Shows
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastCross-Examination | Charismatic Authority Radio Vérté Presents: The Spoon River Gothic Podcast - True Crime Narratives Written & Narrated by Cory Zimmerman Daniella Mestyanek Young was born a third-generation member of the infamous Children of God religious cult.She grew up being trafficked around the world before escaping that life and moving to the United States at age 15. She put herself through high school and graduated as college valedictorian before commissioning into the US Army as an intelligence officer. She received a Master of Arts in Organizational Psychology at the Harvard Extension School and focuses he...
2024-07-0344 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastChapter 11 | Part II - An Ordinary Country RoadRadio Vérté Presents: The Spoon River Gothic Podcast - True Crime Narratives Written & Narrated by Cory ZimmermanExecutive Producer Cory Zimmerman.Written, Edited & Narrated by Cory Zimmerman.Research by Rachel Laubis, Moira King & Allison Hester.Blog Written by Samantha Thomas.Subscribe to THE SRG AGENCY @ https://www.patreon.com/SpoonRiverGothicPodcast & Access The SPOON RIVER GOTHIC CASE FILE for Bonus Weekly Episodes & Investigative Materials (Audio Interviews, Trial Footage, Police Files, Court Documents, Photos, Diagrams, etc.) to Accompany each Season Two Episode.Patreon @ www.patreon.com/SpoonRiverGothicPodcast...
2024-07-0140 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastCross-Examination | The Charlie That I KnewRadio Vérté Presents: The Spoon River Gothic Podcast - True Crime Narratives Written & Narrated by Cory ZimmermanExecutive Producer Cory Zimmerman.Written, Edited & Narrated by Cory Zimmerman.Research by Rachel Laubis, Moira King & Allison Hester.Blog Written by Samantha Thomas.Subscribe to THE SRG AGENCY @ https://www.patreon.com/SpoonRiverGothicPodcast & Access The SPOON RIVER GOTHIC CASE FILE for Bonus Weekly Episodes & Investigative Materials (Audio Interviews, Trial Footage, Police Files, Court Documents, Photos, Diagrams, etc.) to Accompany each Season Two Episode.Patreon @ www.patreon.com/SpoonRiverGothicPodcast...
2024-07-011h 13
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastChapter 11 | Part I - A Strange ThingRadio Vérté Presents: The Spoon River Gothic Podcast - True Crime Narratives Written & Narrated by Cory ZimmermanExecutive Producer Cory Zimmerman.Written, Edited & Narrated by Cory Zimmerman.Research by Rachel Laubis, Moira King & Allison Hester.Blog Written by Samantha Thomas.Subscribe to THE SRG AGENCY @ https://www.patreon.com/SpoonRiverGothicPodcast & Access The SPOON RIVER GOTHIC CASE FILE for Bonus Weekly Episodes & Investigative Materials (Audio Interviews, Trial Footage, Police Files, Court Documents, Photos, Diagrams, etc.) to Accompany each Season Two Episode.Patreon @ www.patreon.com/SpoonRiverGothicPodcast...
2024-06-2952 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastCross-Examination | The LimelightRadio Vérté Presents: The Spoon River Gothic Podcast - True Crime Narratives Written & Narrated by Cory ZimmermanExecutive Producer Cory Zimmerman.Written, Edited & Narrated by Cory Zimmerman.Research by Rachel Laubis, Moira King & Allison Hester.Blog Written by Samantha Thomas.Subscribe to THE SRG AGENCY @ https://www.patreon.com/SpoonRiverGothicPodcast & Access The SPOON RIVER GOTHIC CASE FILE for Bonus Weekly Episodes & Investigative Materials (Audio Interviews, Trial Footage, Police Files, Court Documents, Photos, Diagrams, etc.) to Accompany each Season Two Episode.Patreon @ www.patreon.com/SpoonRiverGothicPodcast...
2024-06-1135 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastChapter 10 | In & of ItselfRadio Vérté Presents: The Spoon River Gothic Podcast - True Crime Narratives Written & Narrated by Cory ZimmermanExecutive Producer Cory Zimmerman.Written, Edited & Narrated by Cory Zimmerman.Research by Rachel Laubis, Moira King & Allison Hester.Blog Written by Samantha Thomas.Subscribe to THE SRG AGENCY @ https://www.patreon.com/SpoonRiverGothicPodcast & Access The SPOON RIVER GOTHIC CASE FILE for Bonus Weekly Episodes & Investigative Materials (Audio Interviews, Trial Footage, Police Files, Court Documents, Photos, Diagrams, etc.) to Accompany each Season Two Episode.Patreon @ www.patreon.com/SpoonRiverGothicPodcast...
2024-06-1053 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastINTRODUCING - A PLACE OF PARADOXRADIO VÉRTÉ Presents: A PLACE OF PARADOXA Literary Fiction Podcast Written & Narrated by Cory Zimmerman.SEASONAL | WEEKLY-SEASON ONE- THE WILD WIND - A Novel by Cory Zimmerman. The Wild Wind is an American gothic tale of a woman born and raised on the grounds of a psychiatric institution—not as a patient, but the daughter of the asylum’s farmer—who learns of love and loss while grappling with the question of what it means to be sane when insanity is the norm.
2024-06-0701 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastCross-Examination | Ain't Gotta Lie to MeRadio Vérté Presents: The Spoon River Gothic Podcast - True Crime Narratives Written & Narrated by Cory ZimmermanExecutive Producer Cory Zimmerman.Written, Edited & Narrated by Cory Zimmerman.Research by Rachel Laubis, Moira King & Allison Hester.Blog Written by Samantha Thomas.Subscribe to THE SRG AGENCY @ https://www.patreon.com/SpoonRiverGothicPodcast & Access The SPOON RIVER GOTHIC CASE FILE for Bonus Weekly Episodes & Investigative Materials (Audio Interviews, Trial Footage, Police Files, Court Documents, Photos, Diagrams, etc.) to Accompany each Season Two Episode.Patreon @ www.patreon.com/SpoonRiverGothicPodcast...
2024-05-2318 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastChapter 9 | Stockholm SyndromeRadio Vérté Presents: The Spoon River Gothic Podcast - True Crime Narratives Written & Narrated by Cory ZimmermanExecutive Producer Cory Zimmerman.Written, Edited & Narrated by Cory Zimmerman.Research by Rachel Laubis, Moira King & Allison Hester.Blog Written by Samantha Thomas.Subscribe to THE SRG AGENCY @ https://www.patreon.com/SpoonRiverGothicPodcast & Access The SPOON RIVER GOTHIC CASE FILE for Bonus Weekly Episodes & Investigative Materials (Audio Interviews, Trial Footage, Police Files, Court Documents, Photos, Diagrams, etc.) to Accompany each Season Two Episode.Patreon @ www.patreon.com/SpoonRiverGothicPodcast...
2024-05-2231 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastCross-Examination | The Story of the Waffle Stomper ShoeRadio Vérité Presents: The Spoon River Gothic Podcast - True Crime Narratives.Think, feel, understand the sideways world around you. We go where the others don’t. We dive deeper!Seasonal | Long Form | WeeklyWritten and hosted by Cory Zimmerman, our flagship series, THE SPOON RIVER GOTHIC PODCAST, is a growing collection of true crime narratives revealing tales of romance, greed, obsession, murder, and terror.We seek only those stories that cry out for justice--those untold, buried, and forsaken tales of madness, and those silenced voices dese...
