Shows
Rated P For ParanormalDeadly FriendOwen doesn’t have any friends, but you sure do: Tony & Matty! And they’re gonna guide you through this 80’s lost gem. Plus top three balls in film history.
2025-11-271h 32
Rated P For ParanormalNosferatu & Top 3 "Can This Be Over Now" Love Moments in film historyVe Vant To Suck Yer Blood.
Just lie there and enjoy it if you can.
It'll be over soon.
PLUS! Tony gets mad at Matty's reaction to Werner Herzog's version.
AND! Our Top 3 "Can This Be Over Now?" Love Scenes in film history.
2024-11-151h 16
Rated P For ParanormalJohn Carpenter's HALLOWEEN & Top 3 Dumb BoyfriendsHAPPY HALLOWEEN p4p 'ers!
Not so much review, as tribute.
Love,
Tony & Matty
2024-10-281h 17
Rated P For ParanormalFRIDAY THE 13th & Top 3 Crazy Moms in FilmThe true horror is how many times Matty has mentioned he is 1 degree of Kevin Bacon.
2024-10-241h 14Rated P For Paranormal30 Coins & T3 Bad BabiesWill Matty freak out over this series which includes a Catholic storyline?
Will he be able to shoe horn in more Sly & Arnold references?
The answers are YES & NO, but not necessarily in that order...
PLUS! Top 3 Bad Babies in film history.
2024-10-091h 23Rated P For ParanormalWhen Evil LurksIs this one lurking around possibly being an all-time p4p film? Plus: Top 3 “We Don’t Wanna Go To THAT School” in film history.
2024-02-011h 10
Rated P For ParanormalThe Last Voyage of the Demeter🎶The Dracula Boat…promises something for everyone 🎶
2024-01-191h 07
Rated P For ParanormalThe 2024 TONY & MATTY AWARDSWe look back at the best & worst of our 2023 reviews!
2024-01-1245 min
Rated P For ParanormalTalk To MeTalk to us about Talk To Me. Plus our Top 3 Holiday Hi-jinks for Christmas!
2023-12-211h 10
Rated P For ParanormalNo One Will Save You-The boys review this new alien film, but who really needs saving? The characters? All humans? The script? -Tony takes us back to the movies, this week: 1931. -PLUS our Top 3, this week: TOP 3 ALIEN KILLS in film history. Let’s go!
2023-11-3057 min
2023-11-181h 07
2023-10-3156 min
Rated P For ParanormalEndangered SpeciesOh, wait. Maybe WE are the endangered species...?
Or maybe not.
We're deeply confused.
This one's a doozy.
2023-08-301h 22Rated P For ParanormalThis One's For Mr. ArkinA special episode in which we pay homage to Tony's father & friend, the GREAT Alan Arkin.
But as Mr. Arkin would want the boys get right to it and talk movies!
In this case THE OMEN (1 &2).
This one (and every one after this)...is for Tony's Dad.
Thank you Alan Arkin.
2023-08-151h 23
Rated P For ParanormalM3GANWe have a doll.
Her name is MeTHREEgan.
Come play with us.
PLUS! Top 3 Misspelled Titles In Film History.
2023-06-021h 11
Rated P For ParanormalThe BirdsWe take on a classic film & director.
THE BIRDS
Plus: our TOP 3 High Pants in film/tv history!
COME FLY WITH US!
2023-04-301h 06
Rated P For ParanormalPOUND RIDGE & Top 3 Cigarette Moments In Film HistoryTony & Matty finally talk about their short POUND RIDGE.
With a very special guest!
We seriously recommend you watch their short (on our social media & Matty Blake's YouTube channel) before you listen!
If you are a young budding artist or a salty 'ole pro or maybe just need some creative spark...this episode is for you!
Speaking of sparks: our Top 3 this week is based on Matty's excellent cigarette smoking in Pound Ridge. We'll rank the TOP 3 Cigarette Moments in Film!
2023-04-131h 27
Rated P For ParanormalMONKEY SHINES w/ The Puppy Bowl RefHe's back!
