Shows
The Mystery Spotcast: A Supernatural RewatchBobby’s Sassy Man Apocalypse: Ep. 68Join Ollie and Klaudia for a traipse through Supernatural S6E12: "Like A Virgin," and S6E13: "Unforgiven." Points of Interest: The Panera Ad, an ode to midseason finales, turning bulbasaur around, sex ed with John Winchester, an embarrassingly emotional World of Warcraft rant, the sin of not giving Cas a hug, a dragon with a truck, plot relevant flashbacks, the Dean Gender Binary, on-again off-again Bufus, her web literally connects us all, and choosing not to talk about breeding. ---Listen to Ollie talk about The ICJ vs. Magneto on Mutant Studies 101: Sp...
2025-11-181h 54The Mystery Spotcast: A Supernatural RewatchWATCH-ALONG BONUS: Lazarus RisingIn honor of the five year anniversary of November 5th, 2020, Klaudia and Ollie present their LIVE commentary on Supernatural S4E1: "Lazarus Rising."LIVE COMMENTARY STARTS AT 4:46---Fight For the Future's frontline organizations list, updated to include LA immigrant rights orgs.Teen Vogue's excellent political reporting on how to be an activist when you can't attend protestsWired's comprehensive guide on protest and resistance in the digital ageFollow the Palestinian Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions movement directly: Instagram / Bluesky / TikTok---Follow...
2025-11-0450 minThe Mystery Spotcast: A Supernatural RewatchGetting Sam and Dean in Fortnite: Ep. 67Join Klaudia and Ollie for a totally not off the rails recap of Supernatural S6E10: "Caged Heat" and S6E11: "Appointment In Samarra." Points of Interest: “A transcript, a wiki, and a dream”, good old fashioned queerbaiting, “speaking of Omegaverse-”, the official Dean Winchester period tracker, PRESIDENTIAL ALERT: The girls are captured, Castiel’s pornographic DVD, Dick Cheney has kissed Crowley, Sam’s piss kink, Crowley is tastefully slutty, and Supernatural’s astronomical abandon warehouse budget.---Fight For the Future's frontline organizations list, updated to include LA immigrant rights orgs.Teen Vogue's...
2025-10-211h 56The Mystery Spotcast: A Supernatural RewatchSocialized Supernatural Season 16 (feat. Meghan Fitzmartin): Ep. 66Join Ollie, Klaudia, and special guest Meghan Fitzmartin as they draw back the curtain on Supernatural, and happen to recap S6E9: "Clap Your Hands If You Believe." Points of Interest: Setting the scene for November 5th, an Omegaverse bombshell, new writer’s room position: Weird Freak Who’s Too Online, the argument for filler episodes, inheriting Dean Winchester’s music taste, monks were the earliest form of stans, pitching a Lisa-centric episode, getting pizza rolled, Dean’s most cancellable moments, leprechaun improv, and Sam's fraudulent NPR donations. ---Follow Meghan on Bluesky / Instagram...
2025-08-202h 12The Mystery Spotcast: A Supernatural RewatchUndercover Boss Crowley: Ep. 65Join Klaudia and Ollie as they struggle through Supernatural S6E7: "Family Matters" and S6E8: "All Dogs Go to Heaven." Points of Interest: Escaping before the point of no return, Crowley’s TikTok Shop grift, pre-recorded crowdwork, Sam’s younger sibling behavior, Samuel Campbell’s thoughts on queer discourse, 1950s housewife Cas, losing against the urge to nitpick, a fast food aside, Crobby second chance romance, soulless Sam is just a little guy, not even the worst episode about dogs, Bible fanfiction (not in a fun way), “Where the mpreg at?”, the ghost of Supernatural future, and the Ben...
2025-08-122h 12The Mystery Spotcast: A Supernatural RewatchThe Destiel Cream Cheese/Pill Theory: Ep. 64Join Ollie and Klaudia as they trudge through Supernatural S6E6: "Live Free or Twihard" and S6E6: "You Can't Handle The Truth." Points of Interest: It’s actually over, baby’s first fujo moment, destroying Twilight to save the media landscape, a different Dean in every scene, atmospheric thunder sounds, the heirs to the Campbell’s Soup fortune, “If Castiel was here, he would have made Dean pregnant.”, a Rachel Maddow-themed disagreement, “Come here, fujo!”, gaslight gatekeep Samboss, and a call for The Mystery Spotcast fanfiction.---Fight For the Future's frontline organizations l...
2025-07-012h 03The Mystery Spotcast: A Supernatural RewatchBalthazar's Brat Summer: Ep. 63Join Klaudia and Ollie as they get into Supernatural S6E3: "The Third Man" and S6E4: "Weekend at Bobby's." Points of Interest: Jensen Ackles queerbaiting is a recession indicator, the post-NDA Supernatural production tell-all, bragging about being the first omega, Rowena waiting to give Sam estrogen, Can Sam munch?, the Men of Letters bunker is the Supernatural Avengers tower, Yahoo! Answers user Bobby, Why Garth the bus driver?, pitching the young Bobby/Rufus TV show, put-upon mother Bobby, Chekhov’s wood chipper, and a literal dick measuring contest. ---Fight For the Futu...
2025-06-172h 45The Mystery Spotcast: A Supernatural RewatchSam and Dean’s Cheesecake Factory Orders: Ep. 62Join Ollie and Klaudia as they break into a new season, starting with Supernatural S6E1: "Exile on Main Street" and S6E2: "Two and a Half Men." Points of Interest: Torturing Jared by making him watch Ahsoka, a diagetic “previously on” segment, Supernatural’s obsession with dilapidated sets, the in universe transvestigation of Dean, “Is it gay to own a magazine?”, canonical Mayflower descendants Sam and Dean Winchester, Dean’s “Old Enough”-esque diaper run, the Campbells are lowkey shady AF, and #GetDeanWinchesterPregnant.---Check out Fight For the Future's frontline organizations list---
2025-05-271h 57The Mystery Spotcast: A Supernatural RewatchGrant Us a Dean (Winchester) Who Doubts: Ep. 61Join Klaudia and Ollie as they recap the final episodes of the season, Supernatural S5E21: "Two Minutes to Midnight" and S5E22: "Swan Song." Points of Interest: Good ending ≠ good ending, this happened in The Magnus Archives, Real ID killed Supernatural, getting sued for calling Dean gay, an extended conversation on improv comedy, Pestilence is one of our biggest fans, asking important questions (has the pope seen Supernatural?), Crobby has canonically kissed, Until Dawn plagiarized Supernatural, “Is it just me, or is Crowley a little problematic?”, stud Rufus, the Devil’s fidget spinner, Bobby’s big naturals, d...
