Shows
Mama Mystery with Kelly EvansThe Weekly Docket : A Missing Woman's Shocking Return, Church Camp Chaos, Cold-Case Confession, Fatal Neglect, and a Bizarre KidnappingOn this week’s Weekly Docket, we cover five shocking cases making headlines. First, an Arkansas woman missing for over a year is found alive, leaving her family stunned and desperate for answers. Next, we unpack the troubling scene in Iowa where 88 children were abruptly removed from a church summer camp amid serious abuse allegations. Then, we revisit the infamous Matthew Muller case, as the Netflix star finally confesses to a brutal kidnapping from three decades ago. In Florida, a disturbing trial reveals a grandson’s horrific neglect leading to his grandmother’s tragic death. And lastly, in Tennessee, a bizarre...2025-06-2734 min
Mama Mystery with Kelly EvansEp 205 : From Harvard Alumna to Mass Murderer : Dr. Amy BishopAmy Bishop was supposed to be the classic success story: a Harvard-educated biologist, devoted mom of four, and respected professor climbing the academic ladder. But beneath her impressive résumé was a history of buried secrets, unchecked rage, and disturbing red flags that no one seemed willing to acknowledge. Until one cold afternoon in February 2010, when Amy walked into a faculty meeting armed with a loaded gun, ruining lives and revealing a past that would make everyone wonder...was this shocking violence really so unexpected after all?
This is the story of Amy Bishop.
Learn more about your ad choices. Vi...2025-06-2455 min
Mama Mystery with Kelly EvansThe Weekly Docket : Karen Read VERDICT!, 796 Babies found in a septic tank, Search for 3 year old Claire Bell, and an Attack on 2 MN Lawmakers1. (1:08) The Karen Read Verdict
2. (8:18) 796 Babies in the Septic Tank – The Mother and Baby Home Tragedy
3. (16:31) Christina Formella Case Updates – A Teacher’s Shocking & Explicit Texts to Student
4. (25:24) Rachel Todd’s Arrest and the Search for 3-Year-Old Claire Bell
5. (34:10) Attack on Two Minnesota Lawmakers by Vance Luther Boelter
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoicesSupport this podcast at — https://redcircle.com/mama-mystery-with-kelly-evans6609/donations2025-06-2048 min
Mama Mystery with Kelly EvansEp 204 : Two Days Before ‘I Do’: The Murder of Molly WatsonJust two days before her dream Disney-themed wedding, Molly Watson was found murdered on a quiet Missouri backroad, shot execution-style. Molly had believed she’d finally found her soulmate in James Addie, her fiancé and coworker. But as investigators dug deeper, they uncovered a chilling secret: James was living a double life, hiding a wife of 23 years and spinning a web of lies so tangled it stunned even seasoned detectives. This episode unravels the shocking events leading up to Molly’s tragic end, revealing twisted motives, devastating betrayal, and the courtroom battle that finally brought justice to Molly and her griev...2025-06-171h 00
Mama Mystery with Kelly EvansThe Weekly Docket : Father on the Run, First-Date Murder Conviction, Jersey Mike’s Rescue, and Karen Read Trial Bombshells1:00 - Manhunt for Travis Decker – Father on the Run in Washington
11:01 - “First Date” Murder Trial – Maxwell Anderson and the Death of Sade Robinson
21:05 - A Note in the Sandwich Shop – Florida Woman Rescued from Months of Captivity
29:08 - The Karen Read Trial : The Defense RESTS!
Sources:
Washington triple-murder manhunt – Fox 13 Seattle (Tyler Slauson & Alejandra Guzman) ; NPR News ; Associated Press .
Maxwell Anderson trial – WISN 12 Milwaukee ; CNN/WYMT News .
Florida captivity rescue – PEOPLE.com (Christina Coulter) ; KATV/WKRC report ; WEAR ABC3 News .
Karen Read trial – Boston.com live updates ; WCVB 5 Boston ; CBS Boston (WBZ) ; Court testimony via AP/Pool .
Learn more about your ad choices. Vis...2025-06-1349 min
Mama Mystery with Kelly EvansEp 203 : The Turbulent Life and Tragic Fall of Aaron Hernandez: Fame, Football, and Fatal DecisionsIn this episode, Austin and I dive into the complicated life and shocking downfall of Aaron Hernandez, the NFL player whose promising career unraveled amidst violence and controversy. From his challenging childhood marked by family turmoil, abuse, and hidden trauma, Aaron rose to become a standout high school athlete with immense potential. However, beneath the surface, troubling signs started to emerge...drug use, explosive anger, and several encounters with the law.
We take a close look at Aaron’s college years at the University of Florida, where his football success continued, but off-field incidents were routinely overlooked due to his ta...2025-06-101h 28Mama Mystery with Kelly EvansThe Weekly Docket : Washington Family Tragedy, Chrisley Pardons, JP Miller’s Shocking Wedding, and Karen Read Trial Drama0:00 Father, Travis Decker, Murdered 3 Daughters and is On The Run
9:52 JP Miller Remarries
13:58 Todd and Julie Chrisley Pardoned by Trump
20:13 Karen Read Trial Updates
Keywords: Karen Read, Micah, Micah Miller, Chrisleys, Travis Decker, true crime, trial updates, forensic evidence, witness testimonies, evidence tampering, public perception, media influence, legal analysis, Trump
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoicesSupport this podcast at — https://redcircle.com/mama-mystery-with-kelly-evans6609/donations2025-06-0654 minMama Mystery with Kelly EvansEp 202 : The Villisca Axe Murders : Unsolved Iowa Massacre of 1912In this episode, we take a detailed deep dive into one of America’s darkest and most haunting unsolved mysteries: The Villisca Axe Murders. On a quiet night in June of 1912, the peaceful town of Villisca, Iowa, was shaken by the brutal murder of the Moore family and their two young guests. Eight innocent victims, bludgeoned in their sleep with their own axe.
Go to https://zbiotics.com/MAMA and use MAMA at checkout for 15% off any first time orders of ZBiotics probiotics.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoicesSupport this podcast at — https://redcircle...2025-06-0351 min
Mama Mystery with Kelly EvansThe Weekly Docket : Harvard Morgue Scandal, OnlyFans Revenge Murder, and the Shocking ‘Pop-Tart’ Abuse Case1. (1:11) “Harvard Morgue Scandal: Former Manager Pleads Guilty to Selling Stolen Body Parts”
2. (6:06) “Deadly Hit-and-Run Horror: Alabama Man Charged with Killing Woman Using Her Own Car”
3. (9:58) “Florida Man’s Shocking Rampage: Survives Alligator Attack Only to Be Fatally Shot by Police”
4. (15:50) “OnlyFans Model’s Revenge Murder: Coast Guard Veteran Pleads Guilty to Killing Alleged Rapist”
5. (23:35) “Arkansas ‘Pop-Tart’ Abuse Case: Couple Charged with Torturing and Starving Young Girl”
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoicesSupport this podcast at — https://redcircle.com/mama-mystery-with-kelly-evans6609/donations2025-05-3031 min
Mama Mystery with Kelly EvansThe Weekly Docket: Diddy Trial Shocks, TikTok Star’s Livestream Murder, Manhattan CEO Assassination, and Hawaii Bullying Attack(0:35) Hawaii Bullying Horror: Teens Arrested After Brutal Attack on Special-Needs Woman Sparks Viral Outrage
(6:17) CEO Murdered in Manhattan: Luigi Mangione’s Trial for Killing UnitedHealthcare Executive Sparks Political Firestorm
(11:42) South Carolina House of Horrors: Infant Rescued, Over 40 Animals Found Amid Shocking Neglect
(18:27) Diddy Trial Bombshells: Cassie’s Emotional Testimony, Kid Cudi’s Car Bombing, and Shocking Allegations
(34:51) Valeria Márquez Livestream Murder: TikTok Influencer Tragically Shot on Camera – Investigation and Theories
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoicesSupport this podcast at — https://redcircle.com/mama-mystery-with-kelly-evans6609/donations2025-05-2343 min
Mama Mystery with Kelly EvansEp 201 : The Suspicious Disappearance of Kyron HormanIn this episode, we’re diving deep into the haunting disappearance of Kyron Horman, the 7-year-old boy who vanished from Skyline Elementary School in Portland, Oregon, on June 4, 2010. After posing proudly in front of his science fair project, Kyron seemingly vanished into thin air sparking Oregon’s largest-ever search effort.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoicesSupport this podcast at — https://redcircle.com/mama-mystery-with-kelly-evans6609/donations2025-05-2059 min
Mama Mystery with Kelly EvansTHE WEEKLY DOCKET: Menendez Brothers Parole, Diddy Trial Bombshells, Blake Lively & Taylor Swift Blackmail Drama, and More1:09 - Menendez Brothers Resentenced – A Chance at Parole After 35 Years
6:31 - Sean “Diddy” Combs Trial: Shocking Testimony and Bombshell Revelations
15:08 - The Alexander Brothers: Luxury Real Estate Moguls Charged with Sex Trafficking (Including a Minor)
23:21 - Cape Girardeau Tragedy: Cacey Bright Allegedly Shoots Her Adult Daughter with Down Syndrome
32:56 - University of Idaho Murders Case: Bryan Kohberger’s Road to Trial and New Revelations
44:05 - BAD BLOOD: Blake Lively allegedly tried to BLACKMAIL Taylor Swift?!
