Shows
Is This Legal?Ep. 116 Suzanne Morphew's Autopsy Puts Spotlight Back on HusbandSend us a textColin and Russ discuss the bombshell autopsy report that sheds more light on the homicide of Suzanne Morphew. What did the coroner find in Suzanne's system? Can Barry be charged again? Is there enough evidence? Who will prosecute the case? Do Colin and Russ think he will be arrested? All of these questions are addressed in this episode, along with a new Is This Legal and DCOTW. Listen here!
2024-05-0148 minIs This Legal?Ep. 115 The Murder Trial of Karen ReadSend us a textColin and Russ dive into a listener-inspired case (thanks Jay!) involving Karen Read, a Massachusetts woman who is accused of killing her boyfriend, Boston Police officer, John O'Keefe. The allegations are that she ran him over with her SUV after a night of drinking. Her defense is that not only is she innocent, but she is being framed by a large conspiracy of law enforcement personnel to cover up what really happened. Wild, wild case. The trial just started with jury selection this week and Colin and Russ tell you what you need to k...
2024-04-2559 minIs This Legal?Ep.114 Crumbleys Sentenced, Gilbert Goons UpdateSend us a textColin and Russ have a final discussion on Jennifer and James Crumbley, who were both sentenced to prison after their convictions for Involuntary Manslaughter. The convictions entered due to their failures as parents to prevent their son, Ethan, from killing four students in his school. Colin and Russ also discuss new developments in the Preston Lord homicide case in suburban Phoenix, and more on the so-called Gilbert Goons. As always, the fellas play Is This Legal and enjoy a laugh with an international DCOTW. Listen here!
2024-04-1142 minIs This Legal?Ep. 113 The Gilbert Goons and the Killing of Preston LordSend us a textColin and Russ discuss the death of Preston Lord, a 15 year old boy who was allegedly murdered by at least 7 young men in late October of 2023. The perpetrators may have been associated with the Gilbert Goons, a gang of teenagers who have been linked to several violent assaults in the last 18 months in the Phoenix suburbs. After a 5 month investigation, charges have been filed against several young men in Lord's killing. Colin and Russ break it all down here and discuss what happened and what's next. Plus, we play Is This Legal and have a...
2024-04-0452 minIs This Legal?Ep. 112 'Rust' Shooting: Hannah Gutierrez-Reed on Trial, What's Next for Alec Baldwin?Send us a textColin and Russ pick up where they left off in episodes 88 and 95 to continue discussing the accidental shooting and killing of cinematographer Halyna Hutchins that occurred on the set of the movie 'Rust" in October of 2021. Hannah Gutierrez-Reed is currently on trial for involuntary manslaughter for causing Hutchin's death because she was the armorer in charge of the weapons on set. The attorneys also discuss what is next for Alec Baldwin, who has been re-charged with Involuntary Manslaughter himself. Plus, an Is This Legal, and a new DCOTW. Check it out!
2024-03-0645 minIs This Legal?Ep. 111 Crumbley Trial Pt. 2, Why Jennifer Crumbley Was ConvictedSend us a textColin and Russ pick up where they left off in Episode 110 to discuss the guilty verdicts and convictions for Involuntary Manslaughter that came down for Jennifer Crumbley, the mother of mass murderer Ethan Crumbley. They also discuss the happy story of Robert Duboise, who was just exonerated of crimes for which he wrongfully spent 37 years in prison. Plus, a new Is This Legal, and a DCOTW. Check it out!
2024-02-1743 minIs This Legal?Ep. 110 The Trial of Jennifer Crumbley- Can the Mom of a Mass Shooter Be Criminally Responsible?Send us a textColin and Russ examine the current trial of Jennifer Crumbley, the mother of Ethan Crumbley, who killed 4 of his classmates in a school mass shooting when he was 15 years old in 2021. Jennifer is charged with Involuntary Manslaughter, and prosecutors allege that she should have done more to prevent this tragedy. Will the charges stick? What defenses does she have? Is this an overreach by the prosecutor? Colin and Russ have the answers! We also have a new Is This Legal and a new DCOTW. Check it out!
2024-02-0253 minIs This Legal?Ep. 109 Can You Shoot a Trespasser? The Trial of Kevin MonahanSend us a textColin and Russ discuss the trial of Kevin Monahan, who is accused of murdering a lost trespasser named Kaylin Gillis in her car who mistakenly turned into his driveway. The trial started this week, and the fellas talk about the case, possible defenses and stand your ground laws. Colin and Russ also discuss the charges facing Kansas City man Andrew Lester, who is charged in a similar case. We also have a new Is This Legal, and a fresh DCOTW. Check it out!
2024-01-1253 minIs This Legal?Ep. 108 Bodies Stacking, Burials Lacking! The Bizarre Story of a Colorado Funeral HomeSend us a textColin and Russ are back to discuss the charges facing Jon and Carie Hallford, who abandoned the Return to Nature funeral home in Colorado that was improperly storing 189 corpses. In addition to the improper storage, they are accused of taking money for cremations they didn't actually perform. They face hundreds of criminal charges, and Colin and Russ break it down. Also, a new Is This Legal, and DCOTW!
2023-12-0841 minIs This Legal?Ep. 107 Love Triangle Turns Deadly Pt. 2, Kaitlin Armstrong GuiltySend us a textColin and Russ continue discussing the completed trial of Kaitlin Armstrong, who was just convicted of murdering Mo Wilson in Austin, TX in 2022. Colin and Russ discuss the defense strategies in more depth and discuss other facts that came out during the trial. Plus, a new Is This Legal and a DCOTW. Check it out!
2023-11-1652 minIs This Legal?Ep. 106 Love Triangle Turns Deadly- Kaitlin Armstrong on Trial for the Murder of Moriah WilsonSend us a textColin and Russ take our listeners to Austin, TX, where former yoga instructor Kaitlin Armstrong is being tried for the 2022 murder of professional cyclist Moriah Wilson. Prosecutors say that Armstrong murdered Wilson because she was jealous of the relationship that Wilson had with Armstrong's boyfriend, pro cyclist Colin Strickland. Opening statements just happened this week, and Colin and Russ break down the evidence, talk about prosecution and defense strategies, and of course, make case predictions. Plus a new Is This Legal and DCOTW. Check it out!