2025-05-132h 17The Mystery Spotcast: A Supernatural RewatchGabriel, Where the Hell Have You Been, Loki?: Ep. 60Join Ollie and Klaudia as they power through Supernatural S5E19: "Hammer of the Gods" and S5E20: "The Devil You Know." Points of Interest: An update on the playlist, asking if Dean can drive a stick shift, Yellowjackets crossover episode, leave a comment if you’re a horsefly in Indiana, a literal elephant in the room, “He’s right behind me, isn’t he?” vs. “You guys might want to take a look at this,” the return of Herpexia, asking if animal actors are a part of SAG, LinkedInfluencer Crowley, demon fake dating/forced proximity/enemies to lovers, if y...
2025-04-292h 22The Mystery Spotcast: A Supernatural RewatchThe Bi-Curious Case of Sam Winchester: Ep. 59Join Klaudia and Ollie for a stroll through Supernatural S5E17: "99 Problems" and S5E18: "Point of No Return." Points of Interest: The Official Mystery Spotcast Playlist, WHEN Buddie becomes canon, Hibachi Chef Dean Winchester, Conclave brainrot, for those with the yaoi goggles on, copius Ethel Cain references, Sam’s out of control sideburns, a W*ncest Freudian slip, a request for feedback from our straight listeners, the Revelations to Omegaverse pipeline, Into the Benedictverse, Castiel’s Diva Cup, “Never kill yourself pookie,” Michael or Muppet, textbook omega poses, and an inappropriately timed Doctor Who joke.---...
2025-04-082h 37The Mystery Spotcast: A Supernatural RewatchPoopernatural: Ep. 58Join Ollie and Klaudia as they creep through Supernatural S5E15: "Dead Men Don't Wear Plaid" and S5E16: "Dark Side of the Moon." Points of Interest: The Flying Monkey’s Paw, Destiel Gelphie AU, Dean never cry, finding the Gen Z Lin-Manuel Miranda, Barnes & Noble’s hunter discount, Bobby copium, the literal man in the chair, Supernatural Dance Moms AU, Supernatural’s Rogue One hallway scene, Sam/Jess are butch/femme goals, you can’t have jokes in heaven, Dean’s road forward (in the closet??), Ash was too poweful to live, letting one rip in heaven’s ga...
2025-03-262h 26The Mystery Spotcast: A Supernatural RewatchSupernatural as Drag: A Cultural Analysis: Ep. 57Join Klaudia and Ollie as they blast through Supernatural S5E13: "The Song Remains the Same" and S5E14: "My Bloody Valentine." Points of Interest: Yet ANOTHER Destiel canonization, the last great American queerbait, mobilizing Destiel shippers to improve children’s literacy, the most unemployed employment announcement, Oscar buzz for the Supernatural spin-off movie, platonic Enochian wards, the Winchesters are Castiel's pookies, masc lesbian Sam Winchester’s crash out, an AIngel, Misha Collins is literally eating, and welcoming you to Team Free Will.---Listen to the Sold a Story podcastCheck...
2025-03-112h 24The Mystery Spotcast: A Supernatural RewatchSam and Dean’s Folie à Deux: Ep. 56Join Ollie and Klaudia as they power through Supernatural S5E11: "Sam, Interrupted" and S5E12: "Swap Meat." Points of Interest: Our table read bonus episode, we love woke and DEI, average closeted gay man pushing 30, diagnosing Dean with being a perfect little boy, getting a lobotomy from Sam, engaging in Omega behaviors, Supernatural-themed pop up lumbar puncture event, the potential of bear Dean, a MILF-heavy episode, Sam is very woman-coded, Dean is a Carrie, and Misha Collins’ enrichment activity (libbing out).---Check out Fight For the Future's frontline organizations list...
2025-02-252h 20The Mystery Spotcast: A Supernatural RewatchThese Crumbs are Kinda Tasty Though: Ep. 55Join Klaudia and Ollie as they return to get into Supernatural S5E9: "The Real Ghostbusters" and S5E10: "Abandon All Hope..." Points of Interest: Supernatural drama sent via carrier pigeon, Dean Winchester got literally shafted by the narrative, Klaudia is a closeted Winc*st shipper /j, Dean can be any gender you want him to be, a controversial take on non-fujoshis, Dean and Sam’s IP Lawyer, when fandom brain makes you commit a felony, Wiki admin Sam, #NotMyCrowley, putting Castiel on Life360, battle scars, and A reference? In my Supernatural?---Che...
2025-02-042h 28The Mystery Spotcast: A Supernatural RewatchWeaponized Cringe: Ep. 54Join Ollie and Klaudia for an examination of Supernatural S5E7: "The Curious Case of Dean Winchester" and S5E8: "Changing Channels." Points of Interest: A Destiel of every election cycle, the Supernatural version of “Pokémon Go to the Polls,” Bobby Bucks, the CDC (Center for Dick and Cock), Supernatural hates the Irish, people looked older in 2009, Ellen Pompeo’s Cease and Desist, the Winchester family jewels, and Dean’s otaku era.---Check out Fight For the Future's frontline organizations list---Help a family evacuate Gaza and rebuil...
2024-12-042h 15The Mystery Spotcast: A Supernatural RewatchBuzzer Ham Sam: Ep. 53Join Klaudia and Ollie for an incidental November 5th episode as they recount Supernatural S5E5: "Fallen Idols" and S5E4: "I Believe the Children Are Our Future." P.S. Sorry if the audio sounds a little weird, especially in the middle! We had some deeply frustrating technical difficulties (likely brought on by November 5th anticipation). Points of Interest: A November 5th message, tweet @KaludiaSays to complain, Sam and Dean’s Dual Vespas, That’s just a theory… a Supernatural theory, the Season 16 ‘The Bachelor’ episode pitch, 'The Voice' Omegaverse fanfiction, HBomberguy’s Supernatural retrospective, Dean make-a da...
