAdvertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brandsPrivacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy2021-04-3032 min
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep72: Sister Cathy, Chasing Alice – Lessons from a TragedyGemma and Shane are joined by Stephanie Fowler, whose book "Chasing Alice" delves into the harrowing account of her high school teacher, Alice, a beacon of hope and refuge in Stephanie's troubled youth. Stephanie's intimate conversation with the hosts reveals the transformative impact Alice had on her life and the heartrending story of Alice's murder at the hands of her husband.Stephanie recounts the sense of safety and understanding Alice provided, which stood in stark contrast to the turbulence of her home life. The discussion pivots to the devastating loss of Alice, a tragedy that reverberated through Stephanie's...2021-01-0540 min
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep71: Sister Cathy, Keeping On with GemmaIn a heartfelt and introspective episode of Foul Play: Crime Series, "Keeping On with Gemma," the spotlight shines on Gemma Hoskins, whose quest for truth has transcended the role of a former student to become that of an author and tenacious investigator. Gemma shares a poignant chapter from her newly published book, "Keeping On," inviting listeners into the intimate spaces of her memories, motivations, and the ongoing journey to resolve the mystery of Sister Cathy Cesnik's murder.Gemma's reading offers a glimpse into the soul of her book and the very essence of her relentless pursuit. "Keeping On"...2021-01-0417 min
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep70: Sister Cathy, Deciphering Deceit – More Behavioral AnalysisThis episode dives deeper into the murky waters of truth and falsehood as Shane and Gemma reconvene with Mike, a behavior detection specialist with a wealth of federal experience. This follow-up episode continues the exploration of lies and deception, scrutinizing interviews and interactions featured in 'The Keepers' to unearth signs of duplicity that might otherwise go unnoticed.Mike lends his refined expertise to break down specific segments of the documentary series, applying his understanding of behavioral cues to assess the honesty of the individuals involved. His analysis focuses on microexpressions, speech patterns, and body language that may suggest...2021-01-0335 min
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep69: Sister Cathy, The Inner Circle – A Round Table on Maskell and MemoriesShane and Gemma facilitate a round table featuring key figures from the Netflix documentary 'The Keepers.' This assembly of minds opens a multi-faceted dialogue on the enigmatic and ominous figure of Dr. Joseph Maskell, his tenure as a teacher at Loyola, and the dark shroud of allegations that link him to the CIA's infamous MKUltra project.The guests share their intimate recollections of Maskell, piecing together a mosaic of memories that paint a disturbing picture of manipulation and power abuse. With each anecdote and shared experience, they build upon the understanding of Maskell's character and the potential...2021-01-021h 15Mind Over MurderGemma Hoskins of The Keepers: Coverup for Murder in Baltimore? (Part 2)In this episode, hosts Bill Thomas and Kristin Dilley interview Gemma Hoskins, star of the hit Netflix series "The Keepers, which explored the unsolved murders of Sister Cathy Cesnik and Joyce Malecki, and possible involvement and coverup by Archbishop Keough High School and the Baltimore Diocese of the Catholic Church. This is part 1 of 2 episodes with Gemma Hoskins, who also discusses her new book, "Keeping On: How I Came to Know Why I Was Born." This is Part of 2 episodes. "Keeping On: How I Came to Know Why I was Born" by Gemma Hoskins: https://www.amazon.com...2020-10-1954 minMind Over MurderGemma Hoskins of The Keepers: Coverup for Murder in Baltimore? (Part 1)In this episode, hosts Bill Thomas and Kristin Dilley interview Gemma Hoskins, star of the hit Netflix series "The Keepers, which explored the unsolved murders of Sister Cathy Cesnik and Joyce Malecki, and possible involvement and coverup by Archbishop Keough High School and the Baltimore Diocese of the Catholic Church. This is part 1 of 2 episodes with Gemma Hoskins, who also discusses her new book, "Keeping On: How I Came to Know Why I Was Born." This is Part 1 of 2 episodes. "Keeping On: How I Came to Know Why I was Born" by Gemma Hoskins: https://www.amazon.com...2020-10-1255 min
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep68: Sister Cathy, Organized Abuse – A Global Call to ActionShane and Gemma join forces with Associate Professor Michael Salter, a criminologist from the University of New South Wales. As an expert deeply immersed in the study and support of organized sexual abuse survivors, Salter brings critical knowledge and urgency to the conversation, spotlighting a subject historically shrouded in doubt and misapprehension.Salter discusses the paradigm shift in how organized sexual abuse, especially involving individuals who endured such atrocities in childhood, is recognized and approached today. With regret, he reflects on the skepticism that once met such cases and how his association with bodies like the ISSTD...2020-04-071h 12
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep67: Sister Cathy, Unmasking Deception – The Language of Lies, Part 2Shane and Gemma are accompanied by Mike, a seasoned expert in behavior detection with a background in federal government operations. Mike brings his expertise to the table, illuminating the conversation with insights into the nuances of human behavior under the lens of scrutiny. His personal recount of a traumatic upbringing in a Catholic school system, marred by harsh discipline, sets the stage for a deeper understanding of the psychological aftermath of such environments.As the conversation delves into the technical aspects of behavior detection, Mike elucidates the subtle yet telling signs that may indicate deception, stress, or fear...2020-03-2534 min
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep66: Sister Cathy, Unmasking Deception – The Language of Lies, Part 1Shane and Gemma are accompanied by Mike, a seasoned expert in behavior detection with a background in federal government operations. Mike brings his expertise to the table, illuminating the conversation with insights into the nuances of human behavior under the lens of scrutiny. His personal recount of a traumatic upbringing in a Catholic school system, marred by harsh discipline, sets the stage for a deeper understanding of the psychological aftermath of such environments.As the conversation delves into the technical aspects of behavior detection, Mike elucidates the subtle yet telling signs that may indicate deception, stress, or fear...2020-03-1141 min
