Shows
Caught Red PawdcastEpisode 101: Sara Anne BushlandAye! Meaghan is on Christmas Break so that means it is time for a couple of new episodes! She is kicking things off with an unsolved case.
Sara Anne Bushland was a 15 year old girl who was last seen at the end of her driveway one afternoon after school. Did she runaway? Was she met with foul play? The family has been asking these questions and many more for nearly 30 years. This case is full of speculations and theories so get ready.2024-12-1754 minCaught Red PawdcastEpisode 100: Buford Pusser vs The State Line MobFrom battling the State Line Mob to avenging his wife's death, Buford Pusser left his mark on Tennessee history before dying in a mysterious car crash. For our 100th episode, we tag team this story. Jesse takes on the story of Buford Pusser and Meaghan goes more in depth about the State Line Mob. 2024-10-241h 29Caught Red PawdcastEpisode 92: Cassie Leigh Cotta*Listener recommendation by Jessica
On today's episode of the Caught Red Pawdcast, Jesse takes us to Fort Smith, Arkansas to tell the story of the fun-loving, free-spirited Cassie Leigh Cotta. By telling Cassie's story, we hope that it'll inspire others to take a stand against domestic violence. One of her favorite phrases was "just keep swimming." 2024-07-251h 05Caught Red PawdcastEpisode 85: Leslie and Mike Mackool, what a killer couple!Back in 2003, a well-loved business owner named Janie Ballard was murdered in her Little Rock home. From looking at the crime scene, it would have appeared that Janie became the victim of a botched robbery. But, was it? 2024-05-0852 minCaught Red PawdcastEpisode 84: Trouble Finds Lee MurrayOn this episode of the Caught Red Pawdcast, joined by a special guest, Jesse tells the story of a talented MMA fighter with all the potential in the world. Unfortunately, trouble just continued to find him. "Lightning" Lee Murray was well on his way to superstardom in the UFC until a series of incidents stopped that momentum in its tracks. With both feet already in the life of crime from a very young age, that's exactly where he turned. On February 21st, 2006, he was involved in the biggest cash heist in UK history.2024-05-022h 07Caught Red PawdcastEpisode 83: Stella NickellThis episode is considered a listener recommendation. One of our Pawd Squawd members sent Meaghan a book!
During the summer of 1986 in the state of Washington, two complete strangers would die from the same thing. One was by accident, the other was intentional. Their deaths would nearly spark a nationwide scare, just like what happened four years prior in another city....
2024-04-251h 16Caught Red PawdcastEpisode 82: Peggy Ann FulfordBetween 2001 and 2014, a number of professional athletes including Dennis Rodman, Ricky Williams, Lex Hilliard, and Rashad McCants put their trust in financial advisor Peggy Ann Fulford to bring them generational wealth. In reality, this hire led to a lot of heart ache and empty bank accounts. Tune in to this episode to find out how!2024-04-1853 minCaught Red PawdcastEpisode 81: The Con Man of LoveFor years, a man named Richard Scott Smith would win over the hearts of numerous women. He would become their dream man, sweeping them off their feet. There was a catch. This man had a secret agenda with every woman he was with. He would mesmerize her then leave her but not before ruining everything that the woman had worked so hard for.