2024-05-0941 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastChapter 8 | 138 MinutesDescriptionRadio Vérité Presents: The Spoon River Gothic Podcast - True Crime Narratives.Think, feel, understand the sideways world around you. We go where the others don’t. We dive deeper!Seasonal | Long Form | WeeklyWritten and hosted by Cory Zimmerman, our flagship series, THE SPOON RIVER GOTHIC PODCAST, is a growing collection of true crime narratives revealing tales of romance, greed, obsession, murder, and terror.We seek only those stories that cry out for justice--those untold, buried, and forsaken tales of madness, and thos...
2024-05-0630 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastCross-Examination | To Bear WitnessRadio Vérité Presents: The Spoon River Gothic Podcast - True Crime Narratives.Think, feel, understand the sideways world around you. We go where the others don’t. We dive deeper!Seasonal | Long Form | WeeklyWritten and hosted by Cory Zimmerman, our flagship series, THE SPOON RIVER GOTHIC PODCAST, is a growing collection of true crime narratives revealing tales of romance, greed, obsession, murder, and terror.We seek only those stories that cry out for justice--those untold, buried, and forsaken tales of madness, and those silenced voices dese...
2024-04-251h 06
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastChapter 7 | Right-Hand GirlRadio Vérité Presents: The Spoon River Gothic Podcast - True Crime Narratives.Think, feel, understand the sideways world around you. We go where the others don’t. We dive deeper!Seasonal | Long Form | WeeklyWritten and hosted by Cory Zimmerman, our flagship series, THE SPOON RIVER GOTHIC PODCAST, is a growing collection of true crime narratives revealing tales of romance, greed, obsession, murder, and terror.We seek only those stories that cry out for justice--those untold, buried, and forsaken tales of madness, and those silenced voices dese...
2024-04-2256 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastChapter 6 | Ark-La-TexRadio Vérité Presents: The Spoon River Gothic Podcast - True Crime Narratives.Think, feel, understand the sideways world around you. We go where the others don’t. We dive deeper!Seasonal | Long Form | WeeklyWritten and hosted by Cory Zimmerman, our flagship series, THE SPOON RIVER GOTHIC PODCAST, is a growing collection of true crime narratives revealing tales of romance, greed, obsession, murder, and terror.We seek only those stories that cry out for justice--those untold, buried, and forsaken tales of madness, and those silenced voices dese...
2024-04-0838 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastCross-Examination | 48th of an InchRadio Vérité Presents: The Spoon River Gothic Podcast - True Crime Narratives.Think, feel, understand. We go where the others don’t. We dive deeper!Seasonal | Long Form | WeeklyWritten and hosted by Cory Zimmerman, our flagship series, THE SPOON RIVER GOTHIC PODCAST, is a growing collection of true crime narratives revealing tales of romance, greed, obsession, murder, and terror.We seek only stories of those who cry out for justice, those untold, buried, and forsaken. Stories sincerely deserving to be told by voices that, for too...
2024-03-2718 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastChapter 5 | Bubble YumRadio Vérité Presents: The Spoon River Gothic Podcast - True Crime Narratives.Think, feel, understand. We go where the others don’t. We dive deeper!Seasonal | Long Form | WeeklyWritten and hosted by Cory Zimmerman, our flagship series, THE SPOON RIVER GOTHIC PODCAST, is a growing collection of true crime narratives revealing tales of romance, greed, obsession, murder, and terror.We seek only stories of those who cry out for justice, those untold, buried, and forsaken. Stories sincerely deserving to be told by voices that, for too...
2024-03-261h 02
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastChapter 4 | .69 Item In this episode, we journey into the enigmatic heart of 1985 Florida, a state pulsating with life and exponential population growth. New residents flock to its shores daily, drawn by promises of economic prosperity and boundless opportunity. Yet beneath the surface lies a tapestry of environmental concerns and human struggles, echoing the age-old question of progress at what cost? We confront Florida's intriguing "frontier mentality," a throwback to the untamed spirit of the Wild West. Here, notions of freedom and exploration coexist with shadows of uncertainty, shaping the state's identity in inspiring and disquieting ways. Our...
2024-03-181h 07
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastCross-Examination | An Affluent ManEric Stull, the nephew of Merle “Chet” Reeder, offers a poignant narrative surrounding the life of his mysterious uncle, whose life was tragically cut short during the 1985 multi-state killing spree masterminded by Daniel Rameta. He offers profound insights as he intimately recounts “Chet” beginnings in Maryland, his diverse ventures, including a successful stint in the nightclub industry in NYC, to owning businesses, to ultimately settling in Florida, where he gave up his possessions and decided to live a simple life devoted to God. Eric paints a picture of a dynamic individual who struggled with strained familial bonds concerni...
2024-03-1239 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastChapter 3 | The Land of Misfit Toys - Part IIA February 8th, 1985, armed robbery at an Ocala gas station that leaves attendant Merle “Chet” Reeder brutally murdered is meticulously dissected with the testimonies of witnesses and law enforcement officers, who piece together the harrowing sequence of events that unfolded in those early morning hours. From the initial discovery of the crime scene by unsuspecting bystanders to the meticulous investigative efforts that followed, every revelation uncovers new layers of intrigue and suspense.However, many unanswered questions remain amidst the investigation, leaving the small community on edge.What motivated the assailants to commit such a heinous act...
2024-03-1131 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastChapter 3 | The Land of Misfit Toys - Part IBeginning with a poignant biblical quote, we explore the intricacies of the courtroom trial against the backdrop of moral dilemmas, community challenges, and themes of justice, personal belief, and societal norms.As the courtroom drama unfolds, we are invited to ponder thought-provoking questions, such as, 'How do our deeply held personal beliefs influence our perception of justice?Are we truly impartial, or are we merely projecting our own values onto the situation?’Can we remain impartial in the face of deeply ingrained biases?The discussion extends to the application of the de...
2024-03-0458 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastCross-Examination | The Passage of ArmsIn today’s gripping episode, we delve deep into the heart of the chaos that unfolded on February 13, 1985, as we listen to the brave officers’ firsthand accounts that granted an intimate glimpse into that climactic showdown with the outlaws, Daniele Rameta, Lisa Dunn, Mark Walters, and James Hunter, that marked the culmination of the highway crime spree that had gripped Thomas County.With vivid detail and poignant insight, these officers recount the harrowing shootout that ensued on a farmstead north of Colby, highlighting the intense exchange of gunfire that left teenager Mark Walter dead and the three othe...
2024-02-2637 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastSRG - TrailerRadio Vérité Presents: The Spoon River Gothic Podcast - A Literary True Crime Podcast.Think, feel, understand. We go where the others don’t. We dive deeper!Seasonal | Long Form | WeeklyExecutive Producer Cory Zimmerman.Written, Edited & Narrated by Cory Zimmerman.Research by Rachel Laubis, Moira King & Allison Hester.Blog Written by Samantha Thomas.Subscribe to THE SRG AGENCY @ https://www.patreon.com/SpoonRiverGothicPodcast & Access The SPOON RIVER GOTHIC CASE FILE for Bonus Weekly Episodes & Investigative Materials (Audio Interviews, Trial Foot...
2024-02-1901 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastChapter 2 | God's CountryIn the wake of a harrowing crime spree that left rural Kansas reeling in 1985, a somber analogy emerged from the lips of a local gas station owner near the junction of Kansas 25 and I-70: "You just don’t know what’s coming down the sewer pipe next." February 13, 1985, marked the culmination of the multi-week, multi-state ordeal, as Highway I-70, the Mainstreet of Kansas, often referred to as the “Sewer Pipe of America,” became the grim stage for the final act. Today, our episode delves into the aftermath of that fateful Wednesday evening in February. We're introduc...
