Shows
Polity Matters97. Inept to Do This Alone (BCO 40)A Ben and Fred duo episode--all about Review and Control.Send us a text message! (but bear in mind the we can't see who sends it unless you tell us...)Support the showScott's TwitterJared's TwitterBen's Twitter
2025-08-1958 minPolity Matters96. Nothing of Substance (RPR w/Thomas Rickard)Scott and Jared are joined by Thomas Rickard to have (another) discussion about Review of Presbytery Records.Send us a text message! (but bear in mind the we can't see who sends it unless you tell us...)Support the showScott's TwitterJared's TwitterBen's Twitter
2025-08-1257 minPolity Matters95. Put Me Out of My Misery (BCO 39)It's all about the modes! Join Scott, Jared, and Fred as the discuss the BCO chapter with the longest title: Modes in Which the Proceedings of Lower Courts Come Under the Supervision of Higher Courts.Send us a text message! (but bear in mind the we can't see who sends it unless you tell us...)Support the showScott's TwitterJared's TwitterBen's Twitter
2025-08-0550 minPolity Matters94. A Good Church, A Bad Church, and Nowhere (BCO 38)He's never introduced, but you can't deny the dulcet tones of RE Howie Donahoe, who joins Scott and Jared to get into BCO 38.Presbytery Clerks Download PageSend us a text message! (but bear in mind the we can't see who sends it unless you tell us...)Support the showScott's TwitterJared's TwitterBen's Twitter
2025-07-2949 minPolity Matters93. BCO Amendments Are Coming!Scott leads us through the BCO amendments sent down from this years General Assembly. https://pcapolity.com/2025/07/22/thirteen-proposed-amendments-in-2025/Send us a text message! (but bear in mind the we can't see who sends it unless you tell us...)Support the showScott's TwitterJared's TwitterBen's Twitter
2025-07-2252 minPolity Matters90. Revisiting RPROur AI substitute wasn't able to record an episode, so it seem like it generated an introduction with NotebookLM and then aired our RPR Deep Dive from last year. Enjoy.Send us a text message! (but bear in mind the we can't see who sends it unless you tell us...)Support the showScott's TwitterJared's TwitterBen's Twitter
2025-06-231h 08Polity Matters89. Crash Course on the PCA General AssemblyJared, Scott, and Ben spend time with friend of the show Steve Dowling, discussing the week of General Assembly and what we might expect at the 52nd.Fred Greco's Overtures RoundupJacob Gerber's Parliamentary Procedure for Presbytershttps://pcaga.orgSend us a text message! (but bear in mind the we can't see who sends it unless you tell us...)Support the showScott's TwitterJared's TwitterBen's Twitter
2025-06-1639 minPolity Matters88. Some Sense of Order (Overtures 2025 Part Two)Alex Ford is back! We quickly put him to work sifting through Overtures with the guys...http://pcahistory.orgOvertures discussed: 2, 3, 4, 5, 9, 11, 12, 17, 18, 19, 20, 26, 27, 28, 29, 33, 34, 35, 36, 41, 42, 44, 45, 46, 47, 48, 49, 50Send us a text message! (but bear in mind the we can't see who sends it unless you tell us...)Support the showScott's TwitterJared's TwitterBen's Twitter
2025-06-121h 06Polity Matters87. It's Almost GA, Where's Our Controversy? (Overtures 2025 Part One)Alex Ford is back! We quickly put him to work sifting through Overtures with the guys...http://pcahistory.orgOvertures discussed: 1, 6, 7, 8, 10, 13, 14, 15, 16, 22, 23, 24, 25, 30, 31, 32, 37, 40Send us a text message! (but bear in mind the we can't see who sends it unless you tell us...)Support the showScott's TwitterJared's TwitterBen's Twitter
2025-06-101h 01Polity Matters86. Orderly MeetingOrderly Meeting WebsiteOrderly Meetings TwitterClerk Download PageClerk of Session HandbookPresbytery Clerk HandbookSend us a text message! (but bear in mind the we can't see who sends it unless you tell us...)Support the showScott's TwitterJared's TwitterBen's Twitter
2025-06-0355 minPolity Matters81. BCO 37: The Removal of CensureMel Duncan joins the show to help us think through the removal of censures in BCO 27. Send us a text message! (but bear in mind the we can't see who sends it unless you tell us...)Support the showScott's TwitterJared's TwitterBen's Twitter
2025-05-271h 00
presbycastMOAR OVERTURES...PCAGA Preview Show #3 w/Nelson & EdburgPastors Scott Edburg and Jared Nelson of the Polity Matters podcast join us along with Presbygirl Zoe Miller to wade through a flood of overtures for the 2025 PCA General Assembly. See all the overtures here: https://pcaga.org/resources/#overtures Watch: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H3fCIE_0ncA
2025-05-141h 22Polity Matters80. BCO 36 The Infliction of Church CensuresDr. Waters joins the guys to discuss the infliction of censures.Send us a text message! (but bear in mind the we can't see who sends it unless you tell us...)Support the showScott's TwitterJared's TwitterBen's Twitter
2025-05-131h 02Polity Matters79. Bigger Problems Than Testifying in a PCA Court (BCO 35 part two)Ben, Jared, Scott, and Fred finish out BCO 35.Send us a text message! (but bear in mind the we can't see who sends it unless you tell us...)Support the showScott's TwitterJared's TwitterBen's Twitter
2025-05-0638 minPolity Matters78. An Out of Date Bunch of Malarkey (BCO 35 part one)Ben, Jared, Scott, and Fred begin PCA BCO Chapter 35 on Evidence. They discuss the competency of witnesses, the rights of the accused and accuser, procedures for handling testimony, and the judgment of evidence in church courts. Send us a text message! (but bear in mind the we can't see who sends it unless you tell us...)Support the showScott's TwitterJared's TwitterBen's Twitter