One day, a very scorned woman started a blog about him, which led many of his victims to come together to find him and stop him. With the help of an amazing bounty hunter...2024-04-041h 05Caught Red PawdcastEpisode 80: Keith Jones27-year-old Keith Jones was a Marine Corps veteran and recent police academy graduate from Daytona Beach, Florida. In 1997, he was traveling across Florida stopping at law enforcement agencies in search of a job. He made a detour in Fort Myers to visit an old friend. They spent some time in his motel room, and all was going good until 4 men burst through the door. They robbed him, beat him, and shot him in the head. Was this a random act of violence or had it been planned for days? 2024-03-2751 minCaught Red PawdcastEpisode 79: The Trader Joe's ShootoutSaturday, July 21, 2018 was just another day for the customers shopping at the Silver Lake location of Trader Joe's. Then, all of the sudden, they would hear a crash and gunshots. A man, on the run from the police, would end up taking them hostage inside the store. Because of this man's actions over the course of that day, there will be one fatality. 2024-03-2041 minCaught Red PawdcastEpisode 78: Ann HarrisonOn March 22, 1989, Ann Marie Harrison was a 15-year-old girl who became the victim of two career criminals when they decided to abduct her while she waited on the school bus to pick her up. These two men were involved in several car thefts in the area. They would leave behind their trademark with every car. This would eventually lead the police to identifying them and connecting them to Ann's case. 2024-03-1349 minCaught Red PawdcastEpisode 77: Deja vu at Horseshoe LakeIn 1996, the small town of Horseshoe Lake, Arkansas was shaken by the murders of two of their own. In 2020, another murder occurs, and again, the town is in shock. What makes it strange is that the murders all happened on the property of the famous Snowden House. Are they connected or is it a coincidence?2024-02-2849 minCaught Red PawdcastEpisode 76: The Legend of Dog BoyIn 1890, a beautiful Victorian era home was built in Quitman, Arkansas known as the Bettis Home. Gerald Bettis grew up there and was infamous for bringing home stray dogs and cats to torture. He became known as Dog Boy. He outgrew this obsession with hurting animals and turned his sights on humans. Long after his reign of terror, there have been stories told of the paranormal activity surrounding the Bettis Home. 2024-02-2134 minCaught Red PawdcastEpisode 75: Pamela CarnahanOn May 9, 2014, Pamela Carnahan would last be seen dropping her daughter off at her bus stop. Hours later, Pamela was found murdered in her locked apartment. One month later, another woman's body would be found not far from Pamela's crime scene. Were these two deaths done by the same killer or just a coincidence?2024-02-1544 minCaught Red PawdcastEpisode 74: Vidocq SocietyOnce a month, some of the greatest minds in law enforcement get together in Philadelphia to discuss cold cases. This group of American heroes is known as the Vidocq Society, named after Eugene Francois Vidocq. He was the founder of the first private detective agency. The society's first case involved a wrongfully accused man in Little Rock, Arkansas in 1991. 2024-02-0846 minCaught Red PawdcastEpisode 73: Lauren DewiseOn the morning of January 7, 2018, a woman ran to her neighbor's house, asking for him to call the police. She had come home to find that her house had been broken into and her two roommates had been shot. One roommate was dead and the other was fighting for her life. Was this a house invasion gone wrong or were the women targets? As the investigation continued on, evidence would show that one of the women had recently filed for divorce from her abusive husband.
The National Domestic Abuse Hotline has different options for...2024-01-3142 minCaught Red PawdcastEpisode 72: El Dorado Jane DoeOn July 10th, 1991 a young woman, known to her friends in El Dorado, Arkansas as Mercedes, was murdered in a motel room by James McAlphin. He was sentenced to 15 years in prison. Case was closed for him but investigators still had a problem to solve. Mercedes was living under a stolen identity and no one knew who she really was. If it wasn't for DNA technology and years of dedication from two women in blue, then the El Dorado Jane Doe's true identity might've never been discovered. 2024-01-2447 minCaught Red PawdcastEpisode 71: Sharon HarrelsonCan you think of anything worse than being cheated on? How about being cheated on and then being murdered? That's exactly what happened in this week's episode. Sharon Douglas Fuller Nelson Harrelson was a black widow. When she set her sights on a man with money, she would have him no matter what it took.2024-01-171h 07Caught Red PawdcastEpisode 70: A Bad Day at Blacksnake RanchOn June 24th 1966, a 13 year old girl, Cathie Ward was found dead after she spent a day horseback riding at Blacksnake Ranch. The ranch owner, Frank Davis, told police that she fell from the horse and her foot got caught in the stirrup. Then the horse dragged her through a field full of rocks and crystals. Frank Davis had a bad reputation around Hot Springs, Arkansas and for good reason. Cathie's death was ruled an accident but the investigation resurfaced after Frank was arrested for the murder of his wife less than a year later.
Bitty Martin wrote about this...2024-01-111h 37Caught Red PawdcastEpisode 69: The Package KillerFor more than three decades, St. Louis, Missouri, was haunted by the deaths of at least four women. All of their deaths were attributed to someone the media named "The Package Killer." The deaths happened between 1990 and 1991. One determined detective in 2008 would work for 14 years to solve these cold cases. Thanks to a DNA match in 2022, the man who committed these murders was finally caught.2023-12-1352 minCaught Red PawdcastEpisode 68: Escaping to Camp KellerAfter spending 8 years building an underground bunker, Peter Keller was finally ready to go through with his master plan. He was ready to throw his whole life away for a permanent vacation in isolation. In 2012, he set fire to his home with his family inside and he disappeared into the woods.2023-12-0647 minCaught Red PawdcastEpisode 67: Arkansas River Bottom MurdersJanuary 5, 1981 should have been just another Monday in the city of Fort Smith, Arkansas. But, instead, a mysterious man would kidnap and murder four people over a car he saw for sale in a newspaper ad.