2023-11-0252 minIs This Legal?Ep. 105 Yes, George Santos Really Is That Dumb!Send us a textColin and Russ continue where they left off in Ep. 96 to further discuss the legal woes of Rep. George Santos after he was charged with 10 new federal crimes in addition to the 13 he was initially charged with earlier this spring. We break down the allegations and discuss his treasurer, Nancy Marks, who just pleaded guilty to charges related to Santos and is awaiting sentencing. Plus, a new, listener-inspired Is This Legal and a fresh #DCOTW!
2023-10-1746 minIs This Legal?Ep. 104 Murder WITH a Body- Suzanne Morphew's Body Found!Send us a textColin and Russ pick up where they left Episodes 61 and 74 in their discussion of the disappearance of Suzanne Morphew. After 3.5 years, her body was found on Sept. 22, 2023. Her husband, Barry Morphew, was previously charged with her murder, but that case was dismissed by the district attorney over a year ago. What does the discovery of the body mean? Who will prosecute any case arising from the discovery of the body? Will embattled DA Linda Stanley get this case back, or will a new DA take over? Will Barry get charged again? Does his $15 million...
2023-10-0651 minIs This Legal?Ep. 103 Is Alex Murdaugh Getting a New Trial?Send us a textColin and Russ revisit the Alex Murdaugh case. Murdaugh was convicted of murdering his wife and son in March of 2023 after a six week trial. However, his attorneys have filed a motion seeking a new trial due to alleged misconduct on the part of Court Clerk Becky Hill, whom they allege made inappropriate statements to jurors that may have pressured them to convict Murdaugh. How bad is this conduct? Will Murdaugh get a new trial? Will Ms. Hill face criminal charges? All these questions will be addressed, plus a new Is This Legal and a...
2023-09-1456 minIs This Legal?Ep. 102 A Wolf In Chiefs ClothingSend us a textIt's almost football season, and Russ and Colin decide to tackle the case of the Chiefsaholic, aka Xaviar Babudar, a Kansas City Chiefs superfan, and alleged interstate bank robber. He's accuse of stealing large amounts of cash in a series of robberies from April- December 2022 and used the proceeds to attend football games and place heavy bets. Colin and Russ break down the tape to determine what's next for Mr. Babudar in the wake of his state and federal charges. Plus a new Is This Legal and DCOTW. Ready, Set, Hike!
2023-09-0242 minIs This Legal?Ep. 101 Blindsided! Michael Oher and Touhy Family Adoption BruhahaSend us a textColin and Russ wade into the public dispute playing out between former NFL offensive lineman Michael Oher and the Touhy family, who were the subject of a 2009 blockbuster movie called The Blind Side. Michael claims that the movie did not accurately portray what really happened with the Touhy's, because he was never adopted by them. He has filed a petition to end a conservatorship by which the Touhy family have been controlling his financial affairs. The Touhy family has also responded to these allegations. We break it all down here. Plus, Colin and Russ...
2023-08-1751 minIs This Legal?Ep. 100! Trump's Indictments and the Is This Legal Origin StorySend us a textColin and Russ bring you the 100th episode of Is This Legal! They break down the newest indictments against Donald Trump from the approach of criminal defense attorneys. How will the prosecution prove their case? Are other co-conspirators in joepardy? What defenses does Trump have available to him? Will he get convicted? Plus, Russ and Colin wax nostalgic as they reflect upon 100 episodes of Is This Legal, and Colin reveals his favorite episode of all time. Check it out!
2023-08-0255 minIs This Legal?Ep. 99 The Gilgo Beach Killings, and How Law Enforcement Arrested Rex HeuermannSend us a textColin and Russ get into the fascinating revelations behind the investigation of the Gilgo Beach murders, which focused around four women whose bodies were found in 2010 and 2011 in Long Island, NY. In July 2023, Rex Heuermann, a New York architect, was arrested and charged with 3 of the murders over a decade later. Colin and Russ walk through the years long investigation and discuss the tools that police and forensic analysts used to get their man.
2023-07-2141 minIs This Legal?Ep. 98 Does the Kansas Two Step Dance Over Your Constitutional Rights?Send us a textColin and Russ break down the controversial Kansas Highway Patrol tactic colloquially known as the Kansas Two Step. What is it? Why do they do it? Is it legal? They bring on guest attorney and former Hebets & McCallin paralegal Pansy Watson who recounts her own experience with the Kansas Two Step. Plus a fresh Is This Legal, and as always, a new DCOTW. Check it out!
2023-06-2356 minIs This Legal?Ep. 97 Bryan Kohberger and the Moscow Idaho Murders Pt. 2, Grand Jury Indictment and New RevelationsSend us a textColin and Russ pick up where they left off from Ep. 87 as they discuss Bryan Kohberger, a man just charged by a grand jury in the murders of 4 college students in Moscow, Idaho. They discuss the prosecutor's unusual decision to have a grand jury charge the case as opposed to presenting evidence in a preliminary hearing. They also discuss updates to the evidence in the case, and make some predictions about what happens next. As always, a new game of Is This Legal and a new DCOTW. Listen here!
2023-05-2548 minIs This Legal?Ep. 96 Is George Santos Really That Dumb?Send us a textColin and Russ discuss beleaguered U.S. Congressman George Santos, who has been charged with 13 federal crimes. They examine his election campaign, the lies he got caught telling, and they walk the listener through the entire indictment. Colin and Russ make predictions about Mr. Santos' future, and theorize why his defense attorney is keeping a bit more quiet than his client. Plus, a new game of Is This Legal and an international DCOTW. Check it out!
2023-05-1254 minIs This Legal?Ep. 95 Alec Baldwin Charges Dropped, Danny Masterson Retrial, Elizabeth Holmes Delays Jail, Linda Stanley SpeaksSend us a textColin and Russ catch up on current events in the law. They break down the dismissal of criminal charges for actor Alec Baldwin stemming from the accidental shooting of a production manager during filming for his movie "Rust." They also discuss Danny Masterson, who is being retried for sexual assault in Los Angeles. Other topics include disgraced Theranos founder Elizabeth Holmes and more on DA Linda Stanley. Test your legal acumen with a game of Is This Legal, and an international DCOTW. Give it a listen!
