Shows
I'm Not Crazy!Chris Benoit Pt.2Have any interesting stories to tell us? Lets us know here!Last we left off, Benoit rose to international fame in the wrestling world, met his wife and victim Nancy, had a son named Daniel, and concluded with the untimely death of his best friend, Eddie Guerrero. From this point on Benoit would be visibly different to everyone. His violent tendencies outside the ring had already started happening more frequently. Combine that with Guerrero being gone, and Benoit was truly broken. Just us as we dive into Benoits brain, CTE, and the ridiculous conspiracies surrounding his...
2025-12-311h 15I'm Not Crazy!Chris Benoit Pt.1Have any interesting stories to tell us? Lets us know here!Known as the Rabid Wolverine, The Canadian Crippler, Wild Pegasus, Pegasus Kid, and most important The Broom, he is often touted as the best damned technical wrestler in the world, Chris Benoit was, and still is to many, one of the greatest to ever grace to ring. But behind the tiny talent hides a very dark past of mental illness, abuse and drugs, all concluding with the murder of his wife Nancy and son Daniel. But was it really Benoit? or could it have been...
2025-11-061h 10I'm Not Crazy!Summer CryptidsHave any interesting stories to tell us? Lets us know here!The summer is a season that is seemingly filled with magic, from the 24/7 society of insects and mammals, to the endless sun, the summer is a time of vacation, relaxation and fun. But that wasn't always the case. Until like two hundred years ago, summer was a brutal months-long slog filled with heat, sweat and exhaustion. It was better than freezing to death but not by much, as now you had to fight fully conscious bears. The summer also brings the earth to life in...
2025-10-2056 minI'm Not Crazy!The Jersey DevilHave any interesting stories to tell us? Lets us know here!The Jersey Devil, possibly one of the most famous cryptids in American history, as well as one of the strangest. Being one of the first cryptids I was exposed to as a kid, I would google and freak out looking at grainy pictures of the strange horse-like creature with leathery wings. And as it turns out, I’m not even close to the only one as The Jersey Devil also happens to be one of the oldest in the country, with history dating back to so...
2025-10-0658 minI'm Not Crazy!The History of CrucifixionHave any interesting stories to tell us? Lets us know here!Do you enjoy learning about horrifying methods of execution?! Well you found the right place, as this week's episode covers the history of crucifixion from ancient time, world wars, and shockingly recent true crime stories. Just us as we learn about some of the facts lost to time for being a little to...macabre. ANY FOLLOWS AND RATINGS HELP THE SHOW A TON!Check out our stuff, but also don't if you don't want to, whateverTiktok and YouTube - imnotcrazypodcast
2025-04-091h 01I'm Not Crazy!Ronald Gene Simmons Pt.2Have any interesting stories to tell us? Lets us know here!Last we left off, it was 1982 and Gene had sold his house in New Mexico in his successful attempt to evade the law after impregnating his own underage daughter. Join us as we dig deeper, revealing a trail of murder that led police down a terrifying exercise in deprivation and depravity. This is part 2 of Ronald Gene Simmons!LIKE, RATE, PIERCE THE JUGULAR OF THAT SUBSCRIBE BUTTONCheck out our stuff, but also don't if you don't want to, whatever
2025-02-251h 11I'm Not Crazy!Ronald Gene Simmons Pt.1Have any interesting stories to tell us? Lets us know here!Join Chris and Andrew as they explore the twisted tale of serial/spree killer/family annihilator, Ronald Gene Simmons. In this episode, we take you into the lead up to his horrific crime spree. JOIN US!LIKE, RATE, PIERCE THE JUGULAR OF THAT SUBSCRIBE BUTTONCheck out our stuff, but also don't if you don't want to, whateverTiktok and YouTube - imnotcrazypodcastInstagram - imnotcrazynyIf you enjoyed the show, please follow us on whatever podcast app y...
2025-02-011h 04I'm Not Crazy!2024 Very Merry Cryptid Christmas!Have any interesting stories to tell us? Lets us know here!Hello everyone, and welcome to the 2024 I’m Not Crazy Very Merry Cryptid Christmas Special! Tonight we will be talking about a handful of cold and creepy monsters, to try and inject a little horror into your holiday season. So sit back, smoke a yule log, and take a couple shots of eggnogs as we sleigh on down to the pits of hell. Also, just for the record, we are going to be covering creatures from all over, specifically avoiding Europe and Scandonavia, as we ar...