Anita Paddock, in her book "Cold Blooded," does an amazing job at honoring the lives of Larry and Jawana Price, Holly Gentry, and Detective Ray Tate.2023-11-2957 minCaught Red PawdcastEpisode 66: Lisa McVeyLisa McVey is the definition of a survivor. From a young age, she went through hell and was ready for it all to go away. On the same day that she planned to take her own life, she was abducted by a serial killer. From then on, she wanted nothing more than to live. Her survival instincts kicked in and after escaping, she had a new chance at life. With her attention to detail, she helped the Hillsborough County Sheriff's department find and arrest the man who killed 10 women in Tampa, Florida in 1984. 2023-11-2250 minCaught Red PawdcastEpisode 65: Mollie TibbettsToday's episode is a listener recommendation*
In July of 2018, a University of Iowa student went for her nightly run and never was seen alive again. While searching for her, the police would come across the body of another young female. In this episode, Meaghan will cover the cases of both of these women along with another woman found less than 100 miles away. 2023-11-1556 minCaught Red PawdcastEpisode 64: Larry Porter ChismOn this episode, Jesse tells the story of a longtime Arkansas fugitive who escaped prison multiple times and could still be on the run today. Larry Porter Chism was convicted in 1974 and was sentenced to 40 years in prison for armed robbery and numerous drug offenses. US marshal services have put together some age progression photos of what Chism could look like today if he is still alive and on the run. Check out our facebook and instagram accounts for those!2023-11-0846 minCaught Red PawdcastEpisode 63: The Moffitt Family HauntingBeginning in 1987, the Moffitt family would be terrorized by an unknown presence for almost 7 years. They did their best to survive. The family tried everything but would learn that nothing could help them...not even Ed and Lorraine Warren had an answer.
2023-10-311h 02Caught Red PawdcastEpisode 62: Lynnette Quast CraftOn this episode of the Caught Red Pawdcast, Jesse tells the story of high school sweethearts from Wisconsin who get married and start their lives together in Ohio. All seems right in the world for this couple. But their relationship starts to show signs of weakness after their first child is born. Find out what happens when their true colors are shown. 2023-10-2453 minCaught Red PawdcastEpisode 61: Elizabeth DecaroIn March 1992, a mother of four was found dead in her home. Suspicion fell on her husband immediately, but why? He was out of town with their children and the family dog. As they searched for the killer, police uncovered many secrets in the so-called picture perfect marriage along with a murder-for-hire scheme.
To learn more details, check out "A Killer Among Us: A true story of a family's triumph over tragedy" by Charles Bosworth Jr.
*The Light dogs were restless towards the end of this episode lol beware!2023-10-191h 10Caught Red PawdcastEpisode 60: Jerry MorkOn July 14th 1985 in Iola, Wisconsin, a police officer, Jerry Mork, was found murdered beside his patrol car in the Riverside cemetery. The small town was hosting their annual old car show that weekend that brought in over 85,000 people from around the country. Could the killer be any one of them? Or was it someone that had it out for Jerry? 2023-10-1154 minCaught Red PawdcastEpisode 59: The Mueller Family MurdersIn the summer of 1996, there was a gruesome discovery in the Illinois Bayou that would lead Arkansas law enforcement on a wild goose chase all over the United States. The Pope County Sheriff's office, with the help of the ATF, would not only solve one family's murder, but uncover several crimes committed by the killers.2023-10-0356 minCaught Red PawdcastEpisode 58: The Willingham FireOn December 23rd, 1991, in Corsicana, Texas, a fire destroyed the home of Todd and Stacy Willingham and took the lives of their three daughters. The question in this case is whether the home burned down by accident or by arson. 2023-09-271h 36Caught Red PawdcastEpisode 57: Nona DirksmeyerOn December 15th, 2005, a small town beauty queen was found murdered in her apartment. Law enforcement would have tunnel vision suspecting her boyfriend from the start. But did he do it? 2023-09-191h 02Caught Red PawdcastEpisode 56: Brent MorrisonOn today's episode, Jesse tells the story of an Arkansas runner who was taking a morning jog on his favorite trail when he was violently shot to death. With the suspect in custody, the detectives would ask the question: was Brent Morrison a specific target or was this a random killing? 2023-09-1252 minCaught Red PawdcastEpisode 55: Hawkins Triple MurderIn the small, close-knit town of Hawkins, Texas, three of their youngest and brightest didn't return home after a day at the lake. No one would have ever expected that they were the victims of an "Animal." The search for him would turn into the largest manhunt in Texas history. 