Shows
Toasted ShenanigansHowdy Strangers!We're back!!! We have missed y'all and are ready to continue the shenanigans! Grab your favorite beverage and join us for some table talk!2024-09-0840 min
Toasted ShenanigansThe Death of the Princess of Wales, DianaDiana, Princess of Wales, was a member of the British royal family. Her activism and glamour made her an international icon, and earned her the title, "The People's Princess". Unfortunately, in 1997 Diana was in a tragic car accident, that claimed her life. Her death left many questions unanswered. Grab your favorite beverage and join us for the conspiracy theories behind the death of Princess Diana. 2024-03-311h 20
Toasted ShenanigansKate MiddletonJoin us for the conspiracies behind the missing Princess of Wales. This episode was recorded before Kate Middleton's unfortunate news about her health. We wish her the best and hope she has a quick and successful recovery. 2024-03-241h 03
Toasted ShenanigansWhere Are They?Native woman Kristelle Day frantically sent messages to her family, telling them she felt unsafe and wanted to come back home to Alaska immediately. They sent welfare checks on her and she told the police she's fine. Suddenly they never hear from her. They attempted three times to report her missing and it was denied. Getting help from a lawyer who is involved with the MMIW suddenly she is then reported missing and soon "found". However, there are many out there that aren't found. They aren't taken serious. They are still missing. Grab you beverage as we talk about...2024-03-1748 min
Toasted ShenanigansSlendermanUnder the influence of Slenderman two young girls attempt to take the life of their friend. Are these two twisted youth mentally ill, or did they know the consequences of their actions? Be apart of our Shenanigans, grab your favorite beverage, and decide for yourself!2024-03-101h 06
Toasted ShenanigansMissing Virginia Tech Student: Johnny RoopJohnny Roop, a Virginia Tech student went home to finish a final exam, but he never shows up. Worried, his family reports him missing. Two weeks later the police contact him and case is closed. However, the family has still not heard from him? Grab you favorite beverage and join us and we discuss the situation and hope to get the word out for John and his family. Anyone with information is asked to call the Montgomery County Sheriff’s Office at 540-382-4343.2024-03-0346 min
Toasted ShenanigansSmells Like Teen SpiritApril 8th, 1994, Kurt Cobain was found dead at his home in Seattle, Washington. Tom Grant, a hired Private Investigator by Courtney Love, exposed a lot of facts behind Kurt Cobain's death. Grab your favorite beverage and join us as we dive into Tom's point of view behind the death of the infamous, grunge rock legend, Kurt Cobain.2024-02-261h 15
Toasted ShenanigansCrumbley Mental Health MessNovember 30, 2021, Ethan Crumbley opened fire at his high school, taking the lives of four students and injuring many. Before this incident there were many signs he was troubled teen, in desperate need of help. His parents disregarded his mental health, and instead they gave him the tool to complete this horrid act. He is now behind bars, for life. On February 6, 2024... his mother was charged and convicted for the actions of her son. His father now waits for his trial. Grab you beverage of choice, open your ear holes, and join us while we discuss the failures not only...2024-02-181h 10
Toasted ShenanigansDisgraced Long Island Police Chief: James BurkeJames Burke was the Chief of the Suffolk County Police Department during the Long Island serial killer investigation. In 2016, he served time in federal prison for beating a man who stole his sex toys, drugs, and snuff film. Burke botched the investigation of the Gilgo Beach Four by refusing to let the FBI help. What is James Burke hiding and why would he stand in the way of the LISK investigation? Grab your favorite beverage and join us for our table talk, as we dive into Burke's past and debate what he could be covering up. 2024-02-111h 11
Toasted ShenanigansThe Gilgo Beach FourRex Heuermann, the man charged with murders of four woman on Gligo Beach, that lead to the discovery of six more victims. Could he be the Long Island Serial Killer? Grab your favorite beverage and join us, as we go over the current evidence and is what yet to come in his trial.2024-02-0453 min