From Animal Planet's PUPPY BOWL it's the REF himself DAN SCHACHNER.
We once again go to our animal correspondent to help us with MONKEY SHINES.
Plus our TOP 3 Small Animal Attacks in film history.
Let's P4P like monkeys!
2023-03-171h 37
Rated P For ParanormalPART 2: INVASION OF THE BODY SNATCHERS (1978) & Top 3 MALE PERMSNow we move from the 50's to the 70's in part DUEX of our Invasion Of The Body Snatchers 2 part special.
Plus: The boys take on the current "shooting down UFO" craze.
Then: Top 3 Male Perms in film history.
YOU'RE NEXT!! (to enjoy a new P4P).
2023-02-241h 22
Rated P For ParanormalInvasion Of The Body Snatchers Pt 1 & Top 3 Syringe StabsA special guest helps the boys open the PODS.
INVASION OF THE BODY SNATCHERS (1956).
Plus Top 3 Syringe Stabs in film history.
This episode is coming for you!
2023-02-101h 10
Rated P For ParanormalSOMETHING IN THE DIRT & Top 3 Crappy ApartmentsWe review the DIY sci fi, paranormal thriller SOMETHING IN THE DIRT.
Matty knows all about searching for treasure in the dirt around the world...but have we found a gem here?
Or should it remain buried? Let's get in this hot cramped apartment together and find out!
And inspired by the cramped quarters of this film our TOP 3 list this week: TOP 3 CRAPPY APARTMENTS IN FILM HISTORY
You don't even have to sign a lease...It's P4P!
2023-01-1958 min
Rated P For ParanormalA Christmas Horror Story & The TONY & MATTY AWARDS!Our Christmas Special!
We'll unwrap A CHRISTMAS HORROR STORY.
Is it a Red Ryder BB Gun or a pink bunny costume from Aunt Clara?
Also get your tuxes ready it's the 2nd Annual Tony & Matty Awards!
Let's GO!!
2022-12-161h 07
Rated P For ParanormalThe Secret Of Skinwalker RanchThis is the long promised discussion w/ an Executive Producer of The Secret Of Skinwalker Ranch.
The boys welcome Jason Shook into the P4P universe.
You can't get anymore behind the scenes of Skinwalker Ranch than this. Unless you go through the gates-like Jason does every day, for months.
A MUST listen and share for anyone interested in this mystery!
2022-12-0152 min
Rated P For ParanormalPREYWe stream the new Hulu hit PREY.
Is this new addition to the Predator universe out of this world?
Or is it one...ugly....Mother....well you know the rest.
And Matty gets emotional w/ the karate kid.
PLUS! Our Top 3 DOG BUDDIES in history.
2022-11-121h 15
Rated P For ParanormalP4P Halloween Special: A NIGHTMARE ON ELM STREETWanna Trick Or Treat w/ Tony & Matty on ELM STREET?
We take on this classic for our Halloween Special.
Plus our TOP 3 list inspired by Freddy: Top 3 Sweaters In Film History.
AND stay til the end for a little Halloween TREAT
HAPPY HALLOWEEN p4p'ers!
We love you all!
2022-10-291h 08
Rated P For ParanormalThe POWER & Top 3 NursesYou had us at 1970's nurses overnight in a haunted hospital during a forced blackout.
But is the POWER all powerful, or did this movie need some electricity?
PLUS...Halloween fun w/ Sly & Arnold.
And our P4P TOP 3 this week? TOP 3 ALL TIME MOVIE NURSES.
Don't fight the power, listen NOW!
2022-10-241h 02
Rated P For ParanormalThe Wretched & Top RoadKill MomentsHow do you get along with your neighbors?
Well, The Wretched takes that question to a whole new level.
What else...oh yeah...no. Forget it. We can't remember what else is in this episode.
That will make sense when you listen. OR WILL IT?
2022-10-141h 15
Rated P For ParanormalNOPE & ET's Earth MamaThe boys take on Jordan Peele's NOPE.