2025-04-2935 minPolity Matters77. All of My Secrets Have Been Exposed (BCO 34)Jared and Scott are joined by RE John Bise to work through matters pertaining to process against TEs.Send us a text message! (but bear in mind the we can't see who sends it unless you tell us...)Support the showScott's TwitterJared's TwitterBen's Twitter
2025-04-2249 minPolity Matters76. Until I Read Them Out Loud (BCO 33)Steve Dowling joins the polity bros to work through BCO 33: Special Rules Pertaining to Process Before Sessions.Send us a text message! (but bear in mind the we can't see who sends it unless you tell us...)Support the showScott's TwitterJared's TwitterBen's Twitter
2025-04-1541 minPolity Matters75. The People I Lied to Are Dead: Part Three (BCO 32 part two)Ben, Jared, Scott, and Fred continue their discussion and explanation of BCO 32.Send us a text message! (but bear in mind the we can't see who sends it unless you tell us...)Support the showScott's TwitterJared's TwitterBen's Twitter
2025-04-0841 minPolity Matters74. The People I Lied to Are Dead (BCO 32 Part One)Ben, Jared, Scott, and Fred deal with the first six sections of BCO 32.Send us a text message! (but bear in mind the we can't see who sends it unless you tell us...)Support the showScott's TwitterJared's TwitterBen's Twitter
2025-04-0149 minPolity Matters73. Best Host Ever (BCO 31 part two)Ben, Jared, Half-Scott, and Steve are back to finish BCO 31. Send us a text message! (but bear in mind the we can't see who sends it unless you tell us...)Support the showScott's TwitterJared's TwitterBen's Twitter
2025-03-2551 minPolity Matters72. Story Time with Steve (BCO 31 part one)Ben, Jared, and Scott are joined by Steve Tipton to dive into BCO 31, which outlines the key players and procedures involved in formal judicial processes within the Presbyterian Church in America (PCA). They start off with a bit of fun—Jared presents a quiz on judicial cases that have shaped the PCA. Then, the discussion turns serious as they unpack the nuances of BCO 31, addressing questions of jurisdiction, the role of the courts, and the necessity of due process in church discipline.Send us a text message! (but bear in mind the we can't see who sends it...
2025-03-181h 04Polity Matters71. Pure Hypothetical (BCO 30)In this episode of Polity Matters, hosts Ben Ratliff, Jared Nelson, and Scott Edberg welcome Dr. Guy Waters of Reformed Theological Seminary to discuss Chapter 30 of the PCA Book of Church Order (BCO), which deals with church censures. They explore the biblical, theological, and practical aspects of church discipline, the different types of censures available to church courts, and how they should be wisely applied in the life of the church.Books by Dr. Waters:How Jesus Runs the ChurchFacing the Last Enemy: Death and the Christian The Sabbath as R...
2025-03-1155 minPolity Matters70. Just Give Me Another Hour (BCO 29)In this episode of Polity Matters, hosts Ben Ratliff, Jared Nelson, and Scott Edberg welcome Ruling Elder John Bise to discuss Chapter 29 of the PCA Book of Church Order: Offenses. The conversation tackles the distinctions between personal and general offenses, as well as private and public offenses, and how church courts should approach discipline in a biblical and pastoral manner. Send us a text message! (but bear in mind the we can't see who sends it unless you tell us...)Support the showScott's TwitterJared's TwitterBen's Twitter
2025-03-0435 minPolity Matters69. The Jared Nelson Memorial Episode (BCO 28)Ben, Jared, and Scott are joined by Steve Tipton --the fourth polity bro-- to discuss BCO 28: Disciplining of Non-communing Members.Send us a text message! (but bear in mind the we can't see who sends it unless you tell us...)Support the showScott's TwitterJared's TwitterBen's Twitter
2025-02-2552 minPolity Matters68. Chapter 27 is Chiastic (BCO 27)Steve Dowling joins Ben, Jared, and Scott to discuss BCO 27 on the nature, subjects, and ends of church discipline.Send us a text message! (but bear in mind the we can't see who sends it unless you tell us...)Support the showScott's TwitterJared's TwitterBen's Twitter
2025-02-181h 06Polity Matters67. Procedural Checklist (w/T. David Gordon)Procedural Checklist for PCA BCO Rules of DisciplineSend us a text message! (but bear in mind the we can't see who sends it unless you tell us...)Support the showScott's TwitterJared's TwitterBen's Twitter
2025-02-1157 minPolity Matters66. Motion to Reconsider: Assistant PastorsIn this special installment of Motion to Reconsider, we return to our interview with TE Adam Parker regarding his article on Assistant Pastors.Send us a text message! (but bear in mind the we can't see who sends it unless you tell us...)Support the showScott's TwitterJared's TwitterBen's Twitter
2025-02-0443 minPolity Matters65. The Sherlocking of Scott EdburgIn this special episode, Ben sits down with co-host Scott Edberg for an inside look at the history and future of the BCO Amendment Tracker—a project that started as a grassroots effort to bring transparency and accountability to the amendment process and has become a vital tool for the denomination.Send us a text message! (but bear in mind the we can't see who sends it unless you tell us...)Support the showScott's TwitterJared's TwitterBen's Twitter
2025-01-2833 minPolity Matters64. Potentially Edifying (Ordination Questions with Groff)In this episode of Polity Matters, Ben Ratliff, Jared Nelson, Scott Edburg, and special guest Zachary Groff take a deep dive into the ordination vows for teaching elders in the Presbyterian Church in America (PCA). The conversation explores the significance of each vow, offering practical insights and theological reflections for ministers and members alike.Presbyterian PolityGreenville Presbyterian Theological SeminaryThe Christian Ministry12 Ways Your Phone Is Changing YouSend us a text message! (but bear in mind the we can't see who...