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep65: The Fight for Justice – The Hidden Predator Act 2020, Part 2In a compelling deviation from its regular format, this episode presents an immersive audio experience direct from the legislative heart of Maryland. This episode departs from the familiar voices of Shane and Gemma, instead channeling the raw advocacy and powerful testimonies that resonated through the halls of Annapolis on February 20th, during the hearing for the Hidden Predator Act of 2020.The episode captures the fervent arguments presented by survivors Teresa Lancaster and Jean Wehner, alongside other courageous individuals and specialists, who stand united on the legislative floor. Their voices echo the distress and determination of countless survivors seeking...2020-03-041h 00
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep64: The Fight for Justice – The Hidden Predator Act 2020, Part 1In a compelling deviation from its regular format, this episode presents an immersive audio experience direct from the legislative heart of Maryland. This episode departs from the familiar voices of Shane and Gemma, instead channeling the raw advocacy and powerful testimonies that resonated through the halls of Annapolis on February 20th, during the hearing for the Hidden Predator Act of 2020.The episode captures the fervent arguments presented by survivors Teresa Lancaster and Jean Wehner, alongside other courageous individuals and specialists, who stand united on the legislative floor. Their voices echo the distress and determination of countless survivors seeking...2020-02-261h 11
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep63: Sister Cathy, Voices Unheard – Listener Q&A, Part 3Shane and Gemma open the floor to the audience, addressing the many questions submitted by dedicated listeners over the series' run. This episode marks the first in a trilogy where the hosts connect with their audience on a personal level, discussing the multifaceted aspects of Sister Cathy's case and the haunting legacy it leaves behind.The episode serves as a platform for inquiry and understanding, where Shane and Gemma bring their investigative insight to bear on the complexities and nuances of the case. They tackle a wide array of questions, ranging from the specifics of the night of...2020-02-1227 min
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep62: Sister Cathy, Voices Unheard – Listener Q&A, Part 2Shane and Gemma open the floor to the audience, addressing the many questions submitted by dedicated listeners over the series' run. This episode marks the first in a trilogy where the hosts connect with their audience on a personal level, discussing the multifaceted aspects of Sister Cathy's case and the haunting legacy it leaves behind.The episode serves as a platform for inquiry and understanding, where Shane and Gemma bring their investigative insight to bear on the complexities and nuances of the case. They tackle a wide array of questions, ranging from the specifics of the night of...2020-01-2924 min
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep61: Sister Cathy, Voices Unheard – Listener Q&A, Part 1In a special interactive session of Foul Play: Crime Series, "Sister Cathy, Voices Unheard – Listener Q&A, Part 1," hosts Shane and Gemma open the floor to the audience, addressing the many questions submitted by dedicated listeners over the series' run. This episode marks the first in a trilogy where the hosts connect with their audience on a personal level, discussing the multifaceted aspects of Sister Cathy's case and the haunting legacy it leaves behind.The episode serves as a platform for inquiry and understanding, where Shane and Gemma bring their investigative insight to bear on the complexities and nu...2020-01-2228 min
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep60: Confronting the Unspeakable – Child Abuse and Recovery"Sister Cathy, Confronting the Unspeakable – Child Abuse and Recovery," is a profound episode, where Shane and Gemma are joined by Kate MacDowell, a seasoned expert in trauma therapy. Kate brings a wealth of knowledge to the table, with 26 years in the field and an academic background that solidifies her expertise. Her personal journey as a survivor of child sexual abuse within the Archdiocese of Minnesota lends an authentic voice to the dialogue, resonating with the gravitas of lived experience.Throughout the episode, the trio tackles the difficult topics head-on, discussing the complex nature of pedophilia as a psychiatric di...2020-01-1530 min
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep59: Sister Cathy, The Examiner's Tale – A Forensic ReckoningIn a unique solo episode of Foul Play: Crime Series, "Sister Cathy, The Examiner's Tale – A Forensic Reckoning," Gemma conducts a rare and insightful interview with Dr. Werner Spitz, the renowned forensic pathologist whose expertise has illuminated some of the most challenging cases in recent history. Dr. Spitz's role as the Medical Examiner for Baltimore at the time of Sister Cathy's murder places him in a unique position to shed light on the cold facts that speak volumes in silence.Dr. Spitz unravels the grim details of Sister Cathy's murder, providing a meticulous forensic analysis of the injuries su...2020-01-0828 min
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep57: Sister Cathy, Decoding the Cover-Up, Part 4Shane welcomes back investigative reporter Tom Nugent to peel back the layers of conspiracy surrounding the Sister Cathy case. With Gemma absent from this episode, Shane and Tom engage in a probing dialogue that ventures deep into the heart of Baltimore's darkest histories, uncovering threads of corruption, church complicity, and law enforcement's enigmatic role in sprawling political scandals.The episode begins with a forensic puzzle: a cigarette butt found at a crime scene, which, after DNA analysis, has failed to directly implicate Father Maskell. Yet, the discussion quickly transcends this singular clue to question Maskell's broader role in...2020-01-0130 min
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep56: Sister Cathy, Decoding the Cover-Up, Part 3In part three of an incisive three-part series, Shane welcomes back investigative reporter Tom Nugent to peel back the layers of conspiracy surrounding the Sister Cathy case. With Gemma absent from this episode, Shane and Tom engage in a probing dialogue that ventures deep into the heart of Baltimore's darkest histories, uncovering threads of corruption, church complicity, and law enforcement's enigmatic role in sprawling political scandals.The episode begins with a forensic puzzle: a cigarette butt found at a crime scene, which, after DNA analysis, has failed to directly implicate Father Maskell. Yet, the discussion quickly transcends this...2019-12-1138 min
