podcast
details
.com
Print
Share
Look for any podcast host, guest or anyone
Search
Showing episodes and shows of
Lawformt.com
Shows
Montana Supreme Court Oral Arguments
Boardwalk Properties v. State — DA 25-0537
Does a 1998 state decision making 117 acres west of Bozeman a resort area give its owners a vested right to seek liquor licenses without regard to the city's quota, one the Legislature could not take away in 2021? The Gallatin County District Court said no and ruled for the State.Brian Gallik argued on behalf of appellants Boardwalk Properties, Michael Delaney and Ileana Indreland. Matthew Cochenour argued on behalf of appellees State of Montana and Department of Revenue. District Judge Matthew Cuffe sat in place of Justice Beth Baker, and Justice Gustafson took part by video.Listen...
2026-10-29
1h 25
Montana Supreme Court Oral Arguments
State v. B. Heck — DA 26-0015
Can consent be a defense to a prostitution charge in Montana? After a Bozeman police sting built around an online ad, Brian Edward Heck was charged with patronizing a prostitute. A Gallatin County District Court judge dismissed the charge before trial, reasoning that the Legislature's carve-outs for children and trafficking victims leave consent available to other adults. The State appealed.Mardell Ployhar argued on behalf of appellant State of Montana. Nicholas Miller argued on behalf of appellee Brian Edward Heck.Listen for Justices Gustafson and Shea asking why the consent statute names the prostitution statute...
2026-10-07
1h 06
Montana Supreme Court Oral Arguments
Johnson v. Spire Home Inspection — DA 25-0480
A home inspection agreement capped the inspector's liability at the $955 fee, and the buyers say the inspection missed defects that will cost $338,000 to repair. Before deciding whether a home inspector may limit liability for its own negligence to a refund, the Court has to decide whether it can reach the question at all, after the buyers settled for $954 to set up this appeal.Nicole Siefert argued for appellants Michael Johnson and Teresa Jenisch, with Justin Stalpes for amicus Montana Trial Lawyers Association. David HagEstad argued for appellees and cross-appellants Spire Home Inspection and Kevin Kivela, with Britton...
2026-09-18
1h 27
Montana Supreme Court Oral Arguments
State v. R. Kulczyk — DA 25-0099
Glasgow's assistant police chief posed online as a fourteen-year-old boy, using an app to make a photo of himself look younger. Ronald Kulczyk, convicted by a Valley County jury of two counts of sexual abuse of children and sentenced to 25 years with 20 suspended, argues that the AI-altered persona was not a person under the 2021 version of the statute, and that the 2025 amendment covering undercover officers proves the gap. He also claims outrageous government conduct, an involuntary Miranda waiver and an illegal sentence.Jeremy Yellin argued on behalf of appellant Ronald William Kulczyk. Thad Tudor, an assistant attorney...
2026-06-25
1h 12
Montana Supreme Court Oral Arguments
S. Brown v. 7th Judicial District — OP 26-0036
A man charged with deliberate homicide and arson asks the Montana Supreme Court to order his case dismissed because the jail recorded 68 of his calls with his lawyers, people at the jail and the sheriff's office listened to parts of 20, and two of his letters to his attorney were opened. The District Court refused to dismiss, suppressed the calls and barred everyone who accessed them from testifying.Matthew Hayhurst and Jenna Lyons argued on behalf of petitioner Sterling Glenn Brown. Roy Brown Jr. argued for the State of Montana. Ryan Aikin argued on behalf of amicus Montana...
2026-05-21
1h 22
Montana Supreme Court Oral Arguments
State v. J. Hubber (UPDATED with the court's opinion) — DA 24-0386
Update: On September 24, 2026, the Montana Supreme Court affirmed Jay Hubber's convictions for deliberate homicide by accountability and aggravated burglary in State v. Hubber, 2026 MT 229. Justice Katherine M. Bidegaray wrote for the Court. District Judge Christopher D. Abbott, sitting for a justice, dissented in part. The Court held that the wrong definition of purposely was not plain error or prejudicial, and that a bondsman has no privilege to enter a third party's home. We predicted an affirmance, and that held up.Can a bail bondsman's power to arrest carry him into a third party's home, and did a...