2025-01-141h 29Polity Matters63. A Heightened Sense of Americana (BCO 26)In this milestone episode, Ben, Jared, and Scott conclude their journey through the Form of Government section of the PCA Book of Church Order. The discussion centers on BCO Chapter 26, which outlines the process for amending the PCA Constitution. The hosts explore the complexities of modifying both the BCO and the Westminster Standards, unpacking the historical, procedural, and theological implications of these changes.Send us a text message! (but bear in mind the we can't see who sends it unless you tell us...)Support the showScott's TwitterJared's Twitter
2024-12-3134 minPolity Matters62. No Authority Over Your Assets (BCO 25)In this episode of Polity Matters, we delve into Chapter 25 of the PCA Book of Church Order, focusing on congregational meetings. We discuss the structure, rights, and responsibilities of the congregation, including voting rights, quorum requirements, the role of trustees, and property ownership. Join us as we explore the practical and theological implications of how congregations govern themselves within the PCA framework.Glorifying and Enjoying God WSC devotional Van Dixhoorn on WCFMatthew Everhard’s Hold Fast the Faith Watson’s Body of Divinity Polity Matters Merch Store Send us a text...
2024-12-2445 minPolity Matters61. Ten Pages of Minor Scruples (BCO 24)BCO 24 Election, Ordination, and Installation of Ruling Elders and DeaconsScott's Superior Navigator's Reading PlanDaily Readings by JC RyleDaily Doctrine by Kevin DeYoungSend us a text message! (but bear in mind the we can't see who sends it unless you tell us...)Support the showScott's TwitterJared's TwitterBen's Twitter
2024-12-1750 minPolity Matters60. Edburgs Don't Live A Long Time (BCO 23)BCO 23 The Dissolution of the Pastoral Relation and the Procedure for Honorable RetirementSend us a text message! (but bear in mind the we can't see who sends it unless you tell us...)Support the showScott's TwitterJared's TwitterBen's Twitter
2024-12-1023 minPolity Matters59. Mercenary of the Session (BCO 22)Polity Matters with Adam ParkerAdam Parker on Assistant Pastors @ Presbyterian PolitySend us a text message! (but bear in mind the we can't see who sends it unless you tell us...)Support the showScott's TwitterJared's TwitterBen's Twitter
2024-12-0326 minPolity Matters58. Good Faith Subscription with David StrainJared, Scott, and Ben are joined by David Strain to discuss good faith subscription in the PCA.David StrainGood Faith Subscription? (Part 1) Confessional Integrity in the PCAGood Faith Subscription? (Part 2) Confessional Integrity in the PCASend us a text message! (but bear in mind the we can't see who sends it unless you tell us...)Support the showScott's TwitterJared's TwitterBen's Twitter
2024-11-261h 04Polity Matters57. Listener Comment on BCO 21Jeff Smith wrote in concerning BCO 21.Send us a text message! (but bear in mind the we can't see who sends it unless you tell us...)Support the showScott's TwitterJared's TwitterBen's Twitter
2024-11-2302 minPolity Matters56. As the Prayer Goes Longer and Longer (BCO 21 Part 2)Ordination services! Ben, Jared, and Steve finish up BCO 21.Send us a text message! (but bear in mind the we can't see who sends it unless you tell us...)Support the showScott's TwitterJared's TwitterBen's Twitter
2024-11-1930 minPolity Matters55. [Insert Title Here] (BCO 21 Part 1)Steve joins Ben and Jared to discuss BCO 21 on the Ordination and Installation of minister. Send us a text message! (but bear in mind the we can't see who sends it unless you tell us...)Support the showScott's TwitterJared's TwitterBen's Twitter
2024-11-1245 minPolity Matters54. Your Ruling Elders Will Be Taxed Further (BCO 20 Part Two)We jump right in to finish up BCO 20 on the election of pastors. Send us a text message! (but bear in mind the we can't see who sends it unless you tell us...)Support the showScott's TwitterJared's TwitterBen's Twitter
2024-11-0544 minPolity Matters53. 🇺🇸 (BCO 20 Part 1)Listen in as the guys begin their discussion of BCO 20 on the Election of Pastors.Send us a text message! (but bear in mind the we can't see who sends it unless you tell us...)Support the showScott's TwitterJared's TwitterBen's Twitter
2024-10-2922 minPolity Matters52. Jared's Mythical Intern Checklist (BCO 19 Part 2)Buy Me A Coffee BCO onlineOvercast podcast appPresbytery of Mississippi ValleySend us a text message! (but bear in mind the we can't see who sends it unless you tell us...)Support the showScott's TwitterJared's TwitterBen's Twitter
2024-10-2239 minPolity Matters52. The Whole Thing Is A Chonk (BCO 19 Part 1)It's time to talk about licensure!PREPARING FOR LICENSURE & ORDINATION EXAMS by Chapell & MeekSend us a text message! (but bear in mind the we can't see who sends it unless you tell us...)Support the showScott's TwitterJared's TwitterBen's Twitter
2024-10-1544 minPolity Matters51. Fantasy Presbytery (BCO 18)The one where Ben comes out against youth ministers. And we talk about BCO 18.Send us a text message! (but bear in mind the we can't see who sends it unless you tell us...)Support the showScott's TwitterJared's TwitterBen's Twitter
2024-10-0844 minPolity Matters50. The Backslap of Fellowship (BCO 17)It's a short chapter today as the boys jump into BCO 17: the Doctrine of Ordination.Send us a text message! (but bear in mind the we can't see who sends it unless you tell us...)Support the showScott's TwitterJared's TwitterBen's Twitter