Request a case AND order a copy of Wicked Women, a collection of true crime stories, at MamaMystery.com!
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit po...2025-05-1655 min
Mama Mystery with Kelly EvansBONUS : Karen Read Trial Day 14 RECAPYesterday, we were shown unseen footage of Brian Higgins strolling around the Canton PD an hour or so after Karen Read dropped John O'Keefe off at the house on Fairview Road. The surveillance showed him doing various things like moving vehicles and transfering items from one car to another... but even more curiously, it showed him talking on the phone despite him denying that he made any phone calls that night. So, who was he talking to that late at night? And what were they talking about?....
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoicesSupport...2025-05-1423 min
Mama Mystery with Kelly EvansBONUS : Karen Read Trial Days 7-13 RECAP!In this episode, I recap Days 7–13 of the Karen Read trial, and things got intense. Since it's a lot to cover, here are the timestamps of each day:
Day 7 (1:25) Jen McCabe is still on the stand, cross with Alan Jackson.
Day 8 (9:00) Paramedic, Katie McLaughlin, reveals Karen’s alleged confession at the scene.
Day 9 (30:26) Emotional voicemails and forensic evidence link Karen's SUV to the crime.
Day 10 (38:05) Digital forensics clarify disputed Google search timeline.
Day 11 (49:30) Evidence mishandling creates courtroom confusion.
Day 12 (58:00) Investigator faces tough cross-examination over integrity concerns.
Day 13 (1:12:00) Defense introduces alternative theories, questioning key witnesses and evidence.
Learn more about your ad choi...2025-05-131h 26
Mama Mystery with Kelly EvansThe Weekly Docket: Superintendent’s Scandal, Amish Country Murder, and Cold Cases Finally Solved1. 2:00 “Zachary Nehus Arrest: Hot Springs Superintendent’s Husband Faces Child Porn Charges Again”
2. 22:38 “Clark Perry Baldwin Convicted: Serial Killer Truck Driver Finally Found Guilty After 30 Years”
3. 27:00 “Michael Pitt Charged: ‘Boardwalk Empire’ Actor Faces Serious Sexual Assault and Abuse Allegations”
5. 31:10 “Former WWF Star Michael Droese Arrested in Dark Web Child Porn Sting”
6. 35:42 “Amish Community Shaken: Samuel Hochstetler Charged in Rosanna Kinsinger’s Murder”
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoicesSupport this podcast at — https://redcircle.com/mama-mystery-with-kelly-evans6609/donations2025-05-0942 min
Mama Mystery with Kelly EvansEp 200 : Roger Keith Coleman : Virginia's Most Controversial ExecutionIn 1981, Wanda McCoy was brutally murdered in the small town of Grundy, Virginia. Her brother-in-law, Roger Keith Coleman, quickly became the prime suspect. Despite Coleman’s consistent claims of innocence, he was convicted and sentenced to death. This controversial case captured national attention, leading to public campaigns, media coverage, and intense debates about the death penalty and wrongful convictions. In an unprecedented move years after Coleman’s execution, posthumous DNA testing finally revealed the shocking truth. But what does this story tell us about the flaws and strengths in our justice system, our perceptions of guilt and innocence, and the power...2025-05-0645 min
Mama Mystery with Kelly EvansThe Weekly Docket: NJ Vigilante Killing, New England Serial Killer Fears, Teen Dating App Murder, and More True Crime Headlines0:45 Deadly Confrontation Over Alleged Assault in Vineland, NJ
5:00 Serial Killer Fears After 8 Bodies Found in New England
15:00 Kansas City Firefighter-Paramedic Stabbed to Death by Ambulance Patient
20:41 Teen Mom Lured to Her Death via Dating App – Florida “Killer Couple” Case
29:00 Missing Missouri Teen Rescued 700 Miles Away in Colorado – Thanks to Instagram
35:40 California Man Predicts His Own Murder on Facebook – And It Comes True
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoicesSupport this podcast at — https://redcircle.com/mama-mystery-with-kelly-evans6609/donations2025-05-0243 min
Mama Mystery with Kelly EvansBONUS : Karen Read Trial Day 6 RECAP!Recapping the events of April 29th in the Karen Read ReTrial! Jen McCabe takes the stand and Judge Bev issues a stern warning to the Defense regarding their relationship with ARCCA.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoicesSupport this podcast at — https://redcircle.com/mama-mystery-with-kelly-evans6609/donations2025-04-3038 min
Mama Mystery with Kelly EvansBONUS : Karen Read Trial Day 5 RECAP!In Day 5, we heard from forensic data analyist and product manager for Cellbrite, Ian Whiffin, regarding the infamous google search, "hos long to die in cold". Then, there was a voir dire for the two ARCCA experts, Daniel Wolfe and Andrew Rentschler. We're still waiting to hear if their testimony, which is CRUCIAL to the defense, will be allowed by Judge Cannone.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoicesSupport this podcast at — https://redcircle.com/mama-mystery-with-kelly-evans6609/donations2025-04-2920 minMama Mystery with Kelly EvansEp 199 : The Wichita Massacre : The Carr BrothersIn this episode, we’re diving into one of the most brutal and heartbreaking cases in Kansas history—the Wichita Massacre. Over the course of just six days in December 2000, brothers Reginald and Jonathan Carr left a trail of unimaginable violence across the city of Wichita. Their crimes included robbery, rape, and the cold-blooded execution of five innocent people. But as horrifying as their spree was, this story is also about survival, resilience, and the strength of one woman who lived to tell the tale. We walk through every detail from the Carr brothers’ troubled upbringings to the night that foreve...2025-04-291h 03
Mama Mystery with Kelly EvansBONUS EPISODE : Karen Read Trial Recap : DAY 3 & 4In Day 3 of Karen Read’s trial, jurors heard revealing text messages between Karen and John O’Keefe, highlighting tension and insecurity in their relationship. The prosecution presented a controversial clip from a recent interview, where Karen described John’s mother, Peggy, remarking, “It looks like he got hit by a car.” The day wrapped up early due to scheduling conflicts, with the trial set to resume with a visit to the scene where John’s body was discovered.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoicesSupport this podcast at — https://redcircle.com/mama-mystery-with-kelly-evans6609/donations2025-04-2508 min
Mama Mystery with Kelly EvansBONUS EPISODE : Karen Read Trial Recap : DAY 2The second trial of the Commonwealth vs. Karen Read started this week and I break it down each day for you in 30 minutes or less! If you appreciate this kind of content, please share it with a friend and I would love you forever!