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep55: Sister Cathy, Decoding the Cover-Up, Part 2In part two of an incisive three-part series, Shane welcomes back investigative reporter Tom Nugent to peel back the layers of conspiracy surrounding the Sister Cathy case. With Gemma absent from this episode, Shane and Tom engage in a probing dialogue that ventures deep into the heart of Baltimore's darkest histories, uncovering threads of corruption, church complicity, and law enforcement's enigmatic role in sprawling political scandals.The episode begins with a forensic puzzle: a cigarette butt found at a crime scene, which, after DNA analysis, has failed to directly implicate Father Maskell. Yet, the discussion quickly transcends this...2019-12-0425 min
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep54: Sister Cathy, Decoding the Cover-Up, Part 1In part one of an incisive three-part series, Shane welcomes back investigative reporter Tom Nugent to peel back the layers surrounding the Sister Cathy case. With Gemma absent from this episode, Shane and Tom engage in a probing dialogue that ventures deep into the heart of Baltimore's darkest histories, uncovering threads of corruption, church complicity, and law enforcement's enigmatic role in sprawling political scandals.The episode begins with a forensic puzzle: a cigarette butt found at a crime scene, which, after DNA analysis, has failed to directly implicate Father Maskell. Yet, the discussion quickly transcends this singular clue...2019-11-2041 min
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep53: Sister Cathy, Reflections of a LegacyToday's solemn episode marks the passage of five decades since the world was robbed of a compassionate soul. Hosts Shane and Gemma invite listeners to join in a moment of reflection, honoring the life of Sister Cathy Cesnik, who left her Carriage House Apartment for the last time 50 years ago. This episode is not about the mystery of her death but a celebration of her life, which blossomed with aspirations and impacted many.In this heartfelt tribute, we hear intimate anecdotes and remembrances from those who knew Cathy best—her friends and former students. Their stories weave a ta...2019-11-0823 min
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep52: Sister Cathy, The Hunter - Unearthing the UnthinkableShane and Gemma sit down with George Brown, the man who stumbled upon the grim scene that would reignite the search for justice in Sister Cathy's case. George's narrative is not just one of happenstance; it is a crucial piece of the puzzle in understanding the events surrounding Sister Cathy's death.George recounts his life with clarity, providing a backdrop to the day he found Sister Cathy's body. He corrects common misconceptions reported in the media about his whereabouts and actions on that fateful day. With an intricate recounting of his varied jobs and residences, George paints a...2019-10-3029 min
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep51: Sister Cathy, Tom Nugent - A Journalist's Quest, Part 2Shane and Gemma are joined by veteran journalist Tom Nugent, who brings his investigative acumen to the perplexing case of Sister Cathy Cesnik. With a career dedicated to uncovering the layers of truth in complex narratives, Nugent's involvement in the case provides an invaluable perspective to the series' relentless quest for justice and understanding.Throughout this first part of a two-episode dialogue, Shane, Gemma, and Nugent delve into the many facets of Sister Cathy's investigation, examining the pervasive abuse within the Maryland religious community and the clergy's harrowing betrayals. They explore the intricate web of silence that has...2019-10-0928 min
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep50: Sister Cathy, Tom Nugent - A Journalist's Quest, Part 1In this milestone 50th episode in Sister Cathy's series, Shane and Gemma are joined by veteran journalist Tom Nugent, who brings his investigative acumen to the perplexing case of Sister Cathy Cesnik. With a career dedicated to uncovering the layers of truth in complex narratives, Nugent's involvement in the case provides an invaluable perspective to the series' relentless quest for justice and understanding.Throughout this first part of a two-episode dialogue, Shane, Gemma, and Nugent delve into the many facets of Sister Cathy's investigation, examining the pervasive abuse within the Maryland religious community and the clergy's harrowing betrayals...2019-10-0238 min
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep49: Sister Cathy, Beyond the Veil – A Nun's Choice, Part 2In this episode Gemma and Shane continue their evocative conversation with Sr. Rose Pacatte about the profound implications of Sister Cathy Cesnik's decision to leave the convent before her untimely death. Sr. Rose, a discerning voice on matters of faith and a seasoned scholar in media studies, provides an informed perspective on the life Sister Cathy chose to step away from, as well as the possible motivations and consequences of such a life-altering choice.This episode journeys into the heart of convent life, guided by Sr. Rose's expertise and the hosts' poignant inquiries. They discuss the nuances of...2019-09-2536 min
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep48: Sister Cathy, Beyond the Veil – A Nun's Choice, Part 1Gemma and Shane engage in an evocative conversation with Sr. Rose Pacatte about the profound implications of Sister Cathy Cesnik's decision to leave the convent before her untimely death. Sr. Rose, a discerning voice on matters of faith and a seasoned scholar in media studies, provides an informed perspective on the life Sister Cathy chose to step away from, as well as the possible motivations and consequences of such a life-altering choice.This episode journeys into the heart of convent life, guided by Sr. Rose's expertise and the hosts' poignant inquiries. They discuss the nuances of commitment and...2019-09-1827 min
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep47: Sister Cathy, The Redacted Truths – MKUltra's ChildrenIn the wake of the profound and unsettling revelations of the previous episode, this episode finds Shane poring over a document that pulls back the curtain on the chilling practices of the CIA's MKUltra program. This week, Shane brings to light a redacted CIA document from 1951, detailing experiments on two young girls—a stark reminder of the program's reach and the innocence it consumed.With a solemn warning for the potentially triggering content ahead, Shane reads excerpts that describe the manipulation of these children into a trance-like state, with the grim objective of achieving complete amnesia post-experimentation. This pr...2019-09-1113 min