2024-10-0125 minPolity Matters49. Just Meant to Shovel Manure (BCO 16)It's all about being called to ministry! BCO 16 is here.Called to the Ministry by Ed ClowneyThe Reformed Pastor by Richard BaxterThe Call by Os GuinnessThe Christian Ministry by Charles BridgesSend us a text message! (but bear in mind the we can't see who sends it unless you tell us...)Support the showScott's TwitterJared's TwitterBen's Twitter
2024-09-2441 minPolity Matters48. I Feel Lost and Alone (BCO 15)We're back! Onto BCO 15! Support Polity Matters: buymeacoffee.com/politymattersRead along in the BCOSend us a text message! (but bear in mind the we can't see who sends it unless you tell us...)Support the showScott's TwitterJared's TwitterBen's Twitter
2024-09-1753 minPolity Matters47. Happy Birthday!It's our first birthday and we threw a party with some friends! Ryan Biese, Steve Tipton, and Fred Greco joined us for some fun and festivities as we celebrated this milestone. Enjoy!Send us a text message! (but bear in mind the we can't see who sends it unless you tell us...)Support the showScott's TwitterJared's TwitterBen's Twitter
2024-09-101h 04Polity Matters46. RPCNA RoundupWe are glad to welcome Nathan Eshelman to the show! He brings greetings and updates from the RPCNA.Nathan is pastor of the Reformed Presbyterian Church of Orlando.Jerusalem Chamber PodcastNathan writes for Gentle Reformation and Meet the Puritans and is the author of I Have a Confession published by Crown & Covenant.Send us a text message! (but bear in mind the we can't see who sends it unless you tell us...)Support the showScott's TwitterJared's TwitterBen's Twitter
2024-08-2744 minPolity Matters45. CRC RoundupScott and Ben catch up with Tyler Wagenmaker of the Christian Reformed Church, following their Synod meeting earlier this summer.Send us a text message! (but bear in mind the we can't see who sends it unless you tell us...)Support the showScott's TwitterJared's TwitterBen's Twitter
2024-08-1355 minPolity Matters44. OPC RoundupThe guys spend time hearing about the PCA's long lost sister, the OPC. With guest Andrew Miller.Glorifying and Enjoying God: 52 Devotions through the Westminster Shorter Catechism (Boekestein, Cruse, Miller)Send us a text message! (but bear in mind the we can't see who sends it unless you tell us...)Support the showScott's TwitterJared's TwitterBen's Twitter
2024-07-3054 minPolity Matters43. EPC RoundupBen and Jared are joined by Dustin Jernigan from the EPC to get the deets on their 2024 General Assembly.Send us a text message! (but bear in mind the we can't see who sends it unless you tell us...)Support the showScott's TwitterJared's TwitterBen's Twitter
2024-07-1651 minPolity Matters42. Bill Clerk for Another Year (ARP Roundup)Ben and Jared are joined by ARP minister Benjamin Glaser for a roundup of everything from the 2024 General Synod of the Associate Reformed Presbyterians.Benjamin Glaser’s Hard Goodbyes and New Beginnings: A Report On the 220th General Synod of the ARP Church” Send us a text message! (but bear in mind the we can't see who sends it unless you tell us...)Support the showScott's TwitterJared's TwitterBen's Twitter
2024-07-0252 minPolity Matters41. GA Debrief 2024PCA GA 51: Summary & 10 Key Decisions (George Sayour)PCA 2024 General Assembly Report (Ryan Biese) Presbycast: PCA General Assembly 2024 Wrap-Up ShowZach Byrd's PCA Floor Speech (corn starch and graveyard)PCA GA on YouTubeSend us a text message! (but bear in mind the we can't see who sends it unless you tell us...)Support the showScott's TwitterJared's TwitterBen's Twitter
2024-06-1844 minPolity Matters40. Beside the GA BusinessWelcome Sarah and Zoe to the show as they explain to Ben everything else about GA. Presbygirls on the Presbycast FeedGA Informational BookletGA Families InformationSend us a text message! (but bear in mind the we can't see who sends it unless you tell us...)Support the showScott's TwitterJared's TwitterBen's Twitter
2024-06-1057 minPolity Matters39. Just Up Your Nerd Alley (NomCom Deep Dive)It's Jared's turn to take over--this episode is all about the GA Nominating Committee!(Be sure to check out BCO 14 and RAO 8 for more details on the work of the NomCOmo)Send us a text message! (but bear in mind the we can't see who sends it unless you tell us...)Support the showScott's TwitterJared's TwitterBen's Twitter
2024-06-0428 minPolity Matters38. Sausage & a Bible & Probably a Cask of Wine (RPR Deep Dive)Steve Tipton steals the show with a thorough explanation of the General Assembly's Review of Presbytery Records Committee.Send us a text message! (but bear in mind the we can't see who sends it unless you tell us...)Support the showScott's TwitterJared's TwitterBen's Twitter
2024-05-311h 07Polity Matters37. GA Overtures CommitteeThe men are joined by RE Steve Dowling to discuss the work of the Overtures Committee at the General Assembly.Send us a text message! (but bear in mind the we can't see who sends it unless you tell us...)Support the showScott's TwitterJared's TwitterBen's Twitter
2024-05-2843 minPolity Matters36. 2024 GA Overtures Overview*DISCLAIMER: Only one person on this episode actually wrote an Overture that we discuss.*It’s Overtures time! The guys assume the roles of the overtures author as Alex Ford joins to talk through alllllll the 2024 Overtures.(With such a long episode, we didn’t have as much fine-tune editing. Apologies for the few times we talk over each other—recording over the internet isn’t always flawless, and Ben’s connection was a little laggy.)Click here to see GA OverturesSend us a text message! (but bear in mind the w...