2024-02-191h 05
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastChapter 1 | Mad DogsRadio Vérté Presents SPOON RIVER GOTHIC - Season Two: Death Rides the Highway - A Thrill Ride of Murder & Terror! This season, we will unravel the captivating story of four vastly different individuals and how they all came together to embark on a cross-country crime spree marked by violence and tragedy. In our inaugural episode, we explore the vast expanse of the American landscape, where ribbons of asphalt traverse the American heartland, as we immerse ourselves in the story of the United States Interstate Highway System. Born out of the Federal Aid Hig...
2024-02-1250 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastCh. 54 - Machinery of DeathWelcome to Hell-- We dive into several accounts from inmates on death row, as they appear in letters written from Death Row. Death Row inmates describe the extreme confinement conditions they face, 23 hours a day in 6x9 feet cells. These accounts offer a deeply thought-provoking insight into the human experience within a system that ultimately aims to end their lives. These narratives strike at the heart of the debate surrounding the death penalty, exposing its underlying brutality. These accounts, shared in letters from around the country, vigorously challenge the conventional notion that society...
2023-10-201h 10
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastS1. Bonus - A Solemn ResponsibilityBonus Author-I will present a bonus chapter written by Spoon River Gothic co-producer Samantha Thomas. This report shall pertain to Samantha’s subjective analysis of the Defense and Prosecution team’s closing arguments during Donald Bull’s 1996 trial. “A Solemn Responsibility” by Samantha ThomasFollow out blog @: www.spoonrivergothi.com
2023-10-1339 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastCh. 53 - All Bets are OffDr. Michael Gelbort-- Notably, Dr. Gelbort starred in the hit Netflix series "I Am a Killer," lending his expertise to the show. Dr. Gelbort assists patients by conducting interviews and coordinating testing for suspected neurological issues. His evaluations contribute essential insights for referring sources, aiding in the understanding of patients' cognitive functioning and potential interventions that could have been implemented before a crime had been committed. A clinical neuropsychologist with a vast and impactful career, Dr. Gelbort’s role in the Donald Bull trial was to provide diagnostic and consultation services for the de...
2023-10-0829 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastCh. 52 - Eye for Eye, Tooth for ToothThe pursuit of closure-- Death penalty cases are a profoundly intricate and emotionally charged process with profound implications for the victims’ families and the defendants. In the case of Donald Bull Jr., his journey through the legal system underscored these complexities. Donnie's appeals, filed in May 1996, opened a new chapter in his case, revealing fundamental allegations, from improper search techniques to evidence-sharing concerns. This legal process, though fraught with intricacies, has far-reaching consequences not only for Bull but also for the victims' families, who yearn for a sense of closure and justice. It's wo...
2023-10-0853 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastCh. 51 - "Something fishy is going on here..."A conversation with Ken & Alan-- Ken, the former deputy who escorted Donnie Bull to and from the courthouse each day of his trial, provides us with a fascinating juxtaposition--his impression of Donnie as calm and self-assured in the face of grave charges, starkly contrasted with Ken's own confidence in Donnie's guilt. This incongruity casts a spotlight on the nuances of human behavior and the challenges of making determinations based on appearances alone. Perhaps the most thought-provoking element was Ken's recollection of the jury's rapid deliberation, spanning just approximately 45 minutes. This brevity raises important questions regarding...
2023-09-2924 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastCh. 50 - A Heavy Burden Mr. Parkinson-- The assistant state's attorney, ardently presenting the prosecution's case with counterarguments to the defense’s closing, reminds us of the importance of recalling the complexity of Donna Tompkins' relationships with multiple male suspects. Was her relationship with them as black and white as the defense describes? While Mr. Parkinson argues his case, we must scrutinize the timeline leading up to that fateful morning—especially when comparing the original account Rod gave investigators. Does how Mr. Parkinson describes this timeline align with Rod’s account? And if not, wouldn’t that be a cause...
2023-09-2839 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastCh. 49 - Burn Hot, Fast & IntenseA closing argument-- McMillian, Donald Bull’s co-defense attorney, masterfully navigates the twists and turns of this complex trial, leading us toward a thought-provoking destination—engaging, challenging, and captivating us as we dissect her closing argument and consider the profound implications of this relentless pursuit of truth, justice, and the presumption of innocence. In a world where doubt can eclipse certainty, McMillian reminds us that the burden of proof rests firmly on the shoulders of those who seek to condemn. At the heart of her case is the absence of evidence that firmly plac...
2023-09-2546 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastSRG: Narrative of a Double Homicide - TRAILERCory Zimmerman and Radio Vérité Present the Literary, Long-Form, True Crime Podcast: "SPOON RIVER GOTHIC - NARRATIVE of a DOUBLE HOMICIDE"A True Crime Saga Revealing a Mystery of Romance, Obsession & Terror. The Borders of the Puzzle - Arson & Murder!A HAUNTING TALE - The perplexing double homicide of mother and child unfolding against a vivid backdrop of a quaint, midwestern town—the story kicks off with the chilling discovery of Donna and Justine Tompkins' lifeless bodies in their fire-ravaged home on a frigid morning in January 1993. As investigators feverishly search for clues, the narr...
2023-09-2402 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastCh. 48 - A Reasonable DoubtThe Legal Arena-- As the pursuit of justice hangs in a precarious balance, the intricacies of the Donald Bull case unravel—what reveals itself to be a gripping courtroom drama that has captivated the public’s attention. Donnie Bull, a name etched in the annals of Canton, Illinois, history, stands, as you know, accused of a heinous crime—the murder of Donna and her daughter, Justine Tompkins. Mr. Stone, Bull's unyielding defense attorney, is at the center of this tumultuous trial. With the weight of justice on his shoulders, Mr. Stone steps up to the...
2023-09-2343 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastCh. 47 - The Stepping StoneAn intricate tapestry-- During closing arguments, the prosecution, led by the formidable Mr. Ed Danner, weaves a compelling narrative, drawing upon several critical threads of evidence. The enigmatic ring found in Donald Bull's possession is at the heart of Danner’s case. It is a piece of jewelry that seems to hold the key to a cryptic connection. The prosecution argues that this ring, belonging to Donna Tompkins, is a compelling link to her, possibly hinting at Donnie's involvement in the tragic events that unfolded. The courtroom quivers with intrigue over a stained ar...
2023-09-1957 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastCh. 46 - Of the Last DrinkCourtroom theater-- Arriving at closing statements during a criminal trial, lives hang in the balance, and the long-awaited trial of Donald Bull is no exception. As lead prosecutor, States Attorney Ed Danner, stands before the jury, acknowledging their attentiveness, we are immediately drawn into a world where justice is paramount. The charges, “first-degree murder,” “concealment of homicidal deaths,” and “aggravated arson,” cast a long shadow over the proceedings, hinting at the gravity and weight of the case—a stark reminder that justice is not a mere abstraction, but a literal matter of life and death. In a cour...
2023-09-1452 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastSRG: "Narrative of a Double Homicide" - TrailerCory Zimmerman and Radio Vérité Present the Literary, Long-Form, True Crime Podcast: "SPOON RIVER GOTHIC - NARRATIVE of a DOUBLE HOMICIDE"A True Crime Saga Revealing a Mystery of Romance, Obsession & Terror. The Borders of the Puzzle - Arson & Murder!A HAUNTING TALE - The perplexing double homicide of mother and child unfolding against a vivid backdrop of a quaint, midwestern town—the story kicks off with the chilling discovery of Donna and Justine Tompkins' lifeless bodies in their fire-ravaged home on a frigid morning in January 1993. As investigators feverishly search for clues, the narr...