2025-01-031h 05I'm Not Crazy!Amelia Earhart Pt IV. - The FinaleHave any interesting stories to tell us? Lets us know here!Join the boys as they embark on the finale episode of Amelia Earhart. WE FINALLY GET TO THE THEORIES! Did she make it to another island? Was she capture by the Japanese? Did she move to New Jersey?! FIND OUT! LIKE, RATE, PIERCE THE JUGULAR OF THAT SUBSCRIBE BUTTONDo you have a story of your own? Share it below! It may show up in a future episode!i'mnotcrazypodcastofficial@gmail.comCheck out our stuffTiktok and YouTube ...
2024-12-171h 27I'm Not Crazy!2024 True Crime BonanzaHave any interesting stories to tell us? Lets us know here!DO YOU TRUE CRIME? Well today's your day! Take a ride through TRUE CRIME and being a TRUE CRIME with this TRUE CRIME bonanza. We’re going to say TRUE CRIME so many times you’re going to forget the meaning and think about how weird the words sound. Join us as we fly through three different stories to make your spine chill. THIS IS THE 2024 TRUE CRIME BONANZA!LIKE, RATE, PIERCE THE JUGULAR OF THAT SUBSCRIBE BUTTONDo you have...
2024-09-161h 21I'm Not Crazy!Jerusalem SyndromeHave any interesting stories to tell us? Lets us know here!JUST IMAGINE! You and your family decide to take a trip to beautiful Jerusalem, for a week of fun in the sun. But once you arrive, your father starts to act strange. Suddenly, he’s claiming to be Jesus Christ, son of God, and making sure that everyone around him understands this new found revelation. Screaming to the heavens, the father falls deeper into his Christhood, now dressing in robes and walking with a shepherd's cane. Christ decides it's time to follow his calling, an...
2024-08-131h 11I'm Not Crazy!Amelia Earhart Pt. IIIHave any interesting stories to tell us? Lets us know here!Welcome back to our podcast series on Amelia Earhart. In this episode, we take to the skies to explore her most significant flight achievements that changed the course of aviation history. From her record-breaking solo transatlantic flight to her daring long-distance journeys, we'll celebrate the milestones that showcased her extraordinary skill and fearless determination. Join us as we soar through the stories of her legendary flights and set the stage for the mystery of her final, ill-fated journey. Welcome to Part Three of "The Amelia...
2024-07-171h 25I'm Not Crazy!4/20 Bonanza!Have any interesting stories to tell us? Lets us know here!Welcome to the I’m Not Crazy Podcast, where every day is 4/20! Join us as we roll up some high-minded discussions on cannabis culture, creativity, and consciousness. From the roots of the herb to its modern-day buzz, we're sparking conversations that'll leave you feeling lit and lifted. So grab your favorite strain, pack it tight, and let's blaze through the hazy depths of thought together!LIKE, RATE, PIERCE THE JUGULAR OF THAT SUBSCRIBE BUTTONDo you have a story of...
2024-04-2250 minI'm Not Crazy!Amelia Earhart Pt. IIHave any interesting stories to tell us? Lets us know here!Welcome back to our podcast series on Amelia Earhart. In this episode, we'll delve into the remarkable journey of the aviation pioneer as she learns to fly and achieves groundbreaking feats that leave an indelible mark on history. From her early days in aviation to the moments of triumph that cement her legacy, we'll explore the highs and lows that defined Earhart's unparalleled career. Join us as we unravel the gripping tale leading up to her ill-fated final flight, a story that continues to captivate...
2024-03-011h 05I'm Not Crazy!Amelia Earhart Pt. IHave any interesting stories to tell us? Lets us know here!Are you ready to step back in time and explore the life, adventures, and enduring mystery surrounding one of aviation's most legendary figures? Join us through this three part series as we unravel the captivating story of Amelia Earhart, from her humble beginnings to her groundbreaking achievements in the world of flight. Delve into the enigmatic events of her final journey and disappearance, and explore the myriad of theories that continue to shroud her fate in mystery. Fasten your seatbelts, as we soar through history...