2023-04-2745 minIs This Legal?Ep. 94 More Prosecutorial Misconduct with DA Linda StanleySend us a textColin and Russ are back to discuss 11th Judicial District Attorney Linda Stanley in Colorado. She is the elected DA who handled Barry Morphew's case that ended up getting dismissed last year after several discovery violations. She is in the news again because another first degree murder charge just got dismissed in a case her office is prosecuting due to multiple discovery violations. In a scathing order, a judge highlighted at least 20 cases where Ms Stanley's office has not complied with basic discovery obligations. Plus, a new Is This Legal, and a new DCOTW...
2023-04-1359 minIs This Legal?Ep. 93 Indictment of Donald Trump, Legal Fun with Gwyneth PaltrowSend us a textColin and Russ discuss the historic indictment of former President Donald Trump, who faces criminal charges from the Manhattan District Attorney's Office. What is he charged with? How will the prosecution prove its case and what challenges do they face? What defenses does Trump have? Colin and Russ make early predictions of the outcome of the case. They also briefly discuss the ski trial and tribulations of Gwyneth Paltrow that wrapped up in Utah last week. Michael Roulier joins the show to play Is This Legal, and as always the boys close it out wi...
2023-04-0554 minIs This Legal?Ep. 92 Guns, Booze, and Shotgun Willies- the Ja Morant StorySend us a textRuss and Colin discuss the investigations into NBA star Ja Morant after he live streamed himself in a Denver gentleman's club holding a gun during a team road trip. They discuss potential criminal charges, give a brief and hilarious history of the legendary Shotgun Willie's, and try to learn a lesson amidst the stupidity. Plus, Dr. Michael Guarnieri of the band Brother Down joins us to play Is This Legal, and as always a brand new #DCOTW. Listen here!
2023-03-1649 minIs This Legal?Ep. 91 Was It Smart For Alex Murdaugh to Testify?Send us a textColin and Russ discuss the interesting choice of Alex Murdaugh to take the stand in his own defense in his murder trial. Was it worth the risk? What would have happened if he didn't take the stand? How did he do? Your two favorite lawyers break it all down. Check it out!
2023-03-0341 minIs This Legal?Ep. 90 Alex Murdaugh on Trial for MurderSend us a textColin and Russ tackle the sensational allegations against prominent South Carolina attorney Alex Murdaugh, who is currently on trial for the murders of his wife and son. They also break down the multitude of other crimes Mr. Murdaugh is accused of committing, as well as the complicated legal timeline that led to where we are now. Plus, Dave Pulliam joins the show to play Is This Legal, and as always, a brand new Dumb Criminal of the Week. Check it out!
2023-02-1644 minIs This Legal?Ep. 89 Attempted Murder by Tesla?Send us a textTesla has been in the news a lot lately, and Colin and Russ are here for all of it. They discuss the attempted murder charges facing Dharmesh Patel, a Bay Area doctor who drove his Tesla with his wife and two children off a cliff...and all survived! Plus, they also provide a case update on another Tesla case (we previously covered in Ep. 71) involving Kevin Riad, a limousine driver who is accused of manslaughter after his Tesla collided with another vehicle killing its two occupants, while the Tesla's autopilot function was turned on...
2023-02-0241 minIs This Legal?Ep. 88 Brian Walshe Boston Murder, Alec Baldwin Charged, Kohberger UpdateSend us a textIt's a true crime bonanza! Colin and Russ go over the shocking details involving the arrest of Brian Walshe, who is charged with murdering his wife Ana. Can prosecutors prove the case without a body? What hurdles will the defense have to overcome? Also, Colin and Russ discuss the involuntary manslaughter charges expected to be filed against Alec Baldwin for the accidental death of cinematographer Halyna Hutchins. Does the prosecutor have a case, or is this political grandstanding? Plus, we have guest Rick Hotchner to play Is This Legal, and of course, a brand n...
2023-01-2056 minIs This Legal?Ep. 87 Bryan Kohberger and the Murders in Moscow, IdahoSend us a textColin and Russ break down the arrest of murder suspect Bryan Kohberger, who is charged with murdering 4 college students near the University of Idaho. They discuss the contents of the arrest affidavit and parse out the details of the thorough investigation that ultimately led to Kohberger's arrest. They also talk about next steps for the case as well as potential defenses Kohberger may raise. Bonus- Denver Broncos super fan Lindsay Bebout from the Crush Podcast joins us to play Is This Legal! A fresh DCOTW is also available for your enjoyment. Check it out...
2023-01-0655 minIs This Legal?Ep. 86 Sam Bankman-Fried Arrested and ChargedSend us a textColin and Russ discuss the captivating case of Sam Bankman-Fried, the CEO of FTX, a cryptocurrency exchange service that collapsed sensationally a month ago due to alleged fraud and co-mingling of investor funds. They discuss his federal charges, civil lawsuits, and also talk about the potential culpability of his parents Joseph Bankman and Barbara Fried, who are both Stanford law professors. Plus, the guys play Is This Legal, and have a fresh DCOTW for your enjoyment! Happy Holidays!
2022-12-1650 minIs This Legal?Ep. 85 Elizabeth Holmes Going to Jail, Danny Masterson Mistrial and Oath Keepers SeditionSend us a textColin and Russ break down the Elizabeth Holmes sentencing, and discuss whether her pending pregnancy had an effect on the sentence she received. Does a baby on board keep her out of the big house? They also discuss what might happen with Danny Masterson's case after his mistrial, as well as the high profile Oath Keepers trial. As always, Russ and Colin play a new game of Is This Legal and have a fresh DCOTW for your listening pleasure. Enjoy!
2022-12-0242 minIs This Legal?Ep. 84 Can You Get a DUI Without Driving?Send us a textYour favorite legal duo are back with a special episode quizzing the listener on when you can and cannot get a DUI, even if you're not driving a car at the time! Also in this week's episode is an update on the trials covered in Episode 83, including Kevin Spacey, Harvey Weinstein, Paul Haggis, the Oathkeepers, and the Masterson trial. Stick around for another incredible Dumb Criminal of the Week!