PLUS Matty got to speak w/ DEE WALLACE & got catty.
And our T3 Helmets in film history.
YUP. The boys are back.
A brand new p4p 4 U!
2022-10-071h 08
Rated P For ParanormalMatty & Tony RAWSorry, you'll get no bells and whistles on this catch-up episode.
What you will get is Matty & Tony raw and in your face. Ew. Gross. Sorry.
Plus a new update and announcement on our incredible next episode.
AND a Top 3 that really should drive away most listeners.
Your Anti-Podcast is back P4P'ers!
---
Send in a voice message: https://anchor.fm/ratedparanormal/message
Support this podcast: https://anchor.fm/ratedparanormal/support
2022-08-1752 min
Rated P For ParanormalTHE GATE & T3 Holes in FilmYou gotta' dig down deep to find gold. Or something like that.
Matty and Tony discuss 1987's underseen "The Gate".
2022-07-081h 08
Rated P For ParanormalStranger Things 4This one goes to Eleven.
Matty & Tony are hip.
They are with it.
So they are taking on STRANGER THINGS 4 on Netflix.
Plus we rate our Top 3 Secret Facilities in film/tv history.
Did the boys get this one right? Or should we cast them into the upside down?
Let's hear from YOU!
2022-06-271h 10
Rated P For ParanormalSPLASH & Top 3 Interspecies RelationshipsWe dive into a new type of cryptid for us to talk about: mermaids.
We take on the 80's classic SPLASH.
Plus our Top 3 Interspecies relationships in film history.
Still wanna dive in? BOCCE BALLS! Let's go!
2022-06-171h 02
Rated P For ParanormalTHE DEEP HOUSE & T3 Underwater Scenes EverMatty tries to pull Tony into deep water but Tony ain't having it.
Plus: our T3 Underwater scenes in film history.
Let's DIVE into THE DEEP HOUSE.
2022-06-071h 04
Rated P For ParanormalCARRIE: A Prom PorkingREPENT and listen to this episode right now or it's back to the prayer closet for you.
We get bloody with CARRIE.
Plus our T3 this week Top 3 Religious Fanatics In Film History.
2022-05-2158 min
Rated P For ParanormalMONSTRUM & THE PUPPY BOWL REFHostile takeover or synergistic partnership?
Dan Schachner returns and much like when Monstrum appears...all hell breaks loose.
Plus we'll list our Top 3 Torn Apart Bodies In Film History.
Have Matty & Tony finally sold out to corporate interests?
Find out now! P4P all NEW just for YOU!
2022-05-111h 29
Rated P For ParanormalBUBBA HO TEP & Top 3 Geriatric Attacks In Film HistoryWear headphones on this one if w/ your kids or at work.
We thank you. WEthankyouverymuch.
P4P
---
Send in a voice message: https://anchor.fm/ratedparanormal/message
Support this podcast: https://anchor.fm/ratedparanormal/support
2022-04-281h 04
2022-04-231h 14
Rated P For ParanormalAMITYVILLE HORROR & Top 3 DADS IN UNDERPANTSGET. OUT.
No, seriously you should get out.
Our Top 3 should be enough to make you run.
2022-03-311h 14
Rated P For ParanormalFROM BEYOND & Top 3 Shoulder Pads in Film HistoryWARNING: This episode may engorge your pineal gland.
We are sorry.
OR ARE WE?
2022-03-241h 19
Rated P For ParanormalARCHIVE 81 & Top 3 First Person Camera Moments In HistoryWe get our stream on w/ the paranormal Netflix series ARCHIVE 81.
Our Top 3 list this week is "Top 3 First-Person Camera Moments" in Film History.
Plus, we learn some St. Paddy's Day dark secrets...or DO WE?
New Ep of P4P 4U NOW. Let's GOOOOO!
2022-03-191h 10
Rated P For ParanormalTHE SHINING & Top 3 Baseball Bats In Film HistoryWe finally take on the maze!