2024-01-231h 19I'm Not Crazy!I’m Not Crazy! TrailerHave any interesting stories to tell us? Lets us know here!If you enjoyed the show, please follow us on whatever podcast app you are using. If you'd like to take it further, a like and review helps as well. It means a ton. Thank you for listening!
2024-01-2000 minI'm Not Crazy!The Bunny ManHave any interesting stories to tell us? Lets us know here!August 1971, Fairfax County, Virginia. You and your best friend are driving around listening to the hit song of the summer “Take Me Home, Country Roads”, complaining about how you were so close to being mentioned in the song. As you approach a tunnel on the road, your headlights illuminate a figure in the distance. JUST THEN, the radio cuts to an announcer who announced the following announcement, “This just in, escaped mental patient loose in Fairfax County. Do not approach as they are considered armed and danger...
2023-12-2651 minI'm Not Crazy!2023 Halloween Bonanza!Have any interesting stories to tell us? Lets us know here!We’re back and just in time for Halloween. Are you ready for bone chilling scary stories, spine tingling conversation, and gut wrenching explanation of where we’ve been? I hope so, because that’s what we are doing this episode. WITH THAT BEING SAID, JOIN US, as we step into the haunted, deranged, and psychedelic. This is the 2023 I’m Not Crazy Halloween Bananza!LIKE, RATE, PIERCE THE JUGULAR OF THAT SUBSCRIBE BUTTONDo you have a story of...
2023-10-3149 minI'm Not Crazy!The Snakeman of Robinson GalleriaHave any interesting stories to tell us? Lets us know here!Just imagine, you and a few friends are hanging out and decide to go shopping at the local mall, the Robinson Galleria. You go into the department store, ready to buy the sweater you’ve been looking at for weeks. You decide you’ll try it on just to make sure it fits, and you find the fitting room. Once inside, you hear a low hiss, but think nothing of it. But suddenly, you’re in a freefall as the floor disappears underneath you, falling right into t...
2023-09-1555 minI'm Not Crazy!Slenderman and the Weird World of CreepypastaHave any interesting stories to tell us? Lets us know here!Close your eyes and come back in time with me to the year 2011. You’re spending the night at a friend's house playing Beatles Rock Band, when an idea crosses his mind. “I saw some really creepy videos on YouTube, you guys wanna see?” says Josh. Reluctantly we come to the conclusion that since we are all in the same room for the night, it would be fun to try and freak ourselves out. And with that we dove down the YouTube rabbit hole, eventually landin...
2023-08-081h 04I'm Not Crazy!The Ourang MedanHave any interesting stories to tell us? Lets us know here!June 1947, the WW2 era ship, Ourang Medan, would send a chilling SOS to anyone who would listen. He claimed to be the last man standing, while everyone else was dead. Immediately a crew is sent out to investigate, but when they board the eerie ship, what awaits them is far worse than anyone could have imagined. Join us tonight, as we explore the controversial modern ghost ship, the Ourang Medan.LIKE, RATE, PIERCE THE JUGULAR OF THAT SUBSCRIBE BUTTONDo...
2023-06-2254 minI'm Not Crazy!Snallygaster, the American ChimeraHave any interesting stories to tell us? Lets us know here!Frederick County, Maryland 1909, a man by the name of Bill Gifferson was walking home on a cold February night, when he was suddenly lifted into the air. A giant creature with a huge beak and wingspan took the helpless man to the top of a nearby hill, where a terrified onlooker witnessed the beast pierce the jugular of Gifferson. Within seconds, Bill had been emptied of all blood. With a screeching roar, the beast flew up and disappeared into the night sky, ushering in the...
2023-06-0650 minI'm Not Crazy!The Abduction of Betty and Barney Hill Pt. IIHave any interesting stories to tell us? Lets us know here!In the last episode, we discussed Betty and Barney Hill, a New Hampshire couple who may have had an experience that was out of this world. After allegedly being abducted while on their honeymoon, the couple went on to toil over what actually happened, only telling a few very close family and friends about the events of that night. But after Betty decided to find her own answers, against the wishes of Barney, she would continue to hear the same suggestion over and over. Hypnosis...
