abductionalexanderannanneaxeblackbridgewaterbrutalcasecathychaoschristopherconvictedconvictioncrimecrimescriminalcryptiddeathdecadesdeedisappearanceepisodesfamilyfoundhalloweenhappenedharrowinghauntinghelenhenryhollyhomicideincrediblejamesjoshuajuliekidnappingkillerleelifelongmariemarymauramelissamichaelmissingmurdermurderedmurdersmurraymysteryoldsandrasenselessspookystrangesurvivalsuspicioussznthreetriangletrueunsolvedvanishedyearyears