2024-11-052h 08The Mystery Spotcast: A Supernatural RewatchBartenderGate: Ep. 52Join Ollie and Klaudia as they traipse through Supernatural S5E3: "Free To Be You and Me" and S5E4: "The End."Points of Interest: Is Destiel a retelling of the watcher’s flood?, being freed from the clutches of the white nightgown, hard-hitting political commentary from Dean Winchester, Jensen Ackles possessed by the spirit of Dean, angels are constantly flopping, fujoshing out, the pandemic year of 2014, John McCain won the 2008 election in the Supernatural universe, unprecedented levels of divorced, and deleted Destiel scenes.---Help a family evacuate Gaza and rebuild their li...
2024-10-222h 17The Mystery Spotcast: A Supernatural RewatchThere Is Destiel Everywhere for Those with Eyes To See It: Ep. 51Join Klaudia and Ollie for the beginning of a new season, in which they recap Supernatural S5E1: "Sympathy for the Devil" and S5E2: "Good God, Y'all."Points of Interest: Spoilers for Wincest, a 3D modeling argument, some very important Maryland comments, visiting MoreThanBrothers.net, Jimmy Novak’s Social Security Number, an insane amount of anti-Irish sentiment, and “I hate this show- Oh my god, Destiel!”---Help a family evacuate Gaza and rebuild their livesResources for Palestine:BDS: What is BDS?BDS: Act Now Agains...
2024-09-261h 52The Mystery Spotcast: A Supernatural RewatchThe Beginning of the End: Ep. 50Join Ollie and Klaudia for their 50th episode, in which they recap the last two episodes of season 4, Supernatural S4E21: "When the Levee Breaks" and S4E22: "Lucifer Rising."Points of Interest: Bobby/Rufus divorced old man yaoi, this is so 9-1-1 coded, an underrated Destiel scene, sealing a godly pact with a kiss, Bobby’s various personas, the most overrated Destiel scene (that isn’t actually overrated), a big win for Virginians, breaking into God’s liquor cabinet, Dean’s “This is for Rachel” voicemail, a completely normal and sane conversation about Destiel, Chuck LARPing, Bil...
2024-09-111h 44The Mystery Spotcast: A Supernatural RewatchJimmy Novak Is Not Demure and Mindful: Ep. 49Join Klaudia and Ollie on an exploration of Supernatural S4E19: "Jump the Shark" and S4E20: "The Rapture"Points of Interest: Letting a tuna sandwich go bad is a skill issue, Covid headcanons for the Winchesters, the Campbell’s heirloom silverware, the Gravity Falls Christmas special where they beat up John Winchester, “1. Gross, 2. Ew, 3. What is wrong with you?”, John did not go to the Destiel wedding, the Godzilla tulpa that exists in the Supernatural universe, Dance Moms parallels, an eternity of Cas’ gay thoughts, and Destiel’s third act break up.---Help a f...
2024-08-271h 43The Mystery Spotcast: A Supernatural RewatchChuck Shurley Is Pink Diamond: Ep. 48Join Ollie and Klaudia as trek through Supernatural S4E17: "It's A Terrible Life" and S4E18: "The Monster at the End of This Book."Points of Interest: Wincest is culture perservering, Sam’s unethical enclosure, Dean is NOT gay, a ghost who can send a believable corporate email, Winstincts, the Supernatural writers have stopped answering our emails, apologies for the deception, Dean’s Goodreads ratings, Wincest is canon (not in the way you think), “Speaking of BL-“, and Chuck Shurley on Undercover Boss.---Help a family evacuate Gaza and rebuild their lives
2024-08-062h 06The Mystery Spotcast: A Supernatural RewatchPavlovian Destiel Response: Ep. 47Join Klaudia and Ollie as they divulge information on Supernatural S4E15: "Death Takes A Holiday" and S4E16: "On The Head Of A Pin."Points of Interest: An angel yaoi recomendation, bro used reverse cursed energy, the Winchesters’ publicist, slut-shaming Sam ONLY, the BBC Ghosts-ification of Dean Winchester, an open invitation to the McElroy brothers, ghosted and talented, Sam Reich!Castiel, a blast from the Cas, Alistair is the first canonical transphobic character, passing the Dean baton, Casual coded, and foreshadowing the rusty nail (again).---Help save a family evacuate Gaza an...
2024-07-232h 08The Mystery Spotcast: A Supernatural RewatchWorking It Out on the Remix with Jared Padalecki: Ep. 46Join Ollie and Klaudia as they give lectures on Supernatural S4E13: "After School Special" and S4E14: "Sex and Violence."Points of Interest: A certified “Et Tu, Brute?” moment, “Dean embraces his authority in gym class,” the effects of being on Tumblr for over half of your life, Nonna Klaudia, getting distracted by The Locked Tomb, the woke mob (Sam and Dean), reading makes you gay in the Supernatural universe, Sam is accidentally an ally, Dean in the strip club talking to a man, and Super Nanny Bobby.---Help save a family e...
2024-07-092h 03The Mystery Spotcast: A Supernatural RewatchOld Man Magician Yaoi: Ep. 45Join Klaudia and Ollie as they detail the events of Supernatural S4E11: "Family Remains" and S4E12: "Criss Angel is a Douchebag."Points of Interest: Misha Collins needs to get a job, giving Jared Padalecki an F slur pass, an 18 mile radius, Supernatural powerscaling TikTok, we can’t have monster anymore (because of woke), an evil version of Encanto, He (IYKYK), rusty nail foreshadowing, welcome back Bobby Nash, we don’t care that Dean tortured people, a reminder that Wincest exists in canon, Party City magician, Sam’s brief magic phase, theories about Dean’s evening with Chi...
2024-06-182h 15The Mystery Spotcast: A Supernatural RewatchDivine Bong Hit: Ep. 44Join Ollie and Klaudia as they make the trek through Supernatural S4E9: "I Know What You Did Last Summer" and S4E10: "Heaven and Hell."Points of Interest: Jensen Ackles’ legal team is coming for us, Garth never experiencing twink death, a second November 5th, Dean wiping down his groceries, questioning the mileage on the impala, Sam kissing ONE guy in college, the angels’ Avengers earpieces, a great Derry Girls reference, “it’s just some white guy”, Ruby’s ethically sourced body, Sam’s version of Who the Fuck Did I Marry, is Supernatural spicy?, Dean’s Stanley cup, Q...