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoicesSupport this podcast at — https://redcircle.com/mama-mystery-with-kelly-evans6609/donations2025-04-2513 min
Mama Mystery with Kelly EvansThe Weekly Docket : FSU Shooting, Belize Plane Hijacking, Judge Convicted of Wife's Murder?!TIMESTAMPS:
(0:36) Florida State University Shooting: Phoenix Ikner Identified as Shooter in Campus Tragedy
(4:20) Cold Case Solved: Paul Hicks Arrested for Wife Regina Rowe Hicks’ 2001 Murder
(7:15) Bronx Apartment Horror: 4-Year-Old Girl Found Alive with Bodies of Mother and Brother
(9:57) Easter Family Tragedy: Shatice Jackson Charged After Killing Ex-Boyfriend Mickese Bostic
(12:12) Mid-Air Hijacking Foiled: Armed Passenger Takes Down Attacker on Belize Tropic Air Flight
(15:30) El Paso Walmart Shooter Patrick Crusius Sentenced to Life Without Parole
(18:00) California Judge Jeffrey Ferguson Convicted of Murder After Texting Confession
(21:36) Teen Arrested for Poisoning Mother’s Milk with Bleach in Volusia County, Florida
(24:27) Some Good News! : ‘Tornado Tortois...2025-04-2528 min
Mama Mystery with Kelly EvansBONUS EPISODE: Karen Read Trial Recap : DAY 1The second trial of the Commonwealth vs. Karen Read started yesterday and I break it down for you in 30 minutes or less! If you appreciate this kind of content, please share it with a friend and I would love you forever.
2:50 - The Prosecution’s Opening Statement
6:19 - The Defense’s Opening Statement
15:15 - Facts vs. Speculation
21:35 - What will be different this time?
25:15 - Testimonies from Day 1
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoicesSupport this podcast at — https://redcircle.com/mama-mystery-with-kelly-evans6609/donations2025-04-2430 minMama Mystery with Kelly EvansEp 198 : The Disappearance of Brian ShafferIn April 2006, 27-year-old medical student Brian Shaffer walked into a popular college bar in Columbus, Ohio and never walked out. Despite security footage showing him entering the Ugly Tuna Saloona, no camera ever caught him leaving. With no sign of struggle, no use of his bank accounts, and no trace of him anywhere, Brian’s disappearance has baffled investigators for nearly two decades. In this episode, we dig into the eerie timeline, explore the suspicious behavior of those closest to him, and unpack the theories—both logical and bizarre—that still swirl around this case. Did Brian vanish on purpose? Was fo...2025-04-2240 min
Mama Mystery with Kelly EvansIntroducing: The Weekly DocketThe Weekly Docket is a new segment I'm introducing where I discuss some of the top headlines from the week! Let me know what you think!
1:00 Menendez Brothers Update
5:30 Indiana Cold Case, Solved After 50+ Years
8:10 Missing 82-year-old Found Buried in Concrete
11:25 Berlin Doctor Accused of Killing 15 Patients
14:51 Huge Update in the Grant Solomon Story
Want to request a case? Go to MAMAMYSTERY.com and fill out the form on the landing page.
For Spotify listeners, Listen to the Grant Solomon (episode 131) story here: https://open.spotify.com/episode/3S0A6dxEIHUdXsnU4FXdw7?si=w8-gAacnTb2aupfNpZ1GQg
For Apple listeners, Lis...2025-04-2122 minMama Mystery with Kelly EvansIN THE NEWS: Stabbing at Frisco, TX High School Track Meet : Karmelo Anthony and Austin MetcalfI'm interrupting our typical schedule to release an extra episode about this case as it is currently developing in Frisco, TX. Karmelo Anthony, a 17 year old student is accused of stabbing 17 year old Austin Metcalf at a track meet after Karmelo refused to leave the tent where Austin and his teammates were sheltering from the rain. An altercation ensued and Austin ultimately lost his life, bleeding to death in his twin brother's arms. Karmelo and his supporters are claiming that this was in self-defense and a GoFundMe account has raised over $450,000 at the time of this recording in support of...2025-04-1830 minMama Mystery with Kelly EvansEp 197 : The Mysterious Death of Noah PresgroveToday we’re diving into a case that has left a small Oklahoma community searching for answers and the internet buzzing with theories. It’s the story of a 19-year-old recent high school grad named Noah Presgrove, who went to a party with friends over Labor Day weekend 2023 and never came home. Instead, in the early hours of Labor Day, Noah’s naked, battered body was found lying on the side of a rural highway. From the start, nothing about the scene made sense; not to Noah’s family, not to the local sheriff, and not to the many people followin...2025-04-1651 minMama Mystery with Kelly EvansEp 196 : Paul Warner Powell : Murder, Mistakes, & a Shocking ConfessionGo to zbiotics.com/MAMA and use MAMA at checkout for 15% off any first time orders of ZBiotics probiotics!
Try BEAM's best selling Dream Powder by going to shopbeam.com/MAMA and use code MAMA at checkout for up to 40% off!
In this episode, I dive deep into the disturbing case of Paul Warner Powell, a story that shook Virginia and stunned the nation. Paul's brutal crime and shocking lack of remorse left a community searching for justice and answers. Join me as I break down the timeline of events, explore his twisted motivations, and discuss the courtroom drama that ulti...2025-04-081h 04Mama Mystery with Kelly EvansEp 195 : The Disappearance of Jonelle Matthews & The Latest on Kei'Mani LatigueIn this episode, I'm diving into two haunting cases that underscore the vulnerability of childhood. First, we revisit the chilling disappearance of 12-year-old Jonelle Matthews, who vanished from her Colorado home in 1984, leaving her family and an entire community desperate for answers for decades. Then, we share the heartbreaking recent story of Kei’Mani Latigue, a vibrant 13-year-old girl from Toledo, Ohio, whose promising life was brutally cut short, allegedly by her own father.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoicesSupport this podcast at — https://redcircle.com/mama-mystery-with-kelly-evans6609/donations2025-04-0134 minMama Mystery with Kelly EvansEp 194 : Patty Prewitt - A Mother's 40 Year Fight for FreedomPatty Prewitt was a mother of five, a small-town business owner, and by all accounts, a devoted wife...until one night in 1984 shattered everything. After her husband was found shot in their bed, Patty reported a violent home invasion and sexual assault. But investigators quickly turned their focus to her and never looked back. In this episode, we walk through Patty’s story in real time. From her life before the murder to the deeply flawed investigation, trial, and her nearly four decades behind bars for a crime she’s always said she didn’t commit.
Learn more about your ad cho...2025-03-2549 minMama Mystery with Kelly EvansBONUS EPISODE : The Tragic Story of Ryan Waller with The Weird True Crime Podcast : Part TwoIn this episode, we hear from the Weird True Crime Podcast about the haunting case of Ryan Waller, a young man involved in a tragic home invasion that left him critically injured and wrongly accused. This shocking story raises serious questions about police misconduct, justice, and the devastating aftermath for victims and families.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoicesSupport this podcast at — https://redcircle.com/mama-mystery-with-kelly-evans6609/donations2025-03-2159 minMama Mystery with Kelly EvansEp 193 : The Tragic Death of Evelyn BoswellIn this deep-dive, we uncover the tragic case of 15-month-old Evelyn Boswell, a little girl whose disappearance and murder shook the nation. Evelyn was last seen in November 2019, but no one reported her missing until February 2020—and the person at the center of the investigation was her own mother, Megan Boswell.
From shocking interviews to false leads, we break down Megan’s tangled web of lies and deception, the heartbreaking discovery of Evelyn’s body, and the trial that led to justice. This case is one of manipulation, neglect, and deceit—and we leave no stone unturned.
Learn more about your ad choices. Vis...2025-03-1854 min
Mama Mystery with Kelly EvansBONUS EPISODE : The Tragic Story of Ryan Waller with The Weird True Crime PodcastIn this episode, we hear from the Weird True Crime Podcast about the haunting case of Ryan Waller, a young man involved in a tragic home invasion that left him critically injured and wrongly accused. This shocking story raises serious questions about police misconduct, justice, and the devastating aftermath for victims and families.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoicesSupport this podcast at — https://redcircle.com/mama-mystery-with-kelly-evans6609/donations2025-03-1456 minMama Mystery with Kelly EvansEp 192 : The Disappearance of Maura MurrayThe disappearance of Maura Murray is one of the most baffling missing persons cases of the 21st century. On February 9, 2004, Maura, a 21-year-old nursing student at UMass Amherst, vanished without a trace after her car was found abandoned on a remote stretch of Route 112 in Woodsville, New Hampshire. The eerie nature of her sudden disappearance, combined with the layers of mystery and unanswered questions, has led to decades of speculation.