2026-04-23
1h 19
Montana Supreme Court Oral Arguments
Ellingson v. State (UPDATED with the court's opinion) — DA 25-0142
Update: On October 6, the Montana Supreme Court affirmed in Ellingson v. State, 2026 MT 233, in an opinion by Justice Beth Baker. Chief Justice Cory Swanson concurred. Justice Katherine Bidegaray, joined by Justices Ingrid Gustafson and Laurie McKinnon, dissented on attorney fees. The Court held that the Legislature may facilitate but not impair the people's initiative power, and it voided SB 93's filing fee, four-year refiling bar and committee vote. We predicted a split result upholding the fee and refiling bar, so our prediction missed.SB 93, passed in 2023, rewrote how Montanans put initiatives on the ballot. The District Court...
2026-04-10
1h 29
Montana Supreme Court Oral Arguments
Blanchard v. Wild Horse Trading — DA 25-0409
A trucker hauling for Pacific Western Lumber was badly hurt when a bundle of logs fell on him during loading at an Amish-owned mill in Plains. The District Court ruled that PacWest, the mill's customer, owed him no duty. The question is whether a buyer that sends its trucker to a seller's yard can answer for how that yard loads the truck.Justin Stalpes argued on behalf of appellants Steve and Roxanne Blanchard. Colin Wallis Phelps argued on behalf of appellee Pacific Western Lumber. The Court limited the argument to the PacWest ruling.Listen for...
2026-03-25
1h 20
Montana Supreme Court Oral Arguments
State v. R. French — DA 23-0528
A Cascade County jury convicted Robert Dan French of sexual intercourse without consent against a four-year-old girl. At trial she said she did not remember, so the conviction rests on her earlier statements to her parents and a forensic interviewer, which Montana law says must be independently corroborated. The Court affirmed in December, then granted rehearing, withdrew that opinion and heard the case again before the full Court.Jeff Wilson, of the Appellate Defender Division, argued for appellant Robert Dan French. Mardell Ployhar argued for appellee State of Montana.Listen for Justice Shea asking whether...
2026-03-04
1h 15
Montana Supreme Court Oral Arguments
MT Voters v. MT Sec of State — DA 25-0187
At stake is the 2023 map for the Public Service Commission. The challengers say it shuts non-Republican voters out of every seat and violates the Montana Constitution's right of suffrage whether or not the Legislature meant it to. The District Court required proof of intent, found none after a trial with an advisory jury, and barred a deposition of the bill's sponsor.Molly Danahy argued on behalf of appellants Montana Conservation Voters and eight individual voters; Michael Russell on behalf of appellee Secretary of State Christi Jacobsen; and Christian Corrigan on behalf of intervenor Keith Regier, the former...
2026-02-11
1h 23
Montana Supreme Court Oral Arguments
City of Kalispell v. S. Doman (UPDATED with the court's opinion) — DA 23-0462
Update: The Montana Supreme Court affirmed Sean Doman's conviction for obstructing a peace officer in City of Kalispell v. Doman, 2026 MT 15, decided February 10, 2026. Justice Beth Baker wrote for the Court, and Justice James Jeremiah Shea concurred. The Court held the evidence was sufficient to show Doman knowingly obstructed the traffic stop and declined plain-error review of his unpreserved First Amendment claims. We predicted a reversal for insufficient evidence, so our prediction did not hold up.Sean Doman stopped his bicycle on a Kalispell sidewalk to film a traffic stop, was told to move back, and was arrested...
2025-10-01
1h 19
Montana Supreme Court Oral Arguments
Wild Montana v. Gianforte — DA 24-0153
Governor Greg Gianforte vetoed Senate Bill 442 on the last day of the 2023 session. That afternoon the Senate adjourned for good before the veto was read there. A District Court ordered a mail-in override poll, and the override failed. Now the Montana Supreme Court must decide whether the appeal is moot. If it is not, the Court must decide whether private groups had standing, whether courts may fill a gap in the Constitution's veto procedure, and whether the Governor and Secretary of State had a clear duty to act.On behalf of the appellants, Dale Schowengerdt argued for...
2025-09-12
1h 24
Montana Supreme Court Oral Arguments
Matter of T.W. (UPDATED with the court's opinion) — DA 22-0645
Update: The Montana Supreme Court affirmed in part and reversed in part in Matter of T.W., 2025 MT 225, decided October 7, 2025, in an opinion by Justice Katherine Bidegaray. Chief Justice Cory Swanson dissented in part, joined by Justice Jim Rice. The Court held that an earlier no-commitment finding did not bar a second petition, but reversed the commitment because the District Court could not compel T.W., who had validly waived her presence, to appear by video over her objection. We predicted reversal, and that held up.A Lincoln County jury found that T.W. had a mental...
