Shows
The Gordy Bonker ShowEvolution of Collectibles and Sports Cards with Brandon SteinerBrandon Steiner joins Gordy Bonker for today's episode of The Gordy Bonker Show to discuss his storied career in the collectibles industry. Brandon started doing player marketing before a partnership with the Yankees changed everything and ultimately evolved into Yankees-Steiner Collectibles and led him to additional partnerships with Notre Dame University, the Dallas Cowboys, Madison Square Garden and more. Now, he's Founder and CEO of CollectibleXchange, offering collectors exclusive collections.
Gordy and Brandon discussed how the collectibles and sports cards industries have evolved, being careful of fakes, his new project with the Buffalo Bills' Highmark Stadium demolition, and affordability...
2025-11-2536 minThe Gordy Bonker ShowHow to Build a COMPLETE Vintage SetIn this episode of The Gordy Bonker Show, Gordy dives deep into the art of vintage set collecting as he gets set to sell his own 1957 Topps set.
Gordy also shares details from his recent visit to the Jackie Robinson Museum before discussing this week's Card of the Week, the 1934 Goudey Lou Gehrig PSA 7, and why it's a standout piece in any collection.
Gordy also shares his expert tips on building a vintage set, from choosing the right set based on budget and goals to sourcing cards efficiently. Leave a comment to let us know...
2025-11-1931 minThe Gordy Bonker ShowThe MOST VALUABLE Negro Leagues Card Ever SoldGordy Bonker sits down with Jonah Dice, a renowned vintage card collector known on Instagram as @JD9cards.
Jonah shares his journey from a young collector to acquiring some of the most coveted vintage baseball cards, including the rare 1952 J.J.K. postcard of Hank Aaron in his Indianapolis Clowns uniform. This card, one of only two known to exist, is a significant piece in the hobby, marking the highest-selling Negro League card of all time.
Jonah discusses the strategic decisions behind his acquisitions, including the sale of other high-value cards like a signed 1954 Hank Aaron rookie card and...
2025-11-1238 min
The Gordy Bonker ShowExplaining My Next Vintage Card Set Break, Mental Health JourneyIt's been a wild last few weeks in the sports card hobby from the Babe Ruth card that dropped $3 million in value to the Upper Deck president's comments on the future of the hobby, the Fanatics/Panini fake news and SGC's numbers continuing to fall. In this week's episode of The Gordy Bonker Show, Gordy breaks down all the latest news and his opinions on the headlines as a vintage card collector.
Then, today's episode centers around Gordy's next vintage set break, which is the 1957 Topps Vintage complete set break. If you don't know what a vintage set break...
2025-11-0536 minThe Gordy Bonker ShowThe Future of Sports Card and Collectibles DisplaysThis week's episode of The Gordy Bonker Show is a special one featuring M1NT founder, Brian Pirrip. To listen to the full interview, be sure to check out the podcast on Spotify or Apple Podcasts. We had some recording difficulties so the interview is abbreviated here in video form.
This week's Card of the Week is a 1949 Bowman Jackie Robinson, which has been on Gordy's radar for over a year. He shared a ton of great insight on the card.
Be sure to leave a comment letting us...
2025-10-291h 10
Ball Card ShowSeason 5 Episode 36 - Gordy Bonker Joins The Ballcard ShowGordy Bonker from Bonkers Cards joins for a great discussion on the vintage card appeal, scaling a card business, and brokering the sale of a '52 Mantle for over 1 million dollars. Be sure to follow bonkers cards on Tik Tok where he has a live vintage show every Sunday evening, and tune into The Gordy Bonker Show where you get podcasts. Follow The Ballcard Show on socials and see full video episodes @theballcardshowBusiness Inquiries: ballcardshow@gmail.com
2025-10-241h 11The Gordy Bonker ShowWhy Pokemon Cards Are Exploding in Value, Collecting for MemoriesLife-long collector Tyler Schmitt joins today's Gordy Bonker Show to share why he collects, what he collects and how Pokemon cards are exploding in popularity. Tyler works for Gary Vaynerchuk aka Gary Vee as the VP of Core Relationships and hosts Card Talk, covering all things cards and collectibles. He shares all the details on how and what he collects for memories, from a Phantom of the Opera ticket to a random rock. He also collects First Edition Pokemon cards.