2022-11-1148 minIs This Legal?Ep. 83 Legal Roundup! So Many Cases, So Little Time!Send us a textRuss and Colin cover a multitude of #Metoo trials, the latest verdict in the Steele Dossier case, Alex Jones’s astronomical verdict, and even dip their toes into the secretive and mysterious world of Scientology. Joseph Roulier tests his legal chops in the latest Is This Legal scenario, and as always they bring the shenanigans of another criminal in the Dumb Criminal of the Week.
2022-10-2051 minIs This Legal?Ep. 82 Election Denier Tina Peters: Maligned Martyr or Future Felon?Send us a textRuss and Colin give an update on the trials and tribulations of ex-Mesa County Clerk and Recorder Tina Peters, from her many civil lawsuits at the hand of Colorado Secretary of State Jenna Griswold, to her pending criminal trial exposing her to 10 felony convictions. Was she defending the Republic, or was she a simple felon? Does she has a leg to stand on, and will her ex-deputy clerk drop a dime on her at trial? All this and more along with more tomfoolery from Jebediah and Cornelius and a fresh #DCOTW!
2022-09-0154 minIs This Legal?Ep. 81 The Search of Mar-A-Lago: Will Trump Be Charged?Send us a textColin and Russ spitball the FBI's search of Mar-A-Lago on Aug. 8. What did they search for, and eventually seize? On what authority did they act? What is a search warrant, and how are they executed? Does Trump face criminal liability? Colin and Russ answer all of these questions and more! Jebediah and Cornelius stop by for a brand new #IsThisLegal?, and as always, the boys discuss knucklehead awards for a fresh #DCOTW! Tune in!
2022-08-1952 minIs This Legal?Ep. 80 Brittney Griner's Russian Drug Case ExplainedSend us a textWNBA star Brittney Griner was stopped on February 12th, 2022, with 0.7 g of hashish oil in her luggage. Colin and Russ explain her charges, her 9 year sentence, and the light at the end of the tunnel in the form of a potential prisoner swap with notorious Russian arms dealer Viktor Bout, the Russian "Merchant of Death." Stick around for a visit to the sunshine state for another Dumb Criminal of the Week.
2022-08-0441 minIs This Legal?Ep. 79 Is Marijuana Basically Legal In America?Send us a textWhile public opinion on marijuana continues to shift, the US Congress has yet to catch up. Russ and Colin talk the latest developments in marijuana law in America including federal legislation, the categorization of marijuana as a controlled substance, banking laws, and where the county is headed. They answer the burning questions: What is the weed capital of America (Hint: it’s not California or Washington), serve up an episode of “Is This Legal?” with guest Dave Ferrante, and shame a dumb criminal from the Show Me state!
2022-07-2150 minIs This Legal?Ep. 78 Abortion, Guns, Prayer and the Supreme CourtSend us a textThe most recent term of the newly appointed Supreme Court has come to an end, including the Trump additions of Neil Gorsuch, Brett Kavanaugh, and Amy Coney Barrett and boy did it end with a bang. Colin and Russ break down new cases overturning Roe v. Wade, extending gun rights, and expanding the right to pray on public school property. Why did they rule the way they did, what is an Originalist, and if you don't like the way the Supreme Court wind is blowing, what can you do about it? All this...
2022-07-0849 minIs This Legal?Ep. 77 Deshaun Watson: Sexual Predator, or Just a Creep?Send us a textAs the train wreck that is Deshaun Watson's trade to the Cleveland Ostriches, whoops, we mean Cleveland Browns, unfolds amid 2 dozen claims of sexual misconduct, Colin and Russ dive into all aspects of the case. What is his criminal liability? Do the Browns, or the Texans have anything to fear? Were teams really hiding their heads in the sand to land Watson as their starting QB, or is the case blown out of proportion? And last of all, are happy endings legal? Tune in for answers to all of this and more!...
2022-06-1349 minIs This Legal?Ep. 76 Gun Laws In America Part 2Send us a textJoin Russ and Colin as they follow up from Ep. 20 and discuss the current legal landscape of gun laws in the USA after the horrific shooting in Uvalde, TX. Can gun manufacturers be sued after a mass shooting? Are red flag laws working? Are there any cases before the Supreme Court on this? Listen to find out, and stay for the Dumb Criminal of the Week! Click here for full transcript.
2022-06-0343 minIs This Legal?Ep. 75 The Johnny Depp/Amber Heard DebacleSend us a textAs the circus, whoops, sorry, the defamation trial between Johnny Depp and Amber Heard unfolds, Russ and Colin take an episode to go over the salacious details, the legal nuances, and the likely winners, if any. What are the courtroom strategies being employed here? Does Amber Heard's countersuit have a chance to succeed? Does the judge regret not going to medical school? These questions will all be explored, along with a pair of Is This Legal? riddles and the exploits of this week's Dumb Criminal of the Week. Gavel drop!For the...
2022-05-131h 00Is This Legal?Ep. 74 Shocking "Discovery!" Barry Morphew Case Part 2Send us a textColin and Russ discuss the shocking events that led to the dismissal of murder charges against Barry Morphew, who was charged with murdering his wife, Suzanne Morphew, a woman who went missing in the summer of 2020. They cover the cavalcade of missteps by the DAs office, from failure to disclose alternative suspects to making up results of a dog-sniff that didn't happen! Follow up from Episode 61. Check it out!For the full transcript, click here.
2022-04-2856 minIs This Legal?Ep. 73 - Should a Nurse Go to Jail for Making a Mistake? The RaDonda Vaught CaseSend us a textIn this episode, Colin and Russ discuss the conviction of nurse RaDonda Vaught following the accidental death of a patient Vaught treated. The Vaught case has the healthcare world in a commotion and may have broad implications for the industry, especially for those considering careers in nursing. The topic of today's episode is brought to you by alert listener Kristin Larson, who is herself a nurse and aspiring lawyer. Listen in as Kristin gives her professional opinion on this tragedy and tests her legal acumen in the Is This Legal? segment. Also, before...