2025-05-01
1h 23
Montana Supreme Court Oral Arguments
State v. A. Smith (UPDATED with the court's opinion) — DA 22-0484
Update: On December 9, the Montana Supreme Court unanimously affirmed Andrew Smith's deliberate homicide conviction in State v. Smith, 2025 MT 281, in an opinion by Chief Justice Cory Swanson. The Court held that a self-defense claim does not categorically bar a mitigated deliberate homicide instruction. But Smith waived the issue by making no offer of proof of mitigation evidence, and his jury-question claim failed plain-error review. We predicted an affirmance with no dissent, and that prediction held up.Can a defendant who claims self-defense also ask the jury to consider mitigated deliberate homicide? Andrew John Smith was convicted by...
2025-04-04
1h 16
Montana Supreme Court Oral Arguments
Matter of Austin Knudsen (UPDATED with the court's opinion) — PR 23-0496
Update: In Matter of Austin Knudsen, 2025 MT 304, decided December 31, 2025, the Montana Supreme Court held that the Attorney General is subject to the Rules of Professional Conduct. Chief Justice Cory Swanson wrote for the Court. It found that Knudsen violated two rules but dismissed the case over due process defects in the Commission's proceedings, treating the opinion as a public admonition instead of the recommended 90-day suspension. Judge Sullivan wrote separately, and Justice Katherine Bidegaray concurred in part and dissented in part.The Commission on Practice recommended a ninety-day suspension of Attorney General Austin Knudsen's law license over...
2025-03-28
1h 26
Montana Supreme Court Oral Arguments
Brandt v. R&R Mountain Esc (UPDATED with the court's opinion) — DA 23-0716
Update: On July 22, 2025, the Montana Supreme Court affirmed in Brandt v. R&R Mountain Escapes, 2025 MT 155, in an opinion by Justice Laurie McKinnon, with Chief Justice Cory Swanson concurring. The Court held that the subdivision's covenants, read together, unambiguously prohibit short-term vacation rentals, rejected the district court's 30-day minimum, and upheld the denial of attorney fees. We predicted an affirmance at argument, and that held up.Can covenants that allow "for rent" signs, but limit land to country residential purposes and forbid "any commercial purpose whatsoever," bar short-term rentals? The Flathead County District Court said yes and...
2025-03-19
1h 19
Montana Supreme Court Oral Arguments
Mullee v. Winter Sports (UPDATED with the court's opinion) — DA 24-0356
Update: On June 3, 2025, the Montana Supreme Court affirmed summary judgment for Winter Sports, Inc. in Mullee v. Winter Sports, 2025 MT 113. Justice Ingrid Gustafson wrote for a unanimous Court, with no dissent or concurrence. Applying the Montana Skier Responsibility Act, the Court held that the resort owed no legal duty to install fencing that would catch a skier who left the trail, citing low foreseeability at that spot and public policy. We predicted a unanimous affirmance, and the decision bore that out.Mark Mullee, a longtime skier at Whitefish Mountain Resort, caught an edge on a beginner ski...
2025-03-06
1h 20
Montana Supreme Court Oral Arguments
EQT CHAP v. EHS (UPDATED with the court's opinion) — DA 24-0328
Update: The Montana Supreme Court reversed and remanded in EQT Chap v. EHS, 2025 MT 237, decided October 15, 2025, in a unanimous opinion by Justice Laurie McKinnon. The Court held that Pennsylvania law, not Montana's Media Confidentiality Act, governs the subpoena for a Pennsylvania-based reporter's research, because the communications occurred in Pennsylvania, and it sent the case back for the District Court to apply Pennsylvania's privileges. We predicted reversal and remand under Pennsylvania law, and that held up.Which state's reporter's privilege applies when a gas company in a Pennsylvania dispute subpoenas a Montana newsroom? EQT CHAP, a party to...
2025-02-26
1h 20
Montana Supreme Court Oral Arguments
O'Neill v. Gianforte (UPDATED with the court's opinion) — DA 23-0555
Update: On January 2, 2025, the Montana Supreme Court reversed in part and affirmed in part in O'Neill v. Gianforte, 2025 MT 2. Justice James Jeremiah Shea wrote for the 4-3 majority. Justice Laurie McKinnon dissented, joined by Justice Ingrid Gustafson and District Judge Leslie Halligan. The Court recognized a narrow gubernatorial privilege grounded in Article VI, Section 15. The governor must prove it in camera through a privilege log. We predicted reversal and a narrow, qualified privilege, and that prediction held up.Can Montana's Governor keep secret the forms in which agency staff advise him whether to sign or veto a...
