Shows
Buzzed and BaffledEpisode 14: I have a Bun to Pick with YouIn this episode we have our second guests, welcome Amy and Dawn!
Today’s story is a relishing ride into a turf war you didn’t know existed—where pickles are pawns, toppings turn treacherous, and mustard might just be murder.
That’s right—we’re diving into the great Hot Dog Wars.
Is it Chicago-style or bust? Ketchup? Blasphemy!
And how did a humble dill spear nearly spark a street fight at a food festival?
Grab your bun, pour the wine—because this beef is fully loaded.
Let’s get buzzed. Le...2025-07-261h 00
Buzzed and BaffledEpisode 13: Remember that Every Dead Body on Mt. Everest was Once a Highly Motivated Person.In this episode, our hosts sip wine and sail into the baffling, buzzed waters of one man’s extreme missionary zeal. Meet John Chau—a guy who thought sneaking onto a remote island full of spear-wielding, uncontacted people was a solid plan. Kyla wonders if he read any history, and Nicole can’t stop shouting “NOPE” into her wine glass. There’s God, Google Maps, and a whole lot of bad decision-making. Grab a drink and join us for this tale of faith, folly, and one truly unadvisable adventure.
2025-07-1955 min
Buzzed and BaffledEpisode 12: The Pickleball SwindlerIn this episode, the ladies dive into the strange case of Rodney Grubbs—a man whose name screams “neighborly BBQ” but whose story takes a dark turn. But before the scam gets unpacked, Lisa steps in with a paddle and a purpose: to coach our confused hosts through the wild world of pickleball. There are buzzers. There is chaos. And yes, someone still thinks the kitchen is for snacks. Grab your wine, your whistle, and your wiffle ball—we're serving up mystery with a side of doubles strategy.
2025-07-1353 min
Buzzed and BaffledEpisode 11: A Quiet ManThis week on Buzzed and Baffled, we are in the snowy stillness of Michigan’s Upper Peninsula. No one suspected the quiet man at the Social Security office hide a dangerous secret. David Goodreau was polite, professional—and hiding something monstrous. In this episode, the wine is chilled and the story turns cold-blooded, as your hosts unravel the shocking crimes of a seemingly mild-mannered bureaucrat who brutally murdered two women and planned to strike again. What drove a church-going Yooper to turn into a serial predator? And how did a small-town community piece together the truth? Pour a glass and...2025-07-0448 min
Buzzed and BaffledE10: Killdozer: Bulldozing the Line Between Justice and Chaos"This week on Buzzed and Baffled, we crack open a bold bottle of red and dive headfirst into one of the wildest rampages you've probably never heard of — the infamous Killdozer.
Join us as one of us tells the jaw-dropping true story of Marvin Heemeyer, a disgruntled welder who turned a bulldozer into a homemade tank and unleashed mechanical mayhem on a Colorado town — while the other hears it all for the very first time, wine glass in hand and jaw on the floor.
🚜 Small-town politics.
🔥 Explosives, armor plating, and revenge.
🍷 And yes… a surprisingly...2025-06-2954 min
Buzzed and BaffledEpisode 9: Come for the Faith, Stay for the Brainwashing...In this episode of Buzzed and Baffled, your favorite wine-sipping sleuths uncork a bold bottle and dive into the blazing controversy of the Kids on Fire School of Ministry—the Pentecostal summer camp made infamous by the documentary Jesus Camp. One host has the facts, the other has no clue what’s coming.
Expect speaking in tongues, tearful altar calls, and one very intense cardboard cutout of George W. Bush. Is it spiritual awakening or childhood indoctrination? You decide—after a few sips, of course.
🍷 Blind reactions. 🔥 Fiery debates. ✝️ Faith, fear, and fermented grapes.
Let the baffl2025-06-1556 min
Buzzed and BaffledEpisode 8: Resurrection, Rebellion and RobesIn this glass-clinking episode of Buzzed and Baffled, the wine flows as one of our hosts dives into the baffling true story of the Quaker Universal Friend—once known as Jemima Wilkinson.
Our other host is totally blind to what’s coming and reacts in real time as the tale spirals from colonial revival meetings to full-on utopian cult vibes. Was the Universal Friend a divine disruptor, a feminist trailblazer, or just the ultimate 18th-century enigma?
Grab your goblet—this one’s got resurrection, rebellion, and robes.
2025-06-0841 min
Buzzed and BaffledEpisode 7: The Worst Crime“Wine, Lies, and Fraud: The Rudy Kurniawan Story”
Grab a glass (or two) and join us for a juicy conversation about the wild world of wine fraud. In this episode, we dive into the shocking story of Rudy Kurniawan, the infamous wine conman who duped the world’s elite into drinking counterfeit bottles worth millions. We’re two women, a bottle of wine, and all the juicy details on how Kurniawan managed to pull off one of the biggest scams in the wine industry. From rare Bordeaux to fraudulent bottles, we break it all down with some humor, a...2025-06-0152 min
Buzzed and BaffledEpisode 6: The Sad Story of Steven StaynerListen to the tale of how Steven believes that his family gave him away but later escaped his kidnapper. See evidence and pictures from the case at buzzedandbaffled.net!
2025-05-2455 min
Buzzed and BaffledEpisode 6: The Sad Story of Steven StaynerListen to the tale of how Steven believes that his family gave him away but later escaped his kidnapper. See evidence and pictures from the case at buzzedandbaffled.net!
2025-05-2455 min
Buzzed and BaffledEpisode 5: Putting the "Lit" in LitigationListen to Part 2 of the Bernie Tiede tale, don't forget to see information about the episode on buzzedandbaffled.net
2025-05-1847 min
Buzzed and BaffledEpisode 4: A Will is Simply a Dead Give AwayPart 1 of the story of Bernie Tiede and his ill fated friendship with Marjorie Nugent. The case spans years past what most people (Kyla) know(s).
2025-05-0447 min
Buzzed and BaffledEpisode 3: Shall We DanceLearn about the dancing plague of 1518.
2025-04-2758 min
Buzzed and BaffledI Tip My Hat to YouToday we look at the 1922 Stray Hat Riots and a frivolous lawsuit. 2025-04-1356 min
Buzzed and BaffledThe Great Molasses FloodJoin us for cocktails and great stories from history. Today we talk about the Great Molasses Flood and the 1904 Olympic Marathon.2025-04-0650 min