Shows
Pod of FameCole Hamels with Steve GardnerJim is joined by USA TODAY sports reporter and Hall of Fame voter Steve Gardner to break down the HOF candidacy of former pitcher Cole Hamels. First, Steve and Jim cover just how devastating Hamels' changeup was throughout his career (9:42). Next, they discuss his historic 2008 postseason performance, compare Hamels career to CC Sabathia, and debate who the best starting pitcher is on the 2026 HOF ballot (15:01). Finally, Steve and Jim determine what tier of pitcher Hamels belongs to in the 21st Century (42:20), before making a final call on whether or not they believe Hamels deserves a plaque in Cooperstown (48:30).
2025-12-1556 minPod of FameJeff Kent Heads to Cooperstown + Moses Malone: The Life of a Basketball Prophet with Paul KnepperJim first covers yesterday's election of Jeff Kent to the Baseball Hall of Fame (1:12). Then, Jim welcomes author Paul Knepper to discuss his latest book, “Moses Malone: The Life of a Basketball Prophet." Jim and Paul cover a number of topics, including Moses Malone playing pickup basketball inside a prison (40:12), the various reasons Malone sometimes gets lost in NBA history (42:23), Malone's offensive rebounding prowess (51:12), and of course, conduct an all-time NBA center draft (1:00:28).
2025-12-081h 14Pod of FamePhilip Rivers with Fernando RamirezJim is joined by Fernando Ramirez, Chargers reporter for The Sporting Tribune, to break down the HOF candidacy of former quarterback Philip Rivers. First, Fernando and Jim debate whether Rivers belongs on Chargers Mount Rushmore and how he stacks up against Dan Fouts (12:48). Next, they cover his one appearance in the AFC Championship and examine just how few quarterbacks have made the HOF without winning a Super Bowl (23:41). Finally, Fernando and Jim discuss where Rivers rank among the best quarterbacks of his era (32:22), before making a final call on whether or not they believe Rivers deserves to be inducted...
2025-12-0150 minPod of FameWill Cooper Flagg end up in the Basketball Hall of Fame?The 2025 NBA Draft is this Thursday and we all know Cooper Flagg is going first. Does that mean he has the best odds of ending up in the Basketball Hall of Fame? Jim provides his thoughts on the top five players in this year's draft that have the best odds of ending up in the Hall of Fame once their careers are all said and done (9:04). Then, Kentucky Correspondent Shannon Miloch joins the podcast to talk about the Kentucky Wildcats that will get their name called this Thursday, as well as a few other SEC players she likes in...
2025-06-2350 minPod of FameRichard "Rip" Hamilton with Keith Black TrudeauJim is joined by NBA historian Keith Black Trudeau to break down the hall of fame candidacy of former NBA shooting guard Richard "Rip" Hamilton. First, Jim and Keith discuss Hamilton's elite ability to move without the ball, as well as his smooth mid-range game (10:10). Next, they cover his performance in the 2004 NBA Finals and Eastern Conference Finals, how he compares to Reggie Miller, and where he ranks among the 15 best shooting guards of the 2000s (20:30). Finally, Jim and Keith try to understand Hamilton's alarmingly poor advanced metrics (53:57), before making a final call on whether or not Hamilton deserves...
2025-06-161h 10Pod of FameJohan Santana with Brandon WarneJim is joined by Brandon Warne, host of Locked on Twins, to break down the HOF candidacy of former MLB pitcher Johan Santana. First, Brandon and Jim cover the best pitchers in Minnesota Twins history (11:03). Next, they discuss Johan's ridiculous second half of 2004 (13-0, 1.21 ERA), his no-hitter with the New York Mets in 2012, and how his peak actually compares to Sandy Koufax (15:25). Finally, Brandon and Jim debate how big of a deal Johan's low career win total (139) actually is (40:45), before making a final call on whether Johan belongs in the Baseball Hall of Fame (49:05).
2025-05-1257 minPod of FameTerry Cummings with Adam RyanJim is joined by NBA sports podcaster Adam Ryan to break down the hall of fame candidacy of former NBA power forward Terry Cummings. First, Jim and Adam cover the top 3 picks of the 1982 NBA Draft (10:01). Next, they discuss the 1985 playoff series where Cummings outscored Michael Jordan, how Cummings compares to James Worthy, and the significance of the 19,000-Point Club (14:10). Finally, Adam and Jim rank Terry among the best power forwards of the 1980s (43:15), before making a final call on whether or not Cummings deserves a place in the Basketball Hall of Fame (47:40).
2025-04-2154 minPod of FameShareef Abdur-Rahim with Neil PaineJim is joined by sportswriter Neil Paine to break down the hall of fame candidacy of former NBA forward Shareef Abdur-Rahim. First, Jim and Neil cover the the absolutely stacked 1996 NBA Draft Class (8:53). Next, they discuss the 50 points Shareef dropped on Ben Wallace in 2001, his elite scoring ability, and where he ranks among the best forwards of the late 1990s/early 2000s (15:20). Finally, Neil and Jim both draft their all-time teams made up exclusively 1X all-stars (49:40), before making a final call on whether or not Abdur-Rahim deserves a place in the Basketball Hall of Fame (63:01).
2025-04-141h 07Pod of FamePOF Book Club. 1978: Baseball and America in the Disco EraIn this edition of POF Book Club, Jim welcomes author David Krell to discuss his new new book, “1978: Baseball and America in the Disco Era" First, David and Jim discuss why he landed on 1978 as the year he would cover and what he personally remembers about that year (4:55). Then, they discuss the most memorable baseball moment of 1978 (9:25) and who really should have won the MVP awards that season (13:40). Finally, David and Jim run through the Hall of Fame cases of a few greats from the 1978 season and debate whether they belong in Cooperstown (19:03).
2025-04-0733 minPod of FameMarques Johnson with Dennis KrauseJim is joined by sports reporter for Spectrum News 1 Wisconsin Dennis Krause to break down the hall of fame candidacy of former NBA small forward Marques Johnson. First, Dennis and Jim cover which NBA legend famously had a poster of Johnson in their dorm room, his role in "White Men Can't Jump" and his unusual Milwaukee Bucks jersey situation (5:49). Next, they discuss Johnson's dominant performance in the 1983 NBA playoffs, how he compares to Bernard King, and how many former AP College Basketball Player of the Year recipients ended up having a great NBA career (12:43). Finally, Jim and Dennis rank...
2025-03-3138 minPod of FameTommy John with Graham WomackJim is joined by journalist Graham Womack to break down the HOF candidacy of former MLB pitcher Tommy John. First Graham and Jim cover whether the historical significance of Tommy John surgery should have any impact on John's case for Cooperstown (8:43). Next, they discuss John's great playoff performances throughout his career, how his baseball resume compares favorably to Jim Kaat and somewhat to Nolan Ryan, and where he ranks in MLB history in several key pitching statistics (17:45). Finally, Graham and Jim debate where John ranks among the best pitchers of the 1960s, 1970s, and 1980s (40:00), before making a final...
2025-03-2455 minPod of Fame2025 March Madness Preview with Shannon MilochIt's finally here. Sick days will be used. Office pools with be formed. Money will be lost. The greatest sports event of the year has arrived and if you think we would talk anything besides March Madness this week, you would be sadly mistaken. Pod of Fame's College Basketball Correspondent Shannon Miloch joins the pod for the fifth annual March Madness Preview to talk all things basketball. First, we power rank the four regions by difficulty (7:45), before making our Final Four picks (27:50). Then, Shannon and Jim each name their top four players you should be keeping your eye on...
2025-03-171h 06Pod of FamePOF Book Club. The Last Manager: How Earl Weaver Tricked, Tormented, and Reinvented BaseballIn this edition of POF Book Club, Jim welcomes author John W. Miller to discuss his new new book, “The Last Manager: How Earl Weaver Tricked, Tormented, and Reinvented Baseball." First, John and Jim discuss the meaning behind the title of the book and why former Baltimore Orioles Manager Earl Weaver can be considered the last manager in MLB history (16:07). Then, they discuss how Earl Weaver is really the origin story of Moneyball, underappreciated components of Weaver's legacy, and how Weaver would fair as a manager in baseball today (18:06). Finally, Jim assists John in building a Mount Rushmore of pe...