2022-04-1553 minIs This Legal?Ep. 72 Will Putin Be Charged with War Crimes?Send us a textColin and Russ discuss the Russian invasion of Ukraine, and whether or not Vladimir Putin can be investigated and charged with war crimes by the International Criminal Court. They are joined by Jeremy Cox for Is This Legal, and have a brand new #DCOTW!
2022-03-1051 minIs This Legal?Ep. 71 - The Riad Case and Self-Driving Car Crashes: Is Tesla at Fault?Send us a textWith self-driving technology becoming more and more common, the inevitable re-drawing of legal lines has begun to figure out who's at fault, and to what extent, when self-driving cars crash. In this episode of the show, Colin and Russ tackle a recent case from California involving a Tesla driver, Kevin Riad, who faces felony charges for an accident resulting in multiple fatalities. Is Mr. Riad liable criminally? Is Tesla? Also features an "Is This Legal?" segment with a guest who must ponder not one but two legal quandaries, and a Dumb Criminal of th...
2022-02-1243 minIs This Legal?Ep. 70 - Trump's Supreme Court LossSend us a textFormer President Donald Trump has taken legal action to prevent the Jan. 6th House committee from obtaining documents, created during Trump's tenure, that pertain to the January 6th riot at the U.S. Capitol last year. His efforts have been rejected by the lower courts, and now the Supreme Court has issued a decision not to hear the case. Listen in as your intrepid podcast hosts Russ and Colin discuss how this process unfolded, and what it means going forward with regard to criminal liability for Trump. Then, test your wits against a...
2022-01-2246 minIs This Legal?Ep. 69 - Piles o' Trials and the Make-A-Wish Mom Goes to JailSend us a textNew year, new news! In this episode, the boys give an update on some of the high-profile trials from 2021 that have now ended, including the Elizabeth Holmes Theranos trial and the trial of Ghislaine Maxwell. Then, they throw out a fresh Is This Legal? scenario for you to ponder, wrapping up the episode with a discussion of Kelly Turner, the Make-A-Wish mom who just pled guilty to a handful of felonies. Also features a Dumb Criminal of the Week you won't want to miss. Happy New Year!
2022-01-1144 minIs This Legal?Ep. 68 - 110 Years in Prison for a Traffic Accident?Send us a textRuss and Colin break down the case of Colorado truck driver Rogel Aguilera-Mederos, who lost his brakes on interstate 70, crashing into traffic and ultimately resulting in the death of 4 people and injury of 6 others. Mr. Aguilera-Mederos, despite having no prior criminal history, and no intent to injure or kill anyone, was sentenced to 110 years in prison, the minimum mandatory for the crimes pursued by District Attorney Alexis King. Tune in and see why this disproportionate result, and whether the sentencing will be revisited. As always, a guest plays Is This Legal, and they...
2021-12-2849 minIs This Legal?Ep. 67 Legal Roundup! Crumbley, Potter, Maxwell, Smollett TrialsSend us a text2021 is going out with a flurry of high-profile criminal trials, so it's only right that Colin and Russ take an episode to bring you up to speed on all of them. In this 67th iteration of Is This Legal?, the guys take a look at the cases of Ethan Crumbley, Kim Potter, and Ghislaine Maxwell, and they give a tip of the cap to Jussie Smollett as well during an extended DCOTW segment. Also features some quick thinking from this week's guest interviewee, and a whole lot more. Don't miss it!...
2021-12-1047 minIs This Legal?Ep. 66 - Is Kyle Rittenhouse Guilty?Send us a textThis week's Is This Legal takes a trip to Kenosha, Wisconsin, to analyze the trial of Kyle Rittenhouse. Armed with an assault rifle, baby-faced teenager Kyle Rittenhouse took to the streets, answering a call to protect property. The night took a tragic turn as 2 men were killed and another wounded at the hands of Mr. Rittenhouse. Russ and Colin break down Rittenhouse's case for self defense and give their best educated guesses as to whether he will be convicted. All this, plus another fan-favorite round of Is This Legal and of course, the al...
2021-11-1158 minIs This Legal?Ep. 65 - You're Under Arrest! (But I'm Not a Cop): Ahmaud Arbery, Confederate Flags, and Citizen ArrestsSend us a textRuss and Colin are back to discuss the tragic Ahmaud Arbery killing that spurred protests and outrage across the country. Is citizen's arrest a legal defense tactic? What evidence will be admissible at trial? Answers in this episode. Plus: A spicy round of "Is This Legal?" and our much-loved "Dumb Criminal of the Week."
2021-11-0253 minIs This Legal?Ep. 64- The Gabby Petito Murder Part 2 – Strangulation, Domestic Violence & The Moab Police DepartmentSend us a textHere is the sequel you’ve been waiting for. The boys are back and bringing you the newest developments in the tragic Gabby Petito case. Russ and Colin discuss strangulation, domestic violence, and whether the Moab Police Department are to blame for Gabby Petito’s death. Plus, we put a loyal listener to the test and bring you another Dumb Criminal of the Week.For anyone interested in helping bring some holiday cheer to children in need, please consider donating to kenziscauses.org.For the full transcript, click here.
2021-10-1551 minIs This Legal?Ep. 63 The Gabby Petito Murder. Are Brian Laundrie's Parents Liable?Send us a textThe discovery of Gabby Petito's body recently in Wyoming, and her boyfriend Brian Laundrie's unusual behavior in the weeks after her disappearance, raise legal questions: could Laundrie's parents be liable for helping cover up a crime? What tactics will authorities use to draw out information in the case? Also features an intriguing Is This Legal? issue to consider and a rollicking new DCOTW (Dumb Criminal of the Week).For the full transcript, click here.
2021-10-0143 minIs This Legal?Ep. 63 - The Gabby Petito Murder. Are Brian Laundrie's Parent's Liable?The discovery of Gabby Petito's body in Wyoming recently, and the behavior of her boyfriend Brian Laundrie in the weeks following her disappearance, brings up legal questions: are Laundrie's parents legally compelled to tell authorities if they know where Brian is or how Gabby died? What is their criminal liability? What tactics will authorities use to draw out information in this case? Also features an intriguing Is This Legal? issue to consider and a rollicking new Dumb Criminal of the Week (DCOTW).