Was Maura running away from her life? Did she meet with foul play? Or was she simply in the wrong place at the wrong time? While police have considered the...2025-03-1155 minMama Mystery with Kelly EvansEp 191 : Amanda Riley aka, "Scamanda"Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoicesSupport this podcast at — https://redcircle.com/mama-mystery-with-kelly-evans6609/donations2025-02-2553 minMama Mystery with Kelly EvansEp 190 : Blake Lively vs. Justin Baldoni pt 2What started as a behind-the-scenes battle between Blake Lively and Justin Baldoni quickly spiraled into a full-blown Hollywood controversy, dragging in power players like Ryan Reynolds, Taylor Swift, and Sony executives. In this episode, we uncover the manipulations, media strategies, and legal battles behind the fight for creative control over It Ends With Us.
Did Taylor Swift and Ryan Reynolds play a bigger role in sidelining Baldoni? Was Colleen Hoover pressured into choosing sides? And could this entire PR storm have been orchestrated to seize the rights to It Starts With Us? We break down the industry power moves, leaked em...2025-02-1939 minMama Mystery with Kelly EvansEp 189 : Blake Lively vs. Justin Baldoni Part 1When Blake Lively and Justin Baldoni signed on to adapt Colleen Hoover’s bestselling novel It Ends With Us, no one expected it to ignite one of Hollywood’s most shocking legal battles. What started as a highly anticipated film adaptation about domestic violence has now spiraled into a war of lawsuits, social manipulation allegations, PR disasters, and an ugly behind-the-scenes power struggle.
But how did we get here? And who, if anyone, is telling the truth? Let’s break down the entire saga - chronologically, factually, and with every key detail intact.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices...2025-02-111h 24Mama Mystery with Kelly EvansEp 188 : Kansas City Serial Killer John RobinsonTHIS IS A REPLAY OF EP 67 - So please forgive me for the audio quality, I know it's not great. But I'm working on the most extensive DEEP DIVE for you all on the Blake Lively and Justin Baldoni lawsuit. You guys... this legal battle is insane. Is Blake Lively the next Amber Heard? Find out next week on Mama Mystery!
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoicesSupport this podcast at — https://redcircle.com/mama-mystery-with-kelly-evans6609/donations2025-02-0447 minMama Mystery with Kelly EvansIntroducing: Mind of a Serial KillerWhat makes a serial killer? Mind of a Serial Killer takes you deep into the twisted minds of history’s most notorious serial killers. Every Monday, hosts Vanessa Richardson and Dr. Tristin Engels, a Clinical and Forensic Psychologist, combines gripping true crime storytelling with expert psychological analysis to answer the question - what makes a serial killer? From Jeffrey Dahmer to Ted Bundy, explore not only their chilling crimes but the dark psychology behind them. Follow Mind of a Serial Killer wherever you get your podcasts!
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoicesSupport this podcast...2025-01-2806 minMama Mystery with Kelly EvansEp 187 : Honeymoon Horror : The Tragic Murder of Emily SchwartzIn this episode, we uncover the devastating case of Emily Schwarz, a 22-year-old whose romantic anniversary trip turned into a nightmare. Found dismembered in a camper by her husband, Joseph Ferlazzo, Emily’s tragic death was initially shrouded in lies and conflicting accounts. Joseph claimed self-defense, but the evidence—including post-mortem injuries and a disturbing confession—revealed the truth.
Join Austin and I as we explore Emily’s life, the details of the investigation, and the trial that exposed the shocking actions of the man who vowed to love and protect her. This is a story of betrayal, deception, and the endu...2025-01-2137 minMama Mystery with Kelly EvansEp 186 : The Tragic Story of Telma Boinville : A Brutal Murder That Shook Hawaii’s ParadiseDiscover the heartbreaking story of Telma Boynville, a devoted mother and teacher whose life was forever changed in 2017 during a routine day in Oahu’s North Shore. This shocking crime, involving violence and the abduction of her young daughter, sent shockwaves through Hawaii’s close-knit community. Explore the investigation, courtroom drama, and the lasting impact of this tragedy on her family and beyond.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoicesSupport this podcast at — https://redcircle.com/mama-mystery-with-kelly-evans6609/donations2025-01-1431 minMama Mystery with Kelly EvansEp 185 : The Murder of Kelsey BerrethThe shocking murder of Kelsey Berreth, a 29-year-old Colorado mother and pilot instructor, captivated the nation after she vanished on Thanksgiving Day 2018. Her fiancé, Patrick Frazee, was later convicted of her brutal murder, aided by his ex-girlfriend, Krystal Lee Kenney, who confessed to helping cover up the crime.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoicesSupport this podcast at — https://redcircle.com/mama-mystery-with-kelly-evans6609/donations2025-01-0729 minMama Mystery with Kelly EvansEp 184 : The Bizarre "Disappearance" of Hannah KobayashiJoin me and my special guest, Daisy, as we unravel the mysterious disappearance of Hannah Kobayashi in this gripping episode. From her unexpected detour at LAX to cryptic messages and sightings that left her loved ones searching for answers, we dive deep into the bizarre twists and turns of her case. Plus, special guest Daisy joins the discussion to explore where the investigation stands today.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoicesSupport this podcast at — https://redcircle.com/mama-mystery-with-kelly-evans6609/donations2024-12-1755 minMama Mystery with Kelly EvansEp 183 : Wade Wilson: The ‘Deadpool Killer’ and the Murders of Christine Melton and Diane RuizWade Wilson, infamously dubbed the ‘Deadpool Killer,’ left a trail of violence, deception, and tragedy in October 2019. In this episode of Mama Mystery, we uncover his troubled past, the horrific murders of Christine Melton and Diane Ruiz, and the justice system’s failures that allowed him to escalate. We also explore the unsettling trend of TikTok romanticizing this convicted killer, sparking outrage and questions about the impact of social media. Explore the chilling details of his crimes, his trial, and the death sentence that shocked the nation.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoicesSupport this po...2024-12-1048 minMama Mystery with Kelly EvansEp 182 : How ‘Dr. Love’ Fooled the World and Risked LivesTeenager Malachi Love-Robinson, known as ‘Dr. Love,’ pulled off one of the most audacious frauds in modern history—posing as a doctor, opening a clinic, and treating patients, all without a medical license. In this episode of Mama Mystery, we unravel his shocking scams, from conning vulnerable patients to his arrest in a sting operation. Discover how his lies risked lives and left a trail of deception. Was he a master manipulator or a misguided teen with dangerous ambition? Tune in to explore the rise and fall of ‘Dr. Love.’
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoicesSu...2024-12-0334 minMama Mystery with Kelly EvansEp 181 : The Maddie Russo Cancer ScamWhat if everything you thought you knew about someone—someone you admired, donated to, and rallied around—turned out to be a carefully crafted lie? That’s the story of Maddie Russo, a seemingly courageous 19-year-old college student from Iowa who captured the hearts of thousands with her tearful TikTok updates about battling not one but multiple forms of cancer. Her story was inspiring—she maintained a 4.0 GPA, worked her dream internship, and even supported others through their own battles with illness.