2025-03-1041 minPod of Fame🇳🇮 Nicaragua Travel Log 🇳🇮We take a break from sports (kinda) to bring you a travel log episode documenting another Pod of Fame trip outside of the United States. Jim recaps his experience on Little Corn Island, a tiny speck of land 50 miles off the coast of Nicaragua. Jim touches on a variety of topics, including how the hell one gets to the 1.5 square mile island in the Caribbean Sea and what is was like eating, drinking, and living amongst the local population (8:10). Then, Jim builds (and this will make more sense when you listen) Oklahoma City Thunder Rushmore (36:00) and Nicaraguan Baseball Rushmore (39:57).
2025-03-0352 minPod of FameDwight Howard with David "Wando" WandolowskiJim is joined by friend of the pod David "Wando" Wandolowski to break down the hall of fame candidacy of former NBA center Dwight Howard. First, Jim and Wando cover the ridiculous athleticism of Howard in his early days with the Orlando Magic, as well as why Howard attended prom in their hometown of Naperville, IL (10:52). Next, they discuss the 2009 NBA playoffs, how Howard's career compares to Alonzo Mourning, and the lack of center talent during Howard's era (24:56). Finally, Jim and David debate where Howard ranks among the best centers of the last 35 years (59:25), before making a final call...
2025-02-241h 15Pod of FameCarmelo Anthony with David ShepardJim is joined by SiriusXM NBA Radio and Infinity Sports Network Radio Host David Shepard to break down the hall of fame candidacy of former NBA small forward Carmelo Anthony. First, Jim and David cover the impressiveness of Carmelo's diversified basketball portfolio, from his NCAA championship at Syracuse to his four Olympic medals (13:55). Next, David shares a Kobe Bryant/Carmelo Anthony story, Jim discusses how Carmelo compares to Alex English, and David ranks Carmelo among the best small forwards of the 2000s/2010s (19:30). Finally, Jim and David debate the significance of basketball advanced metrics (40:12), before making a final call...
2025-02-1748 minPod of FameIchiro Suzuki with Jeff Cirillo, Not Gaetti, Adam Darowski, and MoreSince Ichiro Suzuki officially retired from the MLB in 2019, we have all known he would selected to Cooperstown as soon as he became eligible. Well, time flies, as Ichiro will officially be elected to the Baseball Hall of Fame tomorrow. First, Jim will cover Ichiro's arrival in Seattle as a 27-year old rookie right fielder, how seemingly impossible Ichiro's 262-hit season really was, and why Ichiro was Jim's generations Roberto Clemente (8:40). Then, Jim is joined by a number of guests, including 2X MLB All-Star third baseman Jeff Cirillo (29:08), baseball Twitter personality Not Gaetti (39.49), and Baseball Reference's Adam Darowski (51:03), to...
2025-01-201h 11Pod of FameAdam Vinatieri with Christopher PriceJim is joined by Christopher Price from the Boston Globe to break down the HOF candidacy of former NFL kicker Adam Vinatieri. First, Chris and Jim cover Vinatieri's two clutch kicks in the Snow Bowl against the Oakland Raiders (6:02). Next, they discuss both of Vinatieri's Super Bowl winning kicks, how he compares to the other two full-time kickers in the HOF, and whether Vinatieri is the most famous kicker in NFL history (10:35). Finally, Chris and Jim break down the significance of Vinatieri only being named to three pro bowl teams (24:16), before both stating whether or not they believe he...
2025-01-1335 minPod of FameCurt Flood with Benjamin HochmanJim is joined by St. Louis Post-Dispatch sports columnist and Hall of Fame voter Benjamin Hochman to break down the HOF candidacy of former St. Louis Cardinals centerfielder Curt Flood. First, Benjamin and Jim cover Flood's legacy as a trailblazer in the world of professional sports and workers' rights (11:33). Next, they discuss Flood's role on two Cardinals World Series championship teams, how as a player Flood compares favorably to Hall of Fame center fielder Richie Ashburn, and Flood's relatively high WAR total in just 12 full MLB seasons (17:11). Finally, Benjamin and Jim break down the significance of the fact that...
2025-01-0650 minPod of FameEli Manning with Jason RomanoJim is joined by Jason Romano, Executive Producer at Sports Spectrum, to break down the HOF candidacy of former New York Giants quarterback Eli Manning. First, Jason and Jim discuss "The Helmet Catch" and whether it was the greatest play in Super Bowl history (12:04). Next, they compare Eli to 3X Super Bowl champ Troy Aikman, where Eli ranks among the best QBs of the 2000s/2010s, and the importance of the eye test (36:21). Finally, Steve and Jim debate whether Eli's career was actually better than Ben Roethlisberger (51:44), before making a final call on whether or not they believe Eli deserves...
2024-12-301h 06Pod of FameDustin Pedroia with Chad FinnJim is joined by Boston Globe sports columnist and Hall of Fame voter Chad Finn to break down the HOF candidacy of former Boston Red Sox second baseman Dustin Pedroia. First, Chad and Jim cover Pedroia's playing style and violent swing (9:20). Next, they discuss Pedroia's performance in the 2008 ALCS, how he compares to HOF second baseman Bobby Doerr, and where he ranks among the best second basemen since 2000 (13:35). Finally, Chad and Jim discuss whether Pedroia's peak was great enough to overcome his weaker counting stats (37:00), if he was better than Nomar Garciaparra (44:01), and whether he deserves a plaque in...
2024-12-0955 minPod of FameLuis Tiant with Chris BodigJim is joined by former producer for ESPN's Baseball Tonight and the creator of the website "Cooperstown Cred", Chris Bodig, to break down down the hall of fame candidacy of former MLB starting pitcher Luis Tiant. First, Chris and Jim cover Tiant's famous windup and where it ranks among the greatest windups we have seen on a pitching mound (6:55). Next, they discuss Tiant's legendary performance in the 1975 World Series, his largely forgotten dominant 1968 season with the Cleveland Indians, and why Tiant reminds us both of a lot of Juan Marichal (12:02). Finally, Jim and Chris rank Tiant among the best...
2024-12-0256 minPod of FameKen Boyer with Adam DarowskiJim is joined by Sports Reference's Executive Design Director Adam Darowski to break down down the hall of fame candidacy of former MLB third baseman Ken Boyer. First, Adam and Jim cover how Boyer is the most forgotten man from the greatest era of baseball (7:12) . Next, they discuss the 1964 World Series, how Boyer compares to Ron Santo, and how Boyer was on 3B Mount Rushmore when when he retired in 1969 (19:05). Finally, Adam and Jim walk through the best third baseman that came right after Boyer left baseball and where he ranks among them (51:10), before they both state whether or...
2024-11-251h 11Pod of FameFélix Hernández with Steve GardnerJim is joined by USA TODAY Sports reporter and Hall of Fame voter Steve Gardner to break down the HOF candidacy of former Seattle Mariners pitcher Félix Hernández. First, Steve and Jim cover Hernández's immense popularity in Seattle and the unfortunate fact that he never pitched in the postseason (8:20). Next, they discuss Hernández's perfect game in 2012, pitchers with under 169 wins enshrined in Cooperstown, and how long does a peak have to last to make up for low counting statistics (12:10). Finally, Steve and Jim rank the best pitchers in the MLB since 2005 (38:19), before making a final call...