Our thoughts on mega classic THE SHINING.
Plus our Wendy Torrance inspired Top 3: Baseball Bats in film history.
Heeere's Tony&Matty!!!
2022-03-101h 07
Rated P For ParanormalALIENS AT THE PENTAGON & TOP 3 JACKETS IN FILM HISTORYWe are DONE w/ UFO documentaries. Certain kinds, anyway...
This one gets ugly.
Find out why Tony & Matty are spitting fire on this one.
Jackets ARE required, sorry Mr. Collins.
2022-03-031h 18
Rated P For ParanormalThe 8th Night & Top 3 Creepy SmilesDick Van Patten might have thought 8 is Enough but does Tony Van Matty?
That makes no sense, which is a perfect theme for this episode.
Plus: our Top 3 Creepy Smiles in film history.
Love us 8 times, baby!
Ew.
Let's GO!
2022-02-251h 11
Rated P For ParanormalAbbott & Costello Meet Frankenstein & Top SLAPS In HistoryBud & Lou got us ranking the top open hand SLAPS in film history.
But does the film "hurt so good" like the slaps?
Or was this just a slap in the face.
FIRE BAD...or IS IT?
FInd out now P4P'ers!
2022-02-171h 09
Rated P For ParanormalATTACK THE BLOCK & Top 3 Arm Yourself MomentsIt's another alien invasion in ATTACK THE BLOCK.
But why is this one so unique?
AND: you might need to arm yourself for our TOP 3 ARMING YOURSELF moments in film history, where Matty pushes Tony to his action - movie limits.
Gear up and turn on those subtitles cuz we're attackin' the block!
2022-02-101h 04
Rated P For ParanormalWENDIGO & The Top 3 Creepy LocalsWhere did you go, WENDIGO?
Was this film a bit forgotten for a reason?
Or is this a lost gem?
Find out now.
Plus: our Top 3 Creepy Locals in film history.
Let's go Wendigo!
2022-02-021h 17
Rated P For ParanormalPET SEMATARY & THE PUPPY BOWL REFThe Puppy Bowl Ref himself Dan Schachner drops in to help us review PET SEMATARY.
Plus, our TOP 3 CHILDREN ATTACKS in film history.
This is our funniest episode yet, which is saying something for a movie about re-animating corpses.
P4P let's go!
2022-01-271h 12
Rated P For ParanormalALIEN and the Matty & Tony Awards!It's our 1 year / 50th episode celebration with ALIEN!
PLUS The 1st Annual Matty & Tony Awards!
We'll look back at the 50 movies we've covered and award a Tony in the following categories:
-Favorite Shot
-Favorite Scene
-Favorite Line
-Best Overall Performance
-Best Overall FILM
Play along, won't you? Happy 50th P4P'ers!
2022-01-211h 07
Rated P For ParanormalEND OF DAYS: The Arnold ArgumentTony & Matty do battle over ARNOLD.
The End Of Days may begin with a war between podcast hosts!
Plus: A new Top 3: The Top 3 "I've Never Held A Gun Before But I'm Going To Use One" moments in film history!
Play & Fight along P4P'ers!
2022-01-131h 03
Rated P For ParanormalGhostBusters 2: We Feel SlimeyGhostbusters is beloved, but what of the second attempt?
Tony & Matty get trudge in the paranormal sludge for you.
And! Our Top 3 Tall Hair Moments in film history.
Let's bust some slimes!
2022-01-061h 23
Rated P For ParanormalThe GINGERDEAD MAN: This Cookie Didn't CrumbleOur Christmas special is under your pod tree.
The GingerDead Man.
You need to dunk this movie into your Christmas nog.
Trust us, we are as surprised as you are.
Plus: a new Matty game!
And: Our Top 3 "Why Are You Eating That?" moments in film history.
MERRY CHRISTMAS YOU WONDERFUL 'OLE P4Pers!
2021-12-241h 06
Rated P For ParanormalELVES: Why Are You Touching That?We venture into the forest to review ELVES.