2024-06-052h 10The Mystery Spotcast: A Supernatural RewatchDestiel Warrior Ben Edlund: Ep. 43Join Klaudia and Ollie as they give you an urgent update on queer television and cover Supernatural S4E8: "Wishful Thinking."Points of Interest: The fast fashion of anime, Ryan Murphy is going directly to Hell, a Young Sheldon fun fact, saving a baby from a pipe in the wall, Korra walked so Buck could run, “I entertain its possibility,” intended Destiel subtext, Schrodinger’s homophobia, killing Dean Winchester with hammers, Vancouver tourism ad, BookToker Sam Winchester, our personal opinions on Bigfoot, Dean’s morning sickness, Jinkx Monsoon Slime Tutorials, Sam and Dean’s pretty privilege, and Dean’s fin...
2024-04-301h 48The Mystery Spotcast: A Supernatural Rewatch#NotMyDeanWinchester: Ep. 42Join Ollie and Klaudia as they dive into Supernatural S4E6: "Yellow Fever," and S4E7: "It’s the Great Pumpkin, Sam Winchester."Points of Interest: Spinning straw into gold in a gay way, contact tracer Sam Winchester, “you’re never gonna beat rusty nail,” MCU-coded (not in a good way), life is an elaborate Dean Winchester cosplay, Musical.ly star Jensen Ackles, you’re never gonna be her (Dead in the Water), the epic highs and lows of high school football, Supernatural Lizzie Bennet Diaries AU, the foundations of Destiel, and “You are gay, and that’s final!”
2024-04-102h 37The Mystery Spotcast: A Supernatural RewatchSexism Against Sam Winchester: Ep. 41Join Klaudia and Ollie as they explore Supernatural S4E4: "Metamorphosis," and S4E5: "Monster Movie."CONTENT WARNING: Conversations about SA at 37:50-42:35Points of Interest: The Castiel drought, backsliding into Destiel, a modern interpretation of white Jesus Christ, Dean forgot how to mask while he was in Hell, the multiple meanings of AFAB, proof that people who are different can still be friends, Sondheim stan Sam, the least menacing mode of transportation aside from roller skates, ten toes down in the bit, and ending it on Omegaverse (as god intended).---
2024-03-052h 16The Mystery Spotcast: A Supernatural RewatchCastiel's Big Naturals: Ep. 40Join Ollie and Klaudia as they obsess over Supernatural S4E2: "Are You There, God? It's Me, Dean Winchester," and S4E3: "In the Beginning."Points of Interest: The first official Destiel art, Dean’s Freudian slip, Sam getting lost in the sauce, Bobby has invested in gold, baby’s first theology lesson, Cas is Dean’s sneaky link, a rare moment of continuity, the fanfiction writes itself, "Get on that microfiche, girl," Azazel is playing evil Sims, top 10 crazy Castiel moments, and Milton Winchester.---Follow us:@MysterySpotcast on Tiktok / Twitte...
2024-02-202h 10The Mystery Spotcast: A Supernatural RewatchCastiel's Comphet Alarm: Ep. 39Join Klaudia and Ollie they attempt to coherently recap Supernatural S4E1: "Lazarus Rising."Points of Interest: A completely different brand of bad, Lazarus Rising-pilled, manifesting a Castiel tulpa, pandering to the dads in the audience, demon juice (AKA Panera lemonade), Klaudia’s grand reveal, Dean supports print media, the time-honored tradition of yaoi analysis, Sam is straight in a heterophobic world, Dean’s scary boyfriend privileges, Sam’s Vine boom exorcism, and pressing the emergency Castiel button.---Follow us:@MysterySpotcast on Tiktok / Twitter / Instagram / Tumblr---Cont...
2024-02-061h 57The Mystery Spotcast: A Supernatural RewatchDeus Ex Bobbyna: Ep. 38Join Ollie and Klaudia as they take on the Supernatural season 3 finale: "No Rest for the Wicked."Points of Interest: Bobby Serves (unlike Sherlock), we need SuperWhoLock fanfic writers now more than ever, Suby vs. Duby, CHUCKling, “slutty little Yoda”, sick Gale of Waterdeep reference, a neighborhood of Joe Bidens, Bon Jovi fan (derogatory), Dean Winchester says ACAB (once again), nuance? In my Supernatural?, playing fast and loose with every religion, Eric Kripke is not seeing Heaven, and an open call for Destiel fic recomendations. ---For a native perspective on Supernatural S1E2, c...
2024-01-161h 34The Mystery Spotcast: A Supernatural RewatchShrimp! Hell! Now!: Ep. 37Join Klaudia and Ollie as they get into Supernatural S3E14: "Long-Distance Call" and S3E15: "Time Is On My Side." Points of Interest: The horror of the guy who made shrimp and mashed potatoes on a plane, “Can we not reference Hamilton right now?”, spoilers for Jared Padalecki’s life, Hbomberguy we know you’re listening, occulture, John “Dipshit” Winchester, a comprehensive list of blue lives that matter, don’t let AI have phone sex with your wife, the crocotta has become Catholic, sweet The Magnus Archives reference, -1 (for sexism) +1 (for style), and Bobby’s former harem....
2024-01-032h 31The Mystery Spotcast: A Supernatural RewatchToilet Bowl Holy Water: Ep. 36Join Ollie and Klaudia as they regale us with tales of Supernatural S3E12: "Jus In Bello" and S3E13: "Ghostfacers." Points of Interest: Union strikes create more Supernatural, Jensen is somehow the least problematic cast member, Dean’s year of nihilism, a failed language lesson, Hannigram Destiel AU, Dean can survive anything (except for a rusty nail), Sam’s 5-Minute Crafts era, not a deMAN - a deHER, Dean is Christian-shaming, one of Supernatural’s many GLAAD nominations, the Ghostfacers walked so BuzzFeed Unsolved could run, unintentional Destiel foreshadowing, and the best line ever spoken on a telev...
2023-12-051h 44The Mystery Spotcast: A Supernatural RewatchDying Looney Tunes Style: Ep. 35Join Klaudia and Ollie as they memorialize reaching Supernatural S3E11: "Mystery Spot."Points of Interest: Where is the Supernatural bottle episode?, Bill Cipher/Crowley, Dean Winchester once again enters his problematic era, you peed your pants and got hit by a car? There’s a gif for that, the woke mob has come for strawberry syrup, “I heard Sam Winchester was shredded”, Sam is more of an Elsa, Jesnen Axels, death by Taako from TV.---Follow us:@MysterySpotcast on Tiktok / Twitter / Instagram / Tumblr---Conta...