Why does Tyler think Pokemon card popularity is getting so big? It may have...
2025-10-221h 13
ALL IN MiamiHow a Facebook Post Turned into a Million-Dollar Sports Card DealYou know those stories that start small—like, “Hey, I saw this Facebook post…” and somehow end with a seven-figure wire transfer?
Yeah, this is one of those.
In today’s episode, we dive into the fascinating world of high-end sports cards—where nostalgia meets private wealth management. Gordy Bonker, a broker in the sports collectibles world, tells the incredible story behind a private sale of a 1952 Topps Mickey Mantle PSA 8—one of the most coveted cards on Earth, often called “The Mona Lisa of the Hobby.”
We’ll explore:
Ho...
2025-10-1726 minThe Gordy Bonker ShowThe Passion Behind Vintage Card Collecting, Featuring Craig JohnsonGordy Bonker sits down with Craig Johnson, a vintage card enthusiast and one of the founding members of The Bonkers Cards Club. Together, they discuss the nuances of collecting baseball Hall of Famers and the stories that make each card special. Craig shares his experiences navigating the card show circuit and the camaraderie found within the collecting community. Tune in for a heartfelt discussion that delves into the passion and dedication behind vintage card collecting that any passionate collector will be able to relate to. Let us know your thoughts on today's episode in the comments and be sure...
2025-10-1538 minThe Gordy Bonker ShowHow I Sold a $1.1 MILLION Vintage Baseball CardIn today's episode, Gordy Bonker shares the behind the scenes and full story of completing the sale on a 1952 Topps Mickey Mantle PSA 8 for more than $1,100,000!
There is a lot to unpack and reflect on when it comes to this specific deal. Not only just the deal itself, but how Gordy positioned himself to execute a deal on a card of this size and significance.
Gordy was fortunate to broker the deal for this all-time iconic card on behalf of a client. It’s the Mona Lisa of the Hobby and th...
2025-10-0826 min
The Gordy Bonker ShowReacting to the Willie Mays Private Collection AuctionOn this week's episode of The Gordy Bonker Show, Gordy is breaking down his thoughts on the Willie Mays personal collection auction that took place at Hunt Auctions. Was this collection marketed effectively, and did the public even know it was happening?
This week's Card of the Week is the 1954 Hank Aaron PSA 8. The Hank Aaron rookie card needs no introduction and its valuation should only go up.
Plus, Gordy discusses investing in memorabilia vs investing in sports cards. Which is more worthwhile and a better investment? Hear the pros and cons straight from Gordy. ...
2025-10-0129 minThe Gordy Bonker ShowTrading Profit for Passion: Going Full-Time in Sports CardsOn this week's episode of The Gordy Bonker Show, Gordy is joined by fellow vintage sports card collector, Jeff Hopkins of Waterfront Sports Cards. They discuss some of their wildest sports card and trading stories, how to become a full-time collector, the importance of networking in the hobby and much more! Jeff also shares insights on his strategies, memorable finds, and future aspirations. Plus, he shares a story about 5xing his money on a major sale of 1950s Bowmans that he found on Facebook! "You never know what you're going to find."
This week's Card of the Week is...
2025-09-2453 min
The Hobby HandbookDebating Vintage vs Modern Sports Cards with Gordy BonkerVintage vs modern sports cards: what's better? We welcome Gordy Bonker from Bonkers Cards to The Hobby Handbook for an in-depth exploration of the debate between modern and vintage collecting. Clever Cuban Cards and Gordy discuss the transition from corporate life to entrepreneurship, the intricacies of content creation in the hobby industry and how to scale in the business.
Gordy also shares his personal journey, insights into the card market, and the challenges of balancing media presence with business operations. Whether you're a collector, investor, or just curious about the hobby, this episode offers a bit of...
2025-09-181h 08
The Gordy Bonker ShowVintage Sports Card Opportunities, Meet Gordy BonkerWelcome to the first episode of The Gordy Bonker Show! In this episode, Gordy gives his sports card hobby background, how he transitioned from corporate life to being a sports card entrepreneur, why he LOVES vintage cards, and what you can expect from this new show.