2023-09-1001 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastSRG: "Narrative of a Double Homicide" - TrailerCory Zimmerman and Radio Vérité Present the Literary, Long-Form, True Crime Podcast: "SPOON RIVER GOTHIC - NARRATIVE of a DOUBLE HOMICIDE"A True Crime Saga Revealing a Mystery of Romance, Obsession & Terror. The Borders of the Puzzle - Arson & Murder!A HAUNTING TALE - The perplexing double homicide of mother and child unfolding against a vivid backdrop of a quaint, midwestern town—the story kicks off with the chilling discovery of Donna and Justine Tompkins' lifeless bodies in their fire-ravaged home on a frigid morning in January 1993. As investigators feverishly search for clues, the narr...
2023-09-0801 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastPart 3. Prologue - A Reasonable DoubtThe trial: Odds & Obstacles-- Alan Friedman, a seasoned legal professional who headed up Donald Bull’s clemency team, will revisit the legal labyrinth and specific aspects of the case that will take center stage—the discovery of Donnie pawning a ring; scrutiny by Friedman's law students who found inconsistencies in the case; along with other doubts he felt about the integrity of the evidence. These revelations will underscore the delicate balance between such evidence and its interpretation, highlighting how even minor details can loom large in a complex legal puzzle such as this one.Friedman's own...
2023-09-0716 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastCh. 45 - Neither Brave Man Nor CowardA stark reminder-- Within every story, there's a shadow of doubt lurking. To confront this shadow, we must adopt a vigilant skepticism and a relentless pursuit of the truth. It's an arduous journey that demands we question our assumptions, scrutinize testimonies, and explore the recesses of uncertainty. We can only hope to glimpse the elusive light of justice by navigating this labyrinth of doubt with unwavering dedication. Confirmation bias, that insidious inclination to interpret information in a way that confirms our preconceptions, is a looming specter in cases like Donna and Justine Tompkins...
2023-09-071h 09
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastSRG - "Narrative of a Double Homicide" - TrailerCory Zimmerman and Radio Vérité Present the Literary, Long-Form, True Crime Podcast: "SPOON RIVER GOTHIC - NARRATIVE of a DOUBLE HOMICIDE"A True Crime Saga Revealing a Mystery of Romance, Obsession & Terror. The Borders of the Puzzle - Arson & Murder!A HAUNTING TALE - The perplexing double homicide of mother and child unfolding against a vivid backdrop of a quaint, midwestern town—the story kicks off with the chilling discovery of Donna and Justine Tompkins' lifeless bodies in their fire-ravaged home on a frigid morning in January 1993. As investigators feverishly search for clues, the narr...
2023-09-0601 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastCh. 44 - The Thrill of the HuntThe world of criminal investigation-- Within a complex web of strategies and techniques, each agency threads its own path toward justice. The Donna Tompkins case serves as a captivating tableau, shedding light on the striking differences in the approaches taken by opposing agencies, juxtaposing the investigative ideals of the renowned Federal Bureau of Investigation. As we dive into the local Canton Police Department and the intricacies of their own investigative methods, a profound comparison emerges that unveils disparities and prompts us to ponder the significance of their techniques in shaping the pursuit of truth.
2023-08-301h 06
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastCh. 44 - The Thrill of the HuntCory Zimmerman and Radio Vérité Present the Literary, Long-Form, True Crime Podcast: "SPOON RIVER GOTHIC - NARRATIVE of a DOUBLE HOMICIDE"A True Crime Saga Revealing a Mystery of Romance, Obsession & Terror. The Borders of the Puzzle - Arson & Murder!A HAUNTING TALE - The perplexing double homicide of mother and child unfolding against a vivid backdrop of a quaint, midwestern town—the story kicks off with the chilling discovery of Donna and Justine Tompkins' lifeless bodies in their fire-ravaged home on a frigid morning in January 1993. As investigators feverishly search for clues, the narrative swiftly evolves into a comp...
2023-08-301h 06
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastCh. 44 - The Thrill of the HuntCory Zimmerman and Radio Vérité Present the Literary, Long-Form, True Crime Podcast: "SPOON RIVER GOTHIC - NARRATIVE of a DOUBLE HOMICIDE"A True Crime Saga Revealing a Mystery of Romance, Obsession & Terror. The Borders of the Puzzle - Arson & Murder!A HAUNTING TALE - The perplexing double homicide of mother and child unfolding against a vivid backdrop of a quaint, midwestern town—the story kicks off with the chilling discovery of Donna and Justine Tompkins' lifeless bodies in their fire-ravaged home on a frigid morning in January 1993. As investigators feverishly search for clues, the narr...
2023-08-301h 06
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastCh. 43 - NaysayersA Look back at those early suspicions-- Conversations with former Canton police officer Rusty Graham, again, offer a unique look into a first-hand account of that tragic January morning in 1993. Communications with firefighters and fellow officers on scene indicated that the circumstances surrounding the fire were far from ordinary, as the fire commander's observations gave birth to a sense of intrigue—a clue that this wasn't a mere accident. Back in early January 1993, in a town where crimes were few and far between, the puzzle pieces of suspicion were slowly coming together. As th...
2023-08-2344 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastCh. 42 - The Contenders A contrasting depiction of Donald Bull-- Donnie’s letters and newspaper articles paint a complex picture of a man entangled in legal battles and personal struggles. In his letters, Bull appears defiant and assertive about his innocence. He expresses frustration towards the police, alleging interference in his correspondence and manipulation of his letters as evidence. This portrays him as a person who firmly believes in his own innocence and is ready to fight against perceived injustice. On the other hand, the newspaper articles present a more troubled image of Donnie. He is portrayed as being in...
2023-08-2248 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastSeason Two Trailer - Spoon River Gothic Presents: "Death Rides the Highway"“KANSAS CARNAGE CAME BY WAY OF SEWER PIPE”Many people who populate this storybook chunk of American heartland with the endlessly straight rows of corn, neatly painted barns, and carefully tended fences call the highway just outside of town “the sewer pipe.” Late last week, death flowed into northwestern Kansas through that “sewer pipe,” which most other Americans know as Interstate 70, during a two-hour nightmare of screaming tires, hostage-taking, executions, and gunfighting. When the last shot was fired almost precisely at sundown Wednesday, four people were dead, two had been severely wounded, and three suspects were in police custo...
2023-08-1602 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastTrailer - Spoon River Gothic Presents: "Death Rides the Highway"“KANSAS CARNAGE CAME BY WAY OF SEWER PIPE”Many people who populate this storybook chunk of American heartland with the endlessly straight rows of corn, neatly painted barns, and carefully tended fences call the highway just outside of town “the sewer pipe.”Late last week, death flowed into northwestern Kansas through that “sewer pipe,” which most other Americans know as Interstate 70, during a two-hour nightmare of screaming tires, hostage-taking, executions, and gunfighting.When the last shot was fired almost precisely at sundown Wednesday, four people were dead, two had been severely wounded, and three suspects were in police custody.Signs of carnage s...