2023-05-3052 minI'm Not Crazy!The Abduction of Betty and Barney Hill Pt. IHave any interesting stories to tell us? Lets us know here!Just imagine, a loving couple just got married and decided to take a honeymoon all to themselves. But after getting lost, they stumble upon a craft hovering over the road, with creatures lining the windows. After a closer look, terror takes hold and they both turn around and drive away as fast as possible, still confused from what they saw. Then finally once arriving home, they realized a two hour long drive had taken just over three hours. What happened to the couple during this...
2023-05-2347 minI'm Not Crazy!POLYBIUS, the Mind Control Arcade GameHave any interesting stories to tell us? Lets us know here!Close your eyes and IMAGINE! You’re a kid in 1981, and you've started to hear rumors of a new arcade cabinet at the arcade by the mall. You and a few friends decide to head over there hoping to get a chance to play. The line is long, but you wait patiently hoping to get to try the most sought after game in the place. Then, you finally get in front of the machine, and you're immediately hooked. Colors, shapes and graphics like you’ve neve...
2023-04-181h 04I'm Not Crazy!The Exorcism of Roland DoeHave any interesting stories to tell us? Lets us know here!In a small town in Maryland, a 13 year old boy started to feel a darkness grow within him. Roland Doe, as he would be known, started to tell his parents of scratching noises emanating from his walls and floor at night. But once the boy started to show signs of intense possession, they did all that was left to do, call their priest. Little did they know, Roland would go on to be one of the most frightening cases of possession in known history. This...
2023-03-301h 03I'm Not Crazy!The Case of Amy Saint Laurent | Psychic Case #3Have any interesting stories to tell us? Lets us know here!October 20, 2001, PORTLAND, MAINE, Amy Saint Laurent was out on the town with a friend of hers, enjoying the Halloween season. After some food and drinks, the friends settled on a club called The Pavillion, where at about 1am Amy would disappear forever. Fast-forward a few days after Amy would disappear, Deputy Chief Joseph Loughlin would be listening to the radio when the voice of Vicki Monroe, a radio psychic. Completely desperate for a lead, Loughlin calls Monroe, but wasn’t prepared for what happened next. This is...
2023-03-2353 min
I'm Not Crazy!Interview With: Karla!Have any interesting stories to tell us? Lets us know here!Join us today, as we explore some legends and true story coming from Karla and her family in Mexico. Disappearing pyramids, mountain spirits, and more! JOIN US.Do you have a story of your own? Share it below! it may show up in a future episode!i'mnotcrazypodcastofficial@gmail.comCheck out our stuffTiktok and YouTube - imnotcrazypodcastInstagram - imnotcrazynyMusic:Karl Casey @ White Bat AudioIf you enjoyed the show, p...
2023-02-1248 minI'm Not Crazy!The Beast of Bray RoadHave any interesting stories to tell us? Lets us know here!On a dark night, imagine you are driving on a lonely Wisconsin road. You have been driving for hours and are starting to fade, hoping to find a rest stop nearby. But just then something darts in front of your car, making you swerve out of the way to narrowly avoid hitting it. Curious to know what it was you look in the rearview mirror, but what you see is far more strange than you could have imagined. What seems to be a werewolf starts...
2023-02-0242 minI'm Not Crazy!The Flatwoods MonsterHave any interesting stories to tell us? Lets us know here!Today I’m going to take you back, all the way to 1952, as we said last week, before color was invented. Three children were playing in the town of Flatwoods, West Virginia, when suddenly what looks like a meteor crash lands on a nearby farm. The kids immediately went to investigate. Once at the crash site, they would see a “pulsating ball of fire”, followed by a noxious smell. And then a creature started to emerge, changing the future of the town forever. This is the...
2023-01-2551 minI'm Not Crazy!The Loveland FrogmanHave any interesting stories to tell us? Lets us know here!Imagine, it's 2016, and you and a friend are playing the brand new smash hit game, Pokemon Go. While walking near a lake, you see something unbelievable, and rush to get your friends' attention. You both see a giant frog, much larger than any frog you've ever seen. You switch to your camera, and start to take a video in the darkness, when suddenly the giant frog stands up and begins walking towards you. Your friend grabs your arm and you both run for safety, hearing...
2023-01-1747 minI'm Not Crazy!A Very Cryptid ChristmasHave any interesting stories to tell us? Lets us know here!On a cold snowy winter's night, December 5th, good children are full of joy as they get ready for bed, for the following day is The Feast of St. Nicholas and their good deeds have not gone unnoticed. They will awaken to gifts of chocolate or a toy, but not all are rushing to go to bed that night. The bad children are awake all night, thinking of their misdeeds when suddenly, their nightmares come true. Just down the hall he hears the sound of...