And present our TOP 3 "Why Are You Touching That?" scenes in film history.
Plus: we get lost in our own junk drawer!
All that & more on this all new CHRISTMAS themed P4P!
2021-12-161h 02
Rated P For ParanormalSENDER: Darling You Sender Me, Honest You DoThis is the episode we've been dreaming of for a long time: Matty interviews Tony about his film SENDER.
We are joined by the Producer (and one of the stars of the film) Michael King.
If you haven't...WATCH SENDER by ANTHONY ARKIN!
A momentous episode for P4P.
2021-12-081h 07
Rated P For ParanormalThe FRIGHTENERS: Matty Thinks Michael J Is A FOXParanormal Investigator BRIAN CANO suggested this film.
Did he want us to rediscover a lost gem?
Or was did he set a paranormal ghost trap?
Plus! Matty's got (another) Man Crush!
A brand new P4P 4U!
2021-12-011h 07
Rated P For ParanormalFIRESTARTER: "We Didn't Like The Fire" w/ special guest Brian CanoA special guest joins us for this mega episode: Paranormal Investigator BRIAN CANO.
Plus Tony & Matty get heated about 1984's FIRESTARTER
This is episode is LIT P4P is on fire!
2021-11-181h 27
Rated P For ParanormalPATRICK: "Shoulda Stayed In Bed"Grab a bedpan & join Tony & Matty in room 15 as they turn over PATRICK (1978). Plus…in honor of the titular, bed-ridden telepath, we pick our TOP HOSPITAL BED SCENES OF ALL TIME. * no frogs were harmed during the recording of this podcast.
2021-11-1153 min
Rated P For ParanormalDEAD ZONE: "Dead Man WALKEN'Enter 1983's THE DEAD ZONE w/ Tony & Matty
Can you see the future and predict what we will think of this film?
PLUS: the return of SCREAMIN' SHEEN!
A brand new P4P 4 U!
2021-11-041h 08
Rated P For ParanormalHalloween Kills: MEH-chael MyersBOUNUS HALLOWEEN TREAT EPISODE JUST FOR YOU P4Pers!
The boys ventured into Haddonfield to give you their take on Halloween Kills.
Is this a treat filled with creamy nougat? Or are razor blades in this script?
We promise to never say "creamy nougat" ever again.
HAPPY HALLOWEEN!
2021-10-3043 min
Rated P For ParanormalExorcist III: "You Had Us At Fabio"As promised, our Halloween treat! The final installment of our Exorcist trilogy, William Peter Blatty's Exorcist III.
Amelia Campbell (Arkin) who appears in the film, joins us and talks about her incredible experience.
Also, we dip our toes into the controversy surrounding the recent on-set tragedy involving Alec Baldwin.
Oh, and Tony almost climbs through cyberspace to throttle Matty with his bare hands.
All & all it's everything you'd want in an Exorcist wrap up.
HAPPY HALLOWEEN P4P er's!
2021-10-281h 18
Rated P For ParanormalThe Exorcist 2 "Yo, Regan. I Did It!"You are not ready for this episode.
We weren't.
Exorcist II: The Heretic.
2021-10-211h 21
Rated P For ParanormalTHE EXORCIST: Pazuzu’s PetalsTony & Matty take on The Exorcist.
Tony ties this film to the Rolling Stones, but how?
Meanwhile, Matty steps into the confessional and spills his Catholic guts.
"Care to help out an old alter boy"?
Then listen, rate and review.
The Power Of P4P COMPELS YOU!
2021-10-131h 35
Rated P For ParanormalTHE THING: 2 Outta 3 Ain’t BadOur run to Halloween continues as the boys review THE THING.
Actually, all they review all 3 "THINGS".
Actually, 2 THINGS...as Tony refuses to recognize the 3rd THING.
You gotta be *** kidding me.
2021-10-071h 33
Rated P For ParanormalPOLTERGEIST: Puppy Dog TalesThe boys take on another classic: POLTERGEIST…but should they have run away from the light..?