2024-05-212h 01Polity Matters35. GA Committee ReportsA warm welcome to Mel Duncan as he discusses the work of the General Assembly with us. Oh, and we prove that Scott is not a robot.Mel serves as a Ruling Elder at Second Presbyterian Church in Greenville, SC.Send us a text message! (but bear in mind the we can't see who sends it unless you tell us...)Support the showScott's TwitterJared's TwitterBen's Twitter
2024-05-1452 minPolity Matters34. Opening of AssemblyOur current PCA GA Moderator joins us to discuss what happens at the first meeting of the Assembly.Fred GrecoGA Schedule At the time of publication the PCA AC website was undergoing maintenance. See www.pcaac.org at a later date to see the statistics information.Send us a text message! (but bear in mind the we can't see who sends it unless you tell us...)Support the showScott's TwitterJared's TwitterBen's Twitter
2024-05-071h 00Polity Matters33. Before the GavelPer is the pastor of Free Grace Presbyterian Church in Lewiston, Maine. General Assembly ScheduleSend us a text message! (but bear in mind the we can't see who sends it unless you tell us...)Support the showScott's TwitterJared's TwitterBen's Twitter
2024-04-3041 minPolity MattersCalled Meeting: Everybody Has a VoiceScott, Jared, and Ben are joined by Matthew Bradley and Nathan McCall of the Y’all Saints Podcast, and Adam Parker and Matthew Poole of The Evergreen Beaverton Podcast to discuss church polity for the church member.Book recommendations:The Church of Christ by James BannermanHow Jesus Runs the Church by Guy WatersWell Ordered, Living Well by Guy WatersWelcome to a Reformed Church by Daniel HydeWhat is Church Government? By Sean Michael LucasThe Christian in Complete Armor Daily Devotional by William GurnallSend us a...
2024-04-2340 minPolity Matters32. Live-Action BCO Interpretation (BCO 14)We should have done our homework! Listen in as the guys work through BCO 14 on the General Assembly. Not everything is immediately clear, but we will rectify that in the years to come. Enjoy!Greensboro GA debate about imagesPCA on WikipediaSend us a text message! (but bear in mind the we can't see who sends it unless you tell us...)Support the showScott's TwitterJared's TwitterBen's Twitter
2024-04-1657 minPolity Matters31. A Single Semicolon (BCO 13 Part 2)Will Scott advocate fro the PCA owning church properties? Listen in to find out.Presbyteries Part OneSend us a text message! (but bear in mind the we can't see who sends it unless you tell us...)Support the showScott's TwitterJared's TwitterBen's Twitter
2024-04-0939 minPolity Matters30. Presbytery Altar Call (BCO 13 pt 1)Presbyteries matter! The guys begin their discussion of BCO 13.BCO OnlinePresbytery MapOverture 2PCA HistorySend us a text message! (but bear in mind the we can't see who sends it unless you tell us...)Support the showScott's TwitterJared's TwitterBen's Twitter
2024-04-0242 minPolity Matters29. Another Roll Floating Around (BCO 12 Part 2)The guys finish their discussion about Church Sessions, with more talk about rolls than you'd get at Lambert's.Send us a text message! (but bear in mind the we can't see who sends it unless you tell us...)Support the showScott's TwitterJared's TwitterBen's Twitter
2024-03-2647 minPolity Matters28. Legs Plural? (BCO 12)BCO online Send us a text message! (but bear in mind the we can't see who sends it unless you tell us...)Support the showScott's TwitterJared's TwitterBen's Twitter
2024-03-1930 minPolity Matters27. It's Not Allowed in the Church Courts (BCO 11)Let's discuss jurisdiction from BCO 11. Send us a text message! (but bear in mind the we can't see who sends it unless you tell us...)Support the showScott's TwitterJared's TwitterBen's Twitter