2023-11-1449 minThe Mystery Spotcast: A Supernatural RewatchDumb Ways to Die (Supernatural Version): Ep. 34Join Ollie and Klaudia as they celebrate finally reaching Supernatural S3E11: "Mystery Spot."Points of Interest: Dean Winchester’s “What’s In My Bag” tour, Grunkle Stan/Bobby, the rusty nail haunts the narrative, cancel culture has come for Dean Winchester (again and again), Supernatural has a gif for that, the grand narrative would really harsh my vibe, the Trickster is a professional hater, the first Sabriel fanfiction is lost media, and a game of Is It Supernatural or Did I Just Make It Up?---Follow us:@MysterySpotcast on Tiktok...
2023-07-111h 03The Mystery Spotcast: A Supernatural RewatchThe CinemaSins-ification of Witchcraft: Ep. 33Join Klaudia and Ollie as they drift into Supernatural S3E9: "Malleus Maleficarum" and S3E10: "Dream A Little Dream of Me." Points of Interest: What will Jensen Ackles do in a post-The Winchesters world?, Guy Fieri AU, Peach hates Supernatural, your official Snoop Dogg counters, God forbid women have hobbies, “Sammy, I shit my pants”, if you die in the dream you die for real, everybody loves Bobby, this edible ain’t shit, they cooked Dean in a blorbo machine, men will fight a demon dream version of themself instead of going to therapy, and putting Jared P...
2023-06-271h 50The Mystery Spotcast: A Supernatural RewatchAcross the Winchester-Verse: Ep. 32Join Ollie and Klaudia as they jingle into Supernatural S3E7: "Fresh Blood" and S3E8: "A Very Supernatural Christmas." Points of Interest: Happy Pride (they killed Carlos), Jensen Ackles in The Acolyte, Voltron is the Supernatural of Netflix animated shows, Happy Pride and Merry Christmas, running the Tumblr gamut, Bela “Lean In” Talbot, autism and vampire are next to each other in the DSM-5, Superwholock deathmatch, November 5th 2020 (canon event), not Sam’s biggest flop (but definitely a flop), Dean stole Klaudia’s Sapphire Barbie, and Supernatural is Christianity’s penance.---Follow us:
2023-06-132h 07The Mystery Spotcast: A Supernatural RewatchFellas, Is It Gay to Read the Brothers Grimm?: Ep. 31Join Klaudia and Ollie as they review Supernatural S3E5: "Bedtime Stories" and S3E6: "Red Sky at Morning." Points of Interest: We will fund The Winchesters s2-5, where’s a writers strike when you need one?, moments in autism, clinging to heteronormativity by a thread, proximity to dirt crossroads, professional hater Sam, L + ratio + uneducated, exchanging Dean’s soul for the pink cadillac, Dean’s he/they pronouns, Castiel name drop, Sam loves a girlboss, the Dean-bashing bat, Great Expectations reference in Supernatural (NOT CLICKBAIT).---Follow us:@MysterySpotcast on Tikt...
2023-05-311h 29The Mystery Spotcast: A Supernatural RewatchCapitalism Breeds Castiel: Ep. 30Join Ollie and Klaudia as they dive into Supernatural S3E3: "Bad Day at Black Rock" and S3E4: "Sin City." Points of Interest: The lost Jumanji episode, the season of white women, Marx and Engels are Destiel coded, Gordon is right for the wrong reasons, Supernatural Storage Wars AU, Kevin McCallister vs. John Winchester, nice Asuka Langley Soryu reference, Dean’s rendition of Chip On My Shoulder, discrimination against blonde women, The Honorable Ones parallels, Liberal!Dean Winchester, and the two genders: Bobby and Dick Cheney joke.---Follow us:@Mys...
2023-05-161h 53The Mystery Spotcast: A Supernatural RewatchHibachi Style Demon: Ep. 29Join Klaudia and Ollie where they attempt to recap the Supernatural season 3 premiere, "The Magnificent Seven," and S3E2: "The Kids Are Alright."Points of Interest: Bobby will save you from a sea of flop, Dean as Raymond from Animal Crossing, demons in Ethel Cain’s house in Nebraska, the hunter rumor mill, Jo’s Burn Book, union busters Crowley and Rowena, Bobby reads the classics, a family that slays together stays together, Cas’ absent father era, and Dean’s character journey vs. Sam’s no good very bad day.---Follow us:@Myst...
2023-04-041h 46The Mystery Spotcast: A Supernatural RewatchLazarus Rising Turned Georgia Blue (feat. IcarusPendragon): Ep. 28Join Ollie, Klaudia, and special guest Berklie Novak-Stolz (@IcarusPendragon) for their reflections on the Supernatural universe, with a focus on The Winchesters!Points of Interest: What is Joe Biden’s plan for Destiel?, there is no cure for Dean Winchester disease, top 10 tweets that should have been a text message, accidentally snubbing Jared Padalecki, the Waffle House Approach, Jesen Ackles’ gay wrongs, MILFie Winchester, John Winchester-McCain, has Drake Rodger read Twist and Shout?, our Gotham Knights Antis era, Sam Winchester is Homophobic Dog-coded, and gaslit by Misha Collins (or not?).---Follow Berklie:
2023-03-211h 33The Mystery Spotcast: A Supernatural RewatchHell's Unlimited PTO: Ep. 27Join Klaudia and Ollie for the Supernatural season 2 finale, "All Hell Breaks Loose - Parts 1 & 2"Points of Interest: Supurnurtral, revisiting Kid Nation, our unofficial gay counter, Sam “Ally” Winchester, a pile of Ash, Crowley is babygirl, justice for Ava, Effie Trinket is the Yellow-Eyed Demon, #TeamJake, L + ratio + stabbed in the back, God’s self-insert OC, Dean’s gaslighting behavior, a naturally occurring portal to Hell, and BC (Before Castiel) and AD (After Destiel).---Follow us:@MysterySpotcast on Tiktok / Twitter / Instagram / Tumblr---Contact us:- send...