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep46: Sister Cathy, A Survivor's Account – Unveiling MKUltra, Part 2In an exceptionally stirring episode, Shane and Gemma sit with Lynn, a survivor whose life story challenges the very bedrock of trust we place in our institutions. Lynn's chilling account of abuse spans the gamut from family betrayal to being a pawn in what she describes as a government-sanctioned nightmare. Her testimony aligns with the darkest aspects of Father Maskell's legacy, intertwining with the murky depths of the MKUltra program.Lynn articulates a tale of survival against unspeakable acts of physical, psychological, and sexual torture. She divulges the cruel reality of being manipulated into dissociation, a forced fragmentation...2019-09-0436 min
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep45: Sister Cathy, A Survivor's Account – Unveiling MKUltra, Part 1In an exceptionally stirring episode of Foul Play: Crime Series, Sister Cathy, A Survivor's Account – Unveiling MKUltra, Shane and Gemma sit with Lynn, a survivor whose life story challenges the very bedrock of trust we place in our institutions. Lynn's chilling account of abuse spans the gamut from family betrayal to being a pawn in what she describes as a government-sanctioned nightmare. Her testimony aligns with the darkest aspects of Father Maskell's legacy, intertwining with the murky depths of the MKUltra program.Lynn articulates a tale of survival against unspeakable acts of physical, psychological, and sexual torture. She di...2019-08-2827 min
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep44: Sister Cathy, Shadow of Doubt – MKUltra and Memory, Part 2In part two of a revealing two-part dialogue, Shane and Gemma engage with Dr. Colin Ross to explore a controversial question: Could Father Maskell have been a participant in the CIA's MKUltra program? Dr. Ross, whose expertise in dissociation and trauma-related disorders is recognized worldwide, brings a wealth of knowledge to this enigmatic inquiry. His extensive research and clinical experience provide the groundwork for a discussion on the notorious MKUltra program and its potential connections to the abuse allegations surrounding Father Maskell.As the founder and President of The Colin A. Ross Institute for Psychological Trauma, Dr. Ross...2019-08-0745 min
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep43: Sister Cathy, Shadow of Doubt – MKUltra and Memory, Part 1In part one of a revealing two-part dialogue, Shane and Gemma engage with Dr. Colin Ross to explore a controversial question: Could Father Maskell have been a participant in the CIA's MKUltra program? Dr. Ross, whose expertise in dissociation and trauma-related disorders is recognized worldwide, brings a wealth of knowledge to this enigmatic inquiry. His extensive research and clinical experience provide the groundwork for a discussion on the notorious MKUltra program and its potential connections to the abuse allegations surrounding Father Maskell.As the founder and President of The Colin A. Ross Institute for Psychological Trauma, Dr. Ross...2019-07-3126 min
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep42: Sister Cathy, The Legal Labyrinth – The Doe Roe Case, Part 2In part two of this two-part episode, Wallace opens up about the Doe Roe trial, where disturbing allegations of sexual abuse within a Catholic institution came to the fore. Her articulate and insightful recounting of the case's trajectory offers listeners a rare glimpse into the complexities of legal warfare against a backdrop of systemic abuse and cover-ups.Shane and Gemma facilitate a riveting question and answer session with Wallace, whose detailed narrative encompasses the hurdles of pursuing justice in a system often resistant to confronting such painful truths. The conversation pivots to Wallace's vital role in the Netflix...2019-07-2425 min
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep41: Sister Cathy, The Legal Labyrinth – The Doe Roe Case, Part 1This episode marks a gripping new chapter in Foul Play: Crime Series, as Shane and Gemma welcome a special guest, Attorney Beverly Wallace, to shed light on one of Maryland's most contentious legal battles. In part one of this two-part episode, Wallace opens up about the Doe Roe trial, where disturbing allegations of sexual abuse within a Catholic institution came to the fore. Her articulate and insightful recounting of the case's trajectory offers listeners a rare glimpse into the complexities of legal warfare against a backdrop of systemic abuse and cover-ups.Shane and Gemma facilitate a riveting question...2019-07-1726 min
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep40: Sister Cathy, Shattered Minds - The Psychology of Abuse, Part 3In this third installment of a compelling three-part series, our hosts Shane and Gemma delve into the complex psychological terrain of abuse with Dr. Ellen Lacter, an expert on the harrowing effects of extreme and ritual abuse. This episode offers a sobering look at the mechanisms of dissociation, a survival strategy for victims during overwhelming trauma, and how these fractures in consciousness can echo through a lifetime of aftereffects. Dr. Lacter's insights into the psychological responses to abuse – from the body's automatic reactions to the enduring inner turmoil of self-blame – provide a stark backdrop to the ongoing story of Sister Cath...2019-07-0332 min
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep39: Sister Cathy, Shattered Minds - The Psychology of Abuse, Part 2In this second installment of a compelling three-part series, our hosts Shane and Gemma delve into the complex psychological terrain of abuse with Dr. Ellen Lacter, an expert on the harrowing effects of extreme and ritual abuse. This episode offers a sobering look at the mechanisms of dissociation, a survival strategy for victims during overwhelming trauma, and how these fractures in consciousness can echo through a lifetime of aftereffects. Dr. Lacter's insights into the psychological responses to abuse – from the body's automatic reactions to the enduring inner turmoil of self-blame – provide a stark backdrop to the ongoing story of Sister Cath...2019-06-2637 min
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep38: Sister Cathy, Shattered Minds - The Psychology of Abuse, Part 1In this first installment of a compelling three-part series, our hosts Shane and Gemma delve into the complex psychological terrain of abuse with Dr. Ellen Lacter, an expert on the harrowing effects of extreme and ritual abuse. This episode offers a sobering look at the mechanisms of dissociation, a survival strategy for victims during overwhelming trauma, and how these fractures in consciousness can echo through a lifetime of aftereffects. Dr. Lacter's insights into the psychological responses to abuse – from the body's automatic reactions to the enduring inner turmoil of self-blame – provide a stark backdrop to the ongoing story of Sister Cath...2019-06-1940 min