2021-09-301h 11
Rated P For ParanormalAN AMERICAN WEREWOLF IN LONDON: Wouldn’t You Want To Be A Werewolf Too?Our Halloween season series of classic paranormal movies kicks off with An American Werewolf In London.
Not much needs to be said about this classic...and yet we do. Say a lot.
Agree with our review? Or have we strayed from the road?
2021-09-231h 21
Rated P For ParanormalSEPARATION: Waster Of PuppetsA new game!
A new celebrity Voice Mail!
A new movie called Separation!
All that and more on this new P4P!
2021-09-151h 17
Rated P For ParanormalBRAND NEW CHERRY FLAVOR: Cat Fight!Throw the damn towel. Why did this Netflix show Brand New Cherry Flavor tear our hosts apart? IF WE CAN CHANGE EVERYBODY CAN CHANGE!!!
2021-09-081h 19
Rated P For ParanormalEXTRA ORDINARY: Is This Will’s Forte?ParaComedy is our forte. But is it Will’s?
The boys take on EXTRA ORDINARY starring Will Forte.
Were they possessed by this film?
Or puking pea soup?
THE POWER OF P4P COMPELS YOU!
2021-09-021h 01
Rated P For ParanormalTHE TOMORROW WAR: Pratt FallThe boys are BACK! Today, it’s The Tomorrow War. Yeah, the movie is just as awkward as that sentence. Annie was wrong, we don’t love ya Tomorrow.
2021-08-2359 min
Rated P For ParanormalBLACK SUMMER: Netflix & KillBananaRama may have been singing about BLACK SUMMER when they sang Cruel Summer.
Cuz it's cruel. And it made us bananas.
We feel like we were robbed by zombie.
But hey...this ep has a new segment!
Let's Go!
2021-07-101h 15
Rated P For ParanormalTHE WIND: Everyone Knows It’s WindyThe boys are back in proper studio to break THE WIND!
2021-06-2657 min
Rated P For ParanormalBONUS EPISODE: Don’t Call It A ComebackA very special BONUS episode! Matty gives thanks & tells the story of Andy.
2021-06-2211 min
Rated P For ParanormalDARK SKIES: We Believe In Keri TalesNew ep, better late than never!
The boys talk DARK SKIES starring Keri Russell.
2021-06-1959 min
Rated P For ParanormalTHE MOTHMAN PROPHECIES: Get It In GereMatty is on the road.
Talk about high strangeness.
2021-06-0639 min
Rated P For ParanormalSTARGATE: The Fault In Our StargateWhat happens when you open a stargate?
We still don't know.
And neither does the film Stargate.
Hold on to your nip rings, this interplanetary ride is gonna get bumpy.
2021-05-281h 23
Rated P For Paranormal60 Minutes In Heaven60 Minutes takes on Unidentified Aerial Phenomena.
Find out what Matty & Tony think of the iconic show's handling of UFO disclosure.
And Andy Rooney is BACK baby!
"You ever notice P4P is awesome"?
2021-05-211h 11
Rated P For ParanormalHELLIER: Hellier THAN THOUGoblins & Mothman & Bigfoot...Oh My!
The boys take a look at the paranormal doc HELLIER.
-What's with Matty and CATS hating him?
-Is Tony about to get a big dose of high strangeness?
-Does Hellier get a P for Paranormal?
Plus...Matty opens up about Oak Island & his old podcast.
Listen now!
2021-05-061h 08
Rated P For ParanormalThe Happening: Marky-Mark’d For DeathWe have finally broken.
The Happening has broken us.
Listen and be forever changed.
2021-05-0133 min
Rated P For ParanormalClose Encounters Pt 2 w/ BOB BALABANWe welcome our first ever guest on the podcast, star of Close Encounters Of The Third Kind...
Mr. Bob Balaban.
Enjoy part 2 of our P4P Close Encounters Extravaganza!
2021-04-221h 09
Rated P For ParanormalClose Encounters Pt 1Part 1 of our very special 2 part episode & the boys take on a classic:
Close Encounters Of The 3rd Kind.