Toasted ShenanigansWho Murdred Shannan Gilbert?In 2010, Shannan Gilbert mysteriously disappeared. Had Shannan never called 911 the night of her disappearance, we would never know about the Long Island Serial Killer. However, her death doesn't seem to have any ties to the Long Island Serial Killer, or does it? Grab your favorite beverage and join us as we go over the murder of Shannan Gilbert and the discovery of the Gilgo Beach Four.2024-01-2850 min
Toasted ShenanigansSpilling the TeaInspired by stumbling on a video by content creator Ryankellycomedy, we learned Celestial Seasonings comes with more then just the number one Sleepytime Tea! That cute bear box had a history of eugenics and aliens! What went from a interest of the aliens to something even more twisted! Grab you favorite beverage and join us as we venture down the rabbit hole!2024-01-211h 07
Toasted ShenanigansThe Wool Over Your Eyes: Gypsy Rose BlanchardGypsy Rose Blanchard orchestrated her mother's death to escape her hell that she had endured for over two decades. Her mother, Dee Dee Blanchard, had a mental disorder called Munchausen syndrome by proxy and used her daughter as a pawn to gain sympathy from others. After serving eight years in prison, Gypsy is a free woman, gaining all the attention her mother so desperately craved. Grab your favorite beverage and join us, as we go over the lies, manipulation, and deception behind Dee Dee Blanchard's murder.2024-01-141h 10
Toasted ShenanigansHappy New Year, Toasties!Welcome back, Toasties! This week we bring you what Shenanigans are to come in 2024! 2024-01-0722 min
Toasted Shenanigans'Twas The Night of Krampus'Twas the night before St. Nicholas, when all through the townNot a human was stirring, all waiting for the sound;The drapes were shut tight and fireplaces blaring with fear,In anticipation that Krampus would soon be there.Thank you, Toasties for being apart of our Shenanigans! 'Tis the season for a special episode! Grab your favorite beverage and join us for our Christmas Shenanigans!2023-12-1756 min
Toasted ShenanigansThe Brown Out StranglerDuring a brownout in Melbourne, Australia, three women were found dead in the street in the single month of May. But who did it? American soldiers were sent to keep an eye on Japan, but one with a dark childhood lurked the streets. Captivated by their singing voice, Eddie Leonski took the life of these lovely woman. Was it his childhood that made him do it? Or was it just a desirable fetish? Grab a drink and open your ear holes to hear the tale of the Brownout Strangler.2023-12-1052 min
Toasted ShenanigansThe Twisted Mind of Pazuzu AlgaradPazuzu Algarad, born John Lawson. He was a twisted individual who took over his mother's home and turned it into house of horrors. He indulged in a life full of sex, alcohol, drugs, satanic rituals, filth, and murder. Was John born Pazuzu, or was he the creator of his damaged mind? Be a part of our shenanigans, grab your favorite beverage, and you decide for yourself!https://toastedshenanigans.com/2023-12-0348 min
Toasted ShenanigansThanksgiving MassacreMost of us were told from a young age, that Thanksgiving was a day to give thanks. The pilgrims had survived a hard winter and were celebrating a successful harvest with neighboring Indians. However, it couldn't be further from the truth. Grab your favorite beverage and join us for the real history of Thanksgiving.2023-11-2638 min
Toasted ShenanigansDon't Eat The EmpanadasGrab your favorite beverage and join in on our Toasted Shenanigans, as we tell the story of a cannibalistic love triangle. Was our twisted trio mentally ill, or just in it for the monetary gain? Just remember, don't eat the empanadas!2023-11-1936 min
Toasted ShenanigansThe Development of a Dangerous Mind: Charles MansonEveryone knows the notorious Charles Manson, but do you know his mind? Why did people follow him like they did? What made him tick? Why did he even do what he did? Was it schizophrenia, or was it something else? Grab you beverage and join us as we go over the study done by Tod Roy and the real mind of Charles Manson.2023-11-121h 13