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep37: Sister Cathy, Echoes of a PremonitionIn this haunting episode of Foul Play: Crime Series, titled "Sister Cathy, Echoes of a Premonition," hosts Shane and Gemma, along with their friends Wendy and Gray, revisit the chilling and unsolved murder of Sister Cathy Cesnik. As a beloved figure at Western High School in Baltimore City, Cathy's disappearance and subsequent murder have long cast a shadow over the community. Shane and Gemma probe the perplexing details of the case, including a startling revelation from Juliana, a former student, who shares her eerie dream that mirrored the events of Cathy's abduction.As they peel back the layers...2019-06-1234 min
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep36: Sister Cathy, The Unsolved Murder of Joyce MaleckiIn this episode, listeners are invited to join a poignant and profound conversation as Shane and Gemma welcome the family of Joyce Malecki to the show. The episode takes a detour from the central narrative to shed light on a case that, while overshadowed by the enigmatic figure of Sister Cathy, is intertwined with the same web of mystery.The murder of Joyce Malecki, just days after Sister Cathy Cesnik's disappearance, has languished in the annals of unsolved crimes for decades. This episode seeks to amplify the voices of the Malecki family, bringing their story, their pain, and...2019-06-0542 min
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep35: Sister Cathy, Yelling in the NightThis episode beckons listeners into the haunting echo of an unsolved past. Join hosts Shane and Gemma as they sit down with Mary Spence, a former student of Archbishop Keough High School, who on the night of Sister Cathy Cesnik's disappearance heard something that would haunt the corridors of her memory for decades to come.In "Episode 35 - Yelling in the Night," Mary transports listeners back to that cold November evening, her narrative imbued with the unsettling clarity of a moment frozen in time. The sound of yelling that night—a startling disruption in an otherwise quiet neighborhood—may...2019-05-2951 min
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep34: Sister Cathy, Echoes of the PastIn this episode, we take our audience on a solemn journey through the landmarks tied to the haunting mystery of Sister Cathy Cesnik's disappearance. Hosts Shane and Gemma transform narrative into experience as they walk the ground that has borne silent witness to the unresolved case.Join the hosts as they navigate the geography of a tragedy, beginning with the Carriage House Apartment complex—a site enshrined in infamy as Sister Cathy's last known residence before her disappearance. Listeners will hear vivid descriptions and on-site observations, adding layers of depth to the story only tangible through physical presence.2019-05-2248 min
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep33: Sister Cathy, The Mystery of the Evidence Box, Part 2This episode brings a new dimension to the puzzling tale of the mystery of the box of evidence. Co-hosts Shane and Gemma sit down to dissect the perplexing events that left listeners on the edge of their seats in a critical follow-up to last week's narrative.Joining them is a special guest, known as 'Jane the phone lady,' who found herself at the center of what was revealed to be a complex scam involving a supposed box of evidence critical to the Sister Cathy Cesnik case. This session is dedicated to unpacking the aftermath of the "box...2019-05-1557 min
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep32: Sister Cathy, The Mystery of the Evidence Box, Part 1Episode 32 - "Sister Cathy: The Mystery of the Evidence Box" revisits a captivating lead in the Sister Cathy Cesnik investigation that took us on an unexpected journey of discovery. In this special release, co-hosts Shane and Gemma retrace their steps following a lead spurred by the release of "The Keepers," which led them to 'Kelly the Box Girl' and a potential trove of hidden evidence.The episode is a repackaging of two pivotal but archived episodes from February 2018, made readily accessible for new and returning listeners alike. The original broadcasts document Shane and Gemma's intense search for a...2019-05-0836 min
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep31: Sister Cathy, The Crusade for JusticeIn this episode, we turn the spotlight on a significant legislative development in the fight against child sexual abuse. This groundbreaking episode delves into the details of House Bill 687 — The Hidden Predator Act of 2019 — and its potential to change the legal landscape for survivors of child sex abuse in Maryland.Listeners will be taken to the heart of Annapolis, Maryland, as Shane and Gemma share an impassioned and powerful speech by House Delegate CT Wilson, a staunch advocate of the bill and a survivor himself. His advocacy is not just political; it's deeply personal. Those who have watched "The...2019-05-0141 min
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep30: Sister Cathy, Secrets of the Sacred GroundsIn this episode, co-hosts Shane and Gemma delve into the macabre revelations unearthed at Holy Cross cemetery—a site that turned from sacred to profane by the deeds of Father Joseph Maskell. Listeners will be drawn into the grim narrative of the cemetery dig, a pivotal moment when the buried secrets of Maskell's past were literally dug up.The episode discusses how, guided by the accounts of survivors, authorities excavated areas of the cemetery to uncover evidence that Maskell may have disposed of incriminating materials, including boxes filled with pornography and psychological tests, beneath the guise of hallowed gr...2019-04-2434 min
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep29: Sister Cathy, The Timeline, Part 2This episode continues to trace the chilling timeline surrounding Sister Cathy Cesnik's disappearance, now focusing on the critical period when Father Joseph Maskell was extracted from Archbishop Keough High School amid rising abuse allegations. Co-hosts Shane and Gemma guide listeners through the murky waters of the aftermath, where whispers of corruption and cover-ups begin to find their voice.We scrutinize the actions taken by the authorities and the church during this tumultuous time, seeking answers to how these events may connect to Sister Cathy's story and the ripple effects they had on the community and potential witnesses. As...2019-04-1735 min