2024-11-1856 minPod of FameLuis Gonzalez with Dalton FeelyJim is joined by Dalton Feely from Jomboy Media to break down the hall of fame candidacy of former MLB left fielder Luis Gonzalez. First, Jim and Dalton cover Gonzalez’s World Series-winning single off Mariano Rivera (7:10). Next, they discuss Gonzalez’s 57 home run, 419 total base season in 2001, how he compares to HOFer Jim Rice, and where Gonzalez ranks among the best left fielders from the 1990s/2000s (10:55). Finally, Jim
and Dalton discuss the lack of evidence connecting Gonzalez to PEDs (33:34), before making a final call on whether or not Gonzalez deserves a plaque in Cooperstown (42:15)
2024-09-3049 minPod of FameBuck Williams with Clayton TrutorJim is joined by author and sports historian, Clayton Trutor, to discuss the hall of fame candidacy of former NBA power forward Buck Williams. First, Clayton and Jim discuss Buck bending the rim in the 1990 NBA Finals and the most overshadowed NBA players of the 1980s (5:34). Next, they cover the best offensive rebounders in NBA history, how well Buck stacks up against Nate Thurmond, and whether Win Shares as a statistic should be used to measure a player's greatness (19:30). Finally, Clayton and Jim rank Buck among the best power forwards of the 1980s (33:10), before making a final call on whether...
2024-09-1652 minPod of Fame2024 NFL Season Hall of Fame PlotlinesOur first NFL Sunday is now behind us and my god, did it feel good for football to be back. First, Jim provides some quick observations from Week 1 (4:05). Then, Jim takes a look at five current players HOF cases and covers what he needs to see from them this season in order to help them inch closer to the goal line we call Canton. Jim discusses Derrick Henry (11:15), Stefon Diggs (18:50), Matthew Stafford (24:45), Khalil Mack (30:42), and C.J. Mosley (35:17).
2024-09-0942 minPod of FameCharlie Keller with Mark ShirkJim is joined by baseball Twitter personality Mark Shirk to break down down the hall of fame candidacy of former MLB left fielder Charlie Keller. First, Mark and Jim discuss why Keller is one of the more unsung New York Yankees in franchise history (9:40). Next, they cover Keller's performance in the 1939 and 1941 World Series and how Keller compares to the few Hall of Famers who played less than 1500 career games (25:20). Finally, Mark and Jim debate why Charlie Keller never received much love in the AL MVP vote during his career (49:05), before they both state whether or not they believe...
2024-08-121h 10Pod of FameJulio Franco with Adam DarowskiJim is joined by Adam Darowski, Director of Design and Product Management at Sports Reference, to break down down the hall of fame candidacy of former MLB player Julio Franco. First, Jim and Adam discuss Franco's age 45 season with the Atlanta Braves in 2004 and his unforgettable batting stance (10:30). Next, they cover the 1990 All-Star Game, Minnie Miñoso, and Julio's membership in the Pro Baseball 4,000 Hit Club (16:26). Finally, Adam and Jim attempt to properly rank Franco among the best 2B/SS from 1980-2007 (50:45), before they both state whether or not they believe Franco deserves a plaque in Cooperstown (59:55)
2024-08-051h 10Pod of FameWho From the 2024 NBA Draft Class Will End Up in the HOF?Jim runs through his yearly exercise of trying to predict the five players from the NBA Draft who have the best odds of ending up in the Basketball HOF based on their NBA potential and team fit (3:02). Then, Jim welcomes POF's College Basketball Insider Shannon Miloch to talk through the new two-day draft format, top players from the draft, and draft day gossip (28:48).
2024-07-011h 10Pod of FameRIP Willie MaysWillie Mays passed away last Tuesday at the age of 93. One of the undisputed greatest players to ever play baseball, Jim first dives deep into Willie's career and attempts to define his legacy (11:57). Then, Jim discusses how Willie and Roberto Clemente are the greatest artists to grace a baseball diamond and just how much Mays reminds Jim of late 1980s/early 1990s Barry Bonds (39:46). Finally, Jim breaks down Baseball Rushmore and why Willie Mays is the greatest player in MLB history (48:41).
2024-06-241h 00Pod of FameLou Whitaker 2.0 with Cody StavenhagenIn May of 2021, Jim was joined by Cody Stavenhagen, Detriot Tigers beat writer for The Athletic, to breakdown the hall of fame candidacy of former Detroit Tigers second baseman Lou Whitaker. As Lou celebrated his 67th birthday yesterday, a rerelease of that episode, along with some new commentary from Jim at the top, was warranted. For the Lou Whitaker 2.0 episode, Jim looks more closely at the 20 second baseman in the HOF today and how Whitaker compares. Then, Jim and John discuss hard it is to talk about Whitaker without bringing up his double-play partner Alan Trammell, who recently was...
2024-05-1358 minPod of FameMark Grace with Jim LicatoJim is joined by former Wrigley Field employee and friend of the pod Jim Licato, to break down the hall of fame candidacy of former Chicago Cubs first baseman Mark Grace. First, they discuss Grace's elite hitting ability and his consistency at the plate and in the field during the 1990s (5:08). Next, they cover the 1989 National League Championship Series, how far back in history you have to go to find a light slugging first baseman that was inducted into the HOF, and whether the fact Grace led the 1990s in hits AND doubles is properly celebrated (10:20). Finally, they try...
2024-04-0157 minPod of FameMarch Madness Preview + Top 5 Most Memorable March Madness Players with Shannon MilochIt's finally here. Sick days will be used. Office pools with be formed. Money will be lost. The greatest sports event of the year has arrived and if you think we would talk anything besides March Madness this week, you would be sadly mistaken. Pod of Fame's College Basketball Correspondent Shannon Miloch joins the pod to discuss all four tournament regions and Final Four picks (3:52). Then, Jim and Shannon both discuss their top five most memorable players in March Madness history, including Mateen Cleaves, Lonny Baxter, and Kevin Pittsnogle (37:35).
2024-03-181h 11Pod of FameHOF MarketWatch: Domantas Sabonis and Keenan AllenJim is buying Domantas Sabonis HOF Stock following his triple-double against the Lakers on Wednesday (17/19/10) and overall hot start to March (averaging 21/17/8 through seven March games). Meanwhile, Jim started selling off Keenan Allen HOF stock following the Thursday night trade that sent Allen to Jim's hometown Chicago Bears for a 4th round pick. Wide receivers historically don't thrive in the windy city and all signs point to a rookie quarterback starting this fall.
2024-03-1515 minPod of FameElton Brand with Clayton TrutorJim is joined by author and sports historian, Clayton Trutor, to discuss the hall of fame candidacy of former NBA power forward Elton Brand. First, Clayton and Jim discuss Brand's college career at Duke and the immediate success he found upon arriving in the NBA with the Chicago Bulls (5:25). Next, they cover the 2006 Western Conference Semifinals against Steve Nash and the Phoenix Suns, how he is wingspan buddies with Kevin McHale, and how he compares to the other great power forwards of the 2000s (19:59). Finally, Clayton and Jim build 2X NBA All-Star Mount Rushmore (43:30), before making a final call...
2024-03-041h 09Pod of FameJohn Beckwith with Adam DarowskiJim is joined by Adam Darowski, Head of User Experience at Sports Reference, to break down down the hall of fame candidacy of former Negro League star John Beckwith. First, Adam breaks down the full history of former Negro League stars and their path to Cooperstown (8:39). Next, Jim and Adam discuss what type of offensive numbers Beckwith may have put up if he had been given the opportunity to play in the National or American League and how Beckwith compares to several Negro League players that have already been inducted into Cooperstown (50:58). Finally, Adam and Jim take a look...
2024-02-121h 26Pod of FameLarry Nance with Alex ChesterJim is joined by sports transactional attorney and host of the podcast 32 Fans, Alex Chester, to discuss the hall of fame candidacy of former NBA power forward Larry Nance. First, Alex and Jim break down Nance's performance in the 1984 NBA Slam Dunk Competition (6:25). Next, they cover the 1984 Western Conference Finals and 1992 Eastern Conference Finals, as well how basketball advanced metrics should factor into a player's HOF case (11:54). Finally, Alex and Jim rank the best PFs of the 1980s (39:42), before making a final call on whether or not Nance belongs in the Basketball HOF (48:06).