Toasted ShenanigansWe're back!!!Thank you, Toasties for your support during our absence. Let the Shenanigans resume!2023-11-0537 min
Toasted ShenanigansThe Conjuring HouseOur spooky time took us down a rabbit hole! Grab your favorite beverage and join us as we debate the facts and history behind the infamous Conjuring House. Is the Conjuring House haunted? Was Bathsheba Sherman the spirit that taunted the Perron family? Were Ed and Lorraine Warren professional paranormal investigators, or was everything a fabricated tale? You decide!2023-10-221h 21
Toasted ShenanigansSpooky Time!Grab your beverage and join us for chatter about a French 1600s witch trial, and a debate as to whom was haunting the Conjuring house!2023-10-1557 min
Toasted ShenanigansThe Story Behind The Exorcist The 1970s film the exorcist was inspired by events from a 14 year old boy named Roland Doe, whose aunt passed away. Before her passing she introduced him to the Ouiji Board. After her passing Roland took it pretty hard, and the rest in history. Open your ear holes, grab your drink of choice, and listen in to see how it all turns out!2023-10-0853 min
Toasted ShenanigansThe Central Park FiveApril 19, 1989, 32 teens entered Central Park. Someone brutally attacked & raped a jogger, Trisha Meili. She was found barely alive and five teens were arrested for the crime. Did these five teens actually commit the crime, or did they fit the narrative for crime that the NYPD needed? Be a part of our Shenanigans, grab your beverage, and decide for yourself!2023-10-0158 min
Toasted ShenanigansSan Francisco Witch KillersFrom Suburban mom to a twisted religious leader, with her faithful disciple at her side. Suzan and Michael tried to rid the world of what they perceived as "witches". Traveling up the west coast and even to Europe trying to spread their version of Islam, turned into a twisted murder of thee people, and possibly more! Maybe it was drugs, maybe it was mental health, either way grab your beverage and open your ear holes and join us for the story of the San Francisco Witch Killers tale.2023-09-241h 00
Toasted ShenanigansThe Real Life Buffalo Bill: Gary Heidnik- Part Two3520 North Marshall Street in Philadelphia was Gary's own house of horrors. Gary craved control and ultimate domination. He preyed on the weak to fulfill his need of empowerment. Was Gary's upbringing to blame for his sins, or was his mental health to blame for his demons? Be a part of our Shenanigans, grab your beverage, and decide for yourself!2023-09-171h 01
Toasted ShenanigansThe Real Life Buffalo Bill: Gary Heidnik - Part One3520 North Marshall Street in Philadelphia was Gary's own house of horrors. Gary craved control and ultimate domination. He preyed on the weak to fulfill his need of empowerment. Was Gary's upbringing to blame for his sins, or was his mental health to blame for his demons? Be a part of our Shenanigans, grab your beverage, and decide for yourself!2023-09-1045 min
Toasted ShenanigansJim Jones: The Jonestown MassacreWhat was the Jonestown massacre? The Jonestown massacre was a mass suicide of the Peoples Temple cult at the behest of their leader, Jim Jones, in 1978. Jim demanded "revolutionary suicide" and served his 900 followers a cyanide cocktail. Was this really mass suicide or mass murder? Be a part of our Shenanigans, grab your beverage, and decide for yourself!2023-09-031h 48
Toasted ShenanigansThe Unfortunate Death of Nicole PerryNovember 19th, 2020 in Bexar County outside of San Antonio, Texas, on the 300th block of West Harlan Avenue... Nicole Perry would tragically be forever silenced. Was Nicole antagonizing her killer? Be apart of our Shenanigans, grab your beverage, and decide for yourself!2023-08-2747 min
Toasted ShenanigansThe Development of a Dangerous Mind: Ted BundyThis week we go over the psyche of Ted Bundy. What made him a killer? Was he born this way or did his past actions bring upon the serial killer we know? Grab your favorite beverage, join us for our debate, and let us know what you think! Reach out to us at https://toastedshenanigans.com/2023-08-201h 13