Also, a big announcement of our FIRST EVER GUEST on P4P.
Who will it be? And what does this guest have to do with Close Encounters Of The Third Kind?
LISTEN NOW!
2021-04-151h 10
Rated P For ParanormalGross EncountersWe tackle our first ever paranormal documentary: "Close Encounters Of The Fifth Kind".
And Roger Ebert makes an appearance from beyond.
Plus, Tony cheats on Matty...and it was glorious!
P4P brand new just for you.
2021-04-091h 02
Rated P For ParanormalClick Click ZOOM!The boys argue over the 2020 Zoom Pandemic film, HOST.
Is a poltergeist destroying Matty Road Studio?
All we wanna do is Zoom - a - Zoom - ZOOM!
2021-04-011h 21
Rated P For ParanormalTHE TIMES THEY ARE 'A CHANGELINGFundamentally fire film faire for your Friday!
This time 1980's The Changeling gets the p4p treatment.
Agree, disagree with our take on this classic piece of paranormal film?
LET US HEAR FROM YOU! Go to www.anchor.fm/ratedparanormal and LEAVE A MESSAGE or go to @ratedparanormal on Insta/Twitter/FB
Let's discuss!
2021-03-261h 10
Rated P For ParanormalBACON, NOT STIRREDStir Of Echoes stirs up some high emotion in our hosts.
Let's all get one degree of Kevin Bacon together!
Plus Matty & Tony each pick their top paranormal scene-- of all time!
A new p4p for your pleasure.
2021-03-171h 28
Rated P For ParanormalDayScream BelieversThe Believers (1987) gets the full Matty & Tony treatment.
Why are Matty's impressions all weird?
Is Tony's cat being trolled?
And why is Martin Sheen screaming so much?
Listen now and find out.
2021-03-111h 16
Rated P For ParanormalSHUT UP AND SQUATCHThe boys are back w/ a Bigfoot vengeance after a 2-week hiatus.
Have they returned with found, found-footage that is unfounded?
Why is Bigfoot so forgiving?
Who the hell is Uncle Bob?
Why are we telling everyone to shut up?
All that and more (SHUT UP!) on this week's edition of P4P.
2021-03-031h 13
Rated P For ParanormalThe Boys BigTime BigfootDon't worry, no Bigfoot were harmed during this special P4P announcement...just slightly miffed.
2021-02-2105 min
Rated P For ParanormalThe Exorcism Of, The Exorcism Of Emily RoseThe power of Arkin compels you.
Anthony unleashed!
Matty tormented!
And what is Nick Nolte doing here?
It's P4P time!
2021-02-111h 07
Rated P For ParanormalThe Devil Went Down To Greenwich VillageSatanic Cults!
1940's era Girl Power!
Black Sabbath & coke mirrors!
PLUS Anthony tells a story about his legendary father on set that is a MUST LISTEN.
What more could you want from a podcast?
New episode is up- please rate subscribe and SHARE.
2021-02-041h 12
Rated P For ParanormalSTAND BY YOUR MOTH-MANThe Mothman is back. For reals!
And along with him the 2002 classic The Mothman Prophecies.
If you don't know Mothman prepare to be FREAKED.
-Plus an update on Anthony's SUNDANCE FILM PREMIERE.
All that and more on this week's all new Rated P4P!
2021-01-281h 05
Rated P For ParanormalVAST OF NIGHTIn this all new Rated P For Paranormal the boys discuss the film THE VAST OF NIGHT (Prime Video).
SPOILER ALERT: Tony & Matty are simpatico on this film and it has them both freaking out!
But why?
How does this film fit with real life UFO events?
And...who exactly is married to our first ever guest-reviewer?
All this and more on this edition of RATED P4P!
2021-01-2158 min
Rated P For ParanormalPOSSESSED by POSSESSORWARNING: We're Gonna Get Bloody.