You can catch new episodes every Wednesday wherever you listen to your podcasts, as well as on the Sports Cards Nonsense YouTube channel.
Let us know what you want to hear about on future episodes! Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
2025-09-1729 min
Sports Cards NonsenseNFL Week 1 Hobby Impact, Fanatics Fest Date Change & Gordy Bonker Joins the ShowNFL Week 1 is in the books, and Jesse Gibson and Mike Gioseffi are here to break down what it means for the hobby. From Aaron Rodgers looking like his 2017 self to Daniel Jones possibly having the best game of his career, the guys sort through which QBs are buys, sells, or completely off the radar (sorry, Cam Ward fans) following Week 1.
They also touch on Justin Fields’ card market, Fanatics Fest updates, and how Ken Griffey Jr. and Michael Jordan collectors are shaping the hobby as their disposable income grows.
Later, Gordy Bonker joins to pr...
2025-09-091h 20
Bangers OnlyMillion-Dollar Mickey MantlesIn this episode of the Bangers Only Podcast, I sit down with Gordy Bonker, the man behind Bonkers Cards, to better understand the vintage sports cards industry.We’re talking million-dollar Mickey Mantles, Honus Wagners worth more than some beachfront homes, and much more.Gordy shares why vintage cards like the 1952 Topps Mickey Mantle and the T206 Honus Wagner may serve as alternative investments in your portfolio.If you’re a collector, an investor, or just love a good story about following your passion, this episode’s for you. Be s...
2025-08-1835 min
Sports Cards LiveBuilding Trust, Avoiding Gimmicks: Bonkers Cards & Mantel on the Hobby Media GamePart 3 of Episode 275 continues the conversation with Gordy Bonker as he shares his philosophy on content creation and community-building in the hobby. From storytelling to education, Gordy explains why he avoids gimmicks and trend-chasing, choosing instead to focus on authenticity, baseball history, and showing the cards with care.
Then, Evan Parker from Mantel joins the conversation, adding insight into how platforms like Mantel aim to support collectors without distorting the experience. The discussion covers content ethics, trust, and how both creators and companies can add real value to the hobby.
It’s a thoughtful look at...
2025-07-1642 minSports Cards LiveIs Vintage Truly the Backbone of the Hobby? + Is the Hobby Bigger Than We Think?In Part 2 of Episode 275, Jeremy Lee, Josh Adams, and guest Gordy Bonker dig deep into what makes vintage cards the true backbone of the hobby. Gordy outlines why nostalgia, cultural relevance, and long-term stability make vintage more than just a niche—and why modern collecting often lacks the same staying power.
We also explore the evolution of Gordy's monthly vintage set breaks, including the mechanics, emotional complexity, and ethical considerations around risk and reward. Plus: a wide-ranging conversation on how massive the sports card hobby actually is—beyond social media bubbles and auction houses—and why so many c...
2025-07-1539 minSports Cards LiveIf the Hobby Feels Like It Sucks... Maybe It's YouWhy collecting with intention matters—and how one collector turned a 1954 Mays into a full-time brand.
We kick off Episode 275 of Sports Cards Live with Jeremy Lee welcoming Josh Adams (Midwest Vintage) as guest co-host in place of the off-gallivanting Joe Poirot. After event previews, including the Road to the National finale, HobbyPalooza, and the Vintage Trade Night at the National we dive into a viral Instagram post that stirred up hobby debate: “If the hobby feels like it sucks... maybe it's you.”
Then, we welcome Gordy Bonker (Bonkers Cards) for a powerful conversation on his jo...
2025-07-1344 minSports Cards NonsenseGordy Bonker on Going Full Time in the Hobby and Connecting With the Younger Audience. Plus, GaryVee Interview Reactions, and Troy Is Dead to Us.Jesse and Mike begin the podcast by discussing their thoughts on the GaryVee interview from Tuesday. Then, they welcome Gordy Bonker, a cards content creator, who discusses leaving a financial career behind to go full time in selling vintage baseball cards. He also talks about the current trends in the vintage card market and the role of TikTok in connecting with younger audiences before he and the guys have a candid discussion about what it takes to make it in this business.