2024-03-1237 minPolity Matters26. Presbytery of Moderator (BCO 10)We’re back, baby! It’s BCO season again and we’re kicking it off in chapter 10: Church Courts!Send us a text message! (but bear in mind the we can't see who sends it unless you tell us...)Support the showScott's TwitterJared's TwitterBen's Twitter
2024-03-0552 minPolity Matters25. Animated By Our Apathy (Witherow's Practical Lessons)The one in which we conclude our time with Thomas Witherow's The Apostolic Church.Send us a text message! (but bear in mind the we can't see who sends it unless you tell us...)Support the showScott's TwitterJared's TwitterBen's Twitter
2024-02-2733 minPolity Matters24. I'm a Generous Grader (Application of the Test)The one where we evaluate Witherow's evaluation of the three forms of church government. Who knew we'd be more generous than him? Send us a text message! (but bear in mind the we can't see who sends it unless you tell us...)Support the showScott's TwitterJared's TwitterBen's Twitter
2024-02-2038 minPolity Matters23. Christian Nationalism (Witherow's 6th Principle)Not as much Christian Nationalism in this episode as you’d expect. Joshua Walker joins us to discuss Witherow’s final principle of the Apostolic church.Joshua is the pastor of Church of the Resurrection PCA in Flagstaff, AZ.Send us a text message! (but bear in mind the we can't see who sends it unless you tell us...)Support the showScott's TwitterJared's TwitterBen's Twitter
2024-02-1335 minPolity Matters22. Sloth Pelican (Witherow's 5th Principle)With no intention of fulfilling any of their new years resolutions, our three hosts work through Witherow’s fourth principle with the help of Rev. Jason Piland.Jason is the Associate Pastor at Redeemer Church in Hudson, OH.Send us a text message! (but bear in mind the we can't see who sends it unless you tell us...)Support the showScott's TwitterJared's TwitterBen's Twitter
2024-02-0641 minPolity Matters21. You’re Not Smart Enough, Ben (Witherow’s 4th Principle)We are pleased to be joined by Job Dalmoba today as we discuss the fourth principle of the apostolic church: ordination is the act of the presbytery–a plurality of elders.Job is the Pastor at Christ Covenant PCA in Woodstock, Georgia. Send us a text message! (but bear in mind the we can't see who sends it unless you tell us...)Support the showScott's TwitterJared's TwitterBen's Twitter
2024-01-3033 minPolity Matters20. You're Not Alone (Witherow's 3rd Principle)Welcome to RE Joshua Torrey and apologies that we subjected him to a new game before discussing the third principle of the apostolic church: in each church there ought to be a plurality of elders.Josh is a ruling elder at Redeemer Pres in Austin, TX. You can find him on Twitter @JoshuaTorrey.Send us a text message! (but bear in mind the we can't see who sends it unless you tell us...)Support the showScott's TwitterJared's TwitterBen's Twitter
2024-01-2335 minPolity Matters19. A Dungeon No One Would Ever Want to Be In (Witherow's 2nd Principle)The Polity Triumvirate is joined by Rev. Jim McCarthy to discuss Witherow's second principle of the apostolic church: the terms elder and bishop are identical.Jim is the Senior Pastor of Trinity PCA in Statesboro, GA. Send us a text message! (but bear in mind the we can't see who sends it unless you tell us...)Support the showScott's TwitterJared's TwitterBen's Twitter
2024-01-1643 minPolity Matters18. Trying to Claim Apostolic Authority (Witherow's 1st Principle)The polity bros are joined by kindred spirit Jacob Gerber to discuss Witherow’s first principle of the apostolic church: the Office-Bearers are Chosen by the People.Jacob Gerber, pastor of Harvest PCA@jacobgerberJacob's book! (get a copy)Polity Matters 13: BCO 8.1-8.4 (The Elder)Polity Matters 14: BCO 8.5-8.10 (The Elder)Polity Matters 15: BCO 9 (The Deacon)Called to the Ministry by Ed ClowneySend us a text message! (but bear in mind the we can't see who sends it unless you tell us...)Support the show...