2021-09-3043 minIs This Legal?Ep. 62 - Karen Garner and the Downfall of Loveland PD, Featuring Sarah SchielkeSend us a textOoh boy, this one's a sizzler. First, the backstory: in episode 56, Colin and Russ discussed the widely-publicized assault on Karen Garner, an elderly woman with dementia, by officers of the Loveland Police Department in Colorado. In this episode, the guys are joined by Karen's attorney, Sarah Schielke, fresh off securing a three-million dollar settlement from the city of Loveland to recompense Karen for her hardship. Sarah breaks down the initial criminal case against Karen, the civil suit Karen's family appointed Sarah to handle subsequently, and the ongoing criminal cases against the Loveland officers...
2021-09-1742 minIs This Legal?Ep. 61 - Murder without a Body? The Barry Morphew CaseSend us a textHere's one for all the true crime fans. Suzanne Morphew's disappearance has attracted a lot of media attention lately, and it's clear why: the story has a love triangle, mysterious circumstantial evidence, and plenty of room for juicy speculation. The case is now before a judge to decide whether there's probable cause to proceed to trial. What are the arguments the prosecution will use to advance the claim that Barry Morphew murdered his wife? What evidence will the defense use to exculpate Morphew? And just as importantly, will our guest Alex Stafford be...
2021-09-0254 minIs This Legal?Ep. 60 - Do Guilty People Deserve a Legal Defense? Featuring Donald Cameron Clark Jr.Send us a textThe boys are back in town! After a little summer hiatus, Russ and Colin jump back on the mic to discuss a topic you've probably wondered about: why should we bother defending people who are obviously guilty? Why give them the chance to evade justice? Why should someone like Bill Cosby go free on a technicality, when he was already convicted in a court of law by a jury of his peers? To help answer these questions, our intrepid podcasters turn to a guest speaker: Don Clark, fellow attorney and author of the ne...
2021-08-2034 minIs This Legal?Ep. 59 - What Chrissy Teigen Teaches us About Cyber BullyingSend us a textChrissy Teigen's past social media activity has landed her in trouble recently. In 2014, the model and television personality directed unfavorable tweets at Courtney Stodden, including some that expressed a wish to see Stodden dead. Those tweets have now surfaced, and Teigen finds herself at the center of a renewed national conversation over cyberbullying. Colin and Russ use this incident as a starting point for the latest Is This Legal? episode, exploring the legal definitions and limits of cyberbullying, the consequences, and contrasting Teigen's troubles with the criminal case of Michelle Carter in 2015. Also...
2021-06-1835 minIs This Legal?Ep. 58 - To Record or Not to Record - Interacting with the Police Part 2Send us a textReady for more tips? Russ and Colin keep the legal tips flowing with more advice on what to do and what not to do when you're dealing with the police. If you see someone getting hassled unfairly, are you allowed to record the interaction? When do you have to answer questions that the police inevitably ask, and will it get you arrested if you don't cooperate? What about your Miranda rights? What if they didn't read you your rights? All these questions and more are answered so gather the family around and let the...
2021-06-0441 minIs This Legal?Ep. 57 - To Speak or Not to Speak - Interacting with the Police Part 1Send us a textGet your notepads out! Episode 57 is overflowing with useful advice. In this one, Russ and Colin go over what to say and do, and more importantly what NOT to say and do, when you're dealing with the police in situations that come up in criminal defense all the time. When the cops stop you on the street and ask your name, what should you say? When they execute a traffic stop and ask if you know why you were pulled over, what should you say? All these questions and more are up for...
2021-05-2141 minIs This Legal?Ep. 56 When Does Resisting Arrest Become Resisting Arrest?Send us a textIn this episode, Russ and Colin take you on a tour of the Karen Garner case out of Loveland, CO, using it as a launchpad for a discussion of resisting arrest in general. Does the law uphold the decision of Loveland PD officers to tackle this elderly woman over a minor shoplifting offense, injuring her in the process? Plus, fellow podcaster Joy Parrish stops by to reminisce about her lawbreaking days and play "Is This Legal?" Should be a good one; don't resist the urge to listen!Find the full transcript...
2021-05-0735 minIs This Legal?Ep. 55 - Derek Chauvin - Guilty and Prison BoundSend us a textOn April 20, 2021, former Minneapolis police officer Derek Chauvin was convicted of murdering George Floyd almost a full year before. Floyd’s death while he was restrained face-down on the street elicited nationwide protests, counter-protests, endless news coverage, and impassioned arguments from all sides on the nature of policing in America and the best way to bring law enforcement agencies into harmony with their host communities. In this momentous episode of Is This Legal? Colin and Russ examine the Chauvin trial, talk about the strategies both sides employed, predict the outcome of Chauvin’s sente...
2021-04-2137 minIs This Legal?Ep. 54 - Do You Have a Right to Hate? How America Treats Bias-Motivated CrimeSend us a textTaylor Swift called it: the haters gonna hate hate hate hate hate. Episode 54 of Is This Legal? covers bias-motivated crime in America, from the history of and rationale for hate crime laws as we know them now, to the elements that make an offense go from merely illegal to legally hateful, including real world examples such as the Atlanta massage parlor shootings of this year. With plenty of hypotheticals and thought experiments along the way, attorneys Colin and Russ break down this category of crime into bite-sized pieces for your delectation. Bon appetit!
2021-04-0930 minIs This Legal?Ep. 53 - Take a Gander at This Slander: Sidney Powell, Defamation, and Amish FacebookSend us a textSydney Powell, ex-lawyer to Donald Trump, made numerous statements in the aftermath of the 2020 election accusing Dominion Voting Systems of election crimes. Now, Powell finds herself on the wrong end of a defamation suit filed by Dominion. What defense will she put forward? What elements are required for a successful defamation suit? What's the difference between defamation, libel, and slander? These questions and more are on the docket in this episode of Is This Legal? , along with everyone's favorite recurring segment, Dumb Criminal of the Week.For the full transcript, click...
2021-03-2641 minIs This Legal?Ep. 52 Barking Mad: Dogs and the LawSend us a textCalling all dog fans! Denver attorneys Russell Hebets and Colin McCallin share their love of dogs in the latest lighthearted Is This Legal episode. How are dogs treated under the law, how do dogs run afoul of the dreaded "dangerous animal" designation, and some of the all-time great dogs of pop culture are on the agenda. Curl up with your favorite furry companion and enjoy! For the full transcript, click here.