Hosts: Mike Gioseffi and Jesse GibsonGuest: Gordy BonkerProducers: Ben Cruz and...
2025-05-231h 22
Bonkers Cards PodcastBonkers Cards Podcast Episode #10 - feat. Dick Perez & Marq EvansIn this interview I meet with Dick Perez, Baseball HOF artist and artist behind legendary Diamond King baseball cards as well as Marq Evans, Director of the new movie about Dick's life - The Diamond King, coming out later this year.
2024-07-0331 minBonkers Cards PodcastBonkers Cards Episode #9 - Interview with Yankees World Series Champion Jim LeyritzI sat down with Jim Leyritz at the Morris County Card show to talk about his career journey, the hobby, and much more!
2024-05-0612 minBonkers Cards PodcastBonkers Cards Podcast Episode #8 - Interview with REA President Brian Dwyer on Spring Catalog Auction & State of the HobbyBrian Dwyer sits down with Gordy Bonker of Bonkers Cards to discuss our Spring Auction and the strong state of the hobby.
2024-05-0218 minBonkers Cards PodcastBonkers Cards Podcast Episode #7 - Rutgers Star RB Kyle Monangai talks about NIL deals, Bowman Chrome U product and collecting!I sat down with the B10 leading rusher at the February Morris County Card Show and talked about his journey collecting cards, how he has navigated his NIL deals, and this upcoming season in the Big10!
Thank you for listening and please rate and subscribe to the pod!
2024-02-2205 minBonkers Cards PodcastBonkers Cards Podcast Episode #6 - Interview with Tyler Tarver from Tarver CardsLast month at the Culture Collision show in Atlanta I got to sit down with Tyler Tarver from Tarver Cards to talk all about the hobby, his journey creating content, his work experience as an educator and content creator, and so much more.
2024-02-0736 minBonkers Cards PodcastBonkers Cards Podcast Episode #5 - When Baseball Was Still Topps - feat. guest Phil CoffinThis week on the podcast, I am joined by guest Phil Coffin, author of his new book, "When Baseball was still Topps". Phil dives deeper into the inspiration for his book, his career at the NY Times, and drops some awesome baseball history knowledge in our interview!
You can pick up Phil's book here:
https://mcfarlandbooks.com/product/when-baseball-was-still-topps/
Or on Amazon:
https://www.amazon.com/When-Baseball-Was-Still-Topps/dp/1476693943/ref=sr_1_1?crid=27QV7QF65DO4W&keywords=when+baseball+was+still+topps&qid=1702672839&sprefix=When+Baseball+Was+Still+Topps%2...
2023-12-1637 minBonkers Cards PodcastBonkers Cards Podcast Episode #4 - Navigating Card ShowsIn this episode I talk about the card show scene, how I handle negotiating deals at card shows, and the upcoming shows I will be attending this year.
Be sure to be subscribed for more future episodes and subscribe to the website at bonkerscards.co
2023-10-2320 minBonkers Cards PodcastBonkers Cards Podcast Episode #3 - Interview with Brian Dwyer, President of REA Auctions on the upcoming Spring Auction!I met up with the REA team at the Just Collect Shop in Milburn NJ for their pop-up event for their Spring 2023 Auction and had the chance to interview Brian Dwyer, President of REA on the upcoming pieces at auction and the state of the vintage cards and collectibles market.
Check out the full video and be sure to follow the podcast, like, and subscribe to the YouTube channel!
2023-04-1712 minBonkers Cards PodcastBonkers Cards Podcast Episode #2 - The 4 Best Vintage Players to BUY!In this episode I talk about the Topps industry conference, what I’ve been collecting, and who my views are on the best 4 players to invest into for the long term as the hobby expands. Check out this episode on Spotify and YouTube, and be sure to join my Facebook group for more exclusive content and to meet fellow vintage collectors in the community!
2023-03-1211 minBonkers Cards PodcastBonkers Cards Podcast Episode #1 - Introduction and Background of Bonkers CardsIn my intro episode to the Bonkers Cards Podcast, I discuss how I got going in the hobby and how my content has progressed leading into the podcast.
I will post these podcasts weekly on Spotify and Apple Podcasts as well as on my YouTube channel @BonkersCards!
2023-03-0406 min