2024-01-0950 minPolity Matters17. Before the Book (Witherow's Statement of the Question)Welcome to Polity Matters: Before the Book. In this new series we will be reading and discussing The Apostolic Church by Thomas Witherow. Today we delve into chapter 1: The Statement of the Question.I Will Build My Church by Thomas WitherowThe Apostolic Church, Which Is It by Thomas WitherowSend us a text message! (but bear in mind the we can't see who sends it unless you tell us...)Support the showScott's TwitterJared's TwitterBen's Twitter
2024-01-0232 minPolity Matters16. Interview with Jonny GibsonBefore we dive into Witherow's The Apostolic Church next week, the bros sit down with Dr. Jonathan Gibson and discuss his study and work on Thomas Witherow.Dr. Jonathan GibsonThe Moon is Always RoundI Will Build My ChurchReformation WorshipFrom Heaven He Came and Sought UsSend us a text message! (but bear in mind the we can't see who sends it unless you tell us...)Support the showScott's TwitterJared's TwitterBen's Twitter
2023-12-2252 minPolity MattersCalled Meeting: TE Adam ParkerTE Adam Parker joined Jared and Ben to discuss his recent article dealing with one of our apparent favorite topics: assistant pastors.Adam's articleAdam's podcastSend us a text message! (but bear in mind the we can't see who sends it unless you tell us...)Support the showScott's TwitterJared's TwitterBen's Twitter
2023-12-1944 minPolity Matters15. Some Godly Dudes (BCO 9)The guys finish up their first season in the BCO, with BCO 9 on Deacons.BCO onlinePolity Matters 12: BCO 7BCO Amendment TrackerThe Reformed Deacon (a Podcast from the OPC Committee on Diaconal Ministries)The Deacon by Cornelis Van DamI Will Build My Church by Thomas WitherowSend us a text message! (but bear in mind the we can't see who sends it unless you tell us...)Support the showScott's TwitterJared's TwitterBen's Twitter
2023-12-1254 minPolity Matters14. Interlopers or Conflicts, Etc. (BCO 8.5-8.10)The polity bros resume their discussion with PCA Grand Poobah Fred Greco on BCO 8: The Elder.Listen to Part 1 hereBCO onlineFred is the pastor of Christ Church Katy, TX.The Shepherd Leader by Timothy WitmerSend us a text message! (but bear in mind the we can't see who sends it unless you tell us...)Support the showScott's TwitterJared's TwitterBen's Twitter
2023-12-0543 minPolity Matters13. I'm Very Interested In Plumbing (BCO 8.1-8.4)The first annual Polity Matters Holiday Gift Guide is here! And also the guys are joined by TE Fred Greco to discuss BCO 8 on The Elder.BCO onlineFred is the pastor of Christ Church Katy, TX. Witherow’s Apostolic Church (series in January) Presbyterianism by Samuel MillerZebra double-ended highlightersJacob Gerber’s Parliamentary Procedure for PresbytersJames Bannerman's The Church of ChristWitherow's I Will Build My ChurchESV Creeds and Confessions BibleCoffee subscriptionRobe...
2023-11-2851 minPolity MattersCalled Meeting: RE Howie DonahoeJared sits down with RE Howie Donahoe to discuss churchmanship, including GA moderating all the way to how to write an overture.Send us a text message! (but bear in mind the we can't see who sends it unless you tell us...)Support the showScott's TwitterJared's TwitterBen's Twitter
2023-11-2343 minPolity Matters12. Who's the Half? (BCO 7)Officers everywhere in BCO 7! A Scottless, Jaredless episode... but Steve Tipton jumps in to cover for them. BCO onlineSteve Tipton is the pastor of Covenant PCA in Panama City, FL, and an editor at Presbyterian Polity.PCA Studies & Reports, 1973 - 2021Report of the Ad-Interim Committee on Number of OfficesAppendix A: Two Offices and Two Orders of Elders Appendix B: Ministers of the WordAppendix C: Empowered to ServeAppendix D: Biblical Study on "Ordination"Polity Matters #7: BCO 3How Jesus Runs the...
2023-11-2152 minPolity Matters11. Not This Timeline (BCO 6)The guys are back together this week to discuss BCO 6, but only after reminiscing about wedding officiating and trying to decide if Jared actually has a dog.BCO onlinePolity Matters 5. BCO 1Report of the Ad-Interim Committee to Study the Question of PaedocommunionSend us a text message! (but bear in mind the we can't see who sends it unless you tell us...)Support the showScott's TwitterJared's TwitterBen's Twitter
2023-11-1432 minPolity Matters10. You're a Church (BCO 5.9-5.10)Ben is joined by Matt and another Ben to discuss Mission Churches in real life.BCO onlineBen Kappers is the pastor of All Saints Reformed Church in St. George, UTMatt Bradley is the pastor of All Saints Presbyterian Church in Brentwood, TNSupport the work of All Saints in St George!Send us a text message! (but bear in mind the we can't see who sends it unless you tell us...)Support the showScott's TwitterJared's TwitterBen's Twitter
2023-11-0754 minPolity Matters9. Big Ole Spreadsheet (BCO 5.1-5.8)Ben and Jared are joined by Stephen and Jeremy to discuss the many details of Mission Churches from BCO 5.BCO OnlineBe sure to tweet a presbytery emoji or tumbleweeds at @SEdburgStephen SpinnenweberJeremy ByrdBirmingham Theological Seminary (BTS)Studying the Book of Church Order: Some Resources by Jared NelsonScott’s screamo bandScott’s favorite excel function: =IF(MAX(XLOOKUP($A24, 'Current Worship'!$F$3:$F$105, 'Current Worship'!$A$3:$A$105, FALSE, 0,-1), XLOOKUP($ A24, 'Current Worship'!$0$3:$0$105, 'Current Worship'!$A$3:$A$105, FALSE, 0,-1...
2023-10-311h 06Polity Matters8. So We're Taking A Stance On That (BCO 4)The guys discuss what they’re preaching, Scott takes a wild stance on Hebrews authorship, and then they get into BCO 4.BCO onlineClearly Reformed on YouTubePolity Matters 7: BCO 3Polity Matters 3: BCO Preface Pt2Send us a text message! (but bear in mind the we can't see who sends it unless you tell us...)Support the showScott's TwitterJared's TwitterBen's Twitter
2023-10-2451 minPolity Matters7. The Church is the Arena (BCO 3)BCO onlineBe sure to tweet murder mystery recommendations to Scott: @SEdburgHow Jesus Runs the Church by Guy Prentiss WatersPolity Matters 1.1.1WTJ Vol 85 (which contains Sean Michael Lucas's article on Francis Grimke)Send us a text message! (but bear in mind the we can't see who sends it unless you tell us...)Support the showScott's TwitterJared's TwitterBen's Twitter
2023-10-1749 minPolity Matters6. No One Wanted To Be On My Team (BCO 2)Jared forces Ben and Scott to play a guessing game about theology quotes, and then the three discuss the visible church from BCO chapter two.Scott Swain on TwitterTim Keller on TwitterBurk Parsons on Twitter Polity Matters episode #5Covenant Theology resources:RTS App on Apple App StoreRTS App on Google PlayLigon Duncan Covenant Theology courseJonty Rhodes' Covenants Made SimpleO. Palmer Robertson's Christ of the CovenantsDr. Randy Thompson’s sermon at 50th PCA GASe...