2024-09-13
1h 22
Montana Supreme Court Oral Arguments
Held v. State (UPDATED with the court's opinion) — DA 23-0575
Update: The Montana Supreme Court affirmed in Held v. State, 2024 MT 312, decided December 18, 2024, in an opinion by Chief Justice Mike McGrath. Justice Sandefur concurred in the result, and Justice Jim Rice dissented. The Court held that Montana's constitutional right to a clean and healthful environment includes a stable climate system, and that the MEPA Limitation barring greenhouse gas analysis in environmental review is unconstitutional. We predicted affirmance with a dissent from Justice Rice, and that held up.Sixteen young Montanans won a trial ruling that the Montana Environmental Policy Act's ban on considering greenhouse gas emissions and...
2024-07-10
1h 18
Montana Supreme Court Oral Arguments
MEIC v. DEQ (UPDATED with the court's opinion) — DA 23-0225, DA 23-0320
Update: In MEIC v. DEQ, 2025 MT 3, decided January 3, 2025, the Montana Supreme Court affirmed in part and reversed in part in an opinion by Justice Beth Baker. Justice Laurie McKinnon, joined by Justice Ingrid Gustafson, dissented on the remedy. Justice Jim Rice, joined by Justice Dirk Sandefur, concurred. DEQ must analyze the Laurel plant's greenhouse gas emissions and lighting, but the permit is reinstated because vacatur required statutory findings. We predicted the outcome correctly.NorthWestern Energy is building a 175-megawatt gas plant near Laurel. The state permitted it without studying its greenhouse gas emissions. A Yellowstone County judge...
2024-05-15
1h 15
Montana Supreme Court Oral Arguments
State v. D. Wood (UPDATED with the court's opinion) — DA 21-0260
Update: The Montana Supreme Court reversed Danielle Wood's deliberate homicide conviction and remanded for a new trial in State v. Wood, 2024 MT 318, decided December 31, 2024, in an opinion by Justice Dirk Sandefur. Chief Justice McGrath concurred, joined by Justices Rice and Shea. The Court held that the accountability theory lacked evidentiary support and, paired with a general verdict form, was not harmless. We predicted affirmance, and the decision went the other way.A Sanders County jury convicted Danielle Wood of deliberate homicide in the 2018 shooting of Matthew LaFriniere in Thompson Falls, and she was sentenced to prison without...
2024-04-22
1h 19
Montana Supreme Court Oral Arguments
Trout Unlimited v. DNRC (UPDATED with the court's opinion) — DA 23-0268
Update: On January 2, 2025, the Montana Supreme Court affirmed in Trout Unlimited v. DNRC, 2025 MT 1. Justice Jim Rice wrote for the Court, holding that groundwater pumped from a mine and returned without further use is neither beneficial use nor waste, so it falls outside DNRC's water-permit authority. Chief Justice Mike McGrath concurred, and Justice Laurie McKinnon dissented, joined by Justice Ingrid Gustafson. We predicted an affirmance with one dissent joined by one other justice, and that held up.Tintina Montana plans the Black Butte copper mine upstream of the Smith River. Up to 807 acre-feet of groundwater a year...
2024-03-29
1h 21
Montana Supreme Court Oral Arguments
Planned Parenthood v. State (UPDATED with the court's opinion) — DA 23-0272
Update: The Montana Supreme Court affirmed in Planned Parenthood v. State, 2024 MT 178, decided August 14, 2024, in an opinion by Justice Laurie McKinnon for a unanimous Court, with a separate concurrence by Justice Rice. The Court held that the Parental Consent for Abortion Act violates a minor's fundamental right of privacy and her right to equal protection under the Montana Constitution. We predicted affirmance, and that held up, though we expected a dissent rather than a concurrence.Can Montana require a minor to get a parent's notarized consent before an abortion? The Legislature's 2013 Parental Consent for Abortion Act has...
2024-03-06
1h 23
Montana Supreme Court Oral Arguments
Little Big Warm v. Doll (UPDATED with the court's opinion) — DA 22-0742
Update: The Montana Supreme Court affirmed in Little Big Warm v. Doll, 2024 MT 3, decided January 9, 2024, in an opinion by Chief Justice Mike McGrath, with a concurrence by Justice Jim Rice. The Court held that the District Court properly enforced the Water Court's decree by percentage during low flows, let Doll leave water instream for his downstream diversions, and reasonably found no prevailing party for attorney fees. We predicted affirmance, and that held up.Two Phillips County ranches hold water rights in Big Warm Creek with the same 1889 priority date. When the creek runs low, does the upstream...
2023-10-18
1h 19