alexanswerbahamasbelievescasecelestecoldconvictiond4vddarkdaughterdeathdebradetailsdetectivedisappearancednaexpertfamilyforensicguthriehappenedhelpheuermannhookerhousekeeperhusbandinsideinvestigatorislandkilledkillerkillerslynettemissingmommurdaughmurdermysterynancyneesenewtonnowoverturnedparentspleaprosecutorsquestionsreallyrevealsrexscaredsceneserialskylarsmithspeakspokestephentellstruthuswillyears