2023-09-0542 minCaught Red PawdcastEpisode 54: The Staton FamilyOn this episode, a family-owned jewelry store was robbed on September 10th, 1980, in Van Buren, Arkansas. One of the thieves thought they could get away with the loot without hurting anyone, but his partner had other things in mind. Listen in as Jesse tells the story of the Staton family and the community that did their part in bringing down these terrible criminals. 2023-08-311h 30Caught Red PawdcastEpisode 53: Robin Farnsworth & Kenyatta HaynesOn this episode, Jesse tells the story of two girls from Bald Knob, Arkansas who went missing about a month apart. Are their disappearances connected or just a coincidence? 2023-08-2246 minCaught Red PawdcastEpisode 52: Fern Cowen RodgersToday's episode has it all! A scandalous affair, a murder... and a hitman who should have been named Eugene! (if you know, you know) Meaghan takes us to the quiet town of Searcy, Arkansas, where the residents are shocked at the death of one of their own. The story comes right out of the book, "A Murder in Searcy" written by Deana Hamby Nall and Mike S. Allen. 2023-08-1548 minCaught Red PawdcastEpisode 51: Disappearance of Maya MilleteOn this episode of the Caught Red Pawdcast, Jesse tells the story of a young mother of three who went missing January 7th, 2021 in Chula Vista, California and hasn't been found since. Her husband was later arrested and charged with her murder. Preliminary hearings occurred in early 2023 and the judge ruled that there was enough evidence to have a trial. This case is ongoing so the man in question is innocent until proven guilty.2023-08-091h 13Caught Red PawdcastEpisode 50: Katy HawelkaA young college student spent the evening at the local bars celebrating the upcoming school year. On her way back to campus, she parted ways with a friend. Not long after she was brutally attacked by a stranger in the night. Listen in as Meaghan describes what happened that night. For even more details, check out the book 'A Stranger Killed Katy' written by William D. LaRue. 2023-08-0146 minCaught Red PawdcastEpisode 49: The Panhandle MurderOn a Friday the 13th in 1990, something sinister happened at an abandoned barn nicknamed the Haunted House that left the small town of Panhandle, Texas in a panic. Listen in as Jesse tells the story of the Panhandle Murder to find out more!2023-07-2538 minCaught Red PawdcastEpisode 48: James Appleton & Amy HarrisonIn today's episode, the murder of a man in Northwest Arkansas would ultimately lead to the closure of a 20 year old cold case.
2023-07-1842 minCaught Red PawdcastEpisode 47: Elliott Family Murders*Listener discretion advised.
On a stormy night in Dalton, Arkansas in 1998, there was a domestic disturbance report called on the Elliott family's home over some "hollerin going on." What the police found the next day could only be described as the makings of a horror movie. Over the course of a few years, investigators would slowly discover what happened that fateful night. Listen in as Jesse tells the story of the Elliott Family Murders. 2023-07-1148 minCaught Red PawdcastEpisode 46: The National Forest KillerAlways be aware of your surroundings, especially if you're out for a hike. The victims in today's story were just trying to enjoy the beautiful outdoors, not knowing the evil that lurked around the corner.2023-07-051h 00Caught Red PawdcastEpisode 45: Pauline Storment27 year old Pauline Storment was in her sophomore year studying anthropology at the University of Arkansas in 1971. Like most evenings, she finished up studying after work in the campus library and walked the 15 minute stretch back to her apartment. But, the night of April 12th, she would never make it home.
2023-06-2045 minCaught Red PawdcastEpisode 44: Charles Ray VinesOn this episode of the Caught Red Pawdcast, Meaghan stays in our home state of Arkansas. She tells us how four unlucky women would become victims of one man. This man would be better known, thanks to the media, as The River Valley Killer. 2023-06-1354 minCaught Red PawdcastEpisode 43: Nicholas MarkowitzOn this episode of the Caught Red Pawdcast, Jesse tells the story of a 15 year old kid who was kidnapped and murdered because of a $1200 debt his brother owed to a drug dealer. Let us know if you think the punishment matched the crime for each individual involved. 2023-06-061h 02Caught Red PawdcastEpisode 42: Marjorie Greta MasonOn today's episode of the Caught Red Pawdcast, Jesse tells us about Marjorie Greta Mason, who was a nurse for the Little Rock Air Force base in 1983. Just 10 days after she arrived in Arkansas, she gets abducted and murdered. Pulaski County Sheriff Tommy Robinson and company lock in on Barry Lee Fairchild as the murderer and get him to confess. It sounds like an open close case but there's definitely more to the story. Let us know your thoughts!