2023-08-1501 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastCh. 41 - Crazy EyesJeff Grigsby-- During Jeff’s time in jail, he shared a cell with Donnie Bull. Through Jeff's experience, we gain invaluable insights that shed light on the complexity of Donnie’s character and potential flaws in the justice system. Jeff was born in Canton, Illinois, and possesses a personal connection to the story. Having spent those long hours and days in jail with Donnie, his perspective offers a unique lens through which we can view the man behind the headlines. Jeff and Donnie’s backgrounds and upbringings in Canton laid the foundation for their...
2023-08-1533 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastCh. 40 - Tight Lipped & Tenacious The heart of an intricate puzzle-- Donna and Justine Tompkins’ case grows more compelling through the interviews conducted with individuals who crossed paths with Donald R. Bull. The whispers of Donnie’s involvement in the tragic events highlight the complex interplay of human psychology, behavior, and the haunting influence of drugs and alcohol. These interviews provide a unique lens through which to explore the multifaceted personality of Donnie Bull, particularly the role that his relationship with alcohol played in this enigma. The interviews paint a picture of two distinct personalities residing within Donnie. When...
2023-08-1346 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastS1. Interlude - "Sayin' something wrong."A conversation with Bruce--Local historian Bruce Weirauch, who runs a Facebook page dedicated to Fulton County's history—we gain insights into his experience of encountering pushback from the community due to his coverage of historical cases, much like we’ve dealt with the Donald Bull and Donna Tompkins case. He recounts how he discussed matters like Janice May, who was murdered in the 50s, and how he unintentionally stirred more controversy than anticipated, resulting in accusations of altering narratives. But like Spoon River Gothic, Bruce emphasizes that his only intention was to present facts rather than opin...
2023-08-0431 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastInterlude - "Sayin' something wrong."Spoon River Gothic | Narrative of a Double Homicide.A long-form podcast hosted by Cory Zimmerman.On an icy morning in 1993, an old house beside a pair of rusty tracks burst into flames.And when the charred remains of 30-year-old Donna Tompkins and her 3-year-old daughter, Justine, were discovered, their deaths were ruled a homicide, and a manhunt ensued. In association with CZ Studios and Radio Vérité, Lone Bird Media presents a literary podcast. Follow along with me, your host, Cory Zimmerman, as I uncover a myriad of romance, obsession, and terror. This is...
2023-08-0431 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastCh. 39 - Open WoundsThe ex-girlfriend-- Preferring to remain anonymous, an ex-lover of Donald Bull’s expresses concerns about being on the record due to the rough crowd she is associated with, mentioning that some of her friends and acquaintances believe Donnie is innocent, though preferring to maintain a low profile to avoid getting involved with any further drama, especially considering her job caring for elderly and disabled individuals. She shares her challenging life circumstances, including leaving a painful alcoholic relationship before Donnie and raising three daughters, one of whom is in the midst of a teenage pregnancy. ...
2023-08-0120 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastCh. 38 - The Forest for the TreesInvestigative thinking-- During the criminal inquiry into Donna and Justine Tompkins' double homicide, investigators face the daunting task of sifting through a labyrinth of evidence and testimonies to uncover even a resemblance of truth. As they navigate the complexities of such a daunting examination, a crucial distinction emerges: The difference between investigative tasks and investigative thinking. While the former involves gathering and processing information, the latter demands a profound, unbiased, and introspective approach. Investigative thinking is the lifeblood of any successful criminal investigation—as it transcends the mere collection of facts—demanding a rele...
2023-07-2843 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastCh. 37 - A Strange FeelingThe accounts of Marie and Iona-- We confront Donald Bull's deeply troubling past—a history that includes prior convictions, including rape, which raises concerns about his capacity for violence and wrongdoing. Marie, who lived across the street from Donnie, did not know his previous conviction when he moved in nearby. Understandably, such information might have altered her perception of him, but what's fascinating is how personal experiences and public knowledge can coexist in shaping one's judgment. Marie's sister dated Donnie Bull briefly, and it wasn't a smooth sailing relationship, either. We learn that anger and ag...
2023-07-2424 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastCh. 36 - A Balmy 69 DegreesThe enigmatic suspect-- As the plot thickens, authorities interview multiple individuals connected to Donnie Bull, who has emerged as the prime suspect. The interviews bring to light a maze of inconsistencies, raising questions about the reliability of witnesses and the true motives behind the crime. In this thought-provoking episode, we delve into the complexities of the case and explore the intriguing possibilities that lie beneath the surface. At the heart of any investigation are the witness testimonies, which often serve as crucial building blocks to reconstruct the puzzle of events. However, the recent...
2023-07-2141 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastS1. Bonus - GraceVenture into the realm of human response--Through concepts such as “change” and “questioning” —particularly in the context of the revived investigation into the Donna and Justine Tompkins case, as we dissect the layers of emotions and reactions sparked by reevaluating an ostensibly closed case—we explore the psychological mechanisms that compel individuals to defend their comfort zones and resist confronting unsettling truths.Delving into the analogy of unearthing a long-buried case like Donnie Bull's, we navigate the multifaceted dimensions of fear, anger, and defensive tactics that communities may employ when confronted with the prospect of change. B...
2023-07-1614 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastCh. 35 - Sleepless NightsShedding light on a troubled character, Donald Bull-- An interview with one of Donnie’s ex-wives reveals a relationship that had started seemingly normal but quickly turned into one marked by control and abuse. The ex-wife bravely shares her experience of enduring Donald's controlling tendencies, physical abuse, and sexual assault. She also expresses frustration and sadness over the jurors' decision to acquit Donald for the rape charge, believing that this outcome may have contributed to the subsequent tragedy involving another woman and her child. A second interviewee also shares with detectives a disturbing en...
2023-07-1347 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastCh. 34 - Reluctant to be ToldThe perplexing life of Donald R. Bull-- At the heart of this episode lies the captivating story of Donnie's recorded confession to raping his estranged wife, captured surreptitiously by his wife and the police. While his admission raises eyebrows, the subsequent acquittal by the jury stirs deep-seated questions about the efficacy of our judicial system. A crucial aspect that cannot be overlooked is Donnie's checkered past involving brushes with the law. His previous conviction for aggravated battery adds a layer of suspicion to his character, making him an ideal suspect on paper. While...
2023-07-1144 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastCh. 33 - Shoot the ShitThe intricacies of working in a local coffee spot come to light-- Offering a unique perspective on Donnie Bull through the eyes of a former gas station employee, Jeff Bennett, while seemingly insignificant, this employee's account holds valuable insights. Gas station and convenience store workers often develop a keen sense of observation, witnessing regular customers in their ordinary moments and picking up on subtle cues. Therefore, Jeff's perception of Donnie as ordinary and unremarkable raises intriguing questions. It suggests that Donnie might have effectively concealed any underlying darkness, presenting a facade that went unnoticed by...
2023-07-0339 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastCh. 32 - The Detective DramaPeeling back the layers-- Donna's life gradually reveals a woman hopeful for her future but burdened by uncertainty. The revelation of her potential pregnancy adds an additional layer of complexity to her already challenging circumstances, leaving her grappling with feelings of fear, uncertainty, and the overwhelming weight of a potentially life-altering decision. This intimate exchange between Donna and her sister, Mary, exposes the emotional turmoil that Donna endured in silence, highlighting the profound impact such a revelation can have on an individual's psyche. Rod emerges as a compelling suspect in the investigation for...