But Maddie’s heartbreaking tale wasn’t just improbable—it was entirely fabricated. From falsified medical details to stolen photos...2024-11-2644 minMama Mystery with Kelly EvansEp 180 : Nicole Brown Simpson and Ron Goldman: The Double Murder That Shook Hollywood, Part 2In this episode of Mama Mystery, we revisit the infamous murders of Nicole Brown Simpson and Ron Goldman—one of the most high-profile double homicides in American history. Found brutally slain outside Nicole’s Brentwood home in 1994, their deaths shocked the nation and set the stage for one of the most controversial trials of the century. We’ll explore the chilling details of the crime scene, the events leading up to the murders, and the evidence that pointed to O.J. Simpson, Nicole’s ex-husband and former NFL star. Was it an open-and-shut case, or did the trial reveal something deeper? J...2024-11-1932 minMama Mystery with Kelly EvansEp 179 : Nicole Brown Simpson and Ron Goldman: The Double Murder That Shook Hollywood, Part 1Today, we're diving into one of the most infamous and polarizing cases in modern history – the murders of Nicole Brown Simpson and Ron Goldman, and the subsequent trial of O.J. Simpson. This case captivated the nation, exposing deep-seated issues of race, celebrity, and justice. We'll explore the backgrounds of O.J., Nicole, and Ron, walk through the events of that fateful night, and delve into the trial that became known as "The Trial of the Century." Buckle up, because this story is a rollercoaster of emotions, evidence, and intrigue.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices2024-11-1244 minMama Mystery with Kelly EvansEp 178 : Mica Miller’s Tragic Death: Suicide or Foul Play in Lumber River State Park?Mica Miller’s life ended tragically in April 2024 when her body was discovered in North Carolina’s Lumber River State Park, the apparent victim of a self-inflicted gunshot wound—or so the official report says. Mica’s family, however, believes otherwise. After years of enduring alleged harassment, manipulation, and abuse from her estranged husband, Pastor John Paul (JP) Miller, Mica had been living in fear for her life. She filed police reports, uncovered GPS trackers on her car, and confided in loved ones about her fears.
In this episode of Mama Mystery, we unravel Mica’s journey from a deeply religious u...2024-11-0537 minMama Mystery with Kelly EvansEp 177 : Alexee Trevizo: The Newborn Tragedy That Shook ArtesiaIn January 2023, 18-year-old Alexee Trevizo went to an emergency room in New Mexico for severe back pain. While there, she secretly gave birth in a hospital bathroom, placing the newborn in a trash bag. When hospital staff discovered the baby, it was too late—the child had died. Alexee initially claimed she didn’t know she was pregnant, but later investigations revealed she had been aware for months.
She was charged with first-degree murder and tampering with evidence, sparking debates about teenage pregnancy, mental health, and responsibility. The case is ongoing, with Alexee’s defense arguing she acted out of panic...2024-10-2948 minMama Mystery with Kelly EvansMM #5Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoicesSupport this podcast at — https://redcircle.com/mama-mystery-with-kelly-evans6609/donations2024-10-2436 minMama Mystery with Kelly EvansEp 176 : The Menendez Brothers: Wealth, Abuse, and the Shocking Beverly Hills MurdersOn August 20, 1989, the privileged lives of Lyle and Erik Menendez took a deadly turn when they murdered their parents, José and Kitty Menendez, in their Beverly Hills mansion. What followed was a tale of family secrets, shocking abuse allegations, and one of the most infamous trials in American history. Were they cold-blooded killers motivated by greed, or victims of lifelong trauma pushed to the brink?
In this episode of Mama Mystery, we explore the tragic backstory of the Menendez family, the chilling details of the murders, and the media frenzy surrounding the brothers’ sensational trial. Decades later, new evidence has reig...2024-10-221h 01Mama Mystery with Kelly EvansBONUS : Delphi Trial : Week 1Covering the opening statements + witness testimonies from Days 1 and 2.
SOURCES:
https://x.com/KylaBRussell
https://www.wishtv.com/news/i-team-8/delphi-murders-audio-video-released-by-police-came-from-libby-germans-iphone/
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1Up3YzCxk5VLlEUyvReuCtUyCZgYhGXkB/view
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoicesSupport this podcast at — https://redcircle.com/mama-mystery-with-kelly-evans6609/donations2024-10-2149 min
Mama Mystery with Kelly EvansMama Minute #4Answering more listener write-ins! If you want to write to us, go to www.mamamystery.com
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoicesSupport this podcast at — https://redcircle.com/mama-mystery-with-kelly-evans6609/donations2024-10-1730 minMama Mystery with Kelly EvansEp 175 : The Lundy Family Murders: A Brutal Crime That Shook New ZealandIn August 2000, the quiet town of Palmerston North, New Zealand, was rocked by the gruesome murders of Christine and Amber Lundy. Christine, a devoted wife, and Amber, a bright 7-year-old, were found brutally killed in their home. The crime scene was chillingly violent, and suspicion quickly turned toward Mark Lundy, Christine’s husband. What followed was a controversial investigation and trial that captivated the nation and raised more questions than answers.
In this episode of Mama Mystery, we delve into the details of this tragic case, from the financial struggles that plagued the Lundy family to the forensic evidence that bec...2024-10-1537 minMama Mystery with Kelly EvansSpecial: Rowan's Story with the Like Mother Like Murder PodcastRowan Milford Morey was found murded in an apparent murder/suicide by the hands of his very own father. Two days before... Rowan was supposed to be dropped back off with his Mother, Brandi and when that didn't happen, she knew something was wrong.
Brandi joined us to share stories of her son, talk about a failed system and what exactly happened from trying to report Rowan missing to when she found out he was no longer with us.
Please listen today and share Rowan's story for everyone to hear. Brandi Morey-Pols is determined to make a difference for parents, ch...2024-10-0946 minMama Mystery with Kelly EvansEp 174 : The Murder of Marie Carlson: Trust, Betrayal, and a Pastor’s Deadly SecretMarie Carlson was a vibrant woman rebuilding her life when she crossed paths with Pastor James Flanders and his wife, Tanya. What began as an act of generosity turned into a dark and twisted relationship that led to Marie’s disappearance in 2011. The truth behind her tragic fate involved a secret polygamous relationship, deceit, and a shocking betrayal by those she trusted most.
In this episode of Mama Mystery, we unravel the details of Marie’s life, the suspicious circumstances surrounding her disappearance, and the relentless investigation that finally uncovered the truth. Join us as we explore the shocking confession, the h...2024-10-0840 min
Mama Mystery with Kelly EvansMama Minute #3Todays topics include:
Listener write-ins!
"Daycare Woes"
Friendships with the opposite sex: Where is the line?
Encouraging entrepreneurship in our kids
Kids draw the darndest things..
Wanna be a part of our next Mama Minute episode?! Write to us!
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoicesSupport this podcast at — https://redcircle.com/mama-mystery-with-kelly-evans6609/donations2024-10-0336 minMama Mystery with Kelly EvansEp 173 : The Kansas Moms Murders: Custody Battles, Conspiracies, and Cold-Blooded CrimeOn March 30, 2024, the lives of Veronica Butler and Jillian Kelly came to a tragic end in a shocking case now known as the Kansas Moms Murders. What began as a custody dispute turned into a horrifying plot involving burner phones, staged accidents, and a chest freezer buried 10 feet deep in a cow pasture. Veronica and Jillian were ambushed and murdered by a group of conspirators led by Tiffany Adams, a woman desperate to stop Veronica from regaining visitation rights to her children.
In this episode of Mama Mystery, we unravel the chilling details of the custody-fueled vendetta that led to t...2024-10-0132 minMama Mystery with Kelly EvansEp 172 : The Downfall of Diddy: Allegations, Abuse, and a Mogul’s Fall from GraceSean ‘Diddy’ Combs, a name synonymous with hip-hop success and entrepreneurial brilliance, now finds himself at the center of one of the most shocking downfalls in entertainment history. From his rise as a cultural icon to his dramatic arrest in 2024, Diddy’s empire has been shaken by allegations of abuse, sex trafficking, and manipulation spanning decades.
In this episode of Mama Mystery, we examine the timeline of events that led to Diddy’s public reckoning, including disturbing ‘Freak Off’ parties, accusations of emotional and physical abuse, and a federal indictment that exposed the dark side of his empire. We’ll also discuss th...2024-09-2752 min
Mama Mystery with Kelly EvansMama Minute #2We're back!! I'm so excited to start creating more of these Mama Minute episodes. It's a chance for Austin and I both to be ourselves and actually communicate with our listeners on a more personal level. In this episode, we respond to some write-ins from our listeners. If you'd like to submit a topic for a Mama Minute, go to MamaMystery.com!
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoicesSupport this podcast at — https://redcircle.com/mama-mystery-with-kelly-evans6609/donations2024-09-1928 minMama Mystery with Kelly EvansEp 171 : The Tragic Murder of Madeline Soto: A Disturbing Case of Betrayal and EvilMadeline Soto was a vibrant 13-year-old girl from Kissimmee, Florida, whose life was tragically cut short in February 2024. What began as a desperate search for a missing child unraveled into a horrifying discovery of betrayal, abuse, and murder. Her disappearance led to the arrest of her mother’s boyfriend, Stephan Sterns, whose dark secrets painted a chilling picture of what happened to Madeline.