2024-01-0157 minPod of FameAdrián Beltré with Adam DarowskiJim is joined by Adam Darowski, Head of User Experience at Sports Reference, to break down down the hall of fame candidacy of former MLB third baseman Adrián Beltré. First, Adam and Jim cover just how fun it was to watch Beltré play baseball, antics and all (6:49). Next, they discuss what Beltré's career had in common with Roberto Clemente, just how odd it is that Beltré only made four all-star teams, and whether Beltré belongs on Defensive Third Baseman Mount Rushmore (25:26). Finally, Adam and Jim attempt to determine where Beltré ranks among the best third basemen in MLB his...
2023-12-251h 05Pod of FameChase Utley with Jayson StarkJim is joined by baseball writer at The Athletic and Hall of Fame voter Jayson Stark to breakdown the HOF candidacy of former Philadelphia Phillies second baseman Chase Utley. First, Jayson and Jim discuss the historic double-play combo of Jimmy Rollins and Chase Utley (5:41). Next, they cover Utley's performance in the 2008 World Series, why Utley reminds Jayson of Derek Jeter, and what to make of Utley earning 0 gold gloves despite his elite defensive advanced metrics (12:20). Finally, Jayson and Jim attempt to properly rank Utley among the best second basemen of his era (35:03), before making a final call on whether...
2023-12-1859 minPod of FameJoe Mauer with Steve GardnerJim is joined by USA TODAY Sports reporter and Hall of Fame voter Steve Gardner to breakdown the HOF candidacy of former Minnesota Twins catcher Joe Mauer. First, Steve and Jim discuss Mauer's significance in Minnesota Twins franchise history (5:58). Next, they cover Mauer's remarkable 2009 MVP season and what to make of the fact that Mauer caught less than 1,000 games during his major league career (13:17). Finally, Steve and Jim attempt to properly rank Mauer amongst Buster Posey and Yadier Molina (45:49), before making a final call on whether or not they believe Mauer deserves a plaque in Cooperstown (53:28).
2023-12-111h 01Pod of FameCharlie Bennett with David MetterJim is joined by David Metter (@CooperstownDave) to break down the hall of fame candidacy of former MLB catcher Charlie Bennett. First, Dave and Jim talk about what playing catcher was like in the 19th Century (8:13). Next, they cover the 1887 World Series, compare Bennett to HOFer Gary Carter, and discuss the 1936 Cooperstown ballot (19:46). Finally, Dave and Jim build Defensive Catcher Mount Rushmore (58:28), before making a final call on whether or not Bennett deserves to be enshrined into Cooperstown (1:06:38).
2023-11-271h 17Pod of FameRoger Maris with Paul "Hembo" HembekidesJim is joined by Content Producer for the ESPN morning show Get Up and New York Times bestselling author, Paul "Hembo" Hembekides, to break down the hall of fame candidacy of former MLB right fielder Roger Maris. First, Hembo and Jim discuss the importance of the 61 home runs Maris slugged in 1961 and where the number 61 ranks among the greatest numbers in baseball history (6:40). Next, they cover his 1960 MVP season, how Maris compares to HOFer Hack Wilson, and whether Maris is the best New York Yankee not in Cooperstown today (14:35). Finally, Hembo and Jim determine whether Maris was one of the...
2023-11-2148 minPod of FamePOF Book Club: The Wingmen: The Unlikely, Unusual, Unbreakable Friendship Between John Glenn and Ted Williams with Adam LazarusJim welcomes author Adam Lazarus to discuss his latest book, “The Wingmen: The Unlikely, Unusual, Unbreakable Friendship Between John Glenn and Ted Williams." Adam and Jim cover the baseball career of Ted Williams, John Glenn's most impressive accomplishment, and what a Glenn presidency would have looked like. Then, Jim has Adam build 20th Century American Hero Rushmore.
2023-11-0839 minPod of FameDick Butkus Tribute + Introducing HOF MarketWatchJim pays tribute to Chicago Bears legend Dick Butkus, who sadly passed away last Thursday at the age of 80. Butkus is perhaps the greatest Chicago Bear in the franchise's 100+ year history and Jim discusses what made him great, what made him feared, and how many different Football Rushmore's his face graces. Then, Jim introduces his new weekly segment HOF MarketWatch, which will now be released every Friday morning on this channel (25:30).
2023-10-0935 minPod of FameDevin Hester with Jake AndersonJim is joined by his childhood friend and lifelong Chicago Bears fan Jake Anderson to discuss the hall of fame candidacy of former Bears return man Devin Hester. First, Jim and Jake talk about Hester's first two record-breaking seasons in the NFL, including his kick return touchdown that kicked off Super Bowl XLI (7:35). Next, they cover his field goal return touchdown, discuss how Hester reminds them of Deion Sanders and Ed Reed, and debate whether Hester is the greatest return man in NFL history (17:37). Finally, they discuss the importance of special teams players on a football team (45:32), before making...
2023-09-111h 09Pod of FameEpisode 164: Charles "Peanut" Tillman with Jacob InfanteJim is joined by lead NFL draft analyst and Chicago Bears writer for Windy City Gridiron, Jacob Infante, to discuss the hall of fame candidacy of former Bears cornerback, Charles "Peanut" Tillman. First, Jim and Jacob cover the first thing that comes to anyone's mind when they think of Tillman, the "Peanut Punch" (10:00). Next, they discuss his twice a year duels with Calvin Johnson, his record-setting four forced fumble game against the Tennessee Titans, and his performance in Super Bowl XLI (18:11). Finally, Jim and Jacob create a new statistic to measure defensive playmakers called "Turnover Opportunities," (35:19), before making a...
2023-06-191h 03Pod of FameEpisode 161: Carmelo Anthony Retires + Jim Brown PassesOn May 18th, Hall of Famer Jim Brown passed away at the age of 87. On May 22nd, Carmelo Anthony announced his retirement from the NBA after a 19-year career. In the first half of the podcast, we talk about the Carmelo Anthony's career and legacy (6:14). Then, we cover Jim Brown's NFL career, as well as his life off the field, both good and bad (23:44).
2023-05-2945 minPod of FameEpisode 158: Jim Edmonds with Bob HilleJim is joined by Bob Hille, Senior Editorial Consultant at Sporting News, to discuss the hall of fame candidacy of former MLB center fielder, Jim Edmonds. First, Bob and Jim cover the 2000s St. Louis Cardinals and where Edmonds ranked in the pecking order among Albert Pujols, Scott Rolen, Yadier Molina, and others (6:23). Next, they discuss Jim's famous catch in Game 7 of the 2004 NLCS, whether Edmonds was as good of a center fielder as his eight gold gloves lead us to believe he was, and the invention of Web Gems on Baseball Tonight (14:33). Finally, they compare Edmonds career to...
2023-05-081h 00Pod of FameEpisode 154: Rick Reuschel with Adam DarowskiJim is joined by Adam Darowski, Head of User Experience at Sports Reference, to break down down the hall of fame candidacy of former MLB pitcher Rick "Big Daddy" Reuschel. First, Adam and Jim discuss how WAR essentially makes or breaks Reuschel's HOF candidacy (8:11) . Next, they cover Reuschel's 1977 MLB season with the Chicago Cubs, how he compares to HOF pitchers Jim Kaat and Bert Blyleven, and just how bad of teams Reuschel played on during his career (17:14). Finally, Adam and Jim take a look at where Reuschel ranks among the best pitchers of the 1970s (46:14), before they both state...
2023-04-101h 08Pod of FameEpisode 153: 2023 Basketball Hall of Fame Class Announced + March Madness RecapJim provides his thoughts on the 2023 Basketball Hall of Fame Class, which was just announced over the weekend (2:55). Then, Jim welcomes Pod of Fame's Kentucky Correspondent Shannon Miloch to discuss March Madness, our favorite players of the tournament, the Final Four, and our predictions for the National Championship (34:15).