2023-07-0243 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastCh. 31 - "Hell, I'll pull the switch!"The statement-- The exchange reported by Michelle Bell at Kroger's Grocery Store raises a familiar question: Who should we believe? David Haynes denies ever making the statement about being glad Donna was dead and claiming knowledge about the fire's origin. He offers an alternative account of the conversation, suggesting that the man in line behind him merely made a general comment about setting fires. David emphasizes that Michelle Bell may have had ulterior motives, pointing to the reward money for leads in the case. This divergence in testimonies adds to the complexity of the investigation...
2023-06-2918 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastTrailer - SPOON RIVER GOTHICSpoon River Gothic | Narrative of a Double Homicide - Part Two. A four-part series hosted by Cory Zimmerman. On an icy morning in 1993, an old house beside a pair of rusty tracks burst into flames. And when the charred remains of 30-year-old Donna Tompkins and her 3-year-old daughter, Justine, were discovered, their deaths were ruled a homicide, and a manhunt ensued. In association with CZ Studios and Radio Vérité, Lone Bird Media presents a literary podcast. Follow along with me, your host, Cory Zimmerman, as I uncover a myriad of romance, obsession, and terror. This is SPOON RIVER GO...
2023-06-2600 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastCh. 30 - "Grief can take care of itself."Grief-- Amongst the intricate web of emotions that entangle those who experience the loss of a loved one, we witness the profound impact of murder on a family and delve into the depths of their grief. Donna and Justine's tragic deaths have left a trail of devastation, shattering a family's sense of safety and forever altering their perception of the world. The immediate aftermath of such a heinous act is unimaginable as the family grapples with intrusive thoughts, unresolved investigations, and the pain of being unable to bid their loved ones a proper farewell. In...
2023-06-2640 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastCh. 29 - Best People on EarthA spotlight on the Elks Club-- The esteemed and exclusive organization with a long-standing history, the Elks, known for fostering camaraderie and philanthropy among its members, held a significant position within the community. However, as detectives delve deeper into the case, questions arise about whether the tight-knit nature of the Elks fraternity could be protecting its own members, including Terry Haynes. Could the organization's secrecy and elite standing in the community create an environment where influential members are inclined to shield one another from potential accusations or investigations?As the interviews...
2023-06-2027 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastCh. 28 - What Ghosts RemainStep inside the charred remains-- Inside the old Victorian at 356 South First Avenue, we witness the fire's aftermath through the vivid descriptions of investigators who discover a crucial piece of evidence in Donna's living room: the pull-out sofa bed where Donna and Justine’s remains were found. As suspicion arises as they detect the presence of a flammable liquid at the scene, all collected evidence is meticulously examined at the Alcohol Tobacco & Firearms Forensic Science Laboratory in Rockville, Maryland. The analysis reveals alarming findings, verifying the traces of gasoline on clothing, wood, and hair samples ta...
2023-06-1530 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastS1. Bonus - Where the Bodies Were Dumped An interview with Kelly Kurtz--Kelly, a recovering addict and now a dedicated advocate for others facing addiction, shines a peculiar light on some shocking revelations that raise intriguing questions. With her unique perspective on the dark underbelly of Canton, like many others within the community, she believes that Donald Bull is responsible for the murders of Donna and Justine. But through her own investigations, Kelly claims to have uncovered a web of drug crimes and other homicides that might connect—though loosely—to the Bull case, indicating a more extensive criminal/corruptive network at play.Ke...
2023-06-1450 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastCh. 27 - Undetermined The autopsies-- The postmortem examinations conducted on Donna and Justine reveal a disturbing truth that adds a chilling dimension to the investigation. Contrary to initial assumptions, their deaths occurred before the fire, as evidenced by the absence of soot in their lungs. The ruling of their cause of death as "undetermined" underscores the complex nature of the case. And the description of the deaths as occurring under "suspicious conditions" raises many unsettling questions. This revelation transforms the fire investigation into a full-fledged murder inquiry, shrouding the scene with crime scene tape and intensifying the urgency...
2023-06-0937 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastCh. 26 - From There to ZeroCanton, Illinois-- Bruce, a local historian, takes us back in time with his perspective on the community, the case, and his longtime friend, Jon Tompkins. Bruce raises intriguing questions about how we, as people, form judgments and suspicions. Notably, Bruce does not believe Jon would have harmed Justine, which challenges initial assumptions. This complexity underscores the intricacies of human behavior and the intricate nature of investigations. It prompts us to consider the delicate balance between drawing conclusions based on evidence and keeping an open mind to all possibilities, recognizing that perceptions and initial impressions may...
2023-06-0537 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastCh. 25 - A Prodigal HandEchoes of the past-- We are confronted with a bottomless list of crimes from the past that still reverberate through the present, having left an indelible mark on the community's consciousness—tales of unsolved murders and unresolved mysteries become intertwined with the local folklore, generating a climate of suspicion. People are left pondering the question: Could there be a hidden connection between these past crimes and the current tragedy? The weight of history becomes a lens through which every piece of evidence is viewed, every motive scrutinized, and every potential suspect questioned. Like an...
2023-06-0241 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastCh. 24 - "It's not what you know. It's who you know."Terry Haynes-- The interview process of Terry Haynes and its comparison to David Haynes sheds light on the potential influence of personal relationships and insider status in the investigation. Terry's established connections within Canton, including his friendship with Sgt. Ayers and his familiarity with other officers have shaped the tone and approach of his interview. Sgt. Ayers assures Terry that the interview is merely a formality and downplays any suspicion, creating a more relaxed atmosphere. In contrast, David Haynes, being an outsider, faces a different treatment and is subjected to more rigorous questioning. This contrast...
2023-05-2720 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastCh.3 Review – Ramblings of Intrigue - Diving in Head FirstMist, Smoke & Fog - a Spoon River Gothic Review by Tati Garabet. Journey along with Tati as she examines each case episode one by one, covering the innuendo, the mystery, and the intrigue, capturing the essence of Donna's story in her enigmatic words. Produced by August Olsen. Edited, directed, and produced by Cory Zimmerman. Written by Tati Garabet. Mastering and engineering by Emastered.Read the Mist, Smoke, Fog blog at CZStudio.works/mist-smoke-fog
2023-05-2613 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastCh. 2 Review - Dark Vaults - Unraveling the Mysteries of the National BankOn behalf of CZ Studio and Radio Vérité, we would like to present our sister podcast, Mist, Smoke & Fog - a Spoon River Gothic Review by Tati Garabet. Journey along with Tati as she examines each case episode one by one, covering the innuendo, the mystery, and the intrigue, capturing the essence of Donna's story in her enigmatic words. Produced by August Olsen. Edited, directed, and produced by Cory Zimmerman. Written by Tati Garabet. Mastering and engineering by Emastered.Read the Mist, Smoke, Fog blog at CZStudio.works
2023-05-2207 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastCh. 23 - Muddy WatersShifting focus-- Boyfriend Rod Franciscovich was a crucial figure in the lives of Donna and Justine. As his account of events unravels for the police, several prominent themes emerge, shedding light on the intricacies of the case. As investigators focus on gathering valuable information rather than fixating on a single suspect, Rod's detailed recollections provide deeper insights into the crime scene as he reconstructs the apartment's layout and offers crucial eyewitness testimony. Yet, amidst these revelations, ambiguity lingers, and unanswered questions continue to perplex investigators and us as listeners alike. Throughout the interview...