In this episode of Mama Mystery, we walk through the haunting details of Madeline’s final days, from surveillance footage showing her last moments to the damning evidence that revealed Stephan’s role in her death. As we unra...2024-09-1635 minMama Mystery with Kelly EvansEp 170 : The Murder of Dan Markel: A Chilling Tale of Custody, Betrayal, and Murder-for-HireDan Markel was a brilliant legal scholar, a devoted father, and a man deeply respected in his field—but his life came to a shocking end on July 18, 2014, when he was gunned down in his driveway in Tallahassee, Florida. What began as a search for a killer uncovered a complex web of family tensions, a bitter custody battle, and a murder-for-hire plot that exposed deep cracks in a seemingly perfect family.
In this episode of Mama Mystery, we unravel the chilling details of Dan’s murder, from the hitmen who carried out the crime to the Adelson family’s desperate attempt...2024-06-0744 minMama Mystery with Kelly EvansEp 169 : Karen Read Pt 2The trial of the State of Massachusetts vs. Karen Read has begun and witnesses are taking the stand. We'll talk about the opening statements and some of the testimony from key players like the first responders on the scene and notably, Colin Albert.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoicesSupport this podcast at — https://redcircle.com/mama-mystery-with-kelly-evans6609/donations2024-05-1836 minMama Mystery with Kelly EvansEp 168 : Karen Read : Was She Framed or Is She a Murderer?Right now, there is a huge case creating a stir within the true crime space and followers of this story are somewhat divided on what they believe happened on the night of January 29, 2022 outside of a home in Canton, Massachusetts. A man named John O’Keefe, a Boston police officer, was found dead in a blizzard outside of a house in the Boston suburb. Just six hours earlier, his girlfriend, Karen Read, dropped him off at the house in Canton, belonging to a mutual friend, Brian Albert. But what happened during those six hours, remains somewhat of a mystery and with two...2024-05-1037 minMama Mystery with Kelly EvansEp 167 : Our Own True Crime StoryThe past 10 days have been a whirlwind and most of it has been very unpleasant. However, today, one of my worst nightmares came to fruition when an intruder broke into part of our home and we were home to confront him. Please listen and consider our story a PSA to make plans for protecting you, your family, and your home.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoicesSupport this podcast at — https://redcircle.com/mama-mystery-with-kelly-evans6609/donations2024-05-0444 minMama Mystery with Kelly EvansEp 166 : Ezra McCandless: Love, Deception, and the Murder of Alex WoodworthEzra McCandless appeared to be a free-spirited artist trying to find her place in the world—but her story took a dark turn on March 22, 2018, when she was found bloodied and barefoot on a rural road in Wisconsin, claiming she had been attacked. What followed was a murder investigation that revealed a web of love, lies, and betrayal.
In this episode of Mama Mystery, we unravel the tragic and chilling details of Alex Woodworth’s death, the volatile relationships that led to his murder, and Ezra’s shocking transformation from victim to suspect. Was she defending herself, or was this a calcu...2024-04-1953 minMama Mystery with Kelly EvansEp 165 :The Laci Peterson Case: A Christmas Eve Tragedy and a Husband’s Betrayal, Part 2Laci Peterson was eight months pregnant and preparing for the arrival of her son, Connor, when she vanished on Christmas Eve in 2002. What began as a hopeful search for a missing woman turned into a devastating murder investigation that captivated the nation. As the world mourned Laci, suspicion quickly fell on her husband, Scott Peterson, whose lies and infidelity unraveled a story of betrayal and heartbreak.
In this episode of Mama Mystery, we revisit the haunting details of Laci’s disappearance, the evidence that pointed to Scott, and the high-profile trial that gripped the country. Was Scott Peterson truly guilty, or...2024-03-111h 05Mama Mystery with Kelly EvansEp 164 : The Laci Peterson Case: A Christmas Eve Tragedy and a Husband’s Betrayal, Part 1Laci Peterson was eight months pregnant and preparing for the arrival of her son, Connor, when she vanished on Christmas Eve in 2002. What began as a hopeful search for a missing woman turned into a devastating murder investigation that captivated the nation. As the world mourned Laci, suspicion quickly fell on her husband, Scott Peterson, whose lies and infidelity unraveled a story of betrayal and heartbreak.
In this episode of Mama Mystery, we revisit the haunting details of Laci’s disappearance, the evidence that pointed to Scott, and the high-profile trial that gripped the country. Was Scott Peterson truly guilty, or...2024-02-2941 minMama Mystery with Kelly EvansEp 163 : The Murder of Becky Bliefnick: A Shocking Tale of Love, Betrayal, and JusticeRebecca ‘Becky’ Bliefnick was a devoted mother, a brilliant nurse, and a beloved member of her Quincy, Illinois, community. But in February 2023, her life was tragically cut short when she was found brutally murdered in her home. The investigation revealed a story of a contentious divorce, disturbing threats, and a trail of evidence that pointed directly to her estranged husband, Timothy Bliefnick—a man once known for his cheerful appearances on Family Feud.
In this episode of Mama Mystery, we dive into the heartbreaking details of Becky’s life and death, the chilling timeline leading up to the murder, and the damnin...2024-02-2149 min
Mama Mystery with Kelly EvansMama Minute : Let's Chat! Feat. Bachelor Week 1 & 2 RecapLearn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoicesSupport this podcast at — https://redcircle.com/mama-mystery-with-kelly-evans6609/donations2024-02-161h 00Mama Mystery with Kelly EvansEp 162 : The Murder of Lauren Hugelmaier: A Deadly Marriage and the ‘Cold Medicine Defense’Lauren Hugelmaier was a bright, compassionate young woman with a close-knit family and a promising future. But her life was cut short in September 2017 in one of the most shocking domestic violence cases to date. Her husband, Matthew Phelps, made a chilling 911 call claiming he had killed Lauren in a dreamlike state, blaming an overdose of cough medicine. What followed was a harrowing investigation into a marriage riddled with financial strain, infidelity, and dark obsessions.
In this episode of Mama Mystery, we uncover the chilling details of Lauren’s murder, the shocking evidence of Matthew’s double life, and the distu...2024-02-0727 minMama Mystery with Kelly EvansEp 161 : The Murder of Brianna Denison: A College Town’s Nightmare and the Hunt for a Serial PredatorOn a cold January night in 2008, 19-year-old Brianna Denison vanished from a friend’s home in Reno, Nevada, leaving behind only a small bloodstain on her pillow. What began as a missing persons case soon unraveled into a chilling hunt for a serial predator responsible for a string of sexual assaults in the area. Tragically, Brianna’s body was found weeks later, confirming every parent’s worst fear.
In this episode of Mama Mystery, we recount the heartbreaking details of Brianna’s abduction and murder, the relentless investigation to track down her killer, and the DNA evidence that finally led to his ca...2024-02-0233 minMama Mystery with Kelly EvansEp 160 : The Murder of Laura Ackerson: A Custody Battle Turned DeadlyLaura Ackerson was a hardworking young mother determined to build a life for herself and her two sons. But her bitter custody battle with her ex-partner, Grant Hayes, turned into a nightmare when Laura vanished in July 2011. Days later, her dismembered remains were discovered in a Texas creek, marking one of the most chilling domestic murder cases in recent history.
In this episode of Mama Mystery, we explore Laura’s tumultuous relationship with Grant, the shocking involvement of his new wife, Amanda Hayes, and the gruesome details of a crime fueled by greed and control. Join us as we unravel the...2024-01-2348 minMama Mystery with Kelly EvansEp 159 : The Murder of Lauren Giddings: A Law Student’s Life Cut Tragically ShortLauren Giddings was a 27-year-old law student preparing for the next chapter of her life when she suddenly vanished in June 2011. Just days after friends and family reported her missing, police discovered her dismembered remains near her apartment complex in Macon, Georgia. The horrifying revelation sent shockwaves through the community, but the most chilling part? Her killer was someone she knew.