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep28: Sister Cathy, The Timeline, Part 1In this episode, co-hosts Shane and Gemma meticulously construct the timeline of events preceding the baffling disappearance of Sister Cathy Cesnik. Piecing together a chronology that has perplexed investigators for decades, we embark on a journey through time, tracing Sister Cathy's last known movements and the enigmatic days leading up to her vanishing.Shane and Gemma sift through the sequence of events with forensic precision, examining the subtleties and possible connections between Sister Cathy's daily routine and the dark undercurrents that may have led to her fate. By delving into the details of those pivotal days, we aim...2019-04-1039 min
Foul Play: Crime SeriesSister Cathy, Part 19.2 : Q&A with Gemma and Shane [Part 2]PART 2: Gemma and Shane discuss the case, as well as answer questions that listeners have sent in.Visit us online at itsfoulplay.comYou can support our show at Patreon.com/itsfoulplayNetflix's 'The Keepers'Survivors' FundFollow and interact with us:Twitter - @thefoulplaypodInstagram - @itsfoulplaypodJoin in on the discussion on our private facebook group:Foul Play - Crime Podcast Discussion GroupSupport the show (https://www.patreon.com/itsfoulplay)2019-03-2756 min
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep25: Sister Cathy, Decades of QuestionsFifty years have elapsed since the tragic murder of Sister Cathy Cesnik, and yet, her killer remains elusive, shrouded in the mist of unresolved history. "Foul Play: Crime Series" presents Episode 25, "Sister Cathy: Decades of Questions," an episode dedicated to addressing the collective inquisitiveness of a community that has followed this case with bated breath.In this episode, co-hosts Gemma Hoskins and Shane Waters open the floor to the audience, responding directly to the flood of listener-submitted questions. Each inquiry sheds light on different facets of the enduring mystery, from the latest updates in the investigation to the...2019-03-2044 min
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep21: Sister Cathy, The Archdiocese Speaks, Part 2In the twenty-first episode of Who Killed Sister Cathy?, we continue our groundbreaking conversation with the Vice-Chancellor of the Archdiocese of Baltimore. This concluding part of our interview delves deeper into the Church's role and responses following Sister Cathy's disappearance and tragic death. Shane Waters and Gemma Hoskins press on with the questions that have lingered for decades, seeking truth and transparency from one of the Church's most guarded institutions. Conducted with sensitivity and respect, this episode aims to pierce the silence that has long shrouded these discussions, pushing for answers and fostering a greater understanding of Sister Cathy's l...2019-02-1335 min
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep20: Sister Cathy, The Archdiocese Speaks, Part 1In the twentieth episode of Who Killed Sister Cathy?, the team takes a monumental step by securing a sit-down interview with a high-ranking official from the Archdiocese of Baltimore. This two-part interview with the Vice-Chancellor is a pivotal moment in our pursuit of answers. Shane Waters and Gemma Hoskins engage in a candid and respectful dialogue, confronting the silence that has overshadowed Sister Cathy's story for decades. With sensitivity to survivors of clergy abuse, this episode addresses difficult truths while navigating the corridors of a complex historical case. Join us for this rare encounter as we challenge the church's n...2019-02-0637 min
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep19: Sister Cathy, Bombshell: Man in the Trench Coat, Part 2In the nineteenth episode of Who Killed Sister Cathy?, we continue our exploration of the chilling tale of Sister Cathy's disappearance. Gemma Hoskins and Shane Waters delve deeper into the narrative, joined by Sharon Bush, whose close connection to Sister Russell offers an intimate perspective on the night Cathy went missing. Sharon recounts her unsettling experiences, including her encounter with an anxious Sister Russell and a determined detective. Through Sharon's harrowing testimony, we glimpse the atmosphere of tension and urgency that shrouded those crucial hours. Join us as we piece together this twisted narrative, seeking answers and hoping for a...2019-01-3049 min
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep18: Sister Cathy, Bombshell: Man in the Trench Coat, Part 1In the eighteenth episode of Who Killed Sister Cathy?, we uncover a shocking new lead—the mysterious figure known as the Man in the Trench Coat. Shane Waters and Gemma Hoskins dive deep into witness testimonies and recently discovered details that suggest this enigmatic figure may hold critical answers to the enduring mystery of Sister Cathy's murder. As the investigation sharpens its focus, this episode provides listeners with a compelling exploration of the elusive figure who seems to stand at the crossroads of deception and truth. Join us as we peel back the layers of this mystery, one revelation at...2019-01-2334 min
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep17: Sister Cathy, Unmasking Darkness with Jane Doe and The Keepers' Director, Part 2In the seventeenth episode of Who Killed Sister Cathy?, we continue our profound discussion with Ryan White and Jean Wehner, who share unparalleled insights into the lasting impact of The Keepers. Director Ryan White reflects on the documentary's contribution to public awareness and the ongoing challenges of seeking justice. Survivor Jean Wehner bravely details her journey from Jane Doe to a powerful advocate, offering an intimate look at the personal cost of breaking the silence. Shane Waters and Gemma Hoskins lead this critical dialogue, fostering reflection, understanding, and ongoing advocacy. Join us in unraveling the complex web of deceit an...2019-01-1632 min
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep16: Sister Cathy, Unmasking Darkness with Jane Doe and The Keepers' Director, Part 1In the sixteenth episode of Who Killed Sister Cathy?, we welcome Ryan White, the director of The Keepers, and Jean Wehner, whose courageous testimony as Jane Doe became a beacon for truth and justice. Shane Waters and Gemma Hoskins guide a deeply revealing discussion that takes listeners behind the scenes of documenting one of the most harrowing true crime stories and uncovers the ongoing impact of Jean's advocacy. This episode is more than a recount of the past; it is a powerful reminder that the pursuit for justice starts with courage and continues with collective action. Visit its...2019-01-0937 min