2023-01-0648 minI'm Not Crazy!The Assassination and Conspiracy of John LennonHave any interesting stories to tell us? Lets us know here!On December 8th, 1980, a man by the name of Mark David Chapman would go on to change pop culture forever. While standing outside of his Dakota apartment, Chapman would shoot John Lennon, killing him. The world would mourn, and eventually would be clued in to what happened that night, leaving most of the public satisfied. But what if there was more to the story? Was Lennon killed by a lone man, or by the US government? And was Chapman actually a mind controlled MK-Ultra puppet? Find...
2022-12-1055 minI'm Not Crazy!The Lost Colony of RoanokeHave any interesting stories to tell us? Lets us know here!In 1587, an expedition led by John White would be among the first in the New Land. Once landed, a colony was promptly built, but would soon find themselves running out of supplies. John White decides to go on a trip back to England and return with aid for the colonists. But after two long years he returns, and is greeted with an eerie sight. Nothing. The only clue left behind was the word CROATOAN carved into a wooden fence, being the only structure left behind...
2022-11-2854 minI'm Not Crazy!The Staunton Stalker | Psychic Case #2Have any interesting stories to tell us? Lets us know here!1979, a man would go on a crime spree that would strike fear in the tight knit community of Staunton, Virginia. Young woman were being sexually assaulted by a man with a stocking obscuring his face, and worse of all, it was in their own homes. The man would find open windows to climb in, sometimes waiting for hours for the right time to strike. It was clear to authorities, it was only a matter of time before he would go from rapist to killer, but...
2022-11-1854 minI'm Not Crazy!The Black Knight SatelliteHave any interesting stories to tell us? Lets us know here!In 1899, a little known inventor by the name of Nikola Tesla was messing around with the gigantic radio tower in his Colorado Springs lab. He would receive signals from space, where he assumed it was Martians counting at him, but for many years several others have encountered the same signal. As time went on new evidence would emerge of a satellite orbiting earth, but it would seem it was anything but earthly. JOIN US as we talk about aliens, conspiracies, and the birth of one...
2022-11-041h 00I'm Not Crazy!Spring Heeled Jack Pt. IIHave any interesting stories to tell us? Lets us know here!On the last episode of I’m Not Crazy, we spoke of Spring Heeled Jack! The blue flame spitting demon that hopped his way into the psyche of the Victorian Era. But how was this demon able to stay in the minds and nightmares of generations of people, and who could he have been? Was it just a man with a clever disguise, or was it an extraterrestrial toying with the human race? JOIN US as we find out on Spring Heeled Jack Part II!...
2022-10-2852 minI'm Not Crazy!Spring Heeled-Jack Pt. IHave any interesting stories to tell us? Lets us know here!JUST IMAGINE! You are a Victorian English lady, walking home after a long day of work in a dirty, disgusting factory, when you hear a bump in the night. Suddenly, a demon in a black cloak jumps out and spits blue flame in your face, and then starts to claw at you with razor bsharp metal claws. But by the time you are able to react, he's gone! Sounds crazy right? WRONG! This is the story of Spring-Heeled Jack.Do you have a...
2022-10-2354 minI'm Not Crazy!The War of the Worlds PanicHave any interesting stories to tell us? Lets us know here!On October 30th, 1938, fear would spread across the United States of America. The legendary Orson Welles would begin his broadcast of The War of the Worlds. But little did Welles know, his adaptation might have been a little TOO realistic, said to have caused widespread pandemonium across the continent, never seen before. Join us as we uncover what really happened on that fateful Halloween night. It's time to dive into the infamous War of the Worlds panic.Do you have a story of...
2022-10-141h 07I'm Not Crazy!Woodrow DerenbergerHave any interesting stories to tell us? Lets us know here!On a cold and rainy evening, November 2nd, 1966 on a small patch of I-77, a man by the name of Woody Derenberger encountered something out of this world. A cigar shaped craft would land next to him and change the course of his life forever. Join us as we learn more about the legendary Indrid Cold, his planet of Lanulos, and Woodys transformation from salesman to space traveler. Was Woody really impregnated by an alien? Maybe!Do you have a...