In this episode of Mama Mystery, we delve into the tragic case of Lauren Giddings, the meticulous investigation that uncovered the dark and twisted mind of her neighbor, Stephen McDaniel, and the chilling confession that left everyone speechless. Join u...2024-01-1536 minMama Mystery with Kelly EvansEp 158 : The Murder of Megan Nichols: A Missing Teen, A Troubled Boyfriend, and a Heartbreaking DiscoveryMegan Nichols was a bright and talented 15-year-old from Fairfield, Illinois, whose sudden disappearance on July 3, 2014, left her family and community desperate for answers. Initially dismissed as a runaway case, her mysterious disappearance turned into a haunting investigation that spanned years. In 2017, Megan’s remains were discovered in a shallow grave, finally providing the answers her family had been seeking—but also revealing a disturbing truth about those closest to her.
In this episode of Mama Mystery, we uncover Megan’s journey, her tumultuous relationship with Brodey Murbarger, and the chilling evidence that led to his conviction years after her murder...2024-01-0835 minMama Mystery with Kelly EvansEp 157 : The Mysterious Death of Kenneka Jenkins: A Party, A Freezer, and Unanswered QuestionsOn September 10, 2017, 19-year-old Kenneka Jenkins was found dead in a hotel freezer after attending a party at the Crowne Plaza Chicago O’Hare Hotel in Rosemont, Illinois. Her tragic death sparked widespread speculation, fueled by unsettling surveillance footage of Kenneka wandering the hotel halls, clearly intoxicated. How did she end up in the freezer, and could she have been saved?
In this episode of Mama Mystery, we explore Kenneka’s final hours, the missteps that delayed her discovery, and the lingering questions that haunt this case. From conflicting accounts to a $10 million lawsuit settlement, Kenneka’s death remains a heartbreaking reminde...2023-12-1830 minMama Mystery with Kelly EvansEp 156 : Dean Corll: The Candy Man and Houston’s Most Notorious Serial KillerDean Corll, infamously known as ‘The Candy Man,’ was a seemingly ordinary electrician and candy company owner in Houston, Texas. But beneath his friendly exterior lurked one of the most prolific and sadistic serial killers in U.S. history. Between 1970 and 1973, Corll, with the help of two teenage accomplices, Elmer Wayne Henley and David Brooks, tortured and murdered at least 28 young boys in what became known as the Houston Mass Murders.
In this episode of Mama Mystery, we delve into Corll’s chilling double life, the tragic stories of his victims, and the horrifying methods he used to lure his victims...2023-12-1138 minMama Mystery with Kelly EvansEp 155 : The Murder of Ashley Pittman Scott: Love, Control, and a Deadly MarriageAshley Pittman Scott was a beloved teacher, a devoted friend, and a shining light in her Memphis community. But behind the facade of her seemingly perfect life was a volatile marriage that ended in tragedy on Thanksgiving Day in 2006. After a brutal argument with her husband, Jeffrey Scott, Ashley was found unconscious, beaten, and bruised—her injuries far too severe to survive. Jeffrey’s chilling delay in seeking help raised even more questions about the abuse Ashley endured during their marriage.
In this episode of Mama Mystery, we explore Ashley’s journey from a bubbly, magnetic young woman to the victim...2023-12-0436 minMama Mystery with Kelly EvansEp 154 : The Pladl Family Tragedy: A Shocking Tale of Abuse, Incest, and MurderThe Pladl family tragedy is a story almost too bizarre to believe, filled with complex relationships and devastating consequences. It begins with a young woman reconnecting with her biological family, only for this reunion to spiral into a web of manipulation and heartbreak. What started as a search for identity and connection ended in an unimaginable series of events that shocked an entire community.
In this episode of Mama Mystery, we explore the timeline of events leading to this family’s unraveling, the devastating impact on everyone involved, and the lessons that can be drawn from such a haunting case. Joi...2023-11-2033 minMama Mystery with Kelly EvansEp 153 : The Murder of Brenda Powell: A Daughter’s Lies and a Tragic EndBrenda Powell was a beloved mother, a dedicated child life specialist, and a compassionate figure in her Akron, Ohio, community. But on March 3, 2020, her life was cut tragically short in an unthinkable act of violence. Her daughter, Sydney Powell, struggled under the weight of academic failures and mounting anxiety, leading to a shocking confrontation that ended in Brenda’s brutal murder.
In this episode of Mama Mystery, we delve into Sydney’s unraveling, the events that led to her mother’s death, and the subsequent trial that raised questions about mental health, accountability, and justice. Join us as we explore the hea...2023-11-1046 minMama Mystery with Kelly EvansEp 152 : REPLAY : The Girl in the Box: Colleen Stan’s Harrowing Seven-Year OrdealColleen Stan’s story is one of unimaginable horror and resilience. In 1977, the 20-year-old hitchhiker was abducted by Cameron and Janice Hooker in California and held captive for seven years. During her ordeal, Colleen endured physical and psychological abuse, confined for up to 23 hours a day in a coffin-like box beneath her captors’ bed. Manipulated by lies about a sinister organization that would kill her and her family if she escaped, Colleen lived in constant fear and submission.
In this episode of Mama Mystery, we recount the chilling details of Colleen’s captivity, the twisted dynamics between her captors, and her ult...2023-11-0239 minMama Mystery with Kelly EvansEp 151 : Richard Grissom Jr.: The Serial Killer Who Terrorized Kansas CityRichard Grissom Jr. was a charming and intelligent man whose sinister double life left a trail of devastation in Kansas City and beyond. His crimes escalated from theft and burglary to cold-blooded murder, culminating in the disappearance of three young women—Joan Butler, Theresa Brown, and Christine Rusch—in June 1989. Their bodies were never found, but the mountain of evidence against Grissom revealed the calculated and predatory nature of his actions.
In this episode of Mama Mystery, we explore Richard’s troubled past, his manipulative tactics, and the chilling timeline of events that led to his arrest. Join us as we unco...2023-10-2134 minMama Mystery with Kelly EvansEp 150 : The Murder of Lauren McCluskey: A Campus Safety Failure and a Preventable TragedyLauren McCluskey was a talented athlete, dedicated student, and beloved daughter who had a bright future ahead of her. But in October 2018, her life was cut tragically short when she was murdered by an ex-boyfriend on the University of Utah campus. Despite Lauren’s repeated pleas for help and multiple reports to campus and city police about his stalking and harassment, systematic failures allowed her killer to remain free, leading to devastating consequences.
In this episode of Mama Mystery, we recount Lauren’s remarkable life, the timeline of events leading up to her death, and the shocking oversights by law enfor...2023-10-1346 minMama Mystery with Kelly EvansEp 149 : The Murder of Pava LaPere: A Rising Star’s Life Stolen by a Random Act of ViolencePava LaPere was a brilliant 26-year-old entrepreneur, Forbes 30 Under 30 honoree, and a passionate advocate for her Baltimore community. But in September 2023, her life was tragically cut short in a senseless act of violence. Pava was found murdered on the rooftop of her apartment building, her death leaving behind a devastated family, friends, and a city mourning the loss of one of its brightest stars.
In this episode of Mama Mystery, we delve into the details of Pava’s inspiring life, the tragic circumstances surrounding her murder, and the shocking criminal history of her alleged killer, Jason Billingsley. Join us as we...2023-10-0623 minMama Mystery with Kelly EvansEp 148 : The Murder of Doug Benefield: A Ballerina, a Whirlwind Romance, and Deadly BetrayalDoug Benefield was a charismatic entrepreneur, a Navy veteran, and a devoted father when he crossed paths with Ashley Benefield, a former ballerina half his age. Their whirlwind romance and secret marriage shocked those around them, but it was their tumultuous relationship, filled with accusations of abuse, betrayal, and power struggles, that eventually turned deadly. On September 27, 2020, Doug was fatally shot by Ashley in what she claimed was self-defense—a claim that investigators and the courts have heavily scrutinized.