2023-03-071h 34The Mystery Spotcast: A Supernatural RewatchThe Men of Letters Order 66: Ep. 26Join Ollie and Klaudia as they describe Supernatural S2E20: "What Is and What Should Never Be" and episode 10 of The Winchesters. Points of Interest: Write a letter to your congressperson about The Winchesters, the Great License Plate Change, Drake Rodger John Winchester (Good) vs. Jeffrey Dean Morgan John Winchester (Bad), a bitch in an American Girl Samantha nightgown, Dean and Sam crashed the housing market, the Winchesters’ favorite mobile games, the discovery of Supernatural GenderSWAP, and Crowley won’t call Carlos dad.---Follow us:@MysterySpotcast on Tiktok / Twitter / Instagram / Tumbl...
2023-02-211h 30The Mystery Spotcast: A Supernatural RewatchWWCD (What Would Carlos Do)?: Ep. 25Join Klaudia and Ollie for a deep dive into Supernatural S2E19: "Folsom Prison Blues," and a review of episodes 8 and 9 of The Winchesters.Points of Interest: TW: John Winchester, Jensen Ackles is like if Thanos was right, 2015 Tumblr is back, Dean's special interest is prison, our favorite Supernatural character: Tiny, this would never fly on Law and Order, the “I’m With Her” sticker on the back of the Impala, Semen Dan, Dean Winchester’s Birthday 2023, Freud is kicking the Winchesters’ asses, Klaudia’s clown costume, our live Azazel realization, Jensen’s revenge dress, and gay people did not...
2023-02-111h 33The Mystery Spotcast: A Supernatural RewatchBlaming Dean Winchester for the Omegaverse: Ep. 24Join Ollie and Klaudia as they dive into Supernatural S2E17: "Heart" and S2E18: "Hollywood Babylon."Points of Interest: Women can fridge women too (and that’s equality), Sam and Dean’s West Coast tour, our Californian accents, this is a The Untamed podcast, everybody has a fucked up brother, Sam’s marathon lovemaking, is Jared Padalecki canon in the Supernatural universe?, a circlejerk of Hollywood jokes, J*ss Wh*don revenge fantasy, Product placement? In SUPERNATURAL???, and Winchussy.---Follow us:@MysterySpotcast on Tiktok / Twitter / Instagram / Tumblr---
2023-01-241h 41The Mystery Spotcast: A Supernatural RewatchDestiel Minecraft AU: Ep. 23Join Klaudia and Ollie as they examine Supernatural S2E15: "Tall Tales" and S2E16: "Roadkill."Points of Interest: Engels/Marx, Klance jumpscare, Sonic the Hedgehog mpreg, common Bobby W, cancel culture has claimed Dean Winchester, Pansy!Carlos, The Mystery Spotcast is pro animal testing, Bobby made money off the Iraq war, Rick Riordan decanonizes Supernatural, the LGBTQ community has forgiven Loki, POV: Richard Speight Jr. tells you you’re bearing the son of God, and it’s on you if you don’t know who Cohmac Vitus is.---Follow us:@Mys...
2023-01-101h 44The Mystery Spotcast: A Supernatural RewatchJo and Bobby's Multiverse of Madness: Ep. 22Join Ollie and Klaudia as they dive into Supernatural S2E14: "Born Under a Bad Sign" and The Winchesters S1E5: "Art of Dying" and S1E7: "Reflections."Points of Interest: Supernatural is the meth of television, Sam is fighting demons, is this something that happens after Season 5 or did we make it up?, I stand with my canceled brother, hating John Winchester for the wrong reasons, Meg’s method acting, here comes Carlos with a steel chair!, Dean and Sam’s court stenographer grandpa, and Klaudia’s extended Destiel reeling.---Follow us:
2022-12-131h 12The Mystery Spotcast: A Supernatural RewatchIt's Not Gay if It's in Purgatory: Ep. 21Join Klaudia and Ollie as they recap Supernatural S2E13: "Houses of the Holy," and The Winchesters S1E5: "Legend of a Mind."Points of Interest: #Sinner, “Was this on purpose?”, representation win: a Catholic priest who does the right thing, why are you as a man praying to another man?, born again Christian Mary Winchester, Queen’s Shadow (Carlos' Version), shoutout to Benny, and Cas: lmao good one Mary.Listen to Klaudia as a guest on the Saving People, Queering Things podcast talk about this SPN episode earlier this year.---Foll...
2022-11-2951 minThe Mystery Spotcast: A Supernatural RewatchThe Winchesters Abbott Elementary AU: Ep. 20Join Ollie and Klaudia for their one year Mystery Spotcast anniversary special, where they attempt to explain November 5th, 2020 once again, recap Supernatural S2E12: "Nightshifters," and check in on episodes 2-4 of The Winchesters. Points of Interest: the Supernatural cost fallacy, Destiel happened in 2014 in the Berenstain Bears universe, the soda bottle queerbaiting metaphor, Castiel got sent to superhell and you’re laughing?, The Winchesters is #Woke, they’re decanonizing Bobby Singer, Millie Winchester is the Ally Dog, Ellen Harvelle/Ellen’s Husband/John Winchester, and Jacob Black!Castiel.---Follow us:@M...
2022-11-081h 23The Mystery Spotcast: A Supernatural RewatchDestiel Honeymoon Roadtrip: Ep. 19Join Klaudia and Ollie as they recap Supernatural S2E11: "Playthings," and share their thoughts on the premiere of The Winchesters.Points of Interest: the continued meow meowification of John Winchester, Sam and Dean Winchester are unpaid contractors, is he… into antiquing?, Haunted Doll Watch cameo, an extended rant about Monster High, homicide by Javert, hateful to Sasquatches (real), Dean Winchester is back and better than ever (allegedly), Jensen Ackles’ Dean Winchester voice vs. Ariana Grande’s Cat Valentine voice, John Winchester has lead poisoning, #NotMyJohnWinchester, Nico di Angelo!Bobby Singer, and what would Thrawn think of The Wi...
2022-10-251h 10The Mystery Spotcast: A Supernatural RewatchDean "Legalize Weed" Winchester: Ep. 18Join Ollie and Klaudia as they foray into S2E9: "Croatoan" and S2E10: "Hunted."Points of Interest: The allegations are beating Dean’s ass, John Winchester deserves the death penalty, we have integrity at The Mystery Spotcast, shout out to the Bright Sessions girlies, this post was made by Peach, knocking Sam’s socks off, Sam is woman-coded, the Yellow-Eyed Demon is Jonathan Sims (fictional character), Sam’s Sheryl Sandberg era, and three cheers for Ava.---Follow us:@MysterySpotcast on Tiktok / Twitter / Instagram---Contact us:
2022-10-051h 21The Mystery Spotcast: A Supernatural RewatchJohn Winchester Has Kissed the Yellow-Eyed Demon (NOT CLICKBAIT): Ep. 17Join Klaudia and Ollie as they brave Supernatural S2E7: "The Usual Suspects," and S2E8: "Crossroad Blues."Points of Interest: Sam and Dean Winchester are stuck in purgatory (the U.S. Capital Beltway), this episode was made by the DMV Gang, #GirlCop, Dean Winchester watches This Is Us, Sam Winchester’s flop gap year, a PSA about waiting for your lawyer, the boys go to Bertha’s Mussels, a reference to the musical White Christmas, making a demon deal at the I-95 mixing bowl, Sam Winchester practices trademark law, remembering Crobby, and Crowley’s demon rules and re...
