abductionalexanderannanneaxeblackbridgewaterbrutalcasecathychaoschristopherconvictedconvictioncrimecrimescriminalcryptiddanieldeathdecadesdeedisappearanceepisodesfamilyfelixfoundhalloweenhappenedharrowinghauntinghelenhenryhollyhomicideincrediblejamesjoshuajuliekidnappingkillerleelifelongmariemarymauramelissamichaelmissingmurdermurderedmurdersmurraymysteryoldsandrasenselessspookystrangesurvivalsuspicioussznthreetriangletrueunsolvedvanishedyearyears