In this episode of Mama Mystery, we explore the dramatic rise and fall of their relationship, the bizarre and troubled history of...2023-09-2946 minMama Mystery with Kelly EvansEp 147 : The Jessica Boynton Case: A Closet, A Gun, and a Story That Doesn’t Add UpJessica Boynton was just 19 years old, a young mother of two, and navigating a tumultuous marriage to a police officer when her life took a shocking turn. On April 14, 2016, a late-night argument ended with Jessica locked in a closet, found later by officers lying in a pool of blood with what was believed to be a self-inflicted gunshot wound. But as the investigation unfolded, questions emerged: How could there be two bullet holes in the wall, but no bullet wound? And why did Jessica’s version of events conflict with her husband Matthew’s story?
In this episode of Mama Myste...2023-09-2247 min
Mama Mystery with Kelly EvansIntroducing: Murder, She ToldMurder, She Told is an award-winning true-crime podcast created by victim’s advocate, Kristen Seavey, that dives into the lesser-known cold cases and true crime stories from New England and beyond. Murder, She Told uses detailed and documentary style storytelling: weaving in original interviews with family, friends, and investigators closest to the case. Rooted in deep research, straightforward narratives, and the victims and their family at the center of every story, Murder, She Told will speak to any listener no matter where they call home. This is an excerpt from the episode, “The Danielle Bertolini Story”, published in July of 2023.
Listen...2023-09-1807 minMama Mystery with Kelly EvansEp 146 : The Murder of Mary Collins: Betrayal, Injustice, and a Family’s Fight for JusticeMary Collins was a 20-year-old woman with a heart full of love, a bright future, and a trusting nature that endeared her to everyone who met her. But in March 2020, her kindness was exploited in the most horrific way. Lured to an apartment under false pretenses by people she believed were her friends, Mary was brutally murdered, her body hidden for days before being discovered.
In this episode of Mama Mystery, we recount Mary’s tragic story, from her vibrant life and struggles with 22q—a rare genetic condition—to the chilling betrayal by those she trusted. We explore the failure...2023-09-1531 minMama Mystery with Kelly EvansEp 145 : The Disappearance of Dr. John Forsyth: A Mystery of Crypto, Love, and TragedyDr. John Forsyth was a respected ER physician, a cryptocurrency entrepreneur, and a devoted father whose life took a shocking turn in May 2023. After leaving his hospital shift, John vanished without a trace, leaving behind his car, personal belongings, and a shattered phone. Nine days later, his body was discovered in Beaver Lake, Arkansas, with a gunshot wound to the head—a tragic end to a mystery that continues to raise more questions than answers.
In this episode of Mama Mystery, we explore John’s complex life, from his groundbreaking work in cryptocurrency to his turbulent personal relationships, and the timel...2023-09-1036 minMama Mystery with Kelly EvansEp 144 : The Robert Fisher Case: A Family Annihilation, a House Explosion, and a Fugitive on the RunOn April 10, 2001, the quiet Scottsdale neighborhood of Mary and Robert Fisher erupted in chaos as an explosion leveled their home. Inside, authorities found the bodies of Mary Fisher and her two children, Brittney and Bobby, their throats cut and the house intentionally set ablaze. But one person was missing: Robert Fisher, the husband and father, who quickly became the prime suspect.
In this episode of Mama Mystery, we recount the chilling details of the Fisher family murders, Robert’s controlling and volatile behavior, and the desperate manhunt that followed. From his suspected escape to the Arizona wilderness to his placement on...2023-09-0125 min
Mama Mystery with Kelly EvansMama Minute : Let's Chat!DISCLAIMER: Mama Minute episodes have NOTHING to do with True Crime. So, if you're here for that and only that, feel free to skip this episode! But if you're here for a conversational flow of current topics, I wanna know your thoughts!!
In this episode, I cover these topics:
1. The dreaded school pick up line
2. Real Housewives of Orange County & NY
3. And Just Like That - the Sex and the City reboot
4. Peaks and Valleys of the week
5. Big Cedar Lodge & Orlando!!
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoicesSupport this podcast at — https://redcircle.com/m...2023-08-2542 minMama Mystery with Kelly EvansListen Now - Over My Dead Body: Gone HuntingWhen Mike Williams vanishes on a hunting trip, the authorities suspect he was eaten by alligators but the true predators who took Mike may lurk much closer to home. The mystery of Mike’s disappearance might have faded from memory, if it wasn’t for one woman’s tireless crusade. From Wondery, comes a new season of Over My Dead Body; a story about an obsessive love affair, a scandalous secret and a mother’s battle for the truth.
Follow Over My Dead Body: Gone Hunting on Amazon Music or wherever you get your podcasts. You can listen early and ad-free...2023-08-2207 minMama Mystery with Kelly EvansEp 143 : Luka Magnotta: A Trail of Obsession, Infamy, and a Global ManhuntLuka Magnotta’s name became synonymous with one of the most shocking and heinous crimes of the digital age. Born Eric Clinton Kirk Newman, Luka’s descent into infamy began with disturbing online videos, escalated into the brutal murder of Jun Lin, and culminated in an international manhunt that gripped the world. Magnotta’s calculated actions and craving for attention brought to light the dark intersection of social media and crime.
In this episode of Mama Mystery, we trace Luka’s troubled past, the psychological unraveling that preceded his crimes, and the meticulous investigation that brought him to justice. From his chill...2023-08-1843 minMama Mystery with Kelly EvansEp 142 : The Murder of Bianca Devins: Social Media, Obsession, and a Tragic EndBianca Devins was a vibrant 17-year-old from Utica, New York, with a bright future and a growing presence on social media. But her life was tragically cut short in July 2019 by someone she trusted. What began as an innocent night at a concert with a friend, Brandon Clark, ended in a horrific act of violence fueled by jealousy and obsession.
In this episode of Mama Mystery, we explore the story of Bianca’s life, her struggles with mental health, and her openness online that both inspired and attracted the wrong attention. We’ll unpack the events leading to her murder, the d...2023-08-1135 minMama Mystery with Kelly EvansEp 141 : Russell Williams: A Decorated Colonel’s Double Life of Crime and MurderRussell Williams was a highly respected military officer, a commander at Canada’s largest Air Force base, and a trusted pilot for dignitaries. But beneath his polished exterior, he led a horrifying double life of break-ins, sexual assaults, and brutal murders. Between 2007 and 2010, Williams targeted women in the Ontario area, escalating from stealing intimate items to committing heinous crimes, including the murders of Corporal Marie-France Comeau and Jessica Lloyd.
In this episode of Mama Mystery, we uncover the chilling details of Williams’ crimes, the methodical investigation that linked him to his victims, and the shocking confession that ended his reign of te...2023-08-0436 minMama Mystery with Kelly EvansEp 140 : The Murder of Connie Dabate: Secrets, Lies, and a Fitbit’s RevelationConnie Dabate was a devoted wife, a loving mother, and an active member of her Connecticut community. But just two days before Christmas in 2015, her life was tragically cut short in what her husband, Richard Dabate, claimed was a violent home invasion. However, as investigators dug deeper, they uncovered a web of secrets—including an affair, financial troubles, and evidence from Connie’s Fitbit that told a very different story.
In this episode of Mama Mystery, we unravel the timeline of Connie’s final hours, the discrepancies in Richard’s account, and the groundbreaking use of digital evidence that ultimately led to hi...2023-07-2147 minMama Mystery with Kelly EvansEp 139 : The Hart Family Tragedy: A Cliffside Crash, Abuse, and Unanswered QuestionsThe Hart family’s story is a haunting mix of outward appearances and hidden truths. On March 26, 2018, their GMC Yukon was found at the bottom of a cliff along Highway 1 in California, killing all six adopted children and their adoptive parents, Jennifer and Sarah Hart. At first, the crash seemed like a tragic accident, but a deeper investigation revealed a history of abuse, neglect, and control within the Hart household.
In this episode of Mama Mystery, we explore the chilling details of the Hart family’s carefully curated public image, the red flags that were ignored by authorities, and the devas...2023-07-1338 minMama Mystery with Kelly EvansEp 119 : Q&A with Austin & Kelly, celebrating 1 MILLION downloads!We asked our listeners what questions they have for us, related to true crime or not. In this episode, we get deep about our relationship, some of our recent struggles, our favorite episodes, and more! Thank you so much for ONE MILLION downloads of Mama Mystery!!
Support the show
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoicesSupport this podcast at — https://redcircle.com/mama-mystery-with-kelly-evans6609/donations2023-01-171h 06