abductionalexanderannanneaxeblackbridgewaterbrutalcasecathychaoschristopherconvictedconvictioncrimecrimescriminalcryptiddanieldeathdecadesdeedisappearanceepisodesfamilyfoundhalloweenhappenedharrowinghauntinghelenhenryhollyhomicideincrediblejamesjoshuajuliekidnappingkillerleelifelongmariemarymauramelissamichaelmissingmurdermurderedmurdersmurraymysteryoldsandrasenselessspookystrangesurvivalsuspicioussznthreetriangletrueunsolvedvanishedyearyears