2023-10-1038 minPolity Matters5. I Am the Question Asker (BCO 1)Scott, Jared, and Ben, after much anticipation, delve into chapter one of the PCA BCO!BCO onlineThe Bruised Reed by Richard Sibbes- purchase on Banner of Truth- free ebook on MonergismRobert's Rules of OrderLord of the Rings1 Tim. 4:14 Do not neglect the gift you have, which was given you by prophecy when the council of elders laid their hands on you. (ESV)The Art of Prophesying by William Perkins- purchase on Banner of Truth- free ebook...
2023-10-0339 minPolity Matters4. Intentionally Cumbersome (BCO Preface III)Jared is turning 200 and Scott's having a baby! And then the guys discuss the final portion of the BCO Preface: the Constitution of the PCA.BCO onlineMichael Kruger's Canon Revisited"The Confession and Catechisms must be restored to their position as much more than theological shibboleths whose only function in our congregations and our sessions and presbyteries is to screen out doctrinal error."-- David Strain in "Good Faith Subscription?" on The Gospel Reformation NetworkWestminster Standards onlineThe Didache is commonly found in publications of The...
2023-09-2639 minPolity Matters3. I Thought This Would Be About Polity (BCO Preface II.4-8)Scott, Jared, and Ben are joined by Steve Tipton as they conclude their discussions about the PCA BCO Preliminary Principles. PCA BCO onlineEpisode 2: Preface II.1-3Steve Tipton is the pastor of Covenant PCA in Panama City, FL, and an editor at Presbyterian Polity.Send us a text message! (but bear in mind the we can't see who sends it unless you tell us...)Support the showScott's TwitterJared's TwitterBen's Twitter
2023-09-1940 minPolity Matters2. You're Going to Hate Sausage Forever (BCO Preface II.1-3)Scott, Jared, and Ben are joined by Steve Tipton in the first of two conversations about the PCA BCO Preliminary Principles. PCA BCO onlineEpisode 1: Preface ISteve Tipton is the pastor of Covenant PCA in Panama City, FL, and an editor at Presbyterian Polity.RTS JacksonBuy the RPCNA Constitution for FREE! prolegomena: a formal essay or critical discussion serving to introduce and interpret an extended workWestminster Confession 21James Bannerman's The Church of ChristGuy Waters' How Jesus Runs t...
2023-09-1250 minPolity Matters1. I Tend to Skip the Preface (BCO Preface I)Scott, Jared, and Ben discuss the first part of the BCO Preface. Dear Listener, I apologize for speaking ignorantly--our show notes cannot accomodate the entire first section of the Preface. Please visit this link to access the BCO online: PCA BCO onlineBCO CommentariesModern: Morton Smith, Per Almquist forthcomingHistorical: F.P. Ramsay, J.A. HodgeHistorical polity resourcesChanges over the years to BCO: pcahistory.orgFree Church of Scotland - James Bannerman - Church of Christ PCUSA - Alexander McGill...
2023-09-0540 minPolity Matters0. How to Ruin This Meeting Decently & In Order (Podcast Introduction)Scott, Jared, and Ben introduce themselves and discuss the plans for Polity Matters. Where we’re headed (beginning September 5!):Bring Your Own BCO (Fall): PCA BCO chapter by chapter.Before the Book (Winter): History, theology, philosophy of politySome Assembly Required (Spring): In anticipation of PCA GA, assembly operations, overtures, amendmentsParliamentary Inquiry (Summer): Robert’s Rules, parliamentary procedureResourcesMorton Smith's Commentary on the BCO (2007)F.P. Ramsay's Exposition of the Form of Government and the Rules of Discipline of the PCUS (1898)pcahistory.orgJ. Aspinwall Hodge's What is P...
2023-08-1538 minPolity MattersTeaserListen in to our final planning session for the upcoming Polity Matters podcast. We discuss polity resources and how we're going to handle guests and initial topics. There's even some good spreadsheet talk toward the end for all you nerds.Oh, and in the middle is the first round of a trivia game we'll play once in a while...Episode 1.0.0RSS feed: https://feeds.buzzsprout.com/2215222.rssSend us a text message! (but bear in mind the we can't see who sends it unless...
2023-07-3111 min
Bible Theory PodcastThe Church Series Season 2: Part 12 Interview with Pastor Scott EdburgToday we review the PCA!!! What in the world is going on in the PCA today? What is the position of Sanctification in the PCA? What is their view on sexuality? Does Christ really have the power to help us overcome sexual desires? What are Side B, Side A, and Side X? These are some of the terms you will be introduced to in this episode. Pastor Scott Edburg, a PCA Minister from down south at FPC-Tuscumbia, joins me today to review and provide a short update on this issue from the inside. This is only a birds-eye view on...
2022-03-141h 02