2021-03-1232 minIs This Legal?Ep. 51 The Tragedy of Elijah McClainSend us a textOne result of the Black Lives Matter protests of 2020 was a resurgence of public interest in Elijah McClain’s death several days after he was given an overdose of ketamine during police contact. In the push for criminal justice reform, McClain’s name has become shorthand for police misconduct and the damage it can do. In this episode of Is This Legal? Russ and Colin examine the detention and death of McClain, the subsequent internal investigations of the incident by the Aurora Police Department, and talk about what lessons this tragedy may hold for...
2021-02-2638 minIs This Legal?Ep. 50 Fake it Until You're Indicted: The Elizabeth Holmes StorySend us a textIn the early 2000s, plucky entrepreneur Elizabeth Holmes dropped out of college and started a company called Theranos, promising to revolutionize blood screenings for medical patients. By 2014, Theranos was valued at almost 10 billion dollars. Fast forward a few years, and Theranos is gone, while Elizabeth Holmes awaits trial later this year on multiple counts of wire fraud. What happened? Criminal defense attorneys Russell Hebets and Colin McCallin take a look at this fascinating case, the likely defenses Ms. Holmes' attorneys will use, and the problems with those defenses. Get your popcorn!F...
2021-02-1236 minIs This Legal?Ep. 49 - Q&A Mailbag - Ask the Experts!Send us a textRuss and Colin dig deep into the Is This Legal mailbag to answer the best and brightest legal questions from our listeners. Topics covered include eating marijuana edibles out of state, criminal charges and gun rights, and the introduction of our brand now segment: Dumb Criminal of the Week! Don't miss out, it's going to be a fun ride!For the full transcript, click here.
2021-01-2933 minIs This Legal?Ep. 48 Insurrection at the CapitolSend us a textColin and Russ break down the criminal charges and other fallout from the storming of the Capitol on January 6, 2021. These charges will be investigated by the FBI in cooperation with other law enforcement groups such as the ATF and the Marshalls Office, and include a cavalcade of protesters turned rioters, some facing decades in federal prison. They examine potential criminal charges of the insurrectionists as well as President Trump himself. Check it out!
2021-01-1534 minIs This Legal?Ep. 47 - Bail and Bondsmen and Bounty Hunters, Oh My!Send us a textYour favorite legal analysts from Hebets & McCallin discuss the cash bond reform craze that is sweeping the nation. From Michigan prosecutor Eli Savit's move to eliminate cash bail, to California's failed bid to remove cash bonds in the most recent election, states are increasingly including bond reform in their general criminal justice reform agenda. Bondsmen and bounty hunters are voicing their objections locally and nationally, despite widespread acknowledgment of wealth and racial disparities in the cash bail system.
2021-01-0833 minIs This Legal?Ep. 46 Legal Year in Review and Holiday SpectacularSend us a textAttorneys Russell Hebets and Colin McCallin make the yuletide gay with a review the year's most notable cases from the Supreme Court and beyond in this holiday spectacular. Cases from Trump's attempt to quash subpoenas to major developments in the rights of religious institutions are explained.
2020-12-2432 minIs This Legal?Ep. 45 You'd Have to be Crazy: The Insanity DefenseSend us a textAttorneys Colin McCallin and Russell Hebets go crazy on the latest episode of Is This Legal. The insanity defense to criminal charges has been around for thousands of years, but has gone through major transformations throughout the years. The guys at Hebets and McCallin talk the attempted assassination of Ronald Reagan by John Hinkley Jr., what happens when someone is found not guilty by reason of insanity, and how difficult it is for defendants to mount an insanity defense. Kick back and go nuts listening!
2020-12-1138 minIs This Legal?Ep. 44 Are Oregon Voters High? Decriminalizing Hard DrugsSend us a textOregon decriminalized personal use of hard drugs with the passage of Measure 110 in the 2020 election. Criminal attorneys and former prosecutors Colin McCallin and Russell Hebets dive into the benefits and risks of this decriminalization. Is decriminalization the same as legalization? Does this apply to all drugs? How will the police and jails be affected by Measure 110? Will decriminalization reduce overdoses and increase treatment, or will it encourage illicit drug use? Will it raise or lower the crime rate? These and other questions will be answered from Russ and Colin’s unique criminal law perspect...
2020-11-1337 minIs This Legal?Ep. 43 Is Drinking and Driving Legal?Send us a textRussell and Colin break down DUI stops, including what you should do, and what you should definitely not due if you've been drinking but aren't drunk driving. Topics include roadside sobriety tests, blood alcohol tests, breath alcohol tests, and refusals, as well as how to interact with the police officer during an alcohol related stop. Pull up a chair, crack a cold one (but not if you're driving), and enjoy all things DUI!
2020-10-3034 minIs This Legal?Ep. 42 Why You Shouldn't Bring a Gun to a Knife FightSend us a textAttorney Russell Hebets and Colin McCallin talk all things self defense; highlighting the arrest of Matt Dollhoff in Denver. When can you use lethal force? Can you use self-defense in defense of others? In defense of property? What happens if someone breaks into your home? When are you justified? All these questions and more are covered for your listening pleasure!
2020-10-1632 minIs This Legal?Ep. 41 Is Donald Trump Going to Jail?Send us a textCan President Donald Trump be charged with a crime in office? Does it matter if it's a federal or state crime? If so, can he pardon himself or use executive privilege to avoid prosecution? How will the 2020 election affect his criminal liability? Can he hide in office for a second term and let the statute of limitations lapse? Let's find out!
2020-10-0230 minIs This Legal?Ep. 40 Legal Trivia: Test Your SmartsSend us a textColin and Russ have dialed up 13 legal trivia questions to keep their faithful listeners on their toes! How many questions can you answer correctly? Have fun and good luck!
2020-09-1831 minIs This Legal?Ep.39 But I Really Didn't Do It! Exonerations through DNA TestingSend us a textColin and Russell discuss the tragedy of wrongful convictions in America. They talk about specific cases of exoneration, how DNA technology has played a role, and the importance of the Innocence Project.