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep15: Sister Cathy, Reflections from the PodcastersIn the fifteenth episode of Who Killed Sister Cathy?, hosts Shane Waters and Gemma Hoskins take a step back from the investigation to reflect on their journey. They share the challenges, experiences, and the weight of responsibility involved in giving a voice to those silenced by Sister Cathy's unsolved murder. This candid episode offers listeners an inside look at the podcasting process behind such a complex true crime story and explores the impact of The Keepers documentary on their lives and the case. Join us as we prepare for the next chapter in our journey for truth, while gathering ins...2018-12-2256 min
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep14: Sister Cathy, The Vigilant EducatorIn the fourteenth episode of Who Killed Sister Cathy?, we pay tribute to the profound role teachers play in their students' lives, exploring how they often serve as educators, protectors, and advocates. Sister Cathy was a beacon of hope for her students, embodying the essence of what it means to be an attentive and caring teacher. Through reflections on her legacy, Shane Waters and Gemma Hoskins discuss the vital importance of teachers in safeguarding their students and the lasting impact they have, often in ways they "never know." This episode serves as a reminder of the quiet power of e...2018-12-1947 min
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep13: Sister Cathy, Beyond the BlackboardIn the thirteenth episode of Who Killed Sister Cathy?, we sit down with a former student whose connection to Sister Cathy and Sister Russell went beyond the classroom, offering insights into their lives as mentors and friends. Through heartfelt reflections, we explore the personal character and daily lives of these two influential women, shedding light on their passions, concerns, and the human side often lost in the broader true crime narrative. With Gemma Hoskins's insights and Shane Waters's probing questions, this episode provides an intimate glimpse into the lives of Sister Cathy and Sister Russell, enriching our understanding of t...2018-12-1247 min
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep12: Sister Cathy, The Maskell Paradoxn the eleventh episode of Who Killed Sister Cathy?, we hear from Charles Franz, who bravely breaks decades of silence about the harrowing abuse he endured at the hands of Father Joseph Maskell. Shane Waters and Gemma Hoskins honor Charles' courage as he shares his story—a chilling account of a stolen childhood and the dark reality of trusting those in power. This episode broadens the narrative of Maskell's victims, illuminating the nondiscriminatory nature of his abuses and adding a critical piece to the puzzle of Sister Cathy's case. Join us as we continue to shed light on these sto...2018-12-0552 min
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep11: Sister Cathy, Echoes of SilenceIn the eleventh episode of Who Killed Sister Cathy?, we hear from Charles Franz, who bravely breaks decades of silence about the harrowing abuse he endured at the hands of Father Joseph Maskell. Shane Waters and Gemma Hoskins honor Charles' courage as he shares his story—a chilling account of a stolen childhood and the dark reality of trusting those in power. This episode broadens the narrative of Maskell's victims, illuminating the nondiscriminatory nature of his abuses and adding a critical piece to the puzzle of Sister Cathy's case. Join us as we continue to shed light on these sto...2018-11-2844 min
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep10: Sister Cathy, Voices From the VoidIn the tenth episode of Who Killed Sister Cathy?, Shane Waters and Gemma Hoskins dive into a special Q&A session, where listener questions, theories, and reflections take the spotlight. This episode serves as an interactive conversation, addressing the nuances of the investigation while offering new perspectives and clarifications. As Shane and Gemma dissect the complexities provided by listeners, they deepen our collective understanding of the case, weaving through the labyrinth of Sister Cathy's murder investigation. This episode stands as a testament to the power of community engagement in the relentless pursuit of justice. Visit itsfoulplay.com to...2018-11-2129 min
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep9: Sister Cathy, The Prosecutor's PuzzleIn the ninth episode of Who Killed Sister Cathy?, we delve into the enigmatic decisions of Assistant State Attorney Sharon May, exploring her role in the investigation and the controversial choices that have sparked debate for decades. Joined by guest podcaster Brooke Gittings, Shane Waters and Gemma Hoskins unravel the complexities of prosecutorial discretion and the barriers to justice that clouded Sister Cathy's case. Together, they navigate the intersection of law enforcement, power, and accountability, offering listeners a compelling look at the obstacles faced in prosecuting those accused of abuse. This episode provides a thought-provoking examination of justice delayed a...2018-11-1438 min
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep8: Sister Cathy, Unseen WitnessIn the eighth episode of Who Killed Sister Cathy?, we unravel a perplexing layer of the case involving a shadowy figure from the past—Sharon's Uncle Billy. As Shane Waters and Gemma Hoskins engage in a compelling dialogue with Sharon Schmidt, they explore the mysterious connection between Uncle Billy and Sister Cathy's death. Was he merely an unnoticed observer, or was there more behind his silent presence at the apartment complex? With Cathy's car abandoned nearby, questions arise that challenge what we thought we knew. This episode invites listeners to question the nature of observation, memory, and the reliability of...2018-11-0741 min
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep7: Sister Cathy, The Courage of Jane RoeIn the seventh episode of Who Killed Sister Cathy?, we explore the courageous legal battles of Jane Roe and Jane Doe as they sought justice against Father Joseph Maskell despite the state's refusal to press criminal charges. Hosts Shane Waters and Gemma Hoskins delve into the complexities of the civil lawsuits, highlighting the immense bravery required for survivors to confront both their past abusers and the institutions that protected them. This episode honors the resilience of those who demanded accountability, despite systemic barriers and a culture of silence.Visit itsfoulplay.com to stay engaged in our ongoing inv...2018-10-311h 04