Toasted ShenanigansThe Death of Brittany MurphyDecember 20th, 2009, America's sweetheart, Brittany Murphy died in her LA home. The 32 year old died under mysterious circumstances. Her death became even more suspicious when her husband died of the same causes only five months after her. Brittany's ex-mob father was quick to claim it was murder. Her mother refused to believe it was murder and some say it was the house, that previously was owned by Brittney Spears. Was Brittany Murphy murdered, was it the house, or did she actually pass from natural causes? Be apart of our Shenanigans, grab your beverage, and decide for yourself!2023-08-131h 04
Toasted ShenanigansPedro Lopez - The Monster of the AndesPedro Lopez grows up on the streets of Columbia, during the most chaotic time for the country. Trying to adapt and protect himself on the streets of Columbia, Pedro encounters copious amounts of abuse and drug use. As a man his only way of coping with his tragic past is to take revenge on the society that created him. Was it Pedro's trauma that caused him to kill, or was Pedro born a prolific serial killer? Be apart of our Shenanigans, grab your beverage, and decide for yourself!2023-08-061h 03
Toasted ShenanigansAlieen Wuornos - The MonsterAlieen Wuornos was sentenced to death by the Florida judicial system. Over twelve months she killed seven men during acts of prostitution. Alieen was a rare individual and told the courts, "I killed those men. I robbed them as cold as ice. And I'd do it again, too. There's no chance in keeping me alive or anything, because I'd kill again. I have hate crawling through my system ... I am so sick of hearing this 'she's crazy' stuff. I've been evaluated so many times. I'm competent, sane, and I'm trying to tell the truth. I'm one who seriously hates human...2023-07-301h 04
Toasted ShenanigansArmin Meiwes - The Cannibal of Rotenburg Armin Meiwes was so lonely that he believed if he consumed the flesh of another human, they would be with him forever. But Armin was not a murderer, just a cannibal. His victim would have to be willing to feed Armin's emptiness. So, Armin went to the only place he found solace, seeking out for his first taste of human flesh... The Cannibal Cafe. An online chatroom, filled with hundreds of people just like Armin. Did Armin actually believe he could be with a person forever by eating them? Or was he haunted with a fetish of vorephilia? Be apart...2023-07-231h 01
Toasted ShenanigansThe Exorcism of Anneliese MichelAnneliese lived a very religious life. At the age of 16 things started taking a turn. Started as being found in trance-like states, to feeling numb, to seeming like her body and mind was being controlled by someone else. After seeing a doctor and feeling like it was of no help, Anneliese and her family searched for help outside of medicine. After 10 months, unfortunately Anneliese passed away. Was it the new form of help, the lack of conventional medicine or was it true of what Anneliese and her family fear, that she was truly possessed? Be apart of our Shenanigans...2023-07-161h 01
Toasted ShenanigansReporting Current ShenanigansWelcome Toasties, to our current news update! This time we are reporting what is currently happening now, in our world today. Grab your beverage, and join us for Reporting Shenanigans!2023-07-091h 20
Toasted ShenanigansMissing Person: D'wan SimsHey Toasties! This week we bring you a special missing person's case. Four year old D'wan Sims went missing on December 11th, 1994, while shopping with his mother at Wonderland Mall in Livonia, Michigan. If you know of any information regarding D'wan Sims disappearance please contact the Livonia Police Department at 734-466-2470. Or feel free to message us privately at ToastedShenanigans.com. Thank you for any and all support.2023-07-0242 min
Toasted Shenanigans*** Podcast Recommendation - Locating the Lost ***Hey Toasties! We have a special recommendation for y'all! Maybe we can locate some of these individuals together! Go listen to Locating the Lost on your favorite podcast app. A True Crime Podcast of the missing and unsolved Support this podcast: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/locatingthelost/support2023-06-2601 min