2023-05-2023 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastIntroducing "Mist, Smoke & Fog"On behalf of CZ Studio and Radio Vérité, we would like to present our sister podcast, Mist, Smoke & Fog - a Spoon River Gothic Review by Tati Garabet. Journey along with Tati as she examines each case episode one by one, covering the innuendo, the mystery, and the intrigue, capturing the essence of Donna's story in her enigmatic words. Check her out; she is one of a kind. And as always, listener discretion is advised. This is Mist, Smoke & Fog, a review of ch 1, Whispering Tracks - Unraveling the Enigma of a Small Town Tragedy.Produced by August Olsen. Ed...
2023-05-1906 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastCh. 22 - The Pallbearer Part TwoDavid Haynes, part two-- Several unresolved questions emerge, adding to the mystery surrounding Donna and Justine's deaths. One lingering question revolves around Donna's younger brother blowing David and his wife a kiss as they leave the cemetery. This poignant moment remains enigmatic, leaving us to wonder about its significance and those deeper emotions and connections. Another unresolved question concerns Jon, Donna's ex-husband, whom David encountered multiple times after the tragedy. Jon’s remarriage, having more children, his role in the investigation, and his possible insights into the events remain unexplored. Additionally, the interview ra...
2023-05-1218 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastCh. 21 - The Pallbearer Part OneDelving deeper-- David Haynes’ account of his version of events surrounding the tragic fire that claimed the lives of Donna and Justine. Several intriguing points emerge comparing David's account to what was covered in the previous episode. David acknowledges being considered a key suspect for a couple of months. Still, interestingly, he also shares his surprise and gratitude at being asked to be a pallbearer at Donna's funeral. This stark contrast highlights the complexity of his involvement and the conflicting perceptions surrounding his role in the investigation. The theme of suspicions and doubt su...
2023-05-1233 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastCh. 20 - Wake Me With the Morning's LightTrust Officer David Haynes-- Inadvertently offering a fascinating glimpse into the world of investigative technique and interrogation, the meticulous approach taken by the investigators becomes evident as they employ various tactics to uncover the truth. The delicate balance between pursuing the truth and respecting legal boundaries is also apparent, showcasing the fine line investigators must tread. The careful selection of questions, the observance of body language, and the pursuit of factual evidence demonstrate the complexity and precision required in conducting an effective interrogation. Through this, we gain insights into the intricacies of investigative techniques, the challenges faced...
2023-05-1027 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastCh. 19 - Flesh or FightLoss and grief-- The narrative of Donna & Justine’s case casts a somber and poignant atmosphere over their tragic deaths. The profound impact of this devastating event on the community of Canton, particularly those individuals closest to the victims, is personified through the exploration of funeral arrangements, the expressions of condolences, and the collective mourning process. We witness the depth of sorrow and the weight of grief that engulfs the small town. This episode invites listeners to empathize with the raw emotions of loss, reminding us of the fragility of life and the lasting impact su...
2023-05-0522 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastTrailer - Narrative of a Double HomicideCory Zimmerman and Radio Vérité Present the Literary, Long-Form, True Crime Podcast: "SPOON RIVER GOTHIC - NARRATIVE of a DOUBLE HOMICIDE"A True Crime Saga Revealing a Mystery of Romance, Obsession & Terror. The Borders of the Puzzle - Arson & Murder!A HAUNTING TALE - The perplexing double homicide of mother and child unfolding against a vivid backdrop of a quaint, midwestern town—the story kicks off with the chilling discovery of Donna and Justine Tompkins' lifeless bodies in their fire-ravaged home on a frigid morning in January 1993. As investigators feverishly search for clues, the narr...
2023-05-0100 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastPart 2. Prologue - Donnie & DonnaAn ongoing investigation-- A Delve into the Aftermath of the Tragic Fire, light is shed on the role of small-town dynamics, individuals connected to the case's willingness to discuss Donna and Justine's case allow a common theme to emerge—hesitancy.Many, if not most, are reluctant to revisit a case they believe has already been concluded, viewing it as a closed chapter in their community's history. Additionally, there is a palpable fear that openly discussing the case may lead to social repercussions or judgment within the close-knit community. This reluctance to share insights an...
2023-04-2816 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastCh. 18 - Willing & AbleThe aftermath-- John Stanko, Lt. Fire Chief, and Jack Malooly, ATF Agent, provide firsthand accounts and valuable insights into the initial discovery of Donna and Justine’s bodies and shed light on the investigative processes employed after this harrowing incident. Lt. Stanko recalls when investigators determined that the fire had been intentionally set. While he doesn't offer extensive information, he expresses confidence in the overall investigative efforts, asserting that everyone involved performed their duties diligently. As Lieutenant, his role involved coordinating efforts, ensuring proper protocols were followed, and providing guidance to th...
2023-04-2731 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastCh. 17 - “Why the hell is this doll lying here...?”Officer Rusty Graham-- When it comes to criminal investigations, some cases etch themselves deeply into the minds and hearts of those involved. For Rusty Graham, a police officer born and raised in Canton, the Donna & Justine Tompkins case was an indelible experience. As Officer Graham's recollections paint a vivid picture of the morning of the fire, he discusses his role in the investigation and his recollections of that fateful morning at the scene of the fire—his insights shed light on the gravity and emotional toll of this tragic event. As a police of...
2023-04-2634 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastCh. 16 - The Death of AirThe scene-- As a devastating fire claims the lives of Donna and Justine, the scene is chaotic and emotionally charged. The discovery of the bodies sends shockwaves through the officers on the scene, who struggle to come to terms with the tragic reality before them. Amidst the chaos, the investigation begins, and detectives focus on David Haynes, who had made the wellness check request and discovered the blaze. However, his statements and actions raise questions about his involvement and reliability as a witness. Is he being deceptive, trying to hide something, or is...
2023-04-2532 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastCh. 15 - Close to HomeThe babysitter-- Heidi Hunter believes justice was not served in finding Donald Bull guilty. As Justine’s former babysitter, she raises thought-provoking questions about the integrity of the investigation. Her conviction that other suspects should have been explored further challenges the prevailing narrative and raises doubts about the accuracy of the conclusions reached. Heidi's emotional response and her initial conviction that Jon should have been explored further, coupled with her subpoena in the original investigation, lend credibility to her perspective. Her viewpoint compels us to evaluate the evidence critically, consider alternative theories, and question whether al...
2023-04-1833 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastCh. 14 - A Quiet Little, Wild TownTown's folk-- Canton's small-town dynamics foster a unique sense of community and connection. However, interviews with the towns folk reveal a palpable caution among the interviewees, as they hesitate to discuss the town's current state openly. This cautiousness reflects the fear of backlash or repercussions within such tightly-knit communities. It underscores the delicate balance between openness and protection of reputation, urging us to consider the influence of small-town dynamics on shared information and perspective.Behind the quaint veneer of Canton's small-town charm, an undercurrent of drug culture emerges. Recollections from interviewees paint a...
2023-04-1828 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastCh. 13 - As the Hands of Time Neared MidnightDonna-- Amidst a difficult divorce, Donna seeks solace in her faith, and she leans on her boyfriend, Rod Franciscovich, and close friend, Iona Price, for support. Rod suggests a religious retreat to help Donna recenter her mindset and faith. During the retreat, Donna divulges her fears about a man she dubs "Steve" —who turns out to be Terry Haynes—her ex-partner and a source of constant distress. This revelation foreshadows further danger Donna may soon face. Meanwhile, pressure from her father adds to Donna's emotional burden, as she feels judged for her life's dire...
