Pete interviews Ben McCauley, a 25-year veteran of Castle Rental & Pawn in Northwest Arkansas — one of only two companies in the country operating pawn and rent-to-own under the same roof. Ben started as an account manager with no experience, winging it for the first couple weeks after his predecessor left with one day's notice, and eventually worked his way up to running the Centerton location while also serving as marketing director across all six stores.
Castle's origin is unusual. Founder Ron Connolly started as a TV repairman, moved into a Curtis Mathis franchise, rode the VHS rental wave, then pivoted to rent-to-own when Curtis Mathis went bankrupt. He also opened pawn shops separately under the name 71 Pawn Center. About 15 years ago, the team realized both businesses were serving the same demographic and decided to combine them. Castle Rental & Pawn was born, with some locations exceeding 20,000 square feet — all company-owned, all debt-free for 43 years.
The combination pays off in tangible ways. When rent-to-own slows in January, pawn volume spikes. When tax season drives RTO payoffs in March, retail sales on the pawn side surge with the same money. During COVID, Arkansas classified pawnbrokers as an essential service, so Castle never shut down while traditional RTO stores faced uncertainty.
Ben also walks through three specific ways the pawn side supports collections and sales. First, pawn items can be converted into rental agreements — a customer eyeing a $200 guitar on the retail floor can take it home for $20 down on a rental instead. Second, past-due customers can pawn household items to bring their accounts current. Third, customers without a down payment can use a pawn to fund first-week payment on something they need right away, like a washer and dryer before their next paycheck.
The trade-in program was Pete's biggest takeaway from the conversation. Customers can trade in old furniture or appliances as a down payment — no cash required, no waiting for payday. Castle doesn't rent or sell the traded items; they give them to families in need in the community. It secures a new customer, cleans out the old item, and puts something useful back into the neighborhood.
On marketing, Ben keeps it simple: separate Facebook pages for rental and pawn, a combined website with links between them, and no TV or radio advertising. His philosophy is that heavy advertising is often just compensation for poor customer service. Castle competes directly against Rent-A-Center, Aaron's, and Buddy's in their markets and holds its own — not because of the biggest budget, but because of the people.
Join The RTO Newsletter: https://bit.ly/RTOPODnewsletter
Subscribe on Apple: https://apple.co/4wpbUqF
Subscribe on Spotify: https://bit.ly/RTOPODspotify
Learn More About Sponsorship: https://bit.ly/RTOPODsponsor