Toasted ShenanigansThe Injustice of the West Memphis ThreeWith new evidence that has surfaced that omits Damien, Jason, and Jessie from the murders, and time working against them, they have to accept an Alford plea to become free men again after almost twenty years. The evidence looks as though someone closer to the victims home committed the murders, but the authorities do nothing to investigate it further. Do you think the teenage trio should have entered an Alford plea, or should the state of Arkansas acquit them? Be apart of our Shenanigans, grab your beverage, and decide for yourself!2023-06-251h 04
Toasted ShenanigansThe Trials of The West Memphis ThreeJason and Daminen, their convictions left untold in our last episode. In this episode we will go into the truth and as it is told. A crime supposedly committed by a satanic occult is torn a part, and seen for what it actually is... A modern day witch hunt. Now we are left with who killed these three eight year old boys. Do you believe it was the teenage trio, or did the West Memphis Police not fully bring factually evidence to the courtroom? Be apart of our Shenanigans, grab your beverage, and decide for yourself!2023-06-181h 15
Toasted ShenanigansThe Boys of the West Memphis ThreeMay 5th, 1993 the small town of West Memphis was shocked by the brutal murders of three eight year old boys. Instantly the case gains national media coverage. This puts pressure on West Memphis Police Department, they have to act quickly and put the murderer behind bars. Following the easiest option given to them, they play into the 90's horror of satanic panic. They needed someone easy to pin these murders on. Who would commit these acts of satanic crime? Of course, the eighteen year old goth kid who stood out in a small town, and two other teens who listened...2023-06-1147 minToasted ShenanigansFred & Rose WestFred and Rose West were far from your average family. A love that was held together with sex and violence. With many children this family held the biggest horror secret in the home and garden. Fred spent much time "improving" the home on 25 Cromwell to hide their secrets. During this time many girls were reported missing, or as runaways, including Heather West herself. Why were Fred and Rose not concerned by their daughter running away? Where are the other girls? What are the secrets hidden at 25 Cromwell? Be a part of the shenanigans, grab your beverage, and find out!2023-06-041h 02
Toasted ShenanigansThe Suspicious Death of Cindy JamesTortured and harassed for almost seven years, Cindy James swore someone was out to get her. Authorities exhausted all efforts to find Cindy's tormentor, but there was zero evidence for nearly hundred reported incidents. The police thought that Cindy could possibly be staging these horrific incidents. Cindy denied any accusations but refused to tell the authorities what she knew. Was Cindy's suspicious death a murder or suicide? Be apart of our Shenanigans, grab your beverage, and decide for yourself!2023-05-281h 03
Toasted ShenanigansThe Horror Behind Amityville Amityville Horror was a cult classic that we all know and love. With green ooze coming from walls and an odor, no one can find its source. It was more than just the story that we all know. It has haunts and murder. The DeFeo family, the family that was in the home before the Lutz, had a fate that no one would have expected. Resulting in the largest single slaying known at that time. Roger killed his whole family. Did Roger hear voices that told him to kill his family, or was the violence from his father enough to...2023-05-2158 min
Toasted ShenanigansJerry Brudos - The Shoe Fetish SlayerJerome Henry Brudos had more than just an obsession with high heels... and his mother hated him for not being born a girl. Starting at the age of five his found treasure turned into something desirable, after his mother forbidding him wearing them around the house. This desire turned into a fetish as he hit puberty, and his fetish brought on a dark imagination that he craved to bring to life. Preying on innocent women, stealing their heels, and fulfilling his cravings. Was Jerry's mother to blame for his basement of horrors, or was Jerry born this way? Be apart...2023-05-1459 min