2023-05-301h 16Caught Red PawdcastEpisode 41, Part 2: Mary Lee OrsiniToday, Meaghan wraps up her case involving Mary Lee Orsini and her ability to slowly trap men into her giant web. If you thought part 1 was crazy, just wait until you hear part 2. 2023-05-231h 27Caught Red PawdcastEpisode 41, Part 1: Mary Lee OrsiniMeaghan bit off more than she can chew with this case! But here we go! She will introduce us to Mary Lee Orsini, a beautiful manipulative woman, who was involved in two murders and that's just the beginning....2023-05-1655 minCaught Red PawdcastEpisode 40: Amy Lynn BradleyOn this episode of the Caught Red Pawdcast, Jesse tells us about a week long cruise vacation in the Caribbean that turned into a disaster for one family. Amy Lynn Bradley went missing from her stateroom on March 24th 1998 and no one is really sure what happened. There had been possible sightings of her months and even years later, but were they positive it was really her or just someone that looked like her? We'd love to hear your thoughts about what might've happened to Amy.2023-05-091h 02Caught Red PawdcastEpisode 39: Paige RenkoskiOn today's episode of the Caught Red Pawdcast, Meaghan takes us to Livingston County, Michigan, where a woman mysteriously disappeared on the side of the interstate. Her car was left running and some of her personal belongings were still in the vehicle. Over 30 years have gone by, and she is still missing. 2023-05-0452 minCaught Red PawdcastEpisode 38: Brian DenekeOn this episode of the Caught Red Pawdcast, Jesse talks about the turf war between the jocks and the punks in Amarillo, Texas in the 1990s that led to the death of one of the towns most beloved punks, 19 year old Brian Deneke. The punks were considered outcasts in this Texas town that was built on football and cowboys. To get along, you had to go along. And the punks weren't trying to fit in with the crowd. We discuss whether or not the punishment fit the crime and we'd love to hear your thoughts on this. 2023-04-251h 04Caught Red PawdcastEpisode 37: Billy WoodwardOn today's episode, Meaghan describes a conflict between neighbors that turns deadly. A man, who is just trying to protect his family and home, takes matters into his own hands but ends up going too far. 2023-04-2045 minCaught Red PawdcastEpisode 36: Nancy ConnIn September of 1971, Nancy Conn and her cousin Charlotte Parks were abducted from a parking lot in Birmingham, Alabama and later left for dead. Listen in as Jesse tells the story of how Nancy overcame that traumatic experience and became an advocate for other victims like her.2023-04-1150 minCaught Red PawdcastEpisode 35: A Meth-tastic TaleOn this episode of the Caught Red Pawdcast, Meaghan tells a redneck tale of mystery, murder, and meth! This story covers Robert Castleman, a former attorney and judge, who is just as infamous in the town of Pocahontas, Arkansas as the meth is. 2023-04-0452 minCaught Red PawdcastEpisode 34: Alexis RasmussenOn this episode of the Caught Red Pawdcast, Jesse tells the story of a 16 year old girl who used babysitting as a way to earn money to shop and hang out with friends. On a night in September of 2011, Alexis Rasmussen was hired to watch a married couple's two children. That would be the last night anyone heard from her. One woman's testimony would reveal what happened to her.2023-03-281h 01Caught Red PawdcastEpisode 33: Juli BuskenOn this episode of the Caught Red Pawdcast, Meaghan tells the story of Juli Busken. She was a very talented ballerina with dreams of having her own studio, but sadly she was a victim of opportunity and was in the wrong place at the wrong time. Her case would go cold but, with advancements in DNA technology, her killer would be brought to justice. 2023-03-2143 minCaught Red PawdcastEpisode 32: Andre ThomasOn this episode of the Caught Red Pawdcast, Jesse tells the story of Andre Thomas. Since a young age, he had voices in his head that ultimately drove him to do the most horrific act. The main question throughout his trial was his competency. "There are times when the mind is dealt such a blow that it hides itself in insanity."