In this episode the boys break down the film POSSESSOR after breaking down this week's BREAKING PARANORMAL NEWS.
That's a lot of breaking.
PLUS:
-Matty drives Tony slowly insane with his new “P4P News” segment.
-Matty thinks BRANDON CRONENBERG needs to see Tony’s soon to be released film.
-What does Tony Robbins have to do with covert CIA aliens?
All that and more...LET'S GO!
2021-01-081h 12
Rated P For ParanormalEVIL: GET THEE BEHIND ME, 2020!Let's face it, a good portion of you guys were "runnin' with the devil" on New Years Eve...
So New Years Day is the perfect time for our discussion of the show EVIL.
Get some water, aspirin and let's shake of the demons of 2020 by talking about possessions, miracles and more.
How does the Catholic church investigate such claims?
Why is Tony so fired up about Hunter S. Thompson?
And.. have we finally broken poor Matty?
Find out in this all new episode of P4P and HAPPY NEW YEAR!
2021-01-011h 14
Rated P For ParanormalMERRY CHRISTMAS YOU WONDERFUL OLE LISTENERSJust in time for Christmas ! This ep is our gift to you.
-How does the Karate Kid fit into a paranormal Christmas film discussion?
-Does Tony have another film fact, or does Matty just want to shoe-horn in his terrible imaging?
-What do we think of GREMLINS both as paranormal entities and as a film?
Listen now to find out and MERRY CHRISTMAS !
2020-12-241h 13
Rated P For ParanormalSEASON OF THE SUNDANCEFinal film in our witchy trilogy.
In this episode:
We drop a MAJOR announcement.
More witch talk and more disembodied cat hauntings.
How will Anthony and Angelina Jolie help with Matty's ambivalence?
Find out this and more on this week's RATED P FOR PARANORMAL.
2020-12-181h 07
Rated P For ParanormalThe WitchWARNING: This one is scary.
Matty & Anthony discuss the paranormal aspects of witches and the 2015 Robert Eggers film THE WITCH.
While discussing witches, a disembodied "guest" appears out of nowhere and all heck breaks loose.
Plus, Matty reads a passage from his unpublished book.
And...a UFO video emerges that has our hosts' a bewitched and bewildered.
Hang on to your witch hats...this discussion is creepy.
Let's fly!
2020-12-101h 10
Rated P For ParanormalAn American Haunting & The Bell WitchTony & Matty break down the allegedly true tale of the BELL WITCH HAUNTING as depicted in the film An American Haunting.
This may be our most intense episode yet.
Tony also discusses some of his work, like his time on the hit series THE AMERICANS (FX) and SUCCESSION (HBO).
And, does Donald Sutherlands' hair deserve an award?
All this and more on this edition of Rated P4P.
Enjoy, subscribe, rate and review.
THANK YOU!
2020-12-0454 min
Rated P For ParanormalThe Wolf Of Snow HollowMatty & Tony discuss the 2020 werewolf film: The Wolf Of Snow Hollow.
Will they howl in unison, or is there a bad moon rising?
Plus, they tell of a paranormal experience they each had.
And Matty does not know when Thanksgiving is.
But we wanted to GIVE THANKS TO YOU for all of your early support of this podcast.
HAPPY THANKSGIVING EVERYONE!
2020-11-2651 min
Rated P For ParanormalSCANNERSCareful. There's a fairly good chance your head might explode.
And this is only our second episode.
Plus:
-P4P gets our first voicemail!
-Government mind control for all!
--Matty and Anthony have their first on-air fight.
Ah, movie-nerd fights...at least you know nobody gets hurt.
2020-11-1944 min
Rated P For ParanormalCOMMUNIONIn our very first episode Anthony & Matty introduce themselves, and review the film COMMUNION.
Is COMMUNION a great depiction of a real life alien abduction, or an over the top forgettable mess?
Your paranormal pop culture spirit guides will break it down.
The boys also discuss phony looking robots, unwanted alien probes and the most frightening thing of all... bad improv.
2020-11-1353 min2020-11-1200 min