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep6: Sister Cathy, The Shadow NetworkIn the sixth episode of Who Killed Sister Cathy?, we explore the sinister depths of Father Joseph Maskell's actions, focusing on the abuses of power that led to an extensive cover-up within Baltimore's institutions. Hosts Shane Waters and Gemma Hoskins dig deep into Maskell's disturbing past, unraveling the lies and manipulation that allowed him to evade justice for so long. With new voices and chilling revelations, this episode brings Maskell's dark legacy into the light, shedding awareness on the systemic failures that permitted his crimes to continue. Join us as we reveal the unsettling truth and honor those who h...2018-10-241h 06
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep5: Sister Cathy, Donna's Silent StruggleIn our fifth episode of Who Killed Sister Cathy?, we hear the courageous story of Donna Vondenbosch, who survived the manipulative control of Father Joseph Maskell. As a young victim, Donna faced unimaginable threats designed to enforce her silence, including Maskell's chilling warning that speaking out could cost her life. Now a Nurse Practitioner, Donna bravely recounts her journey of breaking through the fear, reclaiming her voice, and transforming her pain into hope. Join hosts Shane Waters and Gemma Hoskins as they navigate Donna's story with care, honoring her resilience while exposing the sinister tactics used to keep the t...2018-10-171h 00
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep4: Sister Cathy, Unearthing Truths with Bob ErlandsonIn the fourth episode of Who Killed Sister Cathy?, investigative journalist Bob Erlandson joins Shane Waters and Gemma Hoskins to delve into the tangled web of corruption, abuse, and cover-ups surrounding Sister Cathy Cesnik's unsolved murder. Erlandson's experience provides unique insights into the complex relationships between the media, law enforcement, and the church, exposing how power structures have long silenced the truth. This episode sheds light on the tireless pursuit of justice, honoring those who have fought to bring hidden stories to the surface.Visit itsfoulplay.com to follow our ongoing investigation.Support this pod...2018-10-101h 28
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep3: Sister Cathy, Cindy's Courageous JourneyIn the third episode of our gripping series, Who Killed Sister Cathy?, we share the resilient story of Cindy Lovell, who bravely recounts her years of torment under Father Joseph Maskell at Archbishop Keough High School. Cindy's experiences reflect institutional failure and the silencing of survivors, but her voice is now ready to emerge. Hosts Shane Waters and Gemma Hoskins guide this difficult conversation, underscoring the significance of Cindy's transformation from victim to survivor. Join us as we lend our ears to Cindy's inspiring journey and continue the fight for justice for Sister Cathy. Visit itsfoulplay.com to f...2018-10-031h 12
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep2: Sister Cathy, Schmidt Family ShadowsIn our second episode of Who Killed Sister Cathy?, we continue to peel back the layers of the unsettling truths surrounding the murder of Sister Catherine Cesnik. This episode dives into the voices of those closest to her, revealing details about her life and the days leading up to her disappearance that had never been fully explored. Co-hosts Gemma Hoskins and Shane Waters introduce new perspectives and revisit pivotal moments that shine a light on the possible motives and key individuals who were part of the complex and chilling web surrounding Sister Cathy. With testimonies that challenge what we t...2018-09-2635 min
Marta on the Move Podcast"The Keepers" Researcher Gemma Hoskins Talks About The Murder of Cathy CesnikGemma Hoskins From "The Keepers" on Netflix This is the lead up to Halloween in which I feature different themes revolving around this holiday. Stories about facing your fears, spooky stories, psychics, magic, murder, and more have been featured, and I could not wait to release this episode. There was once a suggestion on Netflix given to me by a friend, that suggestion was a documentary called “The Keepers”. I had no clue what the show was about, but trusted the source and one weekend while I was ill decided to binge it. I was instantly hooked. Where do I even st...2018-09-2351 min
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS2 Ep1: Sister Cathy, The Silenced TruthIn our opening episode of Who Killed Sister Cathy?, we begin the search for answers in one of Baltimore's most haunting mysteries: the unsolved murder of Sister Catherine Cesnik. As co-hosts Gemma Hoskins and Shane Waters revisit the case, they bring fresh eyes to old evidence and reveal new insights that take listeners beyond what was shown in Netflix's The Keepers. Together, they engage with both familiar voices and new ones, uncovering deeper layers to a story shrouded in cover-ups, power, and the tragic cost of silence. This isn't just a retelling; it's an unyielding pursuit of justice for Si...2018-09-1751 min
Foul Play: Crime Series'The Keepers' search for Kelly 'The box girl', Part 2If you haven't listened to the first episode Gemma Hoskins and I created two weeks ago, please go back and listen before listening to this! This is an important update to hear, after our search for the lead on the box of evidence in Sister Cathy's murder. "The Keepers" is a Netflix Documentary series that Gemma Hoskins is featured in as one of the two grassroots amateur detectives who refuses to let the murder of Sister Cathy die from the public eye. Disclaimer: This podcast episode has no affiliation with Tripod Media or Netflix Visit us online at itsfoulplay.comYou ca...2018-02-1613 minFoul Play: Crime Series'The Keepers' search for Kelly 'The box girl', Part 1Shane teams up with Gemma Hoskins, featured on 'The Keepers', to find Kelly 'the box girl'. Visit us online at itsfoulplay.comYou can support our show at Patreon.com/itsfoulplayFollow and interact with us:Twitter - @thefoulplaypodInstagram - @itsfoulplaypodJoin in on the discussion on our private facebook group:Foul Play - Crime Podcast Discussion Group Support the show (https://www.patreon.com/itsfoulplay)2018-02-0326 min
Foul Play: Crime SeriesS1 Ep3: Throwaways: Viral JusticeIn episode three of "Throwaways: Viral Justice," we explore the ripple effect of storytelling and its power to resurrect cold cases from the silence of the archives to the forefront of public attention. This chapter begins with Shane, whose tenacious research into the forgotten case of the Barbourville Jane Doe ignited a spark of interest across the communities tethered to the Bible Belt's local media. As Shane's narrative found its way onto Foul Play, it wasn't long before the tale of the unsolved murder began to reverberate through the corridors of small-town newsrooms and onto the screens...2014-01-0420 min