2022-09-201h 50The Mystery Spotcast: A Supernatural RewatchHome Alone with HH Holmes: Ep. 16Join Ollie and Klaudia as they attempt to recap Supernatural S2E5: "Simon Said," and S2E6: "No Exit."Points of Interest: Dean Winchester plays CBAT during sex, AO3 Russian roulette, Dean’ Winchesters Jo Harvelle fancam, just like the Magnus Archives!!!, Sam Winchester’s struggle bus is flying cff a Cliff, Jo Harvelle’s sutistic Swag, Dean Winchester has problematic thoughts on OJ, house husband Dean Winchester, fucked up evil Luke Skywalker, a mousekatool for later, U.S. east coast representation, black mold builds character, dated Scientology jokes, step back "Ask A Mortician," and America’s worst escape r...
2022-09-061h 49The Mystery Spotcast: A Supernatural RewatchVampire OSHA Violations: Ep. 15Join Klaudia and Ollie as they attempt to recap Supernatural S2E3: "Bloodlust," and S2E4: "Children Shouldn't Play with Dead Things."Points of Interest: Ty Olsson stans rise up, Supernatural car repair, homeschooled Sam and Dean Winchester, you kinda slayed (literally), Sam Winchester is a Little Monster, area white woman Ellen Harvelle, "Vampires Don’t Tend Bars," our Castiel embargo, Mel cameo, Sam Winchester needs enrichment in his enclosure, and the Casa Erotica Cinematic Universe.---Follow us:@MysterySpotcast on Tiktok / Twitter / Instagram / Tumblr---Contact us...
2022-08-161h 46The Mystery Spotcast: A Supernatural RewatchAsh Walked so Eddie Munson Could Run: Ep. 14Join Ollie and Klaudia as they attempt to recap the Supernatural season 2 premiere, "In My Time of Dying," and S2E2: "Everybody Loves a Clown."Points of Interest: the yellow-eyed demon calls medical billing, Sam and Dean Winchester’s alpha male podcast, work/life balance, the bunker is a new age crystal shop, post spoiler spoiler alert, Dean Winchester is gay because we like him, Ellen “MILF” Harvelle, the woke left mob is coming for Dean Winchester, clowning on The Winchesters, “pure” brass discourse, and Sam Winchester world music minor.---Follow us:@Myst...
2022-08-021h 47The Mystery Spotcast: A Supernatural RewatchJensen Ackles as Fanny Brice: Ep. 13Join Ollie and Klaudia as they attempt to recap the Supernatural season 1 finale,"Devil's Trap."Points of Interest: Supes-ernatural, you’ve been Meg-ed, Bobby Singer AKA Obi-Wan Kenobi, Yondu Bobby parallels, the racist truck was foreshadowing, Supernatural: Kansas Drift, Supernatural legends vs. canon, the new Eddie from Stranger Things, Mary Winchester’s Jughead behaviors, and Riverdale walked so The Winchesters could run.---Follow us:@MysterySpotcast on Tiktok / Twitter / Instagram / Tumblr---Contact us:- send us a question to our TikTok Q&A or Tumb...
2022-07-191h 11The Mystery Spotcast: A Supernatural RewatchI Don’t Know Who You Are and My House is on Fire: Ep. 12Join Klaudia and Ollie as they attempt to recap Supernatural S1E20: "Dead Man's Blood" and S1E21: "Salvation."Points of Interest: having really emotional talks with your brother in the car, suPerNATurAL, Sam and Dean Winchester are our friends, babygirl-ifying John Winchester, where are the monster gatherers?, Dean Winchester’s biggest slay, accidental symbolism, and ordained!John Winchester.---Follow us:@MysterySpotcast on Tiktok / Twitter / Instagram / Tumblr---Contact us:- send us a question to our TikTok Q&A or Tumblr ask box...
2022-07-051h 02The Mystery Spotcast: A Supernatural RewatchSupernatural - The Worst Road Trip Imaginable: Ep. 11Join Ollie and Klaudia attempt to recap Supernatural S1E18: "Something Wicked" and S1E19: "Provenance."Points of Interest: Emperor Palpatine looking ass, Dean Winchester’s mocha cookie crumble Frappuccino, Sam Winchester’s Thrawn era, cosplaying as Dr. Anthony Fauci, camp in a wad Way, RuPalp Podrace’s reference, rusty nail-course, cross shaped cataracts, evil!Carlisle Cullen, coastal elite Sam Winchester, kill the shtriga 3AM challenge, slay: fight your demons, Darth Joker, and Supernatural’s historical inaccuracies.---Follow us:@MysterySpotcast on Tiktok / Twitter / Instagram / Tumblr---Contact...
2022-06-211h 30The Mystery Spotcast: A Supernatural RewatchFandom Coexist T-Shirt: Ep. 10Join Klaudia and Ollie as they attempt to recap Supernatural S1E16: "Shadow" and S1E17: "Hell House."Points of Interest: Supernatural’s 10 episode structure, spoilers for Sonic 2, Dear Evan Hansen stan Sam Winchester, astrology girlie Dean Winchester, Ollie has been cancelled, demon sorority rush TikTok, jumpscared by the CW website, the son of the daughters you couldn’t hang, Dean Winchester’s wack-xis, Klaudia gives up on being a millenial, Jared Padalecki’s top surgery, and the power of manifestation. ---Follow us:@MysterySpotcast on Tiktok / Twitter / Instagram / Tumblr---...