Sources
"Execution delayed for Texas death row inmate who cut out his eyes." Associated Press. March 8, 2023. www.nbcnews.com
"The Struggle for Sanity." Emily G. Thompson...2023-03-141h 07Caught Red PawdcastEpisode 31: Two for One SpecialFor today's episode, Meaghan has a treat for us! 2 cases in 1 episode! The theme is Kids that Kill. The cases involve the extreme measures these kids take to escape the control of their parents in order to be with their lovers. 2023-03-0752 minCaught Red PawdcastEpisode 30: Gene SillerOn today's episode, Jesse tells us the story of Gene Siller, a golf pro who just happened to be in the wrong place at the wrong time. Over the fourth of July weekend in 2021 at the Pine Tree Country Club in Kennesaw, Georgia, golfers and other club members would witness a random act of violence that affected the lives of many.
Case Sources:
www.si.com. "He Followed His Dreams." Brian Burnsed. April 26, 2022.
www.11alive.com. "Man accused in Cobb County golf course triple murder pleads not gui...2023-02-281h 04Caught Red PawdcastEpisode 29: The Green WidowIn today's episode, Meaghan tells us about how one woman's greed led to the death of two men.
Case Sources:
(2005). Stanford Law School - Robert Crown Law Library. Supreme Court of California. Retrieved February 15, 2023, from https://scocal.stanford.edu/opinion/people-v-samuels-33524
(2011). Robert Briskham "Bob" Samuels (1948-1988) Find a Grave. Retrieved February 15, 2023, from https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/67018092/robert-briskham-samuels
(2019). Search and seizure residences - arkchiefs.org. Arkansas association of the chiefs of police. Retrieved February 19, 2023, from https://www.arkchiefs.org/plugins/show_image.php?id=175
2023-02-2142 minCaught Red PawdcastEpisode 28: Brouk Family Murders*Listener discretion advised involving children
On today's episode, Jesse brings to light another small-town case. This story is about the sad endings to otherwise happy and peaceful lives of Susan, Adrian, and Kyle Brouk of Vichy, Missouri.
Case Sources:
courts.mo.gov, Mark A. Christeson v. State of Missouri, appeal from the Circuit Court of Vernon County, Missouri.
ozarksfirst.gov, "The chilling Brouk family murder true crime in Missouri," by Christina Randall, July 7th 2022.
missourideathrow.com, State of Missouri vs. Mark A. Christeson, by smays, December 9, 2008.2023-02-1454 minCaught Red PawdcastBonus Episode #10: Best Animated Characters for a Money HeistOn today's Bonus episode we take a break from true crime and have a little fun talking video games and animated movies/tv. Meaghan, Jesse, and special guest Jordan Bramlett take turns drafting the best animated characters for a money heist! But first we play Guess the Video Game Music & Would You Rather! Get ready for a lot of laughter and trash talk!2023-02-091h 21Caught Red PawdcastEpisode 27: Katie AutryToday's episode is a listener recommendation! Meaghan tells us the story of Katie Autry. She was a freshman at Western Kentucky University and was attending a fraternity party on campus. She was taken home by a DD and should've been safe in her dorm room, but sadly, her life would be cut short.
*Don't mind the Ripley growls in the background. She was hangry.2023-02-071h 00Caught Red PawdcastEpisode 26: Isaiah SweetOn this episode, Jesse discusses the case of Isaiah Sweet, a teenager who murdered his grandparents in 2012. Due to his case and many like it, the Supreme Court had to make changes to the punishments handed out to juveniles. Can someone rehabilitate after such a horrible act or should that person spend the rest of their life behind bars? 2023-01-3157 minCaught Red PawdcastEpisode 25: Elizabeth Ann DuncanIn today's episode, Meaghan tells us about how a mother's obsession with her son led to the death of her pregnant daughter-in-law.2023-01-2453 minCaught Red PawdcastEpisode 24: John GlasgowOn today's episode, we have quite the mystery for yall! Jesse tells the story of the disappearance of John Glasgow, the Chief Financial Officer of CDI Contractors LLC in Little Rock, Arkansas. We need your opinion about what happened to him! Message us on Instagram @caughtredpawdcast2023-01-1957 minCaught Red PawdcastBonus Episode #9: Mythical Creatures and CryptidsIt's story time with our very special guest! We have so many personal stories to share with yall! We talk about some mythical creatures in Arkansas as well as some of the creepiest creatures out there. Can't forget a game of Would You Rather!2023-01-171h 12Caught Red PawdcastEpisode 23: Lisa Rene*Listener discretion advised