Toasted ShenanigansRoger de la Burde & Beverly MonroeRoger de la Burde was a charming man, making it all that much easier to fulfill his career as a con artist. He was a womanizer, constantly discarding lovers for the next. One day Roger was found dead in his Virginia home. What at first appeared to be a suicide, turned into a homicide investigation. With many enemies wanting Roger dead, including scorned lovers, it was easy to see why someone would want him dead. Beverly, his current flame, trapped in the middle of the investigation, with all fingers pointing at her. Did Beverly have motive to kill Roger? Could...2023-05-0936 min
Toasted ShenanigansSylvia Likens & The Torture MotherGertrude Baniszewski was a single mother to seven children, just trying to make ends meet. Sylvia Likens was a daughter, devoted sister, and a beautiful, outgoing sixteen-year-old. As their paths cross, so begins the torturous story of Sylvia's death. Did Gertrude take on more than she could handle, or was her jealously what fueled her heinous attacks on Sylvia? Be a part of our Shenanigans, grab your beverage, and decide for yourself.2023-04-301h 17
Toasted ShenanigansThe Beatrice Six - Part TwoOne man's determination to prove his innocence was all it took to bankrupt Gage County. A new lead investigator determined to prove all six was guilty was enough to prove their innocence. Was this case mishandled from the start, or was the evidence misleading? Be apart of our Shenanigans, grab your beverage, and decide for yourself.2023-04-231h 21
Toasted ShenanigansThe Beatrice Six - Part OneOn February 5th, 1985, 68 year old grandmother, Helen Wilson, was brutally raped and murdered in Beatrice, Nebraska. Panic was brought upon the small town, and years went by with no arrests. Until 1989, after wrongful interrogations, arrests were quickly made. Six to be exact, forming The Beatrice Six. Did any of them do it, or was one investigator too eager to find the murderer? Be apart of our Shenanigans, grab your beverage, and decide for yourself.2023-04-161h 08
Toasted ShenanigansKatherine KnightKatherine Knight was the first woman in Australia to be sentenced to life without parole. Her Hyde outweighed her Jekyll, creating a reign of terror. Preying on all her lovers, succumbing them, and bringing them back for more abuse. Was Katherine a scorned lover or did her loss for control drive her mad? Be a part of our Shenanigans, grab your beverage, and decide for yourself.2023-04-0957 min
Toasted ShenanigansThe Black DahliaElizabeth Short, named The Black Dahlia by the media, was brutally murdered in 1947. Her tragic story was highly publicized, creating rumors and false headlines. With her murderer still at large, and so many questions lefts unanswered, is the media to blame? Be a part of our Shenanigans, grab your beverage, and decide for yourself.2023-04-0252 min
Toasted ShenanigansEd Gein - The Original LeatherfaceEdward Theodore Gein, an inspiration to horror cinema, and the intriguing mind behind many books. Ed was an oddball, raised by an over protective, religious fanatic mother. Was it his hatred for Mother Dearest that spoiled him, or the obsessive love for his mother? Be apart of our Shenanigans, grab your beverage, and decide for yourself.2023-03-261h 07
Toasted ShenanigansTommy Lynn SellsTommy Lynn Sells, also known as "The Coast to Coast Killer", was a sadistic man with a MO preying on children. Tommy traveled multiple states killing 22 people, consistently invading the police. Was his childhood to blame for his horrendous crimes, or was Tommy born this way? Be apart of our Shenanigans, grab your beverage, and decide for yourself.2023-03-1954 min
Toasted ShenanigansJoann Tate - Part TwoMelissa struggles with her demons, Rodney fights for his life, and Missouri miscarries justice. Why won't Missouri let an innocent man go? Is the Missouri judicial system corrupt? Be a part of our Shenanigans, grab your beverage, and decide for yourself.2023-03-141h 04
Toasted ShenanigansJoann Tate - Part OneA mother stolen from her children in a brutal murder, two little girls left for dead, and one man left to blame for the crimes. Does Missouri carryout misjustice, or would you lock Rodney Lincoln away for life? Be a part of our Shenanigans, grab your beverage, and decide for yourself.2023-03-1455 min