2022-06-071h 08The Mystery Spotcast: A Supernatural RewatchWinchester Privilege: Ep. 9Join Ollie and Klaudia as attempt to recap Supernatural S1E14: "Nightmare" and S1E15: "The Benders."Points of Interest: Sam Winchester has IBS, We Don’t Talk About Castiel (because he’s gay), selling the CW off for parts, HBO Max original The Winchesters, Misha Collins coming in and out of the closet, RIP to Superlock (the Who part is still persevering), Party City realness, Was the last supper a Mary Kay MLM party?, Talker: our official Walker podcast, Sam Winchester’s flop era, Skrillex discourse, Killing you with my mind (literally), John “Not As Bad As You C...
2022-05-241h 35The Mystery Spotcast: A Supernatural RewatchTow Mater vs. The Racist Truck: Ep. 8Join Klaudia and Ollie as they attempt to recap Supernatural S1E12: "Faith," and S1E13: "Route 666."Points of Interest: the Mystery Spotcast official cancel counter, maybe Dean Winchester should have finished high school, misgendering the rawhead, reason 8000 that John Winchester can go die, Lil’ Gideon bodies Roy Le Grange, shut the Chuck up, I kept our secret (not of being gay, but that ghosts and monsters are real), serial monogamist Dean Winchester, shout out to Daniel José Older, and The Family Business (loving a girlboss).------Want a story about a demonic car...
2022-04-261h 30The Mystery Spotcast: A Supernatural RewatchOur Flag Means Death x Supernatural Crossover Fanfiction: Ep. 7Join Ollie and Klaudia as they attempt to recap Supernatural S1E10: "Asylum" and S1E11: "Scarecrow."Points of Interest: the ACAB episode, Chuck gaveth twice, Sam Winchester gets cancelled, we hate John Winchester, the power of bad vibes in the medical industrial complex, Yoda (known LGBTQ ally), Dean Winchester is the lead singer of Big Time Rush, Supernatural is a part of the MCU, "good soldiers follow orders"-ification, Meg Masters is my sweetie, and a pagan god vs. gentrification.---Follow us:@MysterySpotcast on Tiktok / Twitter / Instagram / Tumblr
2022-04-121h 28The Mystery Spotcast: A Supernatural RewatchWe Aren't Friends with Bugs: Ep. 6Join Klaudia and Ollie as they attempt to recap Supernatural S1E8: "Bugs," and S1E9: "Home."Points of Interest: so we went to the Hole, progressive and regressive at the same time, #LandBack Larry, speaking of God…, stream Our Flag Means Death and The Owl House, Dean Winchester and Rapunzel parallels, oh the misery, his Sammy Sense is tingling, and Sam Winchester’s stupid little powers.---Follow us:@MysterySpotcast on Tiktok / Twitter / Instagram / Tumblr---Contact us:- send us a question to our...
2022-03-291h 13The Mystery Spotcast: A Supernatural RewatchDefeated Again by PTSD: Ep. 5Join Ollie and Klaudia as they attempt to explain Supernatural S1E6: "Skin," and S1E7: "Hookman."Points of Interest: the Family Guy-ification of Dean Winchester, the Tim Cook of monster hunting, The Mystery Throtcast, taking on Dean Winchester’s compulsory heterosexuality, Dean Winchester and Emily Fields from Pretty Little Liars parallels, Zendaya as Sam Winchester, same day memorial service, #NotMyDeanWinchester, boyboss behavior, I have a lot of questions for Eric Kripke, John Winchester is an anti-vaxxer, and stealing Lucasfilm’s intellectual property.---Follow us:@MysterySpotcast on Tiktok / Twitter / Instagram / Tumb...
2022-03-151h 47The Mystery Spotcast: A Supernatural RewatchDean Is My Poor Little Meow Meow: Ep. 4Join Klaudia and Ollie as they attempt to recap Supernatural S1E5: "Bloody Mary," and play a new game!Points of Interest: funeral after party, Ollie’s qualifications for Poor Little Meow Meows, Dam and Sean Winchester, spoilers for the New New Testament, the power of Sam Winchester, classics major Sam Winchester, Eric Kripke please call me, a rare moment of being smart, normal people don’t do this, and the debut of "Is It a Real Supernatural Fun Fact or Did I Just Make It Up?"---Follow us:@MysterySpotcast on T...
2021-11-301h 03The Mystery Spotcast: A Supernatural RewatchThe PILOT Episode: Ep. 3Join Ollie and Klaudia as they attempt to recap Supernatural S1E4: "Phantom Traveler."Points of Interest: Dean Winchester’s infamous golden ratio moment, Dean Winchester/Thrawn parallels, the Winchester boys go to Men’s Warehouse, neurodivergent king Dean Winchester, So Get This!, just like the movie Cars, “I’m gonna drive like I'm on the motherfucking Autobahn”, Jared Padalecki did kinda snap on this one, another "wait, they were in Supernatural?" moment, Sheldon Big Bang Theory is a Destiel shipper, a great time for insufferable people, and Dean's Chiss name, Ufsa’dean’winchester.---Follow us...
2021-11-161h 02The Mystery Spotcast: A Supernatural RewatchTech Bro Sam Winchester: Ep. 2Join Ollie and Klaudia as they attempt to recap Supernatural S1E2: "W*ndigo," and S1E3: "Dead in the Water."Points of Interest: can Dean Winchester even read?, Dean Winchester is little to ME, Oh no! Our campsite! It’s broken!, Thank you Eric Kripke, How do you do fellow heterosexual?, the evolution of Dean Winchester’s taste, forced perspective hobbit situation, A New Hope Supernatural AU, Klaudia is Dean Winchester Jr., Sam Winchester gatekeeps children, an uh oh situation, I would let Dean Winchester look at my Social Security number, and Dean Winchester gets baby fever.
2021-11-091h 24The Mystery Spotcast: A Supernatural RewatchHumans of Destiel: Ep. 1Join Ollie and Klaudia for the premiere of the Mystery Spotcast, where they attempt to recap the Supernatural pilot episode.Points of Interest: gatekeeping "Carry On Wayward Son," what is gayer than extremely heterosexual Dean Winchester?, Oppa Homeless Style Castiel, the .0001% chance of Destiel, We Did It Joe, Chop Suey 2 is the Destiel theme song, Padmé Amidala!Dean Winchester, Dean Winchester’s TikTok FYP, Delta Nu member Sam Winchester, an apology to Women, the Winchester brothers say ACAB, Elon in White, and oops! all symbolism.---Follow us:@MysterySpotcast on Tiktok / Twi...
2021-11-051h 20