In today's episode, Meaghan tells the story of Lisa Rene, a teenager who had a bright future ahead of her. The poor choices made by her family members may have led to her death. 2023-01-1050 minCaught Red PawdcastBonus Episode #8: Tools of TerrorIn today's Bonus Episode, we draft the craziest weapons in movies! Join along as we play games like Would You Rather, 2 Truths and a Lie, and Guess the Children movie explained horribly.2023-01-0649 minCaught Red PawdcastEpisode 22: Dunbar Armored RobberyIn our first episode of 2023, Jesse gets a little less murdery and a lot more robbery with this case. In 1997, 6 masked gunmen steal 18.9 million dollars in cash from the Dunbar Armored facility. Was it an inside job? Did they get away with it? How do you spend that kind of money without being suspicious? 2023-01-031h 05Caught Red PawdcastEpisode 21: Kirsten CostasIn today's episode, Meaghan tells us a story about how a teenage girl's desperate attempts to be popular turn deadly.2022-12-2044 minCaught Red PawdcastBonus Episode #7: Die Hard is a Christmas MovieOur Bonus episode today is Christmas Movies! Tis the season so our Would You Rather game, draft, and everything else is Christmas themed. We draft our favorite Christmas movies!2022-12-1542 minCaught Red PawdcastEpisode 20: Andres EscobarIn today's episode, Jesse gives us another history lesson. Since the World Cup is going on right now, we thought we would go back to the 1994 World Cup and talk about the unfortunate event following an early elimination of the Colombian national team, which was one of the favorites to win it all. Subscribe and tell your friends about our true crime cases, horror movie debates, and of course our fur nuggets too.2022-12-1345 minCaught Red PawdcastEpisode 19: Kacie WoodyIn today's episode, Meaghan tells us the tragic case of Kacie Woody. 2022-12-0657 minCaught Red PawdcastEpisode 18: Wonderful World of Genetic GenealogyOn today's bonus episode, we shine light on a few cases that might have never been solved if not for the advancements in genetic genealogy. 2022-12-0139 minCaught Red PawdcastEpisode 17: Carter Elliott & Timmy Wayne RobertsonOn today's episode, Jesse tells us about the first double homicide in Conway, Arkansas. Carter Elliott and Timmy Wayne Robertson were found executed in their wealthy suburban home. Who could have brought such tragedy to the families of these victims and why? 2022-11-291h 21Caught Red PawdcastEpisode 16: Missing Women of SE MichiganIn today's episode, Meaghan takes us up north to tell the stories of several missing women. Are they connected or is it just a coincidence?2022-11-2238 minCaught Red PawdcastEpisode 15: Hot Springs ShootoutBefore Vegas was even a thing, Hot Springs, Arkansas was THE place for all the notorious names of organized crime to vacation. Jesse tells us the crazy history behind this town and the fight for the control of illegal gambling that ultimately led to what is known as the Hot Springs Shootout. 2022-11-1550 minCaught Red PawdcastBonus Episode #6: One Liners from Horror MoviesWe have another Bonus Episode for you today! Join in on the fun as we test each other's knowledge of Horror movies with our games like 2 Truths and 1 Lie, Guess the Movie theme songs, and more. In our Would You Rather game, we decide between knowing when we are going to die and how we are going to die. Then, we finish the episode off with a draft of our favorite One Liners from Horror Movies. 2022-11-1051 minCaught Red PawdcastEpisode 14: Texarkana Moonlight MurdersIn today's episode, Meaghan tells us about how a string of random attacks shook the quiet town of Texarkana.2022-11-0835 minCaught Red PawdcastEpisode 13: Samuel LittleConfessing to 93 murders that spanned 3 decades in over 19 states, this monster flew under the radar but was known as the most prolific serial killer in the United States. He had more kills than the well known killers like Bundy, Gacy, and Dahmer had combined. How did he get away with all of this for so long? Listen in as Jesse tells the story of Samuel Little.2022-11-011h 01