2022-10-061h 14I'm Not Crazy!The Murder of Andre Daigle | Psychic Case #1Have any interesting stories to tell us? Lets us know here!On June 9th, 1987, Andre Daigle and his friend met at a chain restaurant, Chi Chis. After a few drinks, Andre decides to give a woman he'd met at the bar a ride home. That would be the last anyone saw of Andre. After four days long days, his sister would contact a local psychic by the name of Rosemary Kerr, in a last-ditch attempt to find her brother. Join us as we explore the grisly murder of Andre Daigle, and the curius mind of Rosemary Kerr.
2022-09-271h 06I'm Not Crazy!The Van Meter VisitorHave any interesting stories to tell us? Lets us know here!On September 29th 1903, in the quiet town of Van Meter, Iowa, a man by the name of U. G. Griffith would see something very odd to him. A light where a light had never been, on the top floor of the local bank. When Griffith went to confront what he assumed was a robber, the light dashed across the street landing onto the opposite rooftop. This would be just the beginning for the town, as they were now being haunted by the Van Meter Visitor.
2022-08-271h 18I'm Not Crazy!The Pigman Of AngolaHave any interesting stories to tell us? Lets us know here!In the outskirts of the small town of Evans, New York, lived a hog farmer that was feared by his neighbors. He was known all over town for putting his recently slaughtered hogs heads on spikes and lining his property with them, warning everyone to keep away. But one day a group of fearless teenagers decided to sneak on the farm anyway, only to be confronted by the Pigman himself. Though I can’t tell you what exactly happened on that farm, I CA...
2022-08-0557 min2022-08-0401 minI'm Not Crazy!John Titor, the Time TravelerHave any interesting stories to tell us? Lets us know here!On July 29th 1998, an anonymous man faxed into the show Coast-to-Coast, claiming to be a time traveler on a mission from the year 2036. He was going back to the year 1975 to retrieve an IBM 5100 computer, for the task of possibly saving the world from impending doom. This would be the first of many interactions with the time traveler, setting into motion one of the strangest internet mysteries of all time. This is the story of John Titor, the Time Traveler....
2022-07-071h 01I'm Not Crazy!The Greenbrier GhostHave any interesting stories to tell us? Lets us know here!On Jan. 22, 1897, Edward Shue had approached a neighbor asking if their son, Anderson Jones, can help his wife with some chores, claiming she wasn't feeling good when he had left the house. When little Andy Jones arrived at the Shue home however, he found the lifeless body of Elva Shue strewn along the foot of their staircase. When the coroner arrived at the scene, the death was attributed to complications due to pregnancy. Devastated, Mary Jane Heaster, mother of Elva, started to pray hoping she'd...
2022-06-211h 04I'm Not Crazy!El ChupacabraHave any interesting stories to tell us? Lets us know here!On a dark night in September 1995, Puerto Rican native Madelyne Tolentino saw a creature that would quickly become a worldwide sensation. Rife with confusion and speculation, the origins of the Chupacabra are dubious at most. Stemming from political unrest and distrust of the US government, the story quickly spread and became a catch all for animal mutilations all across South America, parts of the Caribbean, and the United States. This is the story of the Chupacabra.Do you have a story...
2022-06-031h 14I'm Not Crazy!The Watcher Of WestfieldHave any interesting stories to tell us? Lets us know here!June 2014, Derek and Maria Broaddus had just bought their 1.3 million dollar dream home on 657 Boulevard, in Westfield, New Jersey. While renovating a few days later, Derek decided to take a break and check the mail, triggering a series of events that would turn their dream home into a waking nightmare. This is the terrifying story of The Westfield Watcher.Do you have a story of your own? Share it below! It may show up in a future episode!i'mnotcrazypodcastofficial@gmail...
2022-05-2053 minI'm Not Crazy!The Mothman of West VirginiaHave any interesting stories to tell us? Lets us know here!On a cold night in West Virginia 1966, Five men were out digging a grave. One of those men, Kenneth Duncan, would go on to be the start of a long and tragic story. The report stated that while digging, Kenneth looked out into the trees and saw the Mothman flying in front of him. Though he was the only one to see it on that night, dozens would go on to witness the monster that terrorized Point Pleasant, West Virginia. This is the story of...
2022-05-061h 05