2020-09-0440 minIs This Legal?Ep. 38 Democracy Under Attack? The Post Office ControversySend us a textColin and Russ explain the current controversy regarding President Trump, the Postal Service, and 22 states who have filed a lawsuit claiming their rights to a fair election are being infringed. Let's go postal!
2020-08-2130 min
Is This Legal?Ep. 37 Should We Abolish the Police?Send us a textUsing the scandal-ridden Aurora Police Department as a case study, Colin and Russ discuss the police in 2020 and what practical reforms can be put into place to make police agencies better, for both their officers and the communities they police.
2020-08-0738 min
Is This Legal?Ep. 36 The Scoop on SCOTUSSend us a textColin and Russ give you the skinny on the highest court in the USA. They take on all things Supreme Court in this fact-packed episode!
2020-07-2430 min
Is This Legal?Ep. 35 Are Mask Mandates Constitutional?Send us a textMasks or no masks? Colin and Russ discuss the laws regarding how businesses and governments can require (or not) facial mask coverings in the wake of COVID-19.
2020-07-1023 min
Is This Legal?Ep. 34 Q&A Mailbag- Ask the Experts!Send us a textColin and Russ answer questions from the listener mailbag. Contact us on twitter @IsThisLegalPod or on our FB page- HebetsMcCallin if you have a question for an upcoming episode! Also- NEW THEME MUSIC! Thanks Jason!
2020-06-2629 min
Is This Legal?Ep. 33 The Killing of Rayshard BrooksSend us a textColin and Russ break down the charges that two Atlanta police officers are facing for their roles in the killing of Rayshard Brooks.
2020-06-1834 min
Is This Legal?Ep. 32 The Killing of George FloydSend us a textColin and Russ examine the tragic killing of George Floyd from a legal perspective. How will the prosecutor handle the case? What are possible defenses? Are the other three officers culpable? Russ and Colin try to make sense of the legal issues.
2020-06-0343 min
Is This Legal?BONUS EPISODE - Wisconsin COVID-19 UpdateSend us a textHebets & McCallin updates the latest developments in the Wisconsin Supreme Court legal battle pitting GOP opponents of the Stay at Home Order against the Governor.
2020-05-1405 min
Is This Legal?Ep. 31 Do COVID-19 Lockdowns Violate Civil Rights?Send us a textColin and Russ discuss the constitutional authority of the President, Governors, and Mayors with regard to lockdowns and stay at home orders, and what happens if these orders are in conflict with one another.
2020-05-0527 min
Is This Legal?Ep. 30 COVID-19 and the LawRuss and Colin break down how the Coronavirus, or COVID-19 is wreaking havoc with the criminal justice system, and how judges, prosecutors, and defense attorneys are responding.
2020-03-3028 min
Is This Legal?Ep. 29 Everything You Never Knew You Didn't Know About Criminal LawSend us a textCivil v. Criminal? Felony v. Misdemeanor? Prosecutor v. Defense lawyer? Jail v. Prison? Colin and Russ go back to basics with this primer on general criminal law topics. See how you do on our quiz at the end of the episode!
2020-01-3142 min
Is This Legal?Ep. 28 May the Fourth Be With You! Part 2Send us a textRuss and Colin are back with part 2 of their discussion of the Fourth Amendment. Can the police search your car? How about your phone? Do you have to provide your passcode? We answer these questions and more!
2019-12-2138 min
Is This Legal?Ep. 27 May the Fourth Be With You! Part OneSend us a textIn this multi-part episode, Colin and Russ introduce the Fourth Amendment of the US Constitution. They discuss its importance, history, interpretation by the Supreme Court, and whether or not the cops need a warrant to enter your weed grow house, etc.
2019-12-1338 min
Is This Legal?Ep. 26 Marijauna Now- How High Are We?Send us a textColin and Russ talk about the legality of marijuana in 2019. Can you mail weed? Do the feds care about marijuana anymore? Can you get a loan from a bank to set up a dispensary? We tackle all these and more in our latest ep!
2019-09-2728 min
Is This Legal?Ep. 25 Prison's Right to Privacy?Send us a textColin and Russ discuss the role of private prison and other for-profit enterprises involved in the criminal justice system, and whether they belong there at all.
2019-09-0927 min
Is This Legal?Ep. 24 But I Didn't Mean to Kill Anyone...Send us a textIn this episode, Russ and Colin look at the different mental states required to demonstrate proof of a crime with a wildly hilarious hypothetical situation that will blow (someone's) mind!
2019-06-1428 min
Is This Legal?Ep. 23 Legal Mythbusters, Round 2Send us a textWhen can you use deadly force on an intruder? If the cop got my name wrong on my ticket, my case is dismissed right? Can I get a DUI on horseback? Due to popular demand, Colin and Russ are back at it debunking legal myths! Check it out!
2019-03-2235 min
Is This Legal?Ep. 22 Where's The Body?Send us a textIn this episode, Colin and Russ talk about the legal concept of corpus delecti- evidence needed for a criminal case to go forward. Can you be convicted of murder without a corpse? We talk serial killers, Natalee Holloway, and pros and cons of this obscure rule.
2019-02-2127 min
Is This Legal?Ep. 21 Michael Cohen, Paul Manafort And Witness FlippingSend us a textDon't flip out! In this episode, Russ and Colin talk about witness flipping. In the wake of the guilty pleas entered into by Paul Manafort and Michael Cohen, we examine why, and under what circumstances witnesses turn on others in their criminal enterprise.
2018-09-2626 min
Is This Legal?Ep. 20 Gun Laws In AmericaSend us a textJust over 2 weeks removed from the Parkland, FL school shooting, Russ and Colin provide an overview of gun laws in America. They cover the 2nd Amendment, the Supreme Court opinion that gave it new life, and gun control measures currently on the books.
2018-03-0231 min
Is This Legal?Ep. 11 The Great Clown Panic Of 2016Send us a textCriminal Defense Attorneys Colin McCallin and Russell Hebets break down various topics in criminal law. In this episode: Clowns! We discuss the creepy clown appearances across the country that have us scared silly. Have any laws been broken? We discuss. So put on your squeaky red nose and give us a listen!
2016-10-1024 min