2023-04-1728 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastCh. 12 - All SpadesDonnie Bull enters the scene-- Iona persistently warns Donna about Donnie’s trustworthiness. We are confronted with a testament of intuition and the importance of listening to the concerns raised by others. Despite Donna's initial attraction and connection with Donnie, Iona's intuition leads her to believe that there is something dark and potentially dangerous about him. Will Donna pay attention to these red flags? Or will she ignore the warnings that Iona presents her with? Iona performs a card reading for Donna, and all spades appear—does impending doom and...
2023-04-1719 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastCh. 11 - TrustSeeking self--Donna settles into her new apartment with her daughter Justine and experiences a mix of excitement and hope. In the privacy of her new, private living space, Donna's actions reveal her aspirations to carve out her own identity, distinct from her past. This quest for self-discovery resonates with us, as it speaks to the fundamental human need for personal growth and the courage to step into the unknown. Donna's journey reminds us that within the mundane routines of everyday life, there lies a profound search for authenticity and the unfolding of one's true essence.
2023-04-1730 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastCh. 10 - Reaching OutTap into the realm of a different lens--Astrology, the paranormal, and the tarot provide a unique view into the complex case of Donna and Justine. Exploring these unconventional avenues, we are invited to take a new perspective into the mysteries that elude this baffling investigation.Skepticism and uncertainty are common themes in Donna & Justine’s case. And a young woman who spent time as a child in the home Donna and Justine died in speaks of her ghostly experiences and suspicions of Donna's former boss, David Haynes, as she also acknowledges the need for ca...
2023-04-1727 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastCh. 9 - Prostitutes & Potbelly PigsAn unsettling connection-- A woman who grew up next door to Terry Haynes and attended the same preschool as Justine forces us to ponder the haunting question of what innocent Justine could have become. She casts a sad light on the impact of Donna and Justine's tragic story. Although the woman does not recall Justine vividly, the mere realization that their paths inevitably crossed evokes an unsettling feeling. This sentiment reflects the untold potential within Justine, now forever lost. Moreover, the woman's proximity to Terry Haynes, being his neighbor as a child, adds...
2023-04-1726 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastCh. 8 - Never ForgetBreaking free-- Donna’s story continues to unfold with a series of difficult decisions, personal growth, and the profound impact of her choices on her life and her daughter, Justine. As we embark on this exploration, we are confronted with the complexities and challenges that arise when one finds the strength to break free from the clutches of abusive and possessive partners. Donna's case is a compelling example of the difficulties inherent in escaping toxic relationships. Her marriage to Jon, characterized by possessiveness and abuse, highlights the emotional and psychological challenges individuals trapped in...
2023-04-1722 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastCh. 7 - Larger than Life SkiesA quest--Seeking personal growth and empowerment is a driving force for Donna, and her decision to leave Jon and seek a life that aligns with her aspirations and values is a testament to her strength and determination. It highlights the significance of self-discovery and the willingness to break free from toxic relationships or environments that hinder personal growth. Donna embraces change and new opportunities in her pursuit of personal growth. From her initial move to Connecticut with her family to attending college in Wisconsin to landing a job as a secretary in the heart...
2023-04-1720 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastCh. 6 - Guarding the ThresholdReflecting on the night-- Before Donna and Justine's tragic demise, we are presented with the notion that every choice we make can have far-reaching consequences. The choices made by the individuals involved in this case potentially set the stage for the following heartbreaking events. It invites us to contemplate whether these choices were coincidental or held more profound significance. As we make our way to “the morning of,” we follow the four men in their moments of normalcy, juxtaposing their unsuspecting routines with the forthcoming devastation that will forever alter their lives. Through these narratives, we a...
2023-04-1720 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastCh. 5 - Pretty White TeethTerry Haynes (no relation to David Haynes)-- A key piece in Donna’s story, upon first speaking with him, Terry appears to distance himself from Donna, claiming he barely knew her and feigning ignorance of her tragic demise. His selective recollection of their interactions, coupled with his ability to identify Donna's rings, positively raises intriguing questions. Could Terry's initial denial be a guise to conceal a deeper involvement or connection to the case? Delving into the enigmatic relationship between Donna and Terry, Terry claims that he and Donna were strictly fr...
2023-04-1713 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastCh. 4 - "God will tell you that you belong to me!"Seek solace-- Delving into the events leading up to Donna's murder, we are offered a glimpse into her life the night before the tragic incident. Amidst a difficult divorce, Donna had recently started bartending at the Elks Club—the job providing her with a sense of community and friendship that she craved and a respite from the inappropriate advances she had faced from some clients at her banking job. Donna's decision to work at the Elks Club becomes a therapeutic escape, giving her hope for the future. Meanwhile, Donna becomes increasingly fearful of Te...
2023-04-1724 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastCh. 3 - "I saw things that morning no one saw!"Blurred lines--An interview with David Haynes provides valuable insights into Donna Tompkins’ life and relationships. David leaves us intrigued by the intricacies of her connection with David. He prompts contemplation on the impact of perception, blurred boundaries, and their potential link to the tragic murder of her and her daughter Justine. The dynamic between Donna and Dave presents a complex interplay of friendship and speculation. While David willingly states the two went on a few dates before realizing they were better off as friends, the rumors surrounding their relationship cast a shadow of doubt. This raises in...
2023-04-1721 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastCh. 2 - Bellow & MoanSmall towns: everyone knows everyone-- An intimacy plagued with gossip and judgment frames Donna's experience as an "outsider,” highlighting the delicate balance between acceptance and exclusion. The episode challenges us to reflect on how small communities can foster both a sense of belonging and feelings of isolation—shedding light on the complexities of rural living and its social dynamics. Such is the case with Donna and her boss, trust officer David Haynes—whispers of intimacy and a possible affair fueling jealousy and gossip among their spouses. The intense emotional bond between Donna and David...
2023-04-1719 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastCh. 1 - That Darkest HourA predictable cadence--Waking up, going to work, and returning home gives us a sense of stability and security.But what happens when that routine is abruptly shattered when the ordinary turns unexpectedly into the realm of uncertainty?In the case of Donna Tompkins and her daughter, Justine, a seemingly ordinary morning transforms into a chilling enigma that leaves Donna’s coworkers on edge.Early on that frigid January morning, several members of the quaint community of Canton, Illinois, go about their usual morning routines – Drake Smith arriving for his shift at t...
2023-04-1717 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastS1. Prologue - A Double HomicideWho is Donna Tompkins?Despite this question, we cannot discuss the case of the Tompkins' without delving into the complex figure of Donald R. Bull, the man convicted of their murders. Tireless efforts are made to speak with key individuals directly associated with Bull—including family members, friends, inmates, and legal authorities—whose accounts might shed new light on the case. Individuals such as the elusive jailhouse informant, Chris Chester, whose testimony implicated Donald in first-degree murder, and those with ties who might offer conflicting viewpoints, asserting his innocence and questioning his guilt.An unwavering obje...
2023-04-1711 min
The Spoon River Gothic PodcastTrailer - Narrative of a Double HomicideCory Zimmerman and Radio Vérité Present the Literary, Long-Form, True Crime Podcast: "SPOON RIVER GOTHIC - NARRATIVE of a DOUBLE HOMICIDE"A True Crime Saga Revealing a Mystery of Romance, Obsession & Terror. The Borders of the Puzzle - Arson & Murder!A HAUNTING TALE - The perplexing double homicide of mother and child unfolding against a vivid backdrop of a quaint, midwestern town—the story kicks off with the chilling discovery of Donna and Justine Tompkins' lifeless bodies in their fire-ravaged home on a frigid morning in January 1993. As investigators feverishly search for clues, the narr...
2023-04-1700 min