Caught Red PawdcastBonus Episode #5: Final GirlsOn this bonus episode, we talk about the difference between a murder babe and a final girl. We play Guess that Movie and Explain the Horror Movie Badly followed by Would You Rather. And we had to break out the trivia cards as well! Lastly, we draft our favorite Final Girls. Which Final Girls are on your list? 2022-10-271h 01Caught Red PawdcastEpisode 12: John MarkleIn today's episode, Meaghan takes us to our state's capital, Little Rock, for a murder suicide that no one saw coming. Was it all intentional or was it because John Markle was cursed? 2022-10-2539 minCaught Red PawdcastEpisode 11: Jessica BaggenOn this episode of the Caught Red Pawdcast, Jesse tells the heartbreaking story of the death of Jessica Baggen, a teenager from Sitka, Alaska in 1996. 2022-10-1843 minCaught Red PawdcastBonus Episode #4: Monster MoviesWe've got another bonus episode for y'all! We draft our Mount Rushmore of Monster Movies. We also play Would You Rather and choose if we'd rather only watch horror movies or comedy movies for the rest of our lives. Can't forget our Guess That Movie and 6 Degrees of Kevin Bacon games where you can try to play along with us. 2022-10-1359 minCaught Red PawdcastEpisode 10: Fall River MurdersIn this week's episode, Meaghan takes us to Fall River, Massachusetts, where the murders of three women may be related to a local satanic cult. 2022-10-1141 minCaught Red PawdcastEpisode 9: Janie WardOn today's episode, Jesse tells the story of Janie Ward. She was a 16 year old girl from Marshall, AR who mysteriously fell and died. Was it a freak accident or was there a cover up?2022-10-041h 22Caught Red PawdcastBonus Episode #3: Zombie MoviesOn today's episode, we explain horror movies badly. We also have to choose between Silent Hill and Raccoon City as a place to visit. And we can't choose death although that is a possible outcome! We wrap things up with a draft of our Mount Rushmores of zombie movies. 2022-09-2947 minCaught Red PawdcastEpisode 8: Ricky Ray RectorIn today's episode, Meaghan is going to tell us about Ricky Ray Rector, a man whose trials will go under scrutiny and help shift the courts views on competence. 2022-09-2733 minCaught Red PawdcastEpisode 7: Marvin HarrisonNFL season is back! What better way to celebrate than to talk about a case involving one of the NFL legends, Marvin Harrison. Listen in as Meaghan suffers through some "sportsball" talk while Jesse loves every minute of it!2022-09-2053 minCaught Red PawdcastBonus Episode #2: Paranormal MoviesOn today's bonus episode, we draft our Mount Rushmore of paranormal movies. We play another game of Would You Rather! We also introduce a few new segments that we think you'll enjoy.2022-09-1555 minCaught Red PawdcastCaught Red Pawdcast TrailerWelcome to the Caught Red Pawdcast2022-09-1501 minCaught Red PawdcastEpisode 6: Holly BoboIn today's episode, we travel to Darden, TN to discuss the abduction and death of Holly Bobo.2022-09-1341 minCaught Red PawdcastEpisode 5: Maud CrawfordIn this episode, we talk about the mysterious disappearance of Camden lawyer Maud Crawford, who was a pioneer for women in Arkansas. Beth Brickell, an author, film director, and investigative reporter, shines a light on the town of Camden and helps uncover the mystery behind Crawford's disappearance with her investigative series that made the front page of the Arkansas Gazette. 2022-09-0643 minCaught Red PawdcastBonus Episode #1: Slasher MoviesOn this Bonus Episode, we talk about the horror movies and shows we have watched lately. Then we dive into our first segment called Would You Rather. We save the best for last with a draft of our Mount Rushmore of Slasher Movies!2022-09-0141 minCaught Red PawdcastEpisode 4: Ronald Gene SimmonsOn this episode of Caught Red Pawdcast, Meaghan takes the wheel again to discuss the "Hillbilly from Hell" and his killing spree which was close to home for us. 2022-08-3028 minCaught Red PawdcastEpisode 3: George SmithOn this episode of Caught Red Pawdcast, we are flipping the script! Jesse is telling a true crime story that Meaghan has never heard of, which is a rarity. We are celebrating our 4th anniversary at the beach. What better way to do that than a vacation disappearance case!? On July 5th, 2005, George Smith goes missing on a Royal Caribbean cruise ship. Was it an accident? A suicide? Or was he a victim of foul play? 2022-08-2357 minCaught Red PawdcastEpisode 2: Carson PrinceOn this episode, we will be discussing the murder of Carson Prince in Little Rock, AR in 1999 and its link to two other murders that happened only a few months later. 2022-08-1628 min
Caught Red PawdcastEpisode 1: Amanda TusingOn this episode, we introduce ourselves and our critters! Then, we jump right into our first case. We talk about the death of Amanda Tusing, a native to our state of Arkansas, plus two other women who have slight similarities.2022-08-0930 min