2023-04-031h 02Pod of FameEpisode 150: March Madness with Shannon MilochThe brackets have been released and work productivity is about to plummet. March Madness is officially here! Jim is joined by Pod of Fame's Kentucky Correspondent Shannon Miloch to discuss one of our favorite sporting events of the year. Jim and Shannon give their first reactions to this year's bracket, make their Final Four predictions, discuss their favorite first round matchups, and highlight their three players to watch in this year's tournament.
2023-03-1351 minPod of FameEpisode 143: Kenny Lofton with Jim IngrahamJim is joined by HOF voter and sportswriter Jim Ingraham to discuss the Hall of Fame candidacy of former MLB centerfielder Kenny Lofton. First, Jim talks about Lofton's first spring training with Cleveland and how in awe everyone was with Lofton's out of this world athleticism (6:28). Next, they discuss Lofton's ridiculous baserunning in Game 6 of the 1995 ALCS, how Lofton compares favorably to Tim Raines, and where Lofton's stellar WAR places him among the greatest centerfielders in MLB history (15:05). Finally, they cover how Lofton stacks up against the best centerfielders of the 1990s (37:50), before making a final call on whether...
2023-01-2352 minPod of FameEpisode 142: Willie Anderson with Mike SantagataJim is joined by NFL writer at AllBengals.com, Mike Santagata, to break down the career and Hall of Fame resume of former Cincinnati Bengals right tackle Willie Anderson. First, Mike and Jim cover Anderson's track record against the best sack artists in NFL history (7:14). Next, they discuss Anderson paving the way for Corey Dillon’s 278-rushing yard performance in 2000, how he compares to HOFer Tony Boselli, and if there is any real difference between right and left tackles (16:20). Finally, Jim and Mike run through the top tackles of the 1990s/2000s (28:05), before both making a final call on whether or...
2023-01-1647 minPod of FameEpisode 141: Wedding Week Mailbag with Shannon Bauer (yes, this is about sports)Jim is getting married this week. To celebrate, we have POF Social Media Manager, Kentucky Correspondent, and future Mrs. Miloch, Shannon Bauer joining to run through questions from our listeners. We debate whether or not Andre Iguodala belongs in the Hall of Fame, who the best young quarterback in the NFL is today, our thoughts on Torry Holt's HOF resume, the best ribs in Chicago, and much much more.
2023-01-091h 04Pod of FameEpisode 140: Gene Tenace with Adam DarowskiJim is joined by Adam Darowski, Head of User Experience at Sports Reference, to break down down the hall of fame candidacy of former MLB catcher Gene Tenace. First, Adam and Jim discuss why Tenace may very well have the most "hipster" case for the HOF (5:29). Next, they cover Gene's legendary performance in the 1972 World Series, how he compares to Harmon Killebrew, and what sabermetrics really make Tenace's case for the HOF (7:53). Finally, Adam and Jim have a discussion about how we apply our knowledge of baseball today to how we grade player's of the past (49:35), before they both...
2023-01-021h 12Pod of FameEpisode 138: Alex Rodriguez with Ken DavidoffJim is joined by former New York Post baseball columnist and and Hall of Fame voter Ken Davidoff to breakdown down the HOF candidacy of former MLB superstar Alex "A-Rod" Rodriguez. First, Ken and Jim discuss A-Rod's performance in October of 2009, where he helped lead the Yankees to their last World Series Championship (10:20). Next, they cover power hitting shortstops in baseball history, A-Rod's incredible athleticism and high baseball IQ, build Shortstop Mount Rushmore (20:49). Finally, Ken and Jim discuss PEDs and run through a number of "bad" guys already in the HOF today (29:07), before they both make a final call on w...
2022-12-1947 minPod of FameEpisode 137: Carlos Beltrán with Steve GardnerJim is joined by USA TODAY sports reporter and Hall of Fame voter Steve Gardner to breakdown down the HOF candidacy of former MLB outfielder Carlos Beltrán. First, Steve and Jim discuss how well-rounded of a player Beltrán really was, as he had no glaring weaknesses in his game (5:29). Next, they cover Beltrán's remarkable playoff run with the Houston Astros in 2004, his career's uncanny resemblance to HOFer Andre Dawson, and is membership in the exclusive 400 Home Run/300 Stolen Base Club (9:54). Finally, Steve and Jim discuss Beltran's role in the 2017 Astros sign stealing scandal (43:36), before they both make...
2022-12-121h 02Pod of FameEpisode 136: Fred McGriff Voted into HOF + World Cup Update and Christmas Movie Mount Rushmore with Shannon BauerJim first addresses the Contemporary Era Committees selection of Fred McGriff to the Hall of Fame and what the lack of votes for Barry Bonds and Roger Clemens means for them moving forward. Then, Jim is joined by Kentucky correspondent and POF Social Media Manager Shannon Bauer to discuss Team USA and the World Cup (7:22). Finally, Jim and Shannon each build their Christmas Movie Mount Rushmore (21:15).
2022-12-0539 minPod of FameEpisode 131: Bo Jackson with Jeff PearlmanJim is joined by New York Times bestselling author Jeff Pearlman to break down the Hall of Fame candidacy of former NFL running back and MLB outfielder Bo Jackson. First, Jeff and Jim discuss Bo Jackson's legendary 221-yard rushing performance on Monday Night Football against the Seattle Seahawks in 1987 (17:41). Next, Jeff compares Bo Jackson to both Jim Brown and Shawn Green (100% the first and only time those two athletes are brought up at the same time) and discuss if Bo could have made it into Cooperstown if he would have been able to stay healthy and committed himself to...
2022-10-3143 minPod of FameEpisode 124: Bill Russell TributeNBA legend Bill Russell passed away on July 31, 2022 at the age of 88. When Russell passed, Jim was climbing Mount Kilimanjaro, unaware that one of the best players in NBA history was no longer with us. A tribute to Russell has been long overdue. Jim covers Russell’s life, before exploring five areas of Russell’s career that go slightly overlooked by most (10:17). This includes topics such as just how great of a passer Russell was to how many Finals MVPs and Defensive Player of the Year awards Russell may have won if either award existed when he played. Finally, Jim reve...
2022-09-1250 minPod of FameEpisode 120: Tom Chambers with Jeff WellsJim is joined by Youtuber and Tom Chambers Superfan Jeff Wells to break down the HOF resume of former NBA power forward Tom Chambers. First, Jeff talks about how one becomes a Tom Chambers "Superfan." (3:02). Next, Jim and Jeff discuss Chambers' MVP performance in the 1987 All-Star game, his 60-point performance against his former team in 1990, how Chambers was the stretch 4 OG, and the significance of 20,000 Point Club Membership (14:38). Finally, Jim and Jeff rank Chambers among the best PFs of the 1980s and discuss Chambers' less than impressive advanced metrics totals (54:18), before they both make a final call on whether o...
2022-08-151h 16Pod of FameEpisode 118: Keith Hernandez with Chris BodigJim is joined by former producer for ESPN's Baseball Tonight and the creator of the website "Cooperstown Cred", Chris Bodig, to break down down the hall of fame candidacy of former MLB first baseman Keith Hernandez. First, Jim and Chris discuss Hernandez's defensive prowess and how Pete Rose once compared bunting against Hernandez to driving the lane against Boston Celtics legend Bill Russell (3:58). Next, they discuss his performance in the 1986 playoffs, go all the way back to the 1920s to find Hernandez's HOF twin, and talk through the significance of Hernandez winning 11 Gold Gloves (16:45). Finally, Jim and Chris rank...
2022-08-011h 16
Pod of FameEpisode 115: Paul Gasol with Arash MarkaziJim is joined by former columnist at The LA Times and current host of The Arash Markazi Show on ESPN 1090, Arash Markazi, to break down the hall of fame candidacy of former NBA big man Pau Gasol. First, Jim and Arash cover Pau Gasol's arrival in LA and how it instantly turned the Lakers into a title contender (12:18). Next, they discuss whether or not Gasol deserved Finals MVP in 2010, which HOF Celtics frontcourt player Gasol reminds Jim of, and the top European NBA players of all-time (14:39). Finally, they touch on why Gasol may have never received an MVP vote...
2022-07-1143 minPod of FameEpisode 112: Chad "Ochocinco" Johnson with Mike SantagataJim is joined by NFL writer at AllBengals.com, Mike Santagata, to break down the resume of former NFL wideout Chad Johnson, aka Chad Ochocinco. First, Mike and Jim cover the first thing that comes to everyone's mind when they think of Chad Johnson; the TD celebrations (5:02). Next, they revisit his peak seasons in 2005 and 2006 when he was one of the top two receivers in the NFL, compare his numbers to HOFers Calvin Johnson and Michael Irvin, and break down where Johnson ranks among the best WRs of the 2000s (8:45). Finally, Jim and Mike discuss how much Chad's low career c...
2022-06-2053 minPod of FameEpisode 111: Donovan McNabb with Jeff KerrJim is joined by NFL writer at CBS Sports, Jeff Kerr, to breakdown down the resume of former NFL quarterback Donovan McNabb. First, Jeff and Jim cover the 2002 Eagles game against the Cardinals where McNabb threw 4 TD passes despite playing on a broken ankle (4:16). Next, they compare McNabb to other great QBs that never won a Super Bowl, such as Fran Tarkenton and Jim Kelly, talk through McNabb's lack of All-Pro appearances, and break down where McNabb ranks among the best QBs of the 2000s (15:40). Finally, Jim and Jeff discuss McNabb's membership in the 5+ Championship Game Club (26:55), before they b...
2022-06-1340 minPod of FameEpisode 108: Steve Garvey with Barry BloomJim is joined by Hall of Fame voter and senior sportswriter for Sportico, Barry Bloom, to breakdown down the resume of former MLB first basemen Steve Garvey. First, Barry and Jim discuss Garvey's consistency and ironman streak (6:07). Next, they cover his game-winning home run in Game 4 of the 1984 NLCS, how Garvey compares to recent HOF inductee Gil Hodges, and Barry provides his thoughts on WAR (10:49). Finally, Jim and Barry debate whether there is a place for 1st basemen who only hit for average power in the HOF (39:44), before they both make a final call on whether or not they b...
2022-05-231h 04Pod of FameEpisode 99: Glenn Robinson with Jake KupfermanJim is joined by Milwaukee Bucks Expert and friend of the pod Jake Kupferman to break down the hall of fame candidacy of former Milwaukee Bucks swingman Glenn “Big Dog” Robinson. First, Jake and Jim discuss Robinson's offensive versatility and how he would have performed in today's NBA (9:22). Next, they cover Robinson's performance in the 1994 NCAA Tournament, compare him to two former #1 NBA picks, and rank the top 5 NBA small forwards of the 1990s (18:12). Finally, Jake and Jim build Milwaukee Bucks Mount Rushmore (68:27), before both stating whether or not they believe Robinson deserves a spot in the Basketball Hall of Fame...
2022-03-211h 52Pod of FameEpisode 94: 2022 Pro Football HOF Class RecapJim breaks down the recently announced 2022 Pro Football Hall of Fame Class this week. First, Jim discusses the career of all eight class members and whether or not he would have voted them in this year (3:45). Next, Jim provides his overall thoughts on the class, why he was shocked neither Torry Holt, Andre Johnson, or Reggie Wayne was elected, and how DeMarcus Ware should have made the HOF on his first try (24:19). Finally, Jim previews the 2023 HOF Class while also finding time to butcher the "Legion of Boom" nickname given to the Seahawks secondary of the 2010s (30:28).
2022-02-1436 minPod of FameEpisode 93: Reggie Wayne with George BremerJim is joined by Indianapolis Colts beat writer and sports editor for The Herald Bulletin, George Bremer, to break down the hall of fame candidacy of former Colts wide receiver Reggie Wayne. First, Jim and George discuss Wayne’s consistency throughout his 14-year career (4:34). Next, they cover the orange glove game, compare the peak Colts offenses of the 2000s to the St. Louis Rams “Greatest Show on Turf” teams, and discuss whether or not playing with Peyton Manning hurts his candidacy (6:37). Finally, George and Jim rank Wayne among the top wide receivers of his era (29:27), before both stating whether or not th...
2022-02-0742 minPod of FameEpisode 92: Brady "Retired" + 2022 Baseball HOF Class Recap + Big Ben + Defensive Players in HistoryJim first covers Tom Brady’s possible retirement at the top of the podcast. Next, he tackles the final voting results for the 2022 Baseball HOF class, including a break down of David Ortiz’s career, as well as his thoughts about Bonds/Clemens missing the cut (14:10). Then, Jim discusses Ben Roethlisberger's retirement and where he stands among the best QBs of the 21st Century (29:12). Finally, Jim comments on John Hollinger’s list of the top defensive players in NBA history, before unveiling his own top 10 list of defenders (39:06).
2022-01-3149 minPod of FameEpisode 91: Joe Nathan with Matt MartellJim is joined by Sports Illustrated Baseball Editor Matt Martell to break down the hall of fame candidacy of former MLB Closer Joe Nathan. First, Jim and Matt discuss Nathan's dominant stretch during the mid-2000s (6:21). Next, they discuss Game 163 of the 2009 season, some unfortunate playoff outings against the Yankees, and HOF comps (9:45). Finally, Matt and Jim rank the top relievers of Nathan's era (36:22), before both stating whether or not they believe Nathan deserves a spot in Cooperstown (46:36).
2022-01-2455 minPod of FameEpisode 90: Prince FielderJim goes solo this week when breaking down the hall of fame candidacy of former MLB First Baseman Prince Fielder. First, Jim covers how Prince Fielder owned All-Star week, from winning multiple home run derbies to being named MVP of the 2011 All-Star Game (3:30). Next, he reminisces about Fielder's 2003 50 homerun season and how he stacks up to HOFer Orlando Cepeda, and how Fielder's offensive numbers compare against HOF 1st Baseman and other 2022 candidates (7:16). Finally, Jim discusses the injuries that prematurely ended Fielder's career at the age of 32 (17:44), before stating whether or not he believes Fielder belongs in Cooperstown (23:42).
2022-01-1726 minPod of FameEpisode 86: Torii HunterJim goes solo this week when breaking down the hall of fame candidacy of former MLB center fielder Torii Hunter. First, Jim covers how Hunter earned the nickname "Spider-Man" (1:52). Next, he reminisces about Hunter's performance in the 2002 All-star game, talks about Ken Griffey Jr., and details Hunter's underrated ability to drive in runs (5:05). Finally, Jim discusses a number of Hunter's contemporaries (13:45), before stating whether or not he believes Hunter belongs in Cooperstown (22:35).
2021-12-2027 minPod of FameEpisode 85: Manny Ramirez with Steve GardnerOn today's podcast, Jim is joined by USA TODAY Sports reporter and Hall of Fame Voter Steve Gardner to breakdown down the resume of former MLB outfielder Manny Ramirez. First, Steve and Jim discuss their favorite “Manny being Manny” moments (5:07). Next, they cover the 2004 World Series, Manny's elite slugging numbers, and just how much of a liability Manny was in the outfield (12:51). Finally, Steve explains his take on steroid-era players (37:15), before both Jim and Steve make a final call on whether or not they believe Ramirez deserves to gain entry into Cooperstown (47:29).
2021-12-1353 minPod of FameEpisode 83: Bill Dahlen with Adam DarowskiJim is joined by Adam Darowski, Head of User Experience at Sports Reference, to break down down the hall of fame candidacy of former MLB shortstop Bill Dahlen. First, Adam and Jim discuss how WAR plays a major factory in Dahlen's Cooperstown case. Next, they cover his 42-game hitting streak and rank Dahlen among other shortstops who played in the late 19th Century/early 20th Century. Finally, Adam and Jim talk about how Dahlen's temper and off-the-field issues harmed his HOF candidacy (Jim compares him to Ron Artest and Dennis Rodman, which is definitely the first time all three of...
2021-11-291h 03Pod of FameEpisode 81: Minnie Miñoso with Adam DarowskiJim is joined by Adam Darowski, Head of User Experience at Sports Reference, to break down down the hall of fame candidacy of former MLB outfielder Minnie Miñoso. First, Adam and Jim discuss how Miñoso was a pioneer and his importance in baseball history. Next, they detail Miñoso's path to his first full MLB season in 1951, discuss how Miñoso compares to HOFer Larry Doby and how the MLB finally recognizing Negro League statistics officially impacts Miñoso’s career numbers. Finally, Adam and Jim talk about how Miñoso’s appearances with the White Sox in his 50s ma...
2021-11-221h 13Pod of FameEpisode 78: NBA 75th Anniversary Team RecapJim Miloch is joined by friend of the pod and host of the podcast "Whatever Wando", Dave Wandolowski, to discuss the NBA 75th Anniversary Team that was recently announced to celebrate the 75th Anniversary of the NBA. They discuss the biggest surprises, what players they believe should have made the list that were left off, and finish out by recapping some of the Twitter "fights" Jim got into following the release of the list.
2021-11-011h 10Pod of FameEpisode 76: Del ShofnerJim goes solo this week when breaking down the hall of fame candidacy of former NFL wide receiver Del Shofner. First, Jim walks through Del's peak from 1958-1963 and covers other NFL greats that had short, but HOF careers (7:46). Next, he talks about similarities between Shofner and Calvin Johnson, how significant making the All-Pro 1st team five times is, and how Shofner compares to other great receivers from the 1950s/1960s (15:49). Finally, Jim discusses the glaring holes in Del's HOF resume (32:23), before stating whether or not he believes Shoftner belongs in the Football Hall of Fame (37:05).
2021-10-1840 minPod of FameEpisode 75: Zach Randolph with Joe MullinaxJim is joined by Site Manager of SB Nation's Grizzly Bear Blues and Host of Grizzly Bear Blues Live, Joe Mullinax, to break down the hall of fame candidacy of former Memphis Grizzlies Power Forward Zach Randolph. First, Jim and Joe discuss the Grit and Grind Era and how Randolph was made to be in Memphis, Tennessee (7:00). Next, they talk about the infamous first round of the 2011 postseason when Memphis took down the #1 seed San Antonio Spurs and how Randolph compares best to HOF centers from the 1970s (17:18). Finally, Joe and Jim run through the top power forwards of the 21...
2021-10-1148 minPod of FameEpisode 74: Jim Marshall with Luke BraunJim is joined by the host of the podcast "Locked on Vikings", Luke Braun, to break down down the hall of fame candidacy of former Minnesota Vikings Defensive End Jim Marshall. First, Jim and Luke discuss how Marshall defied the odds by playing in 282 consecutive games as a defensive end in the 1960s and 1970s (5:26). Next, they discuss the infamous 1964 "Wrong Way" game and Luke tries to convince Jim that former kicker Morten Anderson is Marshall's HOF comp (7:56). Finally, Luke and Jim talk about how Marshall retired near the top of the record books in several key statistics, including career...
2021-10-0445 minPod of FameEpisode 73: Walter Davis with Mat IssaJim is joined by the Chief Content Officer of Rise Network and the creator of "The Quest for the Best" podcast miniseries, Mat Issa, to break down down the hall of fame candidacy of former Phoenix Suns shooting guard Walter Davis. First, Jim and Mat discuss the unique NBA scoring record Davis still holds (5:11). Next, they discuss the under-the-radar playoff success Davis had on the Phoenix Suns, how he compares to George "the Iceman" Gervin and Mitch Richmond, and how he grades on a new statistic Mat has created (10:52). Finally, Mat and Jim tackle how cocaine may be the main...
2021-09-271h 12Pod of FameEpisode 69: Dale Murphy with Clayton TrutorJim is joined by author Clayton Trutor to break down down the hall of fame candidacy of former MLB slugger Dale Murphy. First, Jim and Clayton discuss how and why Murphy was the first cable television star in sports history (4:36). Next, they talk about his dominant run in the 1980s, how he compares to HOFer Jim Rice as a player, and whether Murphy passing the Bill James "ink test" matters (8:44). Finally, they discuss whether the success of the 1990s Braves may have hurt Murphy's candidacy (37:58), before both stating whether or not they believe Murphy deserves a plaque in Cooperstown (45:06). After...
2021-08-3059 minPod of FameEpisode 61: Mookie Blaylock with Neil PaineJim is joined by Neil Paine, senior writer for FiveThirtyEight, to break down the hall of fame candidacy of former NBA point guard Mookie Blaylock. Jim and Neil first talk about the unique connection between Mookie and Pearl Jam (4:22). Then, they cover how advanced metrics favor Blaylock, the misfortune of being in the Eastern Conference playoffs during the 90s, and Mo Cheeks (10:37). Next, they discuss a higher unusual statistic that Blaylock ranks first all-time, his stellar career at Oklahoma, and the tragic consequences of Mookie's off-the-court issues (33:50). Finally, Neil and Jim each build a Mount Rushmore composed of the best de...
2021-07-051h 19Pod of FameEpisode 60: Jimmy Rollins with Jayson StarkJim is joined by Jayson Stark, Senior Baseball Writer at The Athletic, to breakdown down the resume of former MLB Shortstop Jimmy Rollins. First, Jayson talks about Jimmy's personality and high baseball IQ (3:18). Next, Jayson and Jim discuss Jimmy's walk-off double in Game 4 of the 2009 NLCS, why Rollins reminds Jayson of Rickey Henderson, and the unique statistical "clubs" Rollins is a member of in MLB history (9:02). Then, they both debate which player on those Phillies World Series teams has the best chance at getting into Cooperstown and why sabermetrics may sink Jimmy's HOF case (28:37). Finally, Jayson and Jim discuss whether...
2021-06-2850 minPod of FameEpisode 59: Already In Series Special on Walter PaytonIn our "Already In" Series debut, Jim breaks down the career of Chicago Bears running back Walter Payton (HOF Class of 93). Jim first talks about the unique combination of power and grace Payton played with during his 13-year career (9:37). Next, he covers the record-setting 275-yard performance against the Minnesota Vikings in 1977 and how Payton compares to LaDainian Tomlinson (13:48). Then, Jim introduces two new segments; What is Your Legacy (22:27) and Rushmore (29:52). Finally, Jim brings on his dad, who talks about what it was like watching Payton live and provides a detailed account of his personal encounter with Payton (44:12).
2021-06-2155 minPod of FameEpisode 52: Shawn Kemp with David WandolowskiJim is joined by friend of the pod and Shawn Kemp superfan, David "Wando" Wandolowski, to discuss the hall of fame candidacy of former Seattle Supersonic Shawn Kemp. Jim and Wando first discuss NBA Jam, the dope Supersonics jerseys from the 90s, and Game 4 of the 1992 playoffs against the Golden State Warriors (06:28). Then, they cover the 1996 NBA playoffs and who the best power forwards of the 90s were (45:20). Finally, Dave and Jim break down Kemp's shortcomings, including his weight and drug problems that ended his career prematurely (1:05:30), before making a call on whether or not they believe Kemp will ever...
2021-05-101h 31Pod of FameEpisode 47: Michael Cooper with Roland LazenbyJim is joined by Roland Lazenby, the author of dozens of nonfiction sports books, to breakdown the hall of fame candidacy of former NBA guard Michael Cooper. Jim and Roland first discuss Cooper's ability to guard Larry Bird (6:08). Then, they cover Cooper's 1987 season, similarities to K.C. Jones, and Cooper's role on Laker teams of the 1980s (8:20). Finally, they discuss whether Magic Johnson would have won five NBA Championships without Coop (32:20), before reaching a final verdict on whether or not Cooper belongs in the Basketball Hall of Fame (36:48). Jim and Roland then briefly discuss the recent passing of HOFer Elgin...
2021-03-2958 minPod of FameEpisode 39: 2021 Football & Baseball Hall of Fame Class ReviewOn this week's special podcast, Jim breaks down the 2021 Football Hall of Fame Class, as well as the non-existent 2021 Baseball Hall of Fame Class. When it comes to Canton, Jim briefly discusses the career of all eight class members and then provides a brief preview of new players eligible for the 2022 class (3:56). Next, Jim covers the rarity of zero inductees for a Baseball HOF Class, reveals what his ballot would have looked like, and then gives the eight players who did not make it past the 5% threshold a proper sendoff, complete with fake HOF plaques for everyone from Aramis...
2021-02-081h 06Pod of FameEpisode 38: Alan Faneca with Joe StarkeyOn today’s podcast, Jim is joined by Joe Starkey from 93.7 The Fan and the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, to breakdown the hall of fame candidacy of former NFL guard Alan Faneca. Jim and Joe first discuss how much of a technician Faneca was on the field and how he was one of the few offensive linemen capable of consistently making highlight plays (6:32). Next, they compare Faneca and HOFer Steve Hutchinson, discuss the lack of respect guards receive from the HOF, and decide whether Faneca passes the "Orlando Pace" test (18:08). Finally, Joe and Jim make podcast history by building the first Mo...
2021-02-0145 minPod of FameEpisode 37: Sam Mills with Darin GanttOn today’s podcast, Jim is joined by hall of fame voter and writer for Panthers.com Darin Gantt to breakdown the hall of fame candidacy of former linebacker Sam Mills. Jim and Darin first discuss how Mills was a foundational piece of every defense he played for and why he means so much to the Panthers organization despite playing only three seasons there (11:39). Next, they talk Mike Singletary, Jim Mora quotes, how HOF voting for defensive players is a blend of art and science, and the dominant USFL career Mills had before reaching the NFL (20:50). Finally, they discuss the hig...
2021-01-2546 minPod of FameEpisode 27: Mark Buehrle with Scott MerkinOn today’s podcast, Jim is joined by Scott Merkin, Chicago White Sox beat writer for MLB.com, to breakdown the hall of fame candidacy of former MLB pitcher Mark Buehrle. Jim and Scott first discuss Buehrle's remarkable efficiency and some of his top performances, including his perfect game and performance in the 2005 World Series (3:49). Then, they talk Catfish Hunter, Bob Lemon, Jack Morris, and Buehrle's consistency (15:00). Finally, they run through a list of the best pitchers from the 2000s, before making a final verdict on whether or not Buehrle deserves a place in Cooperstown (32:03). Jim then debts his new seg...
2020-11-301h 40Pod of FameEpisode 9: Shawn Marion with Gerald BourguetOn today's podcast, Jim is joined by FanSided NBA Junior Editor and Phoenix Suns Reporter Gerald Bourguet to breakdown down the resume of former Phoenix Suns forward Shawn Marion. First, Jim and Gerald discuss the undefeated bubble Suns and what it was like covering a team in the Orlando bubble (2:11), before attempting to describe just how ugly Marion's shooting motion really was (11:38). Next, we discuss Marion's 2006 NBA season and his especially dominant second round playoff performance against the Los Angeles Clippers (19:09), the similarities his career shares with both Ralph Sampson and Jamaal Wilkes (27:07), and just how rare some of h...
2020-08-241h 14Pod of FameEpisode 8: Bobby AbreuOn today's podcast, Jim breaks down the resume of former MLB right fielder Bobby Abreu. First, Jim talks about the show Abreu put on during the 2005 home run derby (1:53) and then breaks down the diversified offensive portfolio Abreu held throughout this career (6:48). Next, Jim compares Abreu and recent Cooperstown inductee Vladimir Guerro and breaks down why Vlad got so much love during his playing career than Abreu did (11:48). Then Jim introduces his newest short segment "Holy Stats" (21:18) and talks about how there have only been 44 legitimate 5-tool players in MLB history, Abreu included (22:50). Jim then talks about how all of th...
2020-08-1744 minPod of FameEpisode 7: Sterling SharpeOn today's podcast, Jim breaks down the resume of former Green Bay Packers wide receiver Sterling Sharpe. Jim talks about the freak injury that ended Sharpe's career prematurely and how different safety protocols were in the NFL during the early 90s (3:02). Next, Jim covers the four touchdown Thanksgiving Day performance Sharpe threw down on the Dallas Cowboys in 1994 (7.58), before breaking down his list of top five turkey day foods (11:48). Then, Jim breaks down the 1992-1994 peak of Sharpe and how his career achievements stack up against Calvin Johnson, Issac Bruce, and other prolific wide receivers of the last 30 years (25:43). Finally, J...
2020-08-1041 minPod of FameEpisode 6: Vince CarterOn today's podcast, Jim breaks down the 22-year Hall of Fame resume of recently retired NBA swingman Vince Carter. Jim talks about the best dunk in Olympic basketball history (4:16), before providing an overly detailed retelling of the 2000 slam dunk competition (13:48). Next, Jim tells us where Vince Carter lands on his list of top dunkers of all-time (27:34) and breaks down just how impressive and improbable having a 22-year career in the NBA really is (31:49). Then, Jim hits on Carter trading 50-point games with Allen Iverson in the 2001 NBA playoffs (39:28) and why Carter only making two All-NBA teams is pretty unimpressive co...
2020-08-0352 minPod of FameEpisode 5: Scott RolenOn today's podcast, Jim breaks down the Hall of Fame resume of former MLB third baseman Scott Rolen. Jim discusses Rolen's defense and how he was the Brooks Robinson of his generation (2:59), before breaking down the 2006 World Series and why Rolen should have been World Series MVP (8:56). For our "And Twins" segment, Jim compares Rolen to Hall of Famer Ron Santo and touches on the unfair treatment of Santo by Hall of Fame voters of years past (13:15). Then, Jim breaks down why sabermetrics are Scott Rolen's friend and uncovers that Rolen may have had the 5th best season by a...
2020-07-2747 minPod of FameEpisode 4: Joe JohnsonOn today's podcast, Jim breaks down the hall of fame resume of former NBA swingman and reigning Big3 MVP Joe Johnson. Jim first discusses Johnson's recent performance in The Basketball Tournament and his record-breaking 2019 Big3 season (3:49) and about just how much money Johnson made during his 17-year NBA career (14:56). Then, Jim talks about how Johnson's NBA resume closely resembles Hall of Famer Alex English, and whether or not the simplicity of Joe Johnson's name actually hurts his HOF candidacy (18:37). Next, Jim attempts to figure out how many career points is the equivalent to the baseball hall of fame milestone...
2020-07-201h 03Pod of FameEpisode 3: Matt ForteOn our third podcast, Jim breaks down the hall of fame resume of former Chicago Bears running back Matt Forte. Jim first discusses how Forte is one of the best three-down backs in NFL history (5:51) and reviews his record-setting 2014 season (10:30). Then, we take a look at how Forte's career closely resembles Buffalo Bills Hall of Fame running back Thurman Thomas (12:58), before coming to the unfortunate realization that Mitchell Trubisky and Matt Forte have more in common than just playing for the Bears (30:15). Finally, Jim ranks the top running backs of the 2010s (36:23) before coming to a verdict on whether o...
2020-07-1344 minPod of FameEpisode 2: CC SabathiaOn our first podcast regarding admittance to Cooperstown, Jim breaks down the hall of fame candidacy of pitcher CC Sabathia. After coming to the realization that CC may have one of last great workhorses to ever play in the MLB (2:31), we take a look at his ridiculous stint in Milwaukee (5:42) and how his career compares to Hall of Famer Mike Mussina (14:22). Then Jim looks at the time CC carried the Yankees to the World Series (23:19), before talking about how many pitchers were actually better than CC during his CY Young season (27.31). Finally, Jim provides his verdict on